Remove ads

“Human Resources” Shouldn’t Be This Literal: A PMMM/ProjectMoon Quest

Would you Distort or manifest EGO?

  • Total voters
    142
Reader mode
.....
Well depends
With carmen she basically being an off their rockers templar
With kyubey they are basically a bunch of innocent extremists uncomprehending of others 'insanity'
Both innocent yet monstrous
 
SunsetPuppet said:
Edit: Since Carmen and Ayin adopted Tiph is she our sister?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Although Carmen took care of the children, it doesn't really seem like it took the form of a family. Part of this can be attributed to Lisa's distrust, but most of it was probably because the Project required a lot of attention.
X might still try to get Tiphereth as a daughter, on the other hand.

But speaking of Magical Girl experts, here's a little bit that I wouldn't have remembered without re-reading:

Lepidoptera said:
A Magical Girl? You suppose you technically fit the definition. Your new body is female, and Singularities are basically magic. Not to mention the EGO you were using was taken from one of the Magical Girl Abnormalities. You could fit the image well enough if you worked in a transformation sequence and some over-the-top attack names to shout.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Lepidoptera said:
The first sensation you register is the cracking of your skin. Agony rips through you as flesh breaks off in stony chunks, the cracks spreading up your arms and running across the rest of your body. You do not scream as you fall apart, like a cocoon being torn open by an emerging butterfly. Beneath the fragments is a primordial lifeblood; the essence of divinity spilling onto the earth. Freed from structure, the pain fades into a dull emptiness. You collapse into an amorphous puddle, a hole in the world that twists and reaches outwards. You cannot see, cannot hear, cannot feel. Everything is but an empty void.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Lepidoptera said:
What was her reasoning again?

Ah, right. Calling your attack names is cool. And you're feeling particularly dramatic right about now.

"The tower shall scrape against the sky, and nothing shall remain on the ground. Render all creation to base, Last Helix!"
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Yes, now you can't say you're not a Magical Girl, can you X?
 
Last edited:
But in general seriousness, If I had to guess possible servant classes for X they'd be
Saber via swords
Lancer via various other melee implements
Archer via long range weapons and I believe one or 2 crossbows or long bows
Assassin via execution bullets
Berserker via meltdowns
Caster via seed of light completion
Mooncancer, can most likely usurp the authority of the moon cell
Ruler via the saint esque characteristics and religious symbolism around them
Alterego via the fact they are a splinter of ayins self that grew beyond him
Foreigner via seed of light and carmen
Gunner via bullets, all the bullets
Pretender via the shell
Saver via core suppressions
And for dosam
Beast due to love of himanity, well intentioned but ultimately apocalyptic actions

A servant period because gender bender and long arse attack names like last helix

Edit will give reasons later
Edit 2 reasons added
 
Last edited:
Kalibrius said:
But in general seriousness, If I had to guess possible servant classes for X they'd be
Saber
Lancer
Archer
Assassin
Berserker
Caster
Mooncancer
Ruler
Alterego
Foreigner
Gunner
Pretender
Saver
And for dosam
Beast

Edit will give reasons later
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

It is noteworthy that almost all classes are on the list, but there is no Avenger because X is too good and compassionate person for this.
 
Eternal_0bserver said:
Yes, now you can't say you're not a Magical Girl, can you X?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
X really needs to trim down on those attack callouts if she wants to be a proper magical girl. With such verbose sentences she's practically the villain of the week rambling about what her latest doomsday device will do to the heroes.

The ordeal names by themselves are short and sweet, and it would be great for X to yell "Grant us love!" every time she chucks an eldritch altar at some evildoers.
 
Eternal_0bserver said:
Although Carmen took care of the children, it doesn't really seem like it took the form of a family. Part of this can be attributed to Lisa's distrust, but most of it was probably because the Project required a lot of attention.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
It might have been more family-like before Enoch kicked the bucket.

Suleverf said:
With such verbose sentences she's practically the villain of the week rambling about what her latest doomsday device will do to the heroes.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
X: This planet will be reborn! All life will become past! Sing your praises. My name is the Daughter of the Sun and Moon, (Last Helix charges up in the background) The Human Order Rejuvenation Protocol, Queen of Abnormalities, ℵ!
Sayaka: Is your mom okay? She's been rambling about her attacks these days.
Mami: ...I have no idea.
 
Last edited:
And I have finished giving my reasons
Read at leisure
Kalibrius said:
But in general seriousness, If I had to guess possible servant classes for X they'd be
Saber via swords
Lancer via various other melee implements
Archer via long range weapons and I believe one or 2 crossbows or long bows
Assassin via execution bullets
Berserker via meltdowns
Caster via seed of light completion
Mooncancer, can most likely usurp the authority of the moon cell
Ruler via the saint esque characteristics and religious symbolism around them
Alterego via the fact they are a splinter of ayins self that grew beyond him
Foreigner via seed of light and carmen
Gunner via bullets, all the bullets
Pretender via the shell
Saver via core suppressions
And for dosam
Beast due to love of himanity, well intentioned but ultimately apocalyptic actions

A servant period because gender bender and long arse attack names like last helix

Edit will give reasons later
Edit 2 reasons added
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...



Unlimited edited quotes complete!!!!
 
Kalibrius said:
Caster via seed of light completion
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Surprisingly, this is unlikely.
Because while the feat of completing the SoL is impressive, it would qualify her more for the Ruler class rather than Caster.
Her sister, Angela would fit the mold of Caster better.

Kalibrius said:
Ruler via the saint esque characteristics and religious symbolism around them
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
This one is unlikely too. Since X certainly has all the things you mentioned. She cannot fit into this mold with how she is. Carmen would fit into this far better (provided the woman took her medications).

Kalibrius said:
Foreigner via seed of light and carmen
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Completely impossible. Everything about X is literally born from Humanity. A foreigner would literally need to come from or is in outer space in order for them to be in the Foreigner Class.

Kalibrius said:
Saver via core suppressions
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Another impossible one. Savers are insane in their requirements. This would fit Ayin better. Or perhaps sane Carmen.

Kalibrius said:
Berserker via meltdowns
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
This is absolutely impossible too. Because she is a BEAST candidate.
 
Alright points
The reason I said foreigner is simple
She is not born from Nasuverse humanity and is not quite human anymore and as shown technically allows what could be considered a foreign reality distorting prescence into the nasuverse
That fits foreigner
Everything else is valid
I did breif look at requirements
Never said they'd completely fit mostly that they were possible
 
Last edited:
Yes
I'd imagine humanity both as a collective entity via... alaya I believe? And on a magus basis would be horribly confused because in a sense X is both not human yet way too human
Id be like a moth was a butterfly at the sametime
They wouldn't know how to react completely to her
 
i feel if she fights a grail war,alaya would be so scared of this 'tumor on humanitys mind' called X, it will supercharge a counter guardian to kill them.
does X have the potential to become a Grand Ruler? you know, Literally killing god with a army and day 49.
 
Last edited:
Rulers have to be neutral figures on the Holy Grail War. That's the most important aspect. I don't think X will stay put and be a fair judge. Specially when the magus community is perfectly tolerant of a lot of bad shit. She's likely going to support some Master she sees as good, thus ruining the entire point of Rulership. Don't think there can be a Grand Ruler because Ruler is a nonstandard class and not included in the original 7-class Grand Servant summoning, just like there is no Grand Avenger/Foreigner/Pretender/etc. Also, there's Servants borne of ideas and not people. Like Nursery Rhyme. X is basically one of those.

Also, Carmen is 100% the Beast here. She fits the role so fucking hard. Ayin hits the Saver role, maybe with his "offshoots" as Alter Egos. Throw in some Abnormalities connected to Lobotomy Corporation there in the blender like Screenwriter's Note or One Sin and it's all good.
 
Last edited:
Well, despite Homura falling into Distortion and becoming Wind-Up Soldier, the situation seems to be mostly positive. X is still in one, appreciably human piece, Kyoko and the rest of the Soul Gems are well and truly out of Nothing There's reach, and if NT isn't already dead, it's running on near empty and will probably get squashed by the Soldier.

Ending up in the Library, within her new Floor of Geography, does have the potential to be good or bad for X. The Library's unique temporal flow means that X isn't likely to spend any effective time away from the battlefield and leave Homura and/or Nothing There to rampage. Jumping straight from intense, semi-enlightened combat to her inevitable reunion with Angela and the Sephirah has the possibility to turn out poorly though, nevermind the anxiety of leaving behind a pissed off ALEPH and a rampaging Homura for her girls to deal with.
 
Last edited:
Funnily enough, this was originally going to be a F/SN crossover before I decided that PMMM had more interesting parallels to Lobotomy Corporation. While X could probably qualify for most classes given access to EGO, the intended options would've been as follows:

- Caster, since that's where most scientists/artists end up
- Ruler, as while they are supposed to be impartial the Fifth Grail War has enough shenanigans going on to justify interfering
- Pretender, imitating Ayin and with all the identity crises that come with it
- Foreigner, by the same merits as Voyager (Humanity reaching beyond its own boundaries)
- Lancer, with the Seed/Pillar of Light as a "spear".

Carmen fits the qualities of a Beast far more accurately than X does.

That said, I don't have as good a grasp of the Nasuverse than I do the Madokaverse, so power system interaction would've been far more of a headache.
 
Last edited:
A few of us here know it well enough
And I can do wiki dives for tv tropes and the wiki itself

Also I agree on caster due to the scuentist
X does have scientific background even if its fragmentary
And why do you think I qualified Dosam as a beast
She got that potential from somewhere and it ain't ayin
Also any oppinions on the possible classes for X I listed earlier?
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top