Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

They bring a lot of concentrated firepower - three high level dragonblooded exalts are a force to be reckoned with.
Not the issue here.
We arent trying to kill all the wizards, especially since at least some of them wont be in their right minds.
A high firepower deployment is contrary to most of our aims with regards to limiting collateral damage.

And Im loath to actually reveal their capabilities until its actually needed.
Not to mention that their origins are a complication in its own right.


Range extension splendor allows her to sap parameters from afar, which is something that's almost impossible to counter.
Lore of Light 1
LIGHT
This simple evocation allows a demon to fill an area with pale silvery light, akin to moonlight. The light seems to emanate from the area's surroundings, allowing individuals to move and act in the illuminated area without penalty. This evocation also has a more tactical application, permitting the demon to stun or disorient opponents with intense, blinding flashes.

System: Roll Stamina + Science, The evocation illuminates one cubic yard per success rolled, centered on the character. The light persists for a number of turns equal to the demon's Faith score.

When used tactically, the intense flashes of light can be focused in a single direction. Any individuals, friend or foe, who look in that direction at the time of the flash suffer a number of levels of bashing damage equal to the successes rolled. Flashes of light appear for only a turn.
Torment: Monstrous demons fill their surroundings with inky, suffocating darkness, affecting an area as above. They can move unhindered though this darkness. Other individuals within the area of effect are effectively blind.
This is a line of sight weapon as literally her first ability in the Lore of Light.
She rolls 9 dice(Stamina 5 + Science 4) with no preptime, or 14 dice(Stamina 10 + Science 4) with preptime to apply Manipulate Flesh to her own physical stats.

Again, she doesnt need range extension. She can knock you out from the horizon.
There's other offensive and defensive applications in her Lores.
A splendor for her needs to be for something she cant already learn to do.
Fascilitate communication, and yes, they apply. We need to absolutely prevent the following:
1) Cult members either joining Red Court or just giving them a lot of strategic information
2) Unsealing any of the ancient evils from their cans.
3) Decapitation strikes
4) Masquerade breakdown
He doesnt do this.
He certainly doesnt appear to do it for free.

Odin is grey council, so we'd basically be showing up to the CIA's office during the cold war with a list of KGB infiltrators all across the world.
I don't think we necessarily need to buy his services, but if he learns those names I think he'd do something with them.
This is reasonable.
As long as we're not making plans based on when he will act on them.
 
VOTE
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
 
Not the issue here.
We arent trying to kill all the wizards, especially since at least some of them wont be in their right minds.
A high firepower deployment is contrary to most of our aims with regards to limiting collateral damage.

And Im loath to actually reveal their capabilities until its actually needed.
Not to mention that their origins are a complication in its own right.
It is my opinion that we need to either kill or subdue as many of the conspirators as possible as quickly as possible.
Lore of Light 1
LIGHT
This simple evocation allows a demon to fill an area with pale silvery light, akin to moonlight. The light seems to emanate from the area's surroundings, allowing individuals to move and act in the illuminated area without penalty. This evocation also has a more tactical application, permitting the demon to stun or disorient opponents with intense, blinding flashes.

System: Roll Stamina + Science, The evocation illuminates one cubic yard per success rolled, centered on the character. The light persists for a number of turns equal to the demon's Faith score.

When used tactically, the intense flashes of light can be focused in a single direction. Any individuals, friend or foe, who look in that direction at the time of the flash suffer a number of levels of bashing damage equal to the successes rolled. Flashes of light appear for only a turn.
Torment: Monstrous demons fill their surroundings with inky, suffocating darkness, affecting an area as above. They can move unhindered though this darkness. Other individuals within the area of effect are effectively blind. This is a line of sight weapon as literally her first ability in the Lore of Light.
She rolls 9 dice(Stamina 5 + Science 4) with no preptime, or 14 dice(Stamina 10 + Science 4) with preptime to apply Manipulate Flesh to her own physical stats.

Again, she doesnt need range extension. She can knock you out from the horizon.
There's other offensive and defensive applications in her Lores.
A splendor for her needs to be for something she cant already learn to do.
Bashing damage can be regenerated in combat time by serious opponents, or this can be resisted by fighting blind. Attribute damage is far harder to counter.
He doesnt do this.
He certainly doesnt appear to do it for free.
I am willing to pay at least something for his involvement. We don't have luxury of allowing cult members to escape.
Are we proceeding with the plan after this or should we vote for a whole line of action as well?
I think we should be proceeding? The update didn't reveal anything significantly game changing, it just shortened the timeline. Maybe add calling Michael?
 
I am willing to pay at least something for his involvement. We don't have luxury of allowing cult members to escape.
And do we have the luxury of continuing to increase our already high debts with him? We owe battles and high-level esplendor.

I'm tired of every time we go to him he want a pice of us.

We must kill the most important ones and then leave the loss of the least to Odin, he decides when or even if he will do anything and we don't owe it to him.
 
And do we have the luxury of continuing to increase our already high debts with him? We owe battles and high-level esplendor.
To be specific Molly and Lydia owe him a single battle and DP said that it's going to be inconvenient/a big ask when he cashes in.

Odin is Grey Council so I agree that we just give him a list of people so he knows who to look for if any escape. Then he can get to them on his own time and we don't incur more debt.
 
1) Cult members either joining Red Court or just giving them a lot of strategic information

Would they really want to be eaten by aliens from the Nevernever and then have their killers walk around in their skin though?

A person can't join the Red Court, anymore than a spider can become a spider wasp, I think.

And while these people are traitors to their species they don't necessarily want to die. The Black Council seems to have motivations beyond nihilism.
 
Last edited:
Would they really want to be eaten by aliens from the Nevernever and then have their killers walk around in their skin though?

A person can't join the Red Court, anymore than a spider can become a spider wasp, I think.

And while these people are traitors to their species they don't necessarily want to die. The Black Council seems to have motivations beyond nihilism.
Depends on how brainwashed they are, I guess? I mean, they are outsider cultists, their minds are corrupted by their patron and magic they do. As to the question of "is the Red Court vampire and the person they were as a human the same person?" - it's a very philosophical question. At least some things, including the interlude in this quest suggests a continuity of consciousness, if not the soul, that makes them the same person.

[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy


I am tempted to reveal more - we do need more friends, but now is not the time. We really should tell Lydia about the Crown, however.
 
Depends on how brainwashed they are, I guess? I mean, they are outsider cultists, their minds are corrupted by their patron and magic they do. As to the question of "is the Red Court vampire and the person they were as a human the same person?" - it's a very philosophical question. At least some things, including the interlude in this quest suggests a continuity of consciousness, if not the soul, that makes them the same person

I don't think the Black Council are cultists though. I think they've an agenda that they're willing to take extreme risks to achieve, but I think Cowl and co want to do something like introduce a magocracy with themselves in charge not have the world eaten by outsiders.

They're trying to use the outsiders, and the outsiders and trying to use them, both planning to stab the other party in the back right before the other's ultimate victory.
 
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy


I dont know if we can afford to assume otherwise.
An office meeting with no magic ritual, no restraints, no use of reagents, suggests unpleasant things about his flexibility.
If I remember the books correctly, the trick was in the ink on the documents the wardens signed. That's the 'reagent' used for the hypnosis.
So it's not a fully unrestrained mind whammy.
E: Though this is OOC knowledge, anyway, so... eh.
 
Last edited:
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
 
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
 
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
 
[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
 
Depends on how brainwashed they are, I guess? I mean, they are outsider cultists, their minds are corrupted by their patron and magic they do. As to the question of "is the Red Court vampire and the person they were as a human the same person?" - it's a very philosophical question. At least some things, including the interlude in this quest suggests a continuity of consciousness, if not the soul, that makes them the same person.

[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy


I am tempted to reveal more - we do need more friends, but now is not the time. We really should tell Lydia about the Crown, however.
It's not, the DF RPG that Butcher approved of made it very clear that a red vampire is not the same as a the person who it was born from. It's a newborn creature with the memories of the host.

The unclear part is if the soul is heavily damaged by the process or not, but continuity of consciousness for the human host follows with the soul. DF is very much a "you are a soul, you have a body" sort of setting.

Edit:

Here's a post from DP on it:

The RPGs make it very clear that you the PC are not the vampire you turn into. It is not a physical parasite, more of a spiritual one that is hatched by the act of murder.
 
Last edited:
What exactly does bare bones mean in this context? I don't want to share the crown or anything incriminating about the timeline of events here, but Usum's note about secrets isn't wrong. If we can cement some more personal loyalty/friendship with a relatively powerful wizard by sharing more of other people's secrets then that's a steal.

If bare bones is "evil wizards are trying to overthrow the council" then going all the way to "Ashraaah the Outsider has X many traitors and Y subverted victims. Mostly on the younger side." Doesn't reveal more than we're already planning to anyway and could pay off.

I'd prefer some more obscuration overall, but if we're going to take that risk we might as well get what we can for it.
 
It is my opinion that we need to either kill or subdue as many of the conspirators as possible as quickly as possible.
As far as Im concerned its a stretch goal.
Nice to have, but secondary to preventing them doing additional harm or getting more wizards killed.

Bashing damage can be regenerated in combat time by serious opponents, or this can be resisted by fighting blind. Attribute damage is far harder to counter.
Not many regenerators out there; healers, yes, but not auto regen.
Even among the Whites and Reds, it costs mojo to use, unlike how the Garou regen for free.
And blind fighters are even rarer, to my recollection, and eat an extra -2DC to their rolls for the attempt.

Bashing rolls over into lethal.
And someone whose health bar is in Incap is vulnerable to, say, a 40 pound dumbell dropped on their skull.
Under most circumstances she's fine, and there's additional Lores open to her.

My design goals for a Tiffany splendor are two-fold:
1)Shaping protection, preventing people from cursing her or transforming her or otherwise dealing shaping damage
2)Hoard Background, increasing her Faith reservoir from 3/3 to at least 15/15

The lady has access to Lores of Fundament, Wind, Storms, Beasts, Wild and possibly Fire, all of which give her additional options for offense, defense and evasion.
She doesnt need a trinket for more kill. She needs utility to make what she has work better for her.
I am willing to pay at least something for his involvement. We don't have luxury of allowing cult members to escape.
Of course we do. They're not the first, and wont be the last bad guys to survive a plot going bad; Cowl and Corpsetaker both survived Dead Beat, and the Denarian Archleone family regularly survive defeat. I'd love to manage a clean sweep, but as long as we know who they are, we can hunt them down in the following months, the way we did Sandra Marling.

There's even a benefit in letting them run, and seeing where and who they run to.
Or in seeing if the White Council will ask us to hunt them down as a future plot thread.

More broadly, we already owe Odin One-Eye a couple debts that havent been paid off, and which he reserves the right to call in at any time of his choosing.
Im averse to just running up that tab when it isnt absolutely necessary.

If I remember the books correctly, the trick was in the ink on the documents the wardens signed. That's the 'reagent' used for the hypnosis.
So it's not a fully unrestrained mind whammy.
E: Though this is OOC knowledge, anyway, so... eh.
Yeah, that was the canon protocol he used, and I wont be surprised if thats what he's using
But unlike canon, this conspiracy appears to involve more than just Peabody, and the mind control spells in use appear to be more flexible/powerful. So we cant assume that everything is the same.
 
Last edited:
Say have I done something here wrong cause I just went to sv and my ip address has been banned? I'm so confused or at least this is what sv says on my laptop. I just downloaded Norton I guess that's the only thing I can think of.
 
Say have I done something here wrong cause I just went to sv and my ip address has been banned? I'm so confused or at least this is what sv says on my laptop. I just downloaded Norton I guess that's the only thing I can think of.
If you're having forum issues?
You're gonna have to post a thread in Forum Technical Support, I think
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Forum Technical Support

Are you having issues with the forum software? Weird things happening when you try to post? We've got you covered.
 
If you're having forum issues?
You're gonna have to post a thread in Forum Technical Support, I think
forums.sufficientvelocity.com

Forum Technical Support

Are you having issues with the forum software? Weird things happening when you try to post? We've got you covered.
Okay I'm so confused though I wasn't having an argument, didn't post any links or images, I've just been here and making comments in one other fic. Nothing I did there seems wrong.
 
Last edited:
Okay I'm so confused though I wasn't having an argument, didn't post any links or images, I've just been here and making comments in one other fic. Nothing I did there seems wrong.
Wait, do you mean SV or SB?
Because this is SV, and you dont seem to be having trouble here.
And as far as I can tell you arent banned on Spacebattles either.

Either way, you need to start a thread in the Technical Support subforum of the site where you are having a problem where one of the site administrators or techies can see it.
Or message a mod.
 
Wait, do you mean SV or SB?
Because this is SV, and you dont seem to be having trouble here.
And as far as I can tell you arent banned on Spacebattles either.

Either way, you need to start a thread in the Technical Support subforum of the site where you are having a problem where one of the site administrators or techies can see it.
Or message a mod.
Nope here my ip address has been banned not my account two different things apparently and I did. I also made an appeal no results yet though. I'm disconnected from my address right now.
 
[x] Carols: Admit that you knew something was the matter months earlier as was Harry and McCoy, but they did not know who to trust
 
Not telling him about the Crown when we just got through freeing him of mental programming.

[X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
[X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy

Adhoc vote count started by BoredMan on Aug 20, 2024 at 1:22 AM, finished with 73 posts and 9 votes.

  • [X] Trainees: The bare bones, there are lots of evil wizards infiltrating the White Council
    [X] Carlos: The bare bones of the conspiracy
    [X] Plan Minimal Information
    -[X] Trainees: You discovered a Plot against the White council.
    -[X] Carlos: Like Trainees + You discovered Outsider involvement and will bring the Information directly to the senior council. You have hints that he is not the only affected Warden.
    [x] Carols: Admit that you knew something was the matter months earlier as was Harry and McCoy, but they did not know who to trust
 
Back
Top