- Location
- Poland
I would also recommend the posts about writing (you need to find them) on Larry Correira blog Monster Hunter Nation.
I can at the very least answer this question. The vast majority of Titan power sources, to be completely blunt, are not suitable for space travel. This is often because they rely on some sort of external phenomena or resource (such as the Titan of Bone's dependence on draining life force), meaning that they just don't work in space, or might not survive an orbital launch.I could sort of buy things up to this point, but at this point the plausibility of the gimmick has just fallen apart. If it's so damn easy to scale infinitely and become immune to harm by just running off into space, why haven't any dungeons done it already? (And, no, "they didn't know physics" isn't a good explanation for dungeons that don't have to worry about dying of radiation poisoning from trial-and-error experimentation.)
Gremlin: SIR! Dragon managed to decommission Titan mk. 3! Orders!
I'm not going down that route; I get enough complaints of Sue-ness already.... Huh. At this point, I wonder if the main character can figure out how to artificially extend his "life" via technology? I wouldn't be surprised if sooner or later he or his goblins wind up developing more modern computers, at which point it's possible a path to making an artificial Dungeon Core that wouldn't fail due to old age could open up. That sort of thing would probably make everyone very concerned, because suddenly you have something that is immortal in a setting where that normally couldn't be a thing, operates in violation of the "known" principles of how magic works, and has access to technology and magic in advance of anything the world had ever seen.
The issue isn't Sue-ness as such, it's a combination of pretty serious power ramp up and a setting that can't supply the kind of challenges it needs long term. If you were to multi-cross into, say, Star Wars, it would instantly stop being a story about magitech nuclear mecha curb-stomping a generic fantasy world and start being something a bit more equal, since they have FTL, shields, reaction-less drives, populations of trillions and so on and you do not.I'm not going down that route; I get enough complaints of Sue-ness already.
I will say this: The challenges I have planned for after Corenzite is dead are not the sort of problems which brute force is a solution to. Well, except for that one, but it's the finale.The issue isn't Sue-ness as such, it's a combination of pretty serious power ramp up and a setting that can't supply the kind of challenges it needs long term. If you were to multi-cross into, say, Star Wars, it would instantly stop being a story about magitech nuclear mecha curb-stomping a generic fantasy world and start being something a bit more equal, since they have FTL, shields, reaction-less drives, populations of trillions and so on and you do not.
In any case, handing yourself the idiot ball doesn't really solve the problem, especially in the absence of characterization that would support it, so if you respond to these complaints by slowing down or stopping the progress for no good in-story reason I will be somewhat disappointed.
the Common Dragon has the ability to flame from both its mouth and hindquarters
The way you have described this has made me even more certain not to go down this route than I already was.Wow, this has totally jumped the shark, me likes! Though the critics have a point too, but who cares? Write unpublishable trash until you can do better. There still is a market, though it's too tiny to harness. Like a little mouse, it won't get you anywhere but it looks cute. You still have readers! Good authors are old people anyway, so don't go breaking yourself trying to get there faster, c'est impossible.
At this point the dragon might believe the steel titan is dead, so now the MC can fade into the background. Build some avatars and envoys and send them down, help more people and make more friends, and see where it gets you. Make it about the people on the surface and how the new skygod affects them. Unless you go for the giant space sharks route and your new space station is now just so much space-shark chow. If your spacesharks don't have lasers on their heads though I'll be disappointed.
I'm calling him a Skygod because his base must be visible from down under. At 1200km height you only need to build a disc 10.8km across to appear as large as the moon or the sun, if only visible from a small portion of the globe at a time and much faster moving. So it wouldn't be hard to build something at lest in appearance larger than the resident skygods. Or, since the resident skygods are so conveniently the same size, you could aim for the same too just to fuck with everyone. Anyway, he will be noticed and endlessly discussed.
You could also make something much much bigger, if mostly empty. If you add enough engines so that it can hover instead of orbit, then you can make passable eclipses and get the surface empires to kowtow to you and adopt any laws you care to tell them. You might want to have reactionless engines for this so you don't fry anyone. Or point them sideways at an angle and cause a halo shaped lightshow all around you but only in the upper atmosphere. Or use those guns that fire those particles that pass harmlessly through planets, as engines, I forget the name? Is is masons? Does this SF gun really fire intangible fathers of the American revolution? I hope this is correct.
You could make lots of huge titans and playhouseOlympus up there where everyone can see. It's like TV, but in space! Then build a planetary news network just so that your fans can keep up with the gods' shenanigans when they're not visible. Make them display some modern values and see how the groundpounders all fall over one another to imitate them faster. And you could sell trips to olympus to the rich where they can address the gods directly and receive a blessing for the good and a bracing radiation bath for the bad. It might kill you but it makes your soul better and that's all that matters! Repent! Biggus Dickus — the shapeshifting god of thunder and therapist of the gods — said it, so it must be true!
Either surgically alter them into clockwork brained cyborgs so I can actually use them in the outside world, or something.How does a dungeon unlock new species anyway? And what kind of dungeon would even create dwarfs anyway?
I'm a bit dubious of his mutant category. Any specific plans for those?
#NotAQuestTbh I'd just land on the moon and start digging into it until the entire thing is made a dungeon populated with billions of goblins. Dedicate some of the goblins to researching how to prevent goblin insanity when outside of our control and then establish a goblin civilization to occupy the moon after the dungeon's death.
Develop human-like partially autonomous clockwork golems to infiltrate the societies run by the Great Dragons. Then perform a mix of fomenting rebellion, inciting conflict between the Great Dragons, and technologically uplifting the natives of a particular region so as to establish an advanced society under our control. Dig down to prevent a dwarven incursion. Build up and create a space elevator from that territory to a space station managed by the no-longer-dungeon-dependent goblins.
Put the humans on some independent rotating tube colonies with engines, a magic generator, and the ability to self-replicate and send the out into the universe. Over the centuries left to us, see what species arise from these colonies. Take samples of the Great Dragons and put our researchers into studying them and incorporating desirable traits into the lineages of our servitors.
etc.
not make dwarf teach the forking dwarfs already in the world dudeHow does a dungeon unlock new species anyway? And what kind of dungeon would even create dwarfs anyway?
I'm a bit dubious of his mutant category. Any specific plans for those?
Stage X: Titan
Worth noting is that not all Dungeons follow the above progression through life exactly. A small minority instead take it upon themselves to build their structure into a mobile form; the vast majority of these fail to achieve Titan-hood due to an insufficient mana supply. That said, Dungeons that happen upon a means of acquiring truly vast quantities of mana are quite capable of building themselves into a Titan any time they choose to. Aside from being mobile and having enough combat capabilities to rival a Grand Dragon, Titans are identical to normal Dungeons in every physiological sense.
If you're getting told multiple times that you've got a problem with Sue-ness, what does that tell you? Does your answer change if the people saying it are offering constructive criticism as opposed to "haha u r the suxdor Sue!!!1!!!122!!" ?I'm not going down that route; I get enough complaints of Sue-ness already.
I will say this: The challenges I have planned for after Corenzite is dead are not the sort of problems which brute force is a solution to. Well, except for that one, but it's the finale.
It might interest you to know that until this point, this entire project has been freewritten. No drafts, no betas, no notes, nada. If you're interested in beta-ing, the help would be appreciated.If you're getting told multiple times that you've got a problem with Sue-ness, what does that tell you? Does your answer change if the people saying it are offering constructive criticism as opposed to "haha u r the suxdor Sue!!!1!!!122!!" ?
Yes, that's lovely, but most people won't keep reading simply because you promise that "No, really, there's challenges and awesome stuff coming! Just give me half a million words to do the curb-stomp setup!" You've spent 16,000 words on curbstomping everything, now get to the actual challenges.
I said this early on -- you don't need to faff about with all this crap. If you want to get to a certain point, timeskip to that with a couple hundred words of appropriate scaffolding and then get on with it. You threadmarked the example I wrote, so clearly you considered it to have some merit, but you don't seem to be actually internalizing it.
There's a story about...Robert Jordan, I believe, although it might have been GRRM. He's writing the first book of his series, sprawling on through hundreds of pages of scenery-chewing setup, and his wife is beta-reading for him.
Wife: Honey, this is great and all, but is something eventually going to happen?
RJ: Yeah, I just need to finish this setup. See, I'm going to need this character in a couple of books, so--
Wife: Honey, if the audience gets frustrated at the lack of things happening, there won't BE another book.
You'll always be able to find more wankery to commit -- atomic turbines to speed, railguns, rods from god, space exploration, whatever. There's a small audience for power-fantasy wankery and scenery chewing, so you'll always get a few likes. If you actually want to improve as a writer, though...well, then you need to stretch a bit. Identify your weaknesses and seek to eliminate them. (For me it's showing the characters' internal reality; I tend to put the camera outside the protagonist's head too much.)
If you're like Bob Forward and you want to write physics textbooks thinly disguised as SF, fine...but you're not doing that.
If you're like Edwin Abbott and you want to write political commentary thinly described as extradimensional fiction, fine...but you're not doing that.
What you've got is a dungeon core fantasy setting with a novel twist: atomic clockpunk. What you don't have is a novel. Seriously, you've got the makings of a decent writer. Stop fucking around.
I had assumed that was the case, actually. We're all super busy these days; writing is fun, but planning and editing are not, so serial fiction passion projects typically aren't planned or edited more than sketchily -- certainly none of my books were.It might interest you to know that until this point, this entire project has been freewritten. No drafts, no betas, no notes, nada. If you're interested in beta-ing, the help would be appreciated.