There Was A Different Idea: An MCU Producer Quest

Honestly, the greatest put off about your plan for me is the Hayden Christensen stuff.
He has a pretty unremarkable career in it but it exists - New York, I Love You was a fun enough anthology film that showed he at least had the capacity for comedy. Mind you that I think the film suffered in other ways, but Hayden at least wasn't one.

Little Italy was another and... we are definitely not using that as an example. I thought some elements were funny, but it was a bad film just in general. And hopefully it'll never exist in this time period.

But it does show he's got at least an existing hand at it, even if it isn't very extensive. I may be going to bat pretty hard for Hayden mind ya, but I'm a fan of him as a person and he has a wider range than most give him credit for - his typecasting into moody teen definitely hurt his career long term which I think sucks.
 
He has a pretty unremarkable career in it but it exists - New York, I Love You was a fun enough anthology film that showed he at least had the capacity for comedy. Mind you that I think the film suffered in other ways, but Hayden at least wasn't one.

Little Italy was another and... we are definitely not using that as an example. I thought some elements were funny, but it was a bad film just in general. And hopefully it'll never exist in this time period.

But it does show he's got at least an existing hand at it, even if it isn't very extensive. I may be going to bat pretty hard for Hayden mind ya, but I'm a fan of him as a person and he has a wider range than most give him credit for - his typecasting into moody teen definitely hurt his career long term which I think sucks.

Maybe he could do Laughton? That's supposed to be a more dour role, which is something of a specialty for him. It could also prove useful to have a 'straight man' for all the comedy nonsense going on.

Y'know, to get a more realistic villainous perspective with the backdrop of all the borderline cartoony villainy of the rest.
 
Maybe he could do Laughton? That's supposed to be a more dour role, which is something of a specialty for him. It could also prove useful to have a 'straight man' for all the comedy nonsense going on.

Y'know, to get a more realistic villainous perspective with the backdrop of all the borderline cartoony villainy of the rest.
Do you really see Arthur Parks as we've written him as a cartoon villain? I think he's a comedic character, and a villain, but that doesn't make him a "cartoon villain" in my mind. I would say that Scarecrow is the outrageous "cartoon villain" of the ensemble, if any. Lacking any self-awareness, and acting out of envy, while Arthur is more laid back.

I would say that Eric Williams is already the "straight man" of the cast. Even Overmind's description said that his audition matched Eric Williams the best. I think putting him in his best role would be the smartest thing to do for his career.
 
Last edited:
Do you really see Arthur Parks as we've written him as a cartoon villain? I think he's a comedic character, and a villain, but that doesn't make him a "cartoon villain" in my mind. I would say that Scarecrow is the outrageous "cartoon villain" of the ensemble, if any. Lacking any self-awareness, potentially.

I would say that Eric Williams is already the "straight man" of the cast.

Cartoony might have been the wrong word, I just wanted a better way to say 'grounded in humor' and my brain failed me. The reason I don't think Hayden works so well as Eric is because… well, the role is basically exactly what he played in Star Wars just under a different name. It doesn't rebrand him or build new skills or anything, it'd be predictable.

Kid manipulated by big bad to resent those who truly cared for him, becoming the baddie in the process. Nothing new, y'know? Also I just didn't see Eric as dour? Idk. Anyways, I think I've got my choices worked out so long as the QM doesn't surprise me with an answer to my question. :V

[] Plan Shake Things Up
-[] [Simon] Henry Cavill
-[] [Eric] James McAvoy
-[] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[] [Laughton] Hayden Christensen (Roll? Wants to be in movie)
-[] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[] Network with Ike Perlmutter (Roll)
-[] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[] Participate in interviews and events in order to hype future movies. (Roll)
 
[x] Plan: Wonderous Wonder Man Movie
-[x] [Simon] Ryan Reynolds
-[x] [Eric] Hayden Christensen
-[x] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[x] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[x] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[x] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[x] Focus on smoothing any obstacles for the Technical Aspects of the production and filming of the movie (Costs all 3 actions)
 
I think right now the only change I might consider is swapping Ryan Reynolds for Henry Cavill, or if someone has a strong case for Parks/Laughton to be someone else but that's about it.
 
[X] Plan Shake Things Up
-[X] [Simon] Henry Cavill
-[X] [Eric] James McAvoy
-[X] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[X] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[X] [Laughton] Hayden Christensen (Roll? Wants to be in movie)
-[X] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[X] Network with Ike Perlmutter (Roll)
-[X] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[X] Participate in interviews and events in order to hype future movies. (Roll)

The vote beginnnnsssss! I'm surprised a 69 for casting got us such a nice mix, to be honest.

Backup vote:

[X] Plan: Saving Private Ryan
 
Last edited:
[X] Plan: Hoarding Ryan and Reviving Others
-[X] [Simon] Hayden Christensen (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[X] [Simon] Henry Cavill
-[X] [Eric] Miles Teller
--[X] [Eric] Hayden Christensen (Use if Fails to Secure "Simon")
-[X] [Nefaria] James McAvoy (Likely a Roll)
--[X] [Nefaria] Michael Fassbender
-[X] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[X] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[X] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[X] Focus on smoothing any obstacles for the Technical Aspects of the production and filming of the movie (Costs all 3 actions)

[X] Plan: Alternative Hoarding
-[X] [Simon] Henry Cavill
-[X] [Eric] Hayden Christensen
-[X] [Nefaria] James McAvoy (Likely a Roll)
--[X] [Nefaria] Michael Fassbender
-[X] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[X] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[X] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[X] Focus on smoothing any obstacles for the Technical Aspects of the production and filming of the movie (Costs all 3 actions)

I really do want Hayden for the lead, but I wouldn't be opposed to him playing Erik. So have an alternate plan that's basically the same minus that. I'm still wanting to save Ryan, and I think Henry is a great lead no matter what.
 
I think right now the only change I might consider is swapping Ryan Reynolds for Henry Cavill, or if someone has a strong case for Parks/Laughton to be someone else but that's about it.

I think one of the Boondock Saints is perfect for Parks, can you imagine his fight scenes in combination with his more eclectic powers? Fighting in synch with birds and stuff, crazy. I still think that Ryan should be saved for another role in the MCU, and that he just doesn't look… Wondery enough. :V

I really do want Hayden for the lead, but I wouldn't be opposed to him playing Erik. So have an alternate plan that's basically the same minus that. I'm still wanting to save Ryan, and I think Henry is a great lead no matter what.

Just can't see Hayden as the lead of a comedy movie, especially one like this, and I already outlined my reasoning for not having him play Eric (in that it would be too predictable of a storyline for watchers). I do want to give him the opportunity to be in the movie though, because he really wants to.
 
[X] Plan With No Name
-[X] [Simon] Ryan Reynolds
-[X] [Eric] Hayden Christensen
-[X] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[X] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[X] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[X] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[X] Network with Ike Perlmutter (Roll)
-[X] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[X] Participate in interviews and events in order to hype future movies. (Roll)
 
Does give me an idea for an Omake where Hayden is absolutely shell shocked, "What do you mean it's a comedy role now?! Oh fuck, I've done like one comedic flick, shit! ... yes I still want the part, what are you even asking?!" At which point he either proceeds to call up Ewan or Samuel Jackson for advice, both of whom he's on a friendly speaking basis with IRL, and both of whom are way more experienced in funny roles.
 
Does give me an idea for an Omake where Hayden is absolutely shell shocked, "What do you mean it's a comedy role now?! Oh fuck, I've done like one comedic flick, shit! ... yes I still want the part, what are you even asking?!" At which point he either proceeds to call up Ewan or Samuel Jackson for advice, both of whom he's on a friendly speaking basis with IRL, and both of whom are way more experienced in funny roles.

It would make sense too, considering that in this AU this is Marvel's first attempt at a comedy-centric movie, he probably got on the train when he saw how successful their other serious movies were.

And then they call and tell Hayden it's a comedy movie, who at this point in time has only ever done a single comedy movie… kind of lol
 
It would make sense too, considering that in this AU this is Marvel's first attempt at a comedy-centric movie, he probably got on the train when he saw how successful their other serious movies were.

And then they call and tell Hayden it's a comedy movie, who at this point in time has only ever done a single comedy movie… kind of lol
Hayden: Hehe, I'm in danger.
 
"Desperation Breeds Talent" byDaOneInDaCorner
Desperation Breeds Talent

"What do you mean it's a "comedy" film now?!" The tension bled thickly into his voice, a spark of panic lining every word.


"It's not that bad!" His agent argued worriedly, attempting to reassure his client as best he could. "Look, the planning stage went through a little bit of reworking, and it looks like the film is going to be more comedy heavy than we planned, that's all! No big deal, relax."


"Relax?" A breathy laugh exited his mouth as he sat at his dining table, fingers steeped into his hairline and his elbows grinding into the wood of the table. "I have been preparing myself for an action flick here, I've been working out in preparation for exactly that, been practicing my line delivery with the expectation of being a serious and down on his luck superhero. Wonder Man barely veers into comedy beyond the odd one-liner if that, so tell me just how I'm supposed to deal with a change this big, huh?" While the question was clearly rhetoric, Hayden hoped for an actual solution. His forays into comedy were… sparse, and average at best. He wasn't bad, per say, but his experience in drama and action had typecasted the actor into a type of role that he had grown largely familiar with over the years. Now potentially his biggest role was going to be one he had hardly any experience with? It was stressful to say the least.


"Look, Hayden, I need you to breathe. This isn't the end of the world," the actor clenched his fists, before letting out a long sigh, attempting to relieve some of his tension. "You can practice, okay? There's other less comedy heavy roles too, we could have you try for Erik, the brother? Still a bigger role."


Something pinged in Hayden's chest, even as he admitted the sensibility to the statement, the actor had been reading the comics for a good few months now, committing the character to heart and suffering through his wife's good natured jabs that he was adding comics to his substantial geekiness after Star Wars. Hayden had learned that, well…


"I wanted the role," he eventually said into the phone, leaning back in a sort of depressed fugue. "I want to play Wonder Man."


Silence over the phone, his agent obviously considering how to respond before he groaned. "No promises Hayden, there's more competition for it than we expected, people who are more familiar with a comedic tone too, no offense."


Hayden nodded, frustration slowly ebbing away. "Right, then that just means I'll need to talk to some people who can get me ready for it."


"Ugh, Hayden, what exactly are you talking ab-"


"I'll call you back," the actor stated, ideas already expanding as he hung up, flitting through his phone to reach his contacts. Two in particular stuck out, old colleagues and both with a wider repertoire of filming experience than he had. Most notably… both had some experience in comedy.


Linking the two into a group chat, he sent out a message.


'Samuel, Ewan. Remember that role I told you two about, the one I've been talking about? … I could use some help.'


A/N
Short Omake though it may be, I wanted to write this and it's pretty difficult to manage from my phone. Hope it's an enjoyable read.
 
Last edited:
[x] Plan: Wonderous Wonder Man Movie
-[x] [Simon] Ryan Reynolds
-[x] [Eric] Hayden Christensen
-[x] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[x] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[x] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[x] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[x] Focus on smoothing any obstacles for the Technical Aspects of the production and filming of the movie (Costs all 3 actions)

[] Plan: Saving Private Ryan
-[] [Simon] Henry Cavill
-[] [Eric] Hayden Christensen
-[] [Nefaria] Brendan Fraser
-[] [Parks] Sean Patrick Flannery
-[] [Laughton] Hamish Linklater
-[] [Neal] Robin Williams
-[] Focus on smoothing any obstacles for the Technical Aspects of the production and filming of the movie (Costs all 3 actions)

[] Plan With No Name

Alternate version of my plan that has Cavill instead of Ryan. We did say how Cavill and Hayden would be a great pair as brothers so here is that in action as an alternate option.

Also voting for this plan because I like the actor choices and I can compromise with the action choice as networking is important. Plus I really like Brendan Fraser as Nefaria and this is the only plan that does it aside from mine I think. @Duke William of @Servo1991 What do you think of swapping potentially to vote for all 3 options at once?
 
Last edited:
Gah, I still really wish there were a way we could have Henry and Ryan audition for the role ahead of time to break the indecisiveness I'm feeling over this choice.

Think I'm gonna stick to my guns for the time being though, despite it all. Might go back and add Saving Private Ryan as my backup vote though.
 
[X] Plan: Hoarding Ryan and Reviving Others

As much as I want to prevent Ryan from being in *That* DC movie, I still want to see if we can help Hayden here. The two omakes for him got me waaay too invested in this to just give up on him without at least trying.
 
Back
Top