There Was A Different Idea: An MCU Producer Quest

I haven't even looked at the options for other characters, but we 100% should bring on ScarJo for Bobbi.

Edit: I also really want Johnny Depp and Neil Patrick Harris. Not because of How I Met Your Mother, but because of Doctor Horrible's Sing-Along Blog.
 
Last edited:
Uh;

[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)

Why yes, I would love to see Johnny Depp on the same screen as Robert, how did you know?
 
[] [Vanko] Mads Mikkelsen – He's no stranger to the big screen, he's even appeared in a Bond film, but you're concerned he might not have enough recognition. Aside from that his mostly calm visage and deep voice leave enough of an impression to consider him.
Why's this guy so mad? :V

Uh;

[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)

Why yes, I would love to see Johnny Depp on the same screen as Robert, how did you know?
I'd love to see him alongside RDJ as well, but I'm concerned about that hard negotiation roll, though.
 
Wow, we got really luck in terms of rolls. I really feel like it might be best if we play it safe, just so that we don't entirely wreck what seems to be the start of a really good movie. We got the pick of the litter in regards to casting, and getting an amazing script is fucking awesome.

Before anything else I just want to say;

[] [Bobbi] Scarlett Johansson

I find this incredibly amusing. She's be playing a different character yet be playing the same role as OT iron man 2.

Edit: And if we go for her she would also still have heavy interaction with Hawkeye. We have to, it's too funny on a meta level to not.

I haven't even looked at the options for other characters, but we 100% should bring on ScarJo for Bobbi.

I do find the fact that we have Scarlett Johansson to be amusing as well. But I am inclined towards Emily Blunt or even Margot Robbie.

On the other hand, we could snipe Margot Robbie

I really kind of want to get Margot Robbie, at least in some female role. Perhaps as the Wasp?

Uh;

[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)

Why yes, I would love to see Johnny Depp on the same screen as Robert, how did you know?

Why's this guy so mad? :V


I'd love to see him alongside RDJ as well, but I'm concerned about that hard negotiation roll, though.

Isn't our character spec'd for negotiations? What's the point if we don't make use of it?

But yeah, 100% yes, I really want to see Johnny Depp with Robert Downey Junior. Now whose goat do we have to sacrifice to the RNG gods and demons to get him? It is a hard negotiation roll, but hopefully we don't lose anything if we roll.

Though I'd love to gets Mads, just for the pure fact that we got Hugh Dancy as well, albeit I don't think he's going to be in this film. If his character survives though, it might lead down to line to some interesting parallels in terms of shipping.

Shipping transcends all.
 
[] [Bobbi] Scarlett Johansson
[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp
[] [Masque] Élodie Yung
[] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris

This is my dream team, I think. Of them I'm the least attached to Élodie Yung, but I think we've seen success in the past by hiring people who can actually do martial arts. If we can't get Depp for Vanko I'd be happy with Mickey Rourke.

I think of these the one I want most is Neil Patrick Harris as Hammer. Of course there are tons of great options, but I just really like him as an actor, and I think he could play a very fun villain.
 
[] Plan Starstruck
-[] [Bobbi] Margot Robbie – Of all the actresses who auditioned no one is greener than Margot. She has just recently come to Hollywood just to audition for the film, recognizing the opportunity (and how similar she looks to the character). She has the talent though, and you have taken chances before.
-[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
-[] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[] Hayden Christensen
-[] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)

This is what I'm currently thinking for a plan, though I can be convinced to change my vote for certain actors if persuaded.
 
[] Plan Starstruck
-[] [Bobbi] Margot Robbie – Of all the actresses who auditioned no one is greener than Margot. She has just recently come to Hollywood just to audition for the film, recognizing the opportunity (and how similar she looks to the character). She has the talent though, and you have taken chances before.
-[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
-[] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[] Hayden Christensen
-[] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)

This is what I'm currently thinking for a plan, though I can be convinced to change my vote for certain actors if persuaded.
Yeah, I think this plan is pretty optimal, but I don't quite get the networking for this actor specifically? Is there a specific character we want him for?

I feel like we really should focus on the production, and ensure it goes smoothly instead of getting involved with politics. But I understand your logic, and I am mildly curious about what is happening with Marvel. Any theories?
 
[] Plan Dream Team
-[] [Bobbi] Scarlett Johansson - Another big name who seems very interested in the part. You didn't think she would ever be in Marvel though it seems she can recognize the way the wind's blowing. She's certainly got enough star power to justify giving her the role outright.
-[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[] Back up: Mickey Rourke
-[] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[] Hayden Christensen
-[] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)

@Duke William of, using your plan but having Scarlett for Bobbi because 1. She's good and 2. It's too amusing not to.
 
Last edited:
Can we get Angelina Joli for Madem Masque? She has the screen presence to hold her own as a foil for a hero, would work as both boss and assassin, and possibly we can see about having her seem like a romantic foil for Pepper early on.
 
[X] Plan: Going with the gut
-[X] [Bobbi] Margot Robbie – Of all the actresses who auditioned no one is greener than Margot. She has just recently come to Hollywood just to audition for the film, recognizing the opportunity (and how similar she looks to the character). She has the talent though, and you have taken chances before.
-[X] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[X] If Depp negotiations fail then [Vanko] Mads Mikkelsen – He's no stranger to the big screen, he's even appeared in a Bond film, but you're concerned he might not have enough recognition. Aside from that his mostly calm visage and deep voice leave enough of an impression to consider him.
-[X] [Masque] Mila Kunis - Born in Soviet Ukraine, her family moved to the United States when she was a young girl. She's fluent in Russian, a talented actress who's hoping to get a chance in a real high-budget blockbuster film, and certainly gorgeous.
-[X] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[X] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)
-[X] Investigate a bit, see what your competition is up to (Roll)
--[X] Fox
-[X] Network with your current Directors (Roll)
--[X] Matthew Vaughn

Ok, on the casting rolls, the only issue I have is that we should decide in advance who our second pick for Vanko should be, yanno just in case that the hard negotiating roll fails.
As for Kunis as Masque, couldn't really tell you why. Something in the choice just speaks to me.

As for off-time picks, we should really invest some time in checking out the competition, and I believe we need to touch bases with Vaugh, before the shooting starts, since yanno, he went to the bat for us for Wonder Man.
 
Last edited:
[X] Plan Dream Team
-[X] [Bobbi] Scarlett Johansson - Another big name who seems very interested in the part. You didn't think she would ever be in Marvel though it seems she can recognize the way the wind's blowing. She's certainly got enough star power to justify giving her the role outright.
-[X] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[X] Back up: Mickey Rourke
-[X] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[X] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[X] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[X] Hayden Christensen
-[X] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[X] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)
 
[] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
If the negotiation roll goes bad will this be a "go for your second choice" or a "you've burned a lot of bridges" type situation? Because I don't think it's worth gambling good-will with our bosses for Depp as Vanko. He's a good actor, but he's far from essential.
 
[X] Plan Starstruck
-[X] [Bobbi] Margot Robbie – Of all the actresses who auditioned no one is greener than Margot. She has just recently come to Hollywood just to audition for the film, recognizing the opportunity (and how similar she looks to the character). She has the talent though, and you have taken chances before.
-[X] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[X] Back up: Mickey Rourke
-[X] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[X] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[X] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[X] Hayden Christensen
-[X] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[X] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)

If convinced, I will change Depp to Rourke because I don't want bad consequences to happen. :V

Edit: If Dream Team ends up pulling ahead of Starstruck, I'm fine with switching to it.
 
Last edited:
[X] Plan Dream Team
-[X] [Bobbi] Scarlett Johansson - Another big name who seems very interested in the part. You didn't think she would ever be in Marvel though it seems she can recognize the way the wind's blowing. She's certainly got enough star power to justify giving her the role outright.
-[X] [Vanko] Johnny Depp – Oh my God, Really!? He's even willing to delay filming the latest Pirates of the Caribbean film for this! You don't think Disney is going to be happy here, but who cares?!...Perhaps the Committee will. (Hard Negotiation Roll)
--[X] Back up: Mickey Rourke
-[X] [Masque] Élodie Yung - A young actress looking for her big break is this half-French half-Cambodian. Yung is not only an attractive woman with acting experience; she's also a black belt who has been doing karate since she was nine years old.
-[X] [Hammer] Neil Patrick Harris – From the very beginning of How I Met Your Mother Neil has shown a truly charming, ruthless, and shameless kind of man who cares only about himself…and yet you can't help but love him anyways.
-[X] Network in Hollywood for a specific Actor (Roll)
--[X] Hayden Christensen
-[X] Network with Marvel Executives (Roll)
-[X] Your friends at Marvel have told you something's going on. You might want to check on it now. (Roll)
— —
Sorry Mikkelsen, but you're not a fit for this role in particular…don't worry, we'll get you a role later that isn't A THROWAWAY FOR DR. STRANGE
 
If the negotiation roll goes bad will this be a "go for your second choice" or a "you've burned a lot of bridges" type situation? Because I don't think it's worth gambling good-will with our bosses for Depp as Vanko. He's a good actor, but he's far from essential.
In this case it depends on the the level of failure, but worst case Disney might be a bit peeved, perhaps enough to try and buy the characters you don't own, perhaps not.

Also, if you want to improve the odds there's always omakes.
 
In this case it depends on the the level of failure, but worst case Disney might be a bit peeved, perhaps enough to try and buy the characters you don't own, perhaps not.
Well, that's foreboding. Let's hope for the best then.

If anyone needs help with writing an omake, I'm willing to help with editing and brainstorming. Just PM me. :D
 
He said worst case. Like, nat 1-3 bad. I'm not worried about it, like I said earlier, our character is spec'd for negotiations. Dont let the fact that we failed one hard negotiation make us shy away from all of them.
Yeah, I know I'm being a bit pessimistic, it's just that I'm being paranoid due to our last Hard Negotiation Roll ending with a 7, with a bonus added. :V
 
So, as someone who doesn't really know that much about either Marvel or actors and who is good or bad, why do we want Anakin as/in Wonder Man?
 
Back
Top