okay , I am a bit tired of how much you seen to actualy believe in Grinderp Harry Potter , so allow me to poke some holes in your arguments
Wrong. Dumbledore held back the light families, while the dark families killed them off, Dumbledore not only dated Grindlewald, but also attempted to kill his brother with Grindlewald, also hexed Grindlewald in the back for the elder wand, before dumping Grindlewald in his own prison Nuermengrad
I have no idea were you got this , IIRC it was Grindlewald who hexed someone in the back for the Elder Wand
And Fawks is Hogwarts property.
there's an scene during Dumbledore's burial where Fawkes goes away never to return , so yea this is wrong
knew Sirius wasn't the secret keeper, and told everyone he was anyways (canon, Dumbledore did the Fidelus)
this is a partial plot hole , it isn't explained how , but is stated that the whole secret keeper thing was only know to James ,Lillian , Sirius and Peter
redirects Harry's mail (his Hogwarts letters are his first and only mail from the Wizarding world before he went, and after, only from those he knew?
there are scenes from the Fourth book onwards that show being swanped by fan mail , so it seens a case of A) people not having anything to say to him or , more probably B) people not actualy knowing his address
Dumbledore harassing Riddle his entire time at Hogwarts because Riddle refused to show difference to him, the rest is just circumstantial
actualy it was because from an young age Riddle showed himself an evil guy that would go to any leghts to fulfil his objectives
keep Severus the dark wizard murdering, rapist in a position to torment Harry as he is? (Author confirmed, heinous crime to get the dark mark, like murder, or rape)
okay ,first timeline Severus redemption only started after Lillian's death , second don't acusse without prof , yes he may have done something heinous to gain the dark mark , doen't mean he did everything trice with a smile
And the only experience we have with crowds is them being angry with us for something we didn't do.
again ,I don't know where you got this ,this kind of thing was only done by the Dursleys
So while they may not have done anything themselves, we're likely fearing that Vernon, and Petunia are going to punish us for meeting so many robed people...
you are forgetting to factor how we saw the Dursleys being troughfuly and easily cowed by Hagrid
In the books, Hagrid held him there, forcing him to meet the approaching crowd. Once it was apparent that they weren't there to blame him for something he didn't do, he thought it was creepy, because they didn't blame him for something he didn't do. Yes, that's interpretation, but Hagrid did hold him there, forcing him to meet the crowd. Like some proud papa for something their child did, and wanting to bask in their kids accolades. Which is canonical Hagrid.
I actualy checked this one , no he didin't he just stood there for like five minutes before thaking Harry away ,because why not ?
So, Harry just mysteriously doesn't get told about his Godfather's will being read, that was made before Sirius was thrown in jail,
actualy Sirius inheritance isn't realy a thing until he dies , and them they don't take long to tell harry about it
no one ever tried an exorcism to find out, much less, oh I don't know... medical/magical exams of the dang scar.
you are assuming that they undertood a lot about a piece of obscure dark magic that in the whole library there was only a single mention of the name
Slander, often, publicly acknowledge everyone's blame, or image attacks against Harry, without clarifying anything... neither did he publicly apologize for these attacks on Harry's reputation, especially when it was proved it wasn't Harr
again , where the hell did you get this ? I can't remenber a single scene where Dumbledore did this , and thats kind of why he never had a reason to insue a public apologie , because he had no reason to
Also, signed off on Black's shipping to Azkaban, without trial, conviction, or interrogation. Canon. I think it was stated as being mentioned in the Sixth book.
you just forget to mention that in the chaos of period after the fall of Voldemort this kind of procedure was par for the course and he had no reason to interced in Sirius behalf
(Canon, eighth book, Severus says Dumbledore had always planed on us sacrificing ourselves so that others may win the war)
now I have to ask , but have you actualy read the books ? is kind of hard to forget that the were only seven of then
