Remove ads

Meow Quest (PMMM Catgirl!Homura)

Reader mode
TheBleachDoctor said:
You're still quite a distance from the end, but the end is indeed set in stone in terms of how far you can go.
Once Upside Down Girl is gone, you can live happily ever after!
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Oh thank goodness its still a ways off then, phew :D Though I guess this means I need to kick up Hitomi's "discover what Kyubey plied me into and also spend more time with puppy-girl and friends" mission. For, um, plot purposes.
Lordsservent said:
I would also like Sayaka, Kyouko and Mami to be around to enjoy the ending with us.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
No love in your heart for Madoka's family or other friends,or Best Cats new bestie? ;)
 
[X] Hi! My name is Amelia too! Amelia Percival Venticus Akemi, to be exact. But everyone calls me Homura.
-[X] Pet me Frilly Girl.

TheBleachDoctor said:
You're still quite a distance from the end, but the end is indeed set in stone in terms of how far you can go.
Once Upside Down Girl is gone, you can live happily ever after!
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

...Is that "set in stone" in terms of the universe's chronology or our personal clock?

I mean, is there any realistic chance of our group not getting through Walpurgisnacht more or less intact, and us therefore having to do another loop or fifty?

Kinda hoping the answer is "no". I already did enough crying with the bit about Amura's mother.
 
Last edited:
apeljohn said:
...Is that "set in stone" in terms of the universe's chronology or our personal clock?

I mean, is there any realistic chance of our group not getting through Walpurgisnacht more or less intact, and us therefore having to do another loop or fifty?

Kinda hoping the answer is "no". I already did enough crying with the bit about Amura's mother.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
There is entirely the chance that you could lose everyone come Walpurgisnacht. Unlike these dream sequences, the real world is very much real, and you may have to loop if you can't pull off a victory. After all
 
Torgamous said:
Could a Madoka wish save Mama cat in subsequent loops?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Mama cat is dead forever. If you have Madoka wish to bring her back, it would bring back something that for all intents and purposes is your mother, but the soul is not the same. Mama Amura is dead; her soul ceased to exist and by no method can it be brought back from nothingness.
 
TheBleachDoctor said:
Mama cat is dead forever. If you have Madoka wish to bring her back, it would bring back something that for all intents and purposes is your mother, but the soul is not the same. Mama Amura is dead; her soul ceased to exist and by no method can it be brought back from nothingness.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
So, Full Metal Alchemist but without the Rending of Souls?
 
[X] Hi! My name is Amelia too! Amelia Percival Venticus Akemi, to be exact. But everyone calls me Homura.
-[X] Pet me Frilly Girl.
 
[X] Hi! My name is Amelia too! Amelia Percival Venticus Akemi, to be exact. But everyone calls me Homura.
-[X] Pet me Frilly Girl.
 
TheBleachDoctor said:
Mama cat is dead forever. If you have Madoka wish to bring her back, it would bring back something that for all intents and purposes is your mother, but the soul is not the same. Mama Amura is dead; her soul ceased to exist and by no method can it be brought back from nothingness.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

You're just worried that we're going to start focusing on "rescuing" mama cat rather than stopping Walpurgisnacht, aren't you? Because that's a totally valid concern...
 
TheBleachDoctor said:
Even if you can bring one into existence now, unless it transcends time, it's too late for Mama Amura.
Also Madoka doesn't have the Karmic weight to make it happen right now.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
I figure even a normal wish level of potential could create a small afterlife, then we just have it grow by virtue of the presence of Souls, like a Witches Barrier except not evil or insane allowing it to eventually reach across time and space.
UbeOne said:
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Well that's just incredibly adorable.
 
[X] Hi! My name is Amelia too! Amelia Percival Venticus Akemi, to be exact. But everyone calls me Homura.
-[X] Pet me Frilly Girl.


And I thought Amelia was Second Best Cat. But She's Clem.
 
Zam said:
I figure even a normal wish level of potential could create a small afterlife, then we just have it grow by virtue of the presence of Souls, like a Witches Barrier except not evil or insane allowing it to eventually reach across time and space.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

It's an interesting concept. I've recently been pondering running a quest from the perspective of a relatively sane witch. The idea that their barrier could function as a bargain-bin afterlife isn't something that had occurred to me previously, so kudos for sparking off some new thoughts there.

That said, we have @TheBleachDoctor's repeated Word of Madokami God that Mama Amura ain't coming back under pretty much any foreseeable set of circumstances. So probably a good time to drop the idea. Even if her death did make me cry when I read it. Both times.
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top