...out of uniform. Which still leaves us with the other part.

We are effectively leading a double life, one of a ghost, and one of a Magical Girl. Both are quite different from each other in how they interact with the world. Are you saying that one is more fundamental to us than the other?

I would argue that it is fundamental to our identity on both ends. I had a bit more here discussing things but I don't want to get bogged down in Quest Philosophy.

But so move away from that and to your unsaid argument (though you hit on it in the post prior and I should have dealt with it then)- I think we could have combat-only relationships. If a girl wants more than that? We'll have to turn them down. I mean, I guess not strictly, but fundamentally the issue is probably going to come up anyway and it's far more efficient to cut things off at the pass. And I admit that I'm not particularly overly inclined to do that; I feel like it strictly limits opportunities for characters and creates a character dynamic between MC and Midori that could easily go problematic places. But maybe it'd be best to continue this debate when the issue actually presents itself.
 
I kind of like the idea of telling maybe one other trustworthy person for now (though it'll be dependent on what the other girls are like; if Orange turns out to be kind of a jerk or something, it might make sense to wait for the next one) so that there isn't just Midori, but then plan to tell the rest eventually, once we're more comfortable with how things are going and have gotten to know them all a bit better.

Still mysterious, but with support, and room for growth and trust later.

creates a character dynamic between MC and Midori that could easily go problematic places.
Us stringing Midori along, or being overly reliant on her to take care of living-person stuff, or something else?
 
Us stringing Midori along, or being overly reliant on her to take care of living-person stuff, or something else?

Especially given how Midori felt about us, this feels kind of like it could become co-dependent... not immediately, but relatively fast, if we basically only allow her an "in" on our secrets and our weaknesses and our personal life.

Honestly I think the best compromise is tell one more person and then that's it. Hopefully it'll be the next girl we meet up with, if not then we can figure thing out from there.
 
might I suggest the alternative of making the other person(s) we trust with our secret a spiritual medium? Specifically a medium we found by shouting on the night of a new moon while untransformed between the hours of 12 and 3 AM. Whoever tells us to keep the noise down gets the position of being our only new connection that isn't in someway professional.

If the medium in question happens to be a teenage girl that's an added bonus because if she can see our spooky self she can definately be a magical girl.
 
Last edited:
might I suggest the alternative of making the other person(s) we trust with our secret a spiritual medium? Specifically a medium we found by shouting on the night of a new moon while untransformed between the hours of 12 and 3 AM. Whoever tells us to keep the noise down gets the position of being our only new connection that isn't in someway professional.

If the medium in question happens to be a teenage girl that's an added bonus because if she can see our spooky self she can definately be a magical girl.
I kinda like this. If we get some free time again, looking up a list of mediums and other supposedly supernatural people and seeing if any of them can actually see/hear us might make a good write-in.
 
I just like the mental image of her going down the road screaming 'notice me please!' makes me wonder though. If we use an audio device (tape recorder, megaphone, a mic) would it record our voice?
 
[x] Go alone (Midori can slip into the back of the crowd before they go back inside and hopefully avoid any major questioning, while you follow the strangers' plan of sneaking into the hospital to speak to the patient, albeit with risk of detection...)
 
If we use an audio device (tape recorder, megaphone, a mic) would it record our voice?
Logic says no, since that would be acoustic vibrations, and if a mic could register that, so would the people around you.

However, our ghost state is somewhat inconsistent. We can interact with solid objects, and I suspect that if we stepped into a pool there would be waves, and we reflect in mirrors... but can't be seen normally and our vocal cords produce no sound. Yet apparently some of it is regulated by our will, and we can walk through walls with a conscious effort... or maybe it's the other way around? Maybe our will is what is keeping us together and by relaxing we are able to become more intangible? If so, does it mean that applying strong will can affect how we are perceived even in our ghost form, and we could actually be heard or seen without transforming that way?

I mean, ghosts in stories do that all the time, or we wouldn't have stories about ghosts! :p
 
Last edited:
Really the Strabger is very bad at thinking things through.

They act like a stressed out manager, more concerned with meeting some performance marker than how all the pieces fit on their way there. Fitting, since they apparently were a bit desperate for recruits until recently.

I bet they have the ways our condition benefits the bottom line taped to their stranger desk. But with regard to the ways that it complicates things, the stranger is likely either

A) unaware, which is somewhat understandable considering our weird circumstances (even if it does make them look incompetant,) or
B) intentionally ignoring them, as they have more pressing concerns and it's not their problem, as long as the gravy is flowing.

So the Stranger's short sightedness might be by design, with the consequences of their actions tossed aside to be worried about when they have time to.
 
Logic says no, since that would be acoustic vibrations, and if a mic could register that, so would the people around you.

However, our ghost state is somewhat inconsistent. We can interact with solid objects, and I suspect that if we stepped into a pool there would be waves, and we reflect in mirrors... but can't be seen normally and our vocal cords produce no sound. Yet apparently some of it is regulated by our will, and we can walk through walls with a conscious effort... or maybe it's the other way around? Maybe our will is what is keeping us together and by relaxing we are able to become more intangible? If so, does it mean that applying strong will can affect how we are perceived even in our ghost form, and we could actually be heard or seen without transforming that way?

I mean, ghosts in stories do that all the time, or we wouldn't have stories about ghosts! :p
I mean if we can do the cliche ghost things, i imagine any voice or audio recordings would distort the voice or make it play backwards. Or come out as static and feed back with a few words making it through. But a simple solution is text to speech programs.
 
Inserted tally - voting is locked. Rolling a die to determine the winner of the tie. Odd for later, even for alone.
Adhoc vote count started by SpoopyGhost on Sep 29, 2018 at 6:00 PM, finished with 49 posts and 29 votes.
SpoopyGhost threw 1 6-faced dice. Total: 3
3 3
 
Last edited:
Here's some tentative ones:

-Are there any rules about magic secrecy? What were you trying to talk to my parents about? Can they know what happened to me?

-Do they expect all three of us to work as a unit? Is that fairly normal? How well do teams usually work

-What's the new teammate like? Can we know her power set?

-What do you like to do in your free time? Any hobbies? Interests? Passions?

-...have you ever watched Monsters, Inc?

That's all I got (I guess those last ones are pretty low priority but I can't help throwing them out there if they don't have somewhere to be)
 
Last edited:
-How widespread are Magical Girls anyway? Just in this city, just in Japan, worldwide, or are there other planets too?
-How long have you been doing this?
-Did you know Midori knew us?
 
Last edited:
- What are the rules surrounding magical secrecy?
This, without question, needs to be our number one priority. If we're even remotely aware of the mahou shoujo genre or even of typical urban fantasy conventions, we'll want to know what are the limits, if any, to revealing ourselves to muggles. And even if we aren't, we would probably want to know if we would be putting anyone else in danger by revealing ourselves or by them coming into knowledge of a system they shouldn't be aware of.

- What is the new girl like?
- Will we be expected to work as a team?
- Is the expectation of teamwork among magical girls a common occurrence?
All three of these feed into one another fairly smoothly, and will give us an idea not only of what the new girl is like, but also gives us an idea of the basic boundaries of how we're expected to act around fellow magical girls. Are we supposed to be friendly to one another? Are we supposed to be enemies, and our tentative alliance with Midori is just a fluke? Will other magical girls be expecting us to join them or fight them?

These stick out to me as being the most important things to ask the Stranger, and if we're pressed for time should be our priority questions. Anything else we might want to ask can come later, if we have the time to chat.
 
Last edited:
Here's a question we should really ask someone: why is being a ghost so similar to being alive? We eat, we need to sleep, we can appearently double die. We're still even going to class! We need an easier way to get in touch with death.
 
Last edited:
I don't think those are needs as opposed to habits, the things we do because we did it when we were alive.
I am pretty sure our physiological processes have stopped, since we don't have a pulse and don't need to breathe.

Oh do we not? We got tired after the first day which would imply the need for rest, though that could have been the emotions. Although eating is more than likely to be a habit.
 
Our magic is likely limited and we can't function at max output at all times, but the need to rest and recover is not the same as the need to sleep. I think it's just how we interpret it.
 
Last edited:
2F - Onward And Downward
"I think it makes the most sense to wait for school to end, and all go together," you suggest. "There's less risk of discovery, it keeps Kazane-san out of trouble for skipping, and more people there means we can come up with better questions."

"That seems reasonable," Midori nods in agreement.

The stranger seems more reluctant, but also acquiesces. "...Very well. However, I will warn you that the hospital's visiting hours end fairly early in the afternoon, so you'll need to be over there quick once the school day is over. I, of course, can help expedite that, but please don't linger too long."

Midori nods again. "Don't worry, I'll be ready."

"Excellent," The stranger confirms. "Then for now, let's adjourn, and get you back over there."

Another door takes you a little bit closer to the school, so it's only a couple of houses and an intersection between Midori and the schoolyard. "Here, I'll follow you and make sure everything goes well," you offer, detransforming. Turning to the stranger, you add "And when I get back, I wanted to ask you about some things." Now, you feel, is as good a time as any to finally get a better look at the full picture. They nod in that frustratingly visible-yet-hidden way of theirs, and you set off after the verdette.

Fortunately, reintegration proves to be fairly simple. Everyone's watching as the firefighters return through the main entrance to speak with the teachers, so Midori is able to slip into the back of the crowd without any issue. After waiting for another couple of minutes, the firetrucks pull away, and the teachers begin ushering everyone back inside. Once it's clear that it was a false alarm, you hear some grumblings about it having happened during lunch break instead of a class period, and you feel a bit guilty about that. Still, what's done is done.

Finally, Midori is the last through the doors, offering a parting thumbs-up… at an approximate right angle from your actual position. You find yourself grinning in amusement at the mistake, until you spot Hotaru rounding the corner of the building, radiating her usual aura of intimidation. She slows down for a moment, staring back at the intersection with a confused glare, but when you turn to look for yourself, you don't see anything out of the ordinary. For her part, she just shrugs it off and heads inside, leaving you on your own again.

Returning to the intersection, you find the stranger waiting again, with a different-looking door this time; you realize suddenly it looks like the one they originally used to arrive in the graveyard the previous evening. "Just in here," they say, ushering you through.

After the bright midday sun, the dimness of the other side takes a few moments to adjust to, giving the stranger time to follow through after you and dismiss the door. "Welcome to my office," the stranger says, somehow sounding more bashful than anything. "I only just moved in, so please don't mind if it's a bit drab yet." Moving to one side, they pull on a chain, and the entire wall shifts, metal shutters slowly shifting aside with each tug, folding away to reveal a wide window. You gasp in surprise at the blue light filtering in to fill the small space; outside, you see mounds of coral, and schools of fish and the occasional shark swimming by in the middle distance. From high above, sun-rays filter through the gently shifting surface, and you can see their refractions on the seabed just outside the window.

"We're underwater?" You ask, though it's plainly obvious. The stunning view reminds you of when you once went to an aquarium in middle school. It had been an impressive view then as well, albeit somewhat intimidating too. "Uh… this is safe, right?"

"Very safe, yes," the stranger assures you. "This place has been here for centuries." That helps ease your concerns, at least a little bit; enough that you feel comfortable looking over the rest of the space. As the stranger said, it is indeed still rather spartan, and surprisingly small despite the size of the window, only slightly bigger than the kitchen in your home, but it still feels luxurious somehow. There's an odd blend of futuristic and antique styles in the architecture and furnishings; the walls comprised of silver angled metal plates, (between which deep-set lights blink without any apparent pattern) while the floor and ceiling are made of a polished redwood, the latter having crossbeams that strike you as being less than necessary. The furnishings are equally anachronic, with a heavy wooden desk offset by a second ergonomic tier like you've seen on modern pieces, and a metal bookcase with raised patterns and lights along the sides. Both of the latter items are mostly bare, aside from a couple of unidentifiable gadgets, and the box you recognize as containing the rings. You also realize that there are no built-in doors, probably because the stranger can summon one themselves.

"So, anyway, make yourself at home," they say, taking a seat between the desk and window. "How can I help you?"

What do you want to ask?
> Write-in


(This vote will not be a competitive one. Just put the usual X before any and all questions you can think of, and they will all be counted. There may be some that can't be answered if the stranger doesn't know either, but don't let that discourage you.)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top