- Location
- Sydney
While I agree you shouldn't restrain yourself when fighting a war there is a tiny problem that we in the real world have never had to deal with. The fact the Imperius curse is real.The problem in canon, and the issue Taylor is going to have to deal with is that the wizarding world under the guidance of Dumbledore is the unwillingness to kill even when confronted by killers. Taylor knows you have to not only match your enemies but take things up a notch to win, but the order of Phoenix, the aurors, etc. are just tossing around kiddy curses instead of doing what needs to be done. No one wants to fight a war, but once you start you have to be willing to do unto others before they can do unto you. Whether he is ultimately a good idiot or a secret dark lord, Dumbledore handicaps everyone fighting Voldemort due to his sister issues.
Sure Death Eaters pretended to be under it to get away with crimes but we also see multiple individuals that were victims used to hurt others. Like Krum or Katie Bell. Meanwhile Sirius said the reason the war was so terrifying was you couldn't trust anyone since they might have been compelled. Additionally Arthur is at one point afraid his wife might have gotten replaced suggest the Death Eaters probably used things like Polyjuice as well in order to infiltrate and attack homes.
Many Death Eater attacks probably involved them grabbing someone off the streets and mind controlling them into throwing curses at there friends or just the public. Killing these people is not only wrong but also useless since the Death Eaters can easily replace them and might have kill them themselves after tormenting them with what they'd done.
Meanwhile other Death Eater attacks probably consisted of sudden strikes followed by running away before the Order can respond. Except on the occasion Voldemort ambushes the Order to sow terror.
This would be how the small number of Death Eaters who are incompetent bullies to effectively harass and terrify the populace even if the Aurors are competent at fighting. It just never comes down to fighting.
Remember terrorists can rarely actual fight against police or soldiers. But they don't need to since they can strike without warning and fade into the general populace before anyone can respond making the hard to find. And you can't guard everywhere without spreading yourself thin while they can strike with all there forces in one place.
Frankly for all its called a war the Death Eaters are terrorists not a army. But that doesn't mean terrorists can be disturbingly effective with the right strategy.