Ok, how would the retelling differ from the story in the bible? And why does the story of Sodom and Gomorrah set off your bullshit detectors?
Don't really plan to change any of the main points just…
look, the part setting off my bullshit detector is that supposedly Lot (guys name) is the one person in the city worth sparing…. Only when a mob forms outside his house demanding they be allowed to rape gods angels who are acting as messenger? His response is to offer up his two daughters to be gang rapped in the street instead.
That's not a good man. Maybe Lot was faithful, and God fearing, but that's not a good man. After hearing him make that offer and being from a time when women had no power at all? Is it really any surprise that his wife looked back? A way to escape that monster?
Then, and I really need to get a physical bible because I'm not sure I trust the internet to play this straight and not fuck with me, so I need a second source confirmation….
Right, so they escape the city flee and find a place to settle down. And according to the verses I found copied online? The daughters (who's father offered them up to get gang rapped) start talking and decide they should continue their family line. But either because there are no other men around, or because only sons count (really not clear on the thought process need to track it down and reread it) they decide to get their father drunk, sleep with him and each bear him a son.
What sounds more likely? The two girls decided they wanted to continue the family line so badly that they rapped their father and both got pregnant the first time? Or, the father who we have already established is not a good man, and who probably had ptsd, was a drunk either as a way to deal or just always was considering where he came from… He gets seriously drunk, couldn't have sex with his wife because she's dead, and instead went after the two closest girls? Probably more than once given both infant mortality rates that far back, any issues from such close inbreeding, and ya know, how people usually don't get pregnant after the first try. It happens, but then again some couples spend months or longer trying…
*shrugs* Maybe I'm assuming the worst where I don't need to. But the bible was written by people and given the culture when it was written? Someone saying oh they got pregnant by Lot? Well God liked him so the fucked up stuff had to be the girls fault.
God needed a messenger to spread the story of what happened. The faithful guy who feared God in a city of rapists might have been the best option, but that doesn't automatically make him a good man.