Remove ads

CHESS MAFIA 2

Reader mode
*begins rapidly trying to catch up*

Nictis said:
Then I misread that.
@Terrabrand mind if I ask why the scum are significantly more informed on their nightkill now?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
they... aren't? Like, you can go back and look, but I literally copy-pasted my old rulings, and then updated them to include the new, relevant edge cases.

Doctor, bodyguard, etc function exactly as I ruled them to the first time.
 
I'll claim in about ten minutes if I'm still the leading vote. This post should be interpreted as softclaiming non-Pawn.
 
I guess that one thing that seemed weird to me in a lot of Nictis' objections to my wagonomics was that I was linking myself to him and Rosen, which seemed to put him and Rosen in the same boat? That seemed weird to me. Something to look at next game day maybe, no matter how this goes.
 
Right now, I think I'm going to place a vote on NinetyNineLies, since I just don't see any good options as it stands now.

[x] Vote NinetyNineLies

Here's my thoughts as it stands now with regards to the way votes are, if NinetyNineLies turns out to be scum, I'd suggest taking a look at the votes on hailcapital, and analyzing the people who voted there for potential scum voters. If they turn out to be innocent, well... I'm a moron, and then it's probably hailcapital who was scum.
 
Okay, I'm a town rook. I watched Nictis last night and did not see anyone visit him. This is part of why I was more in favor of whoever got attacked revealing- I thought scum would have taken the other rook, so I thought that I knew that no town rook bodyguarded. And given I thought that, I thought it was fairly likely at the time that the lack of kill was due to 99Lies getting roleblocked. I don't doubt Usili's claim however, it doesn't make sense to claim for scum. I guess they just didn't want rooks?
 
hailcapital said:
I guess that one thing that seemed weird to me in a lot of Nictis' objections to my wagonomics was that I was linking myself to him and Rosen, which seemed to put him and Rosen in the same boat? That seemed weird to me. Something to look at next game day maybe, no matter how this goes.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
... I did just remember that I joked of like a scumteam of Hugh/99/meso/Nictis, here:

Usili 2.0 said:
As a slight amusing thought considering the last chess mafia game, I'm going to laugh if the scumteam is somehow like hugh, meso, 99, and Nictis.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

Watch as that somehow turns out to be right (barring hugh). :V
 
Ok, I'm not liking Meso. They had a whole lot of nothing day 1 whatsoever besides one post claiming to be more sus of Zae that Hail or Hugh, which is fair, but with no attached reasoning. Then in day 2 they very quickly started throwing shade at the queen, which isn't beyond plausible deniability, as it were, but is suspicious in light of how it really looks like a black queen. Then they cast a bunch of shade on how town shouldn't share info, some wrong mechanics bits which is NAI, and then despite an apparently greater sus for Zae over Hail two days running ended up voting Hail.

[X] Vote Mesonoxian

I don't love the vote, and with 1 town rook already revealed Hail's claim does look sketch, but I think this edges it out, particularly with how stale the vote is.
 
Okay, so I felt last day and for most of this that scum!Hail wouldn't be doing these things? Pushing out of meme phase, organizing stuff. So I still don't feel super good about the wagon there, but I don't really want to throwaway vote or tie things and lead to a no lynch.
 
QTesseract said:
Ok, I'm not liking Meso. They had a whole lot of nothing day 1 whatsoever besides one post claiming to be more sus of Zae that Hail or Hugh, which is fair, but with no attached reasoning. Then in day 2 they very quickly started throwing shade at the queen, which isn't beyond plausible deniability, as it were, but is suspicious in light of how it really looks like a black queen. Then they cast a bunch of shade on how town shouldn't share info, some wrong mechanics bits which is NAI, and then despite an apparently greater sus for Zae over Hail two days running ended up voting Hail.

[X] Vote Mesonoxian

I don't love the vote, and with 1 town rook already revealed Hail's claim does look sketch, but I think this edges it out, particularly with how stale the vote is.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Right, tagging @mesonoxian
 
hailcapital said:
Nictis I also think was getting things wrong in their case against me, and not even just things that could be interpreted in different ways, but just simple factual stuff that anyone can check. And when I corrected him on even those details- for instance, that Cyri and Nemo were not on the hugh wagon, he cast shade on these corrections. I don't know why he did that, since anyone can check that neither of them voted hugh, and Cyri never even mentioned him.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
You don't need to vote to contribute! Also, I did misremember Cyri having been voting hugh at Day start, but I was pulling names by memory (As can be seen by me forgetting Ori). I was doubting rather strongly that Nemo hadn't voted hugh, considering that Nemo put the most reasoning into voting hugh that anyone did.
hailcapital said:
I guess that one thing that seemed weird to me in a lot of Nictis' objections to my wagonomics was that I was linking myself to him and Rosen, which seemed to put him and Rosen in the same boat? That seemed weird to me. Something to look at next game day maybe, no matter how this goes.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Nictis said:
*checks notes*
argle.
NTS, break up wagon in a way that's different than what has been said. I don't like those groupings, particularly hail grouping himself with me and Nemo.
NTSx2: Decent odds I get murked for my hail suspicion and standing in that grouping.
NTSx3, *after* making wagon analysis, make vote log.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
No wonder people don't understand what I'm talking about, I forgot what part I was suspicious about.

Also need to go find out why I was contemplating a Scia/Rosen link midway through Day 1 now...
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
hailcapital said:
Okay, I'm a town rook. I watched Nictis last night and did not see anyone visit him. This is part of why I was more in favor of whoever got attacked revealing- I thought scum would have taken the other rook, so I thought that I knew that no town rook bodyguarded. And given I thought that, I thought it was fairly likely at the time that the lack of kill was due to 99Lies getting roleblocked. I don't doubt Usili's claim however, it doesn't make sense to claim for scum. I guess they just didn't want rooks?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
... Shite.

This sounds accurate on my end.

[x] Null
[x] Vote Mesonoxian

@mesonoxian Things are turning quick right now.
 
And unfortunately, it's 4 to 3, so I would make a tie if I go for the more suspicious sounding 99L?

So um, I think this is where I ask if there's a chance for peopl moving, or a cfd, or. Cause we don't have a lot of time. I'd rather not no lynch cause at least we get info tho.
 
I'm going to be blunt, if hail is innocent for this vote and I wind up like dead in N2, I'm going to really recommend to taking a look at Nictis, mesonoxian, and 99.
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top