An Extra Primarch

Should the Quest switch to a Narrative Base?

  • Yes, it will streamline things.

    Votes: 345 40.5%
  • No, I prefer the current system.

    Votes: 127 14.9%
  • Yes, but not until the Crusade begins/Prologue ends.

    Votes: 379 44.5%

  • Total voters
    851
Why doesn't the Emperor want to replace all humans with Astartes and continuously improve the augmentations until we're all like him? I mean if you can mitigate the risk of augmentation rejection there's no logical reason not to make everyone into Astartes as they and other augmented humans are in all possible and conceivable ways better then standard unaugmented humans so it would only stand to benefit humanity both individually and as a whole if every human in the galaxy was augmented. In addition it's not like there isn't a precedent for this sort of thing either as in the past during the DAOT humans were augmented to a slightly lesser degree on a mass scale so it's not like he can say well it hasn't been done before or anything like that.
That requires a lot of time and better technology to increase the odds of the average person to survive. While that has been solved by us the emperor wants human evolution to be more natural than immediately forces hence why canon astartes are sterile, either by design or by result of the experiment. Another thing is that all the Astartes augmentations were built for built for war purposes thus wouldn't in an era of peace.
 
That requires a lot of time and better technology to increase the odds of the average person to survive. While that has been solved by us the emperor wants human evolution to be more natural than immediately forces hence why canon astartes are sterile, either by design or by result of the experiment. Another thing is that all the Astartes augmentations were built for built for war purposes thus wouldn't in an era of peace.
The Bastion is a post scarcity civilization with the technology, resources and industry to match the amount of time and effort required to accomplish this will be insignificant. In addition we're both a technology and psyker focused Primarch so it wouldn't be difficult for us to master both the biological and Warp aspects of creating augmented humans.

It is unknown if Astartes are sterile what is confirmed is what the child of an Astartes is like and that Astartes do not posses sex drives but not the reason as to why they do not have a sex drive. Although the Emperor did forbid Astartes from ever ruling a planet.

We don't know and it has never been stated that he wants evolution to be natural and if he did wish for this to be the case he would have had to have interfered with human genetic augmentation tens of millennium ago it's a little late for him to get cold feet now especially at the worst possible point. In addition he would have to consciously and willingly disregard this opinion constantly in order to allow for the existence of all current humans, augmented humans and mutated humans.

Astartes augmentation are not only built for war but also have a number of other uses that would be useful for the average civilian such as the ability to withstand a much higher level of psychic power before going insane which is proven by the large amount of beta level psykers in Astartes chapters that often aren't even the most powerful psykers of their respective chapters. In addition it is not like the Emperor or Serras for that matter couldn't alter the augmentations for a more civilian focus.
 
Last edited:
Why doesn't the Emperor want to replace all humans with Astartes and continuously improve the augmentations until we're all like him? I mean if you can mitigate the risk of augmentation rejection there's no logical reason not to make everyone into Astartes as they and other augmented humans are in all possible and conceivable ways better then standard unaugmented humans so it would only stand to benefit humanity both individually and as a whole if every human in the galaxy was augmented. In addition it's not like there isn't a precedent for this sort of thing either as in the past during the DAOT humans were augmented to a slightly lesser degree on a mass scale so it's not like he can say well it hasn't been done before or anything like that.

Plus this line of thinking is entirely against the Emperor's stated goal in universe of destroying Chaos as the only way to effectively fight Chaos is to improve your figurative K/D ratio as Chaos grow directly proportional to the civilization feeding it so the only way to defeat it is to improve your quality.
The Emperor considers Primarchs and Space Marines to be a stopgap measure to further his ends. In this case "naturally reaching his level" would be him directly responsible over the eventual turn of humanity into a race of psykers like the Eldar but better. In this case the Space Marines would be irrelevant as a bio cyborg class of beings in a galaxy where Chaos is practically nonexistent and other threats have become near irrelevant.

And there's also the fact that humans would worry about being replaced by Space Marines.

Speaking about being replaced, I do worry about how other humans are going to see the Bastion people.
 
Last edited:
The Emperor considers Primarchs and Space Marines to be a stopgap measure to further his ends. In this case "naturally reaching his level" would be him directly responsible over the eventual turn of humanity into a race of psykers like the Eldar but better. In this case the Space Marines would be irrelevant as a bio cyborg class of beings in a galaxy where Chaos is practically nonexistent and other threats have become near irrelevant.

And there's also the fact that humans would worry about being replaced by Space Marines.

Speaking about being replaced, I do worry about how other humans are going to see the Bastion people.
That still doesn't invalidate the fact we could use augmentations to speed this up greatly and the fact that most evidence seems to point towards Astartes and other augmented humans being steps on the human evolutionary ladder.

Humans are needed to create Space Marines and we'd be turning all of them into Space Marines anyways there's not reason for them to worry about being replaced when 100% of them are Astartes.

If the augmentations aren't visible they'll only have a problem with our ideals and culture.
 
Speaking of good, ilbgar made good progress on on our SL/Integration Action list. If I'm reading the bonuses right that means we only have 8 things left. Well things collectively.

Completed stuff in red:

[X] [Minor] [SL] Magnus (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Rogal Dorn (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Mehtrya (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Albert Salnus (x2) (max out parent SL and Speech)
Integration Actions (x139)
[X] [Integration] Improve Policy x7
[X] [Integration] The Android Situation (x7): Figure out how to integrate them fully without issues from the Mechanicum. Find out why they could not make more of themselves.

[X] [Integration] Tour the Bastion Sector (x15): We have all these shiny new planets, and we want to know more about their worlds and their people.
-[X] Network with very important people!
-[X] Visit cultural heritage sites of various planets!
-[X] Find out the unique exports of various planets!
-[X] Release the Propaganda Machine!
-[X] Greet the peasants! :V
[X] [Integration] Improve the Guard Command and Fleet Command. (x15): While you might rewritten the manual on warfare several times, it won't do any good if the admirals and generals in your army have not studied them to heart, or if your army and navy themselves are not organized enough to follow their commands.
-[X] Improve the organization standards of our army and navy.
-[X] Set up Academies to train recruited officers and troops.
-[X] Increase recruitment drive for our army and navy.
-[X] Set up War games to promote combat readiness.
-[X] Promote meritocracy within our army and navy.
[X] [Integration] Improve the Scientific Enterprise (x15): Improve existing R&D organizations, bringing the research capabilities of our polity slightly closer to Serras.
-[X] Improve integration between classical scientists, tech-priests, quarian technicians, and various tech-sects within Bastion.
-[X] Improve protocols for resource allocation, research sharing, vetting, and safeguard.

[X] [Integration] Improve Internal Security and Intelligence to counteract sabotage/traitors/spies/criminals (x15)
[X] [Integration] Diplomacy (x42)

Survey Actions (x62)
[X] [Survey] (x62)

Tour Bastion is actually done. You got a bonus to a bunch of background rolls for your polity, a Stress reduction, and +15 to Education: Cultural Analysis.
 
That still doesn't invalidate the fact we could use augmentations to speed this up greatly and the fact that most evidence seems to point towards Astartes and other augmented humans being steps on the human evolutionary ladder.

Humans are needed to create Space Marines and we'd be turning all of them into Space Marines anyways there's not reason for them to worry about being replaced when 100% of them are Astartes.

If the augmentations aren't visible they'll only have a problem with our ideals and culture.
Our extra organs are a bio upgrade, something to compensate for until the human race can produce those naturally.

They'd still be queasy about the idea of being livestock as a template for something "better." Many consider becoming a Space Marine an honor but that might not be the same if a significant bunch of the populace are Space Marines and Space Marines were the ones typically in positions of power.

I'm also assuming that we in general are going to prevent any significant polities of power from trying to brand our people as "heretical mutants who pervert the human form."

Tour Bastion is actually done. You got a bonus to a bunch of background rolls for your polity, a Stress reduction, and +15 to Education: Cultural Analysis.
Yay even more things.
Updating list. Also I'm getting weirded out how updating has become my new favorite word.

Completed stuff in red:

[X] [Minor] [SL] Magnus (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Rogal Dorn (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Mehtrya (x1)
[X] [Minor] [SL] Albert Salnus (x2) (max out parent SL and Speech)
Integration Actions (x139)
[X] [Integration] Improve Policy x7
[X] [Integration] The Android Situation (x7): Figure out how to integrate them fully without issues from the Mechanicum. Find out why they could not make more of themselves.
[X] [Integration] Tour the Bastion Sector (x15): We have all these shiny new planets, and we want to know more about their worlds and their people.
-[X] Network with very important people!
-[X] Visit cultural heritage sites of various planets!
-[X] Find out the unique exports of various planets!
-[X] Release the Propaganda Machine!
-[X] Greet the peasants! :V
[X] [Integration] Improve the Guard Command and Fleet Command. (x15): While you might rewritten the manual on warfare several times, it won't do any good if the admirals and generals in your army have not studied them to heart, or if your army and navy themselves are not organized enough to follow their commands.
-[X] Improve the organization standards of our army and navy.
-[X] Set up Academies to train recruited officers and troops.
-[X] Increase recruitment drive for our army and navy.
-[X] Set up War games to promote combat readiness.
-[X] Promote meritocracy within our army and navy.
[X] [Integration] Improve the Scientific Enterprise (x15): Improve existing R&D organizations, bringing the research capabilities of our polity slightly closer to Serras.
-[X] Improve integration between classical scientists, tech-priests, quarian technicians, and various tech-sects within Bastion.
-[X] Improve protocols for resource allocation, research sharing, vetting, and safeguard.
[X] [Integration] Improve Internal Security and Intelligence to counteract sabotage/traitors/spies/criminals (x15)

[X] [Integration] Diplomacy (x42)

Survey Actions (x62)
[X] [Survey] (x62)

Guess it won't be too long til you're done with this QM. Hope you can stay alive until then.
 
Last edited:
honestly most people probably won't want to turn into Astartes if their quality of life is already greatly improved. Sure being an Astartes like being would be cool and many would possibly chose to turn into Astartes if given the chance but many would probably ask why would they need to when life is already good.
 
Last edited:
Our extra organs are a bio upgrade, something to compensate for until the human race can produce those naturally.

They'd still be queasy about the idea of being livestock as a template for something "better." Many consider becoming a Space Marine an honor but that might not be the same if a significant bunch of the populace are Space Marines and Space Marines were the ones typically in positions of power.
It wouldn't be hard to make the augmentation hereditary as such bypassing the need to wait.

They don't have to be livestock it'd be optional knowing Serras just good luck staying relevant in a meritocracy when everyone can think and learn 100x faster then you can in addition to being bigger, faster, stronger, tougher and longer lived. I mean the approximate average life span for an Astartes is 4000 years them rejecting becoming an Astartes is like them rejecting Juvenat. The amount of people who would reject an improvement to all aspect of themselves is so tiny it's like worrying that your business will fail because you missed one customer out of trillions.
honestly most probably want to turn into Astartes if their quality of life is already greatly improved. Sure being an Astartes like being would be cool and many would possibly chose to turn into Astartes if given the chance but many would probably ask why would they need to when life is already good.
Basically the same response as I gave Citrus.
 
They don't have to be livestock it'd be optional knowing Serras just good luck staying relevant in a meritocracy when everyone can think and learn 100x faster then you can in addition to being bigger, faster, stronger, tougher and longer lived.
See that's the draw. You're saying that it's optional, when the alternative is being left irrelevant in society. It's not like being a customer for a product it's literally changing your life to stay comfy in society or being stuck in the dust.

There's a major difference between our Juvenats and choosing to be an Astartes. The former is a life expanse that a person can deny for any reason. Being an Astartes means a complete change, a permanent one.
 
Last edited:
See that's the draw. You're saying that it's optional, when the alternative is being left irrelevant in society. It's not like being a customer for a product it's literally being pressured into heavily altering your biology or risk losing your place in the galaxy.
There will always be someone who thinks differently, just look at the Amish, and I personally think that we should never lose or work to curb that thought process except where it directly harms or hinders another person.
 
See that's the draw. You're saying that it's optional, when the alternative is being left irrelevant in society. It's not like being a customer for a product it's literally changing your life to stay comfy in society or being stuck in the dust.
I could make this very same argument in the modern day for vaccines, computers, phones and schools Citrus. You will be left irrelevant in this society without making use of these inventions but we don't let the majority suffer just because it would have an negative impact on a certain group of people.
 
Last edited:
There will always be someone who thinks differently, just look at the Amish, and I personally think that we should never lose or work to curb that thought process except where it directly harms or hinders another person.
It would by making an entire class of human an underclass.

I could make this very same argument in the modern day for vaccines, computers, glasses, phones and schools Citrus.
There's a difference between a new technological industry and creating a racial and class divide in our people. This would be the exact opposite of what we've been doing for the past several turns.
 
Last edited:
There's a difference between a new technological industry and creating a racial and class divide in our people. This would be the exact opposite of what we've been doing for the past several turns.
It's just another invention to improve the lives of our people they don't have to use it if they don't want to just be prepared to deal with the consequences. Also I hardly see a difference between allowing the mass production of Astartes and the creation of schools. If you don't become an Astartes well society leaves you in the dust and good luck finding a job that will allow you to survive same thing with school in the modern world.

And again would you rather we let the mass suffering we could alleviate by making everyone Astartes continue just so we could prevent the temporary suffering of a small minority of people who didn't want to transition? And it's not like there is anything preventing these guys from just being another species in our polity we're not barbarians we won't kill them or make them suffer unnecessarily.
When's the last time we spent some invention actions on juvenat?
It hasn't been long enough for anyone who has taken a juvenat treatment to get old yet.
 
Last edited:
It would by making an entire class of human an underclass.

There's a difference between a new technological industry and creating a racial and class divide in our people.
Assuming we don't displaced or killed by anything we could pretty much treat them like the Amish. Give them their own area to live as they please, the right of all sapients not bent on killing everything but allowing those that want to leave to leave. Once we get the rest of humanity into that 2.0 state we surely would have a template to build from to just Biomancy the kid who decided his Rumspringa didn't need to end.
 
It's just another invention to improve the lives of our people they don't have to use it if they don't want to just be prepared to deal with the consequences. Also I hardly see a difference between allowing the mass production of Astartes and the creation of schools.
If you cannot see the difference between creating a class of immortal superhumans who contain our genes and would generally dominate most positions of government, and an education system that intends to expand the knowledge of whoever attends, we're just gonna be at crossroads.

Assuming we don't displaced or killed by anything we could pretty much treat them like the Amish. Give them their own area to live as they please, the right of all sapients not bent on killing everything but allowing those that want to leave to leave. Once we get the rest of humanity into that 2.0 state we surely would have a template to build from to just Biomancy the kid who decided his Rumspringa didn't need to end.
There's quite a few trillions of humans that might not agree to being ruled under an effective immortal dynasty of the Emperor and his direct kin who rule the place.
 
If you cannot see the difference between creating a class of immortal superhumans who contain our genes and would generally dominate most positions of government, and an education system that intends to expand the knowledge of whoever attends, we're just gonna be at crossroads.
Well what's your solution then Citrus? Because I for one will not stand idly by and allow suffering on an unprecedented scale to continue when I have the power to put a stop to it all by offering but a helping hand. So what if a small minority slap my hand away in ignorance they only have themselves and their inability to adapt to blame for their suffering. But I will not allow for this small minority refusal to adapt stop me from alleviating the suffering of those who would take my hand.
 
Last edited:
With the numbers we're gonna be playing with there will always be a few trillion who don't like the status quo. The numbers we're at now there are bound to be some that don't like Serras. We can either acknowledge they exist, setup a substate where they can live out their lives and let them govern themselves within reason OR we can kill them. Ignoring them without doing something is not an option because then they become a bunch of assholes that we have to hunt down and kill or convert after they have fucked something up, which just sounds like us being an asshole.
 
Well what's your solution then Citrus? Because I for one will not stand idly by and allow suffering on an unprecedented scale to continue when I have the power to put a stop to it all by offering but a helping hand. So what if a small minority slap my hand away in ignorance they only have themselves and their inability to adapt to blame for their suffering.
Aside from what we're doing now, which has been working to uplift All Humans there's another thing. Remember how Albert Salnus, our main character's father said we can't do things alone and should rely on others? That also meant the reliance on other people, which is partially why our tech is built around humans eventually being able to go on without us in case anything bad happened.

Our SIA, one of our best bonuses, is predicated on that idea that working alongside others even if they're not on our level is still worthwhile and helps everyone.

Having all our systems, which has benefited from working with everyone, be subverted by just having our Super Soldier children run the place would no different than if we were to ignore that message and had operated by our lonesome.
With the numbers we're gonna be playing with there will always be a few trillion who don't like the status quo. The numbers we're at now there are bound to be some that don't like Serras. We can either acknowledge they exist, setup a substate where they can live out their lives and let them govern themselves within reason OR we can kill them. Ignoring them without doing something is not an option because then they become a bunch of assholes that we have to hunt down and kill or convert after they have fucked something up, which just sounds like us being an asshole.
Or better yet remember that we're not the Emperor and have no obligation to expand too fast and too far beyond what our infrastructure is able to handle. Which also means we're under no obligation to face as many humans as you describe regarding this.
 
Last edited:
Aside from what we're doing now, which has been working to uplift All Humans there's another thing. Remember how Albert Salnus, our main character's father said we can't do things alone and should rely on others? That also meant the reliance on other people, which is partially why our tech is built around humans eventually being able to go on without us in case anything bad happened.

Having all our systems, which has benefited from working with everyone, be subverted by just having our Super Soldier children run the place would no different than if we were to ignore that message and had operated by our lonesome.
It would be no different from how it's run now just with all the citizens of the Bastion being far better off then they were before as the augmentation would be hereditary so it is in no way shape or form ignoring our fathers advice in fact it probably fits the spirit of the advice then not following through with this action as it would bring the average citizen of the Bastion far closer to Serras's level allowing for a much higher degree of cooperation between us.

Also they're not subverting anything that's like saying meritocracies are a subversion of government because the most competent individual rises to the top.
 
Last edited:
It would be no different from how it's run now just with all the citizens of the Bastion being far better off then they were before as the augmentation would be hereditary so it is in no way shape or form ignoring our fathers advice in fact it probably fits the spirit of the advice then not following through with this action as it would bring the average citizen of the Bastion far closer to Serras's level allowing for a much higher degree of cooperation between us.

Also they're not subverting anything that's like saying meritocracies are a subversion of government because the most competent individual rises to the top.
It is apparent that we are unable to convince each other of our respective views. I suggest we stop here. I cannot say that I agree with what you say but I can understand where you're coming from.
 
Or better yet remember that we're not the Emperor and have no obligation to expand too fast and too far beyond what our infrastructure is able to handle. Which also means we're under no obligation to face as many humans as you describe regarding this.
That works until we have the infrastructure and ability to handle more but all that is left is the people that don't want us there. Do we stop there? We could, I actually don't have a problem not enforcing our beliefs and rules on an uncooperative populace. The problem is that we would be working towards an evolution of humanity and there is now a wall between us and them. Human nature would have them warring with us because of the fear that we might enslave them as "lessers."

EDIT: sorry, just saw the updates. here's my stop. Hope everyone is having a great evening!
 
Back
Top