Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

X]Plan Unleash The Dragon
-[X] Lift the curse, then attack
-[X]Sophia: Activate Adaptation, then teleport and attack in melee
-[X]Molly: Switch to counterspelling support. Excellency if necessary.
-[X]Others: Continue as per previous plan
-[X]STUNT: You stare for a moment then shake your head. "Just the curse?" you say, conferring mentally with your companions "Okay." And as you relax your will, Sophia vanishes, reappearing behind a Hollow Man body in the distance with her sword already midswing.
 
X]Plan Unleash The Dragon
-[X] Lift the curse, then attack
-[X]Sophia: Activate Adaptation, then teleport and attack in melee
-[X]Molly: Switch to counterspelling support. Excellency if necessary.
-[X]Others: Continue as per previous plan
-[X]STUNT: You stare for a moment then shake your head. "Just the curse?" you say, conferring mentally with your companions "Okay." And as you relax your will, Sophia vanishes, reappearing behind a Hollow Man body in the distance with her sword already midswing.
your missing a bracket.
 
I don't see them as plausible on their face, but in any case that isn't the biggest issue here. Some amount of mystery is good, but there needs to be consistent understanding of the rules for us to operate.

This situation doesn't make any sense to me even accepting the premise because it doesn't fit the abilities or agenda of Heaven, but I'm more concerned about being able to rely on the character sheet.

Our understanding of Molly's charms doesn't have to be flawless, but it's a problem if we're being randomly punished for OOC material not actually being accurate to the setting anymore.

Which is why I keep bringing up how to parse this for other charms. We can't look at a charm and say "that's Lanka's fire because it says so, which makes it safe to use" because a charm explicitly saying something doesn't make it true anymore.

What's your expectation for someone looking at the character sheet and trying to make decisions based on Molly's abilities?



I think this is a disagreement on what "walking up" means. An Angel doesn't necessarily need to fight us by punching Molly in the nose, but by definition exerting it's power over her domain would be in some way entering it for the purposes of a cosmic being.

Trying technicalities like causing an explosion to happen outside her range that "happens" to hurt people inside of it is like trying to get away with killing someone by ordering a hitman to do it instead of shooting them personally.

Every court on the planet would find you guilty of murder in at least some capacity.


Which is already giving him an advantage because we'll need to break concentration on SSC to use the crown.

More generally, the biggest issue I'm taking with this is not unknown information being revealed as it is "known" information being proven false.

No piece of information is implicitly more or less protected against this sort of thing than any other because they rely on the same presumption of truth for charm text.

How are we supposed to know what things we're told are true for what elements?

I genuinely don't see a difference between something like what happened here and say a perfect defense getting surprise downgraded when we try to use it against something.

You guys hit an edge case in a very strange place, one of the strangest places in existence, even so it was not a perfect defense, it was not something in the world not acting as you expect, it is an actor in the world not acting as you would expect (the angel), potentially at the behest of a third (the Hollow Man).
 
So, I'm just realizing how freaky this should be from Hollow Man's perspective. Here he is, fighting a demon gifted / invested archmage / akuma 2.0 (or however he is conceptualizing Molly). Strange, but not too strange - demons are part of Creation here (that's actually quite interesting, metaphisically, because it might mean that Creation incorporated Malfeas and possibly other Primordials into itself at some point). And then suddenly Molly is dropping an Old One backed and fueled curse on him. Outsider magic of highest caliber. Summoning a Walker to fight him would be a lesser trick. This should be short circuiting his thought processes.

Speaking of, @DragonParadox can we guess how Hollow Man's patrons would react to him calling an angel to stop us waking Ebon Dragon? Because I would expect at least some of them (the Neverborn faction, not the Raksha faction) to want such disasters in Creation. Has he, in desperation to survive, incurred wraith of his masters?
 
So, I'm just realizing how freaky this should be from Hollow Man's perspective. Here he is, fighting a demon gifted / invested archmage / akuma 2.0 (or however he is conceptualizing Molly). Strange, but not too strange - demons are part of Creation here (that's actually quite interesting, metaphisically, because it might mean that Creation incorporated Malfeas and possibly other Primordials into itself at some point). And then suddenly Molly is dropping an Old One backed and fueled curse on him. Outsider magic of highest caliber. Summoning a Walker to fight him would be a lesser trick. This should be short circuiting his thought processes.

Speaking of, @DragonParadox can we guess how Hollow Man's patrons would react to him calling an angel to stop us waking Ebon Dragon? Because I would expect at least some of them (the Neverborn faction, not the Raksha faction) to want such disasters in Creation. Has he, in desperation to survive, incurred wraith of his masters?

Not with any degree of certainty. The thing about outsiders is they do not seem to be the least logical from a non-Outsider PoV. The few times you grasped their logic it was because you saw into their heads as with Nemesis.
 
[X] Abide by the judgement, trust that the angel can drive Drusus off and you can recover the souls you came looking for, though it galls you to let him continue to exist
 
You guys hit an edge case in a very strange place, one of the strangest places in existence, even so it was not a perfect defense, it was not something in the world not acting as you expect, it is an actor in the world not acting as you would expect (the angel), potentially at the behest of a third (the Hollow Man).
Seems like a fine line to draw in this case.

The Angelic warden of the Ebon Dragon's corpse* looking right at the results of a charm and thinking she sees his name being called is very different than Uriel not knowing what the exaltation can do in advance. Angels are a step above the guys who used to administrate natural law for Creation; it's like electromagnetism getting confused about if something is magnetic or not.

If the vice president of the electro-weak force misses the distinction then I'd contend it's one without difference.

* Especially because we're using Kakuri's homework for this and it literally runs up against the Ebon Road.
 
It's complicated, I think? A Yozi dying (undergoing Fetich Death or whatever other transformation) does not revoke an Infernal's ability to use their charms, as I understand it. So, there's connection, but we aren't calling upon Ebon Dragon's power. We are using our own. Good point, though, and another reason to check.

I don't think we would know what would happen to a Yozi who has opened their charmset undergoes Fetich death.

For all we know, like when Theion died, they're partially preserved, and any part of themself defined by a charm a living Imfernal has stays the same.

Seems like a fine line to draw in this case.

The Angelic warden of the Ebon Dragon's corpse* looking right at the results of a charm and thinking she sees his name being called is very different than Uriel not knowing what the exaltation can do in advance. Angels are a step above the guys who used to administrate natural law for Creation; it's like electromagnetism getting confused about if something is magnetic or not.

If the vice president of the electro-weak force misses the distinction then I'd contend it's one without difference.

* Especially because we're using Kakuri's homework for this and it literally runs up against the Ebon Road.

Given that the Ebon Dragon has Ultimate Darkness Internalisation and the deep rules defining what reality can be have changed enough that resurrection is now possible, if there's anyone that managed to develop charm tech that would allow him to flip the polarity of his essence back to being alive if the right combination of unlikely circumstances came to pass it's the Shadow of All Things.

Basically setting up a massive sorcery ritual that was contingent on his Essence signature being present half Outside, half in Creation, and so tricking reality into saying that as one of his charms fuelled by something that looks very much like his essence is being used, he clearly must actually still be alive.
 
Last edited:
Seems like a fine line to draw in this case.

The Angelic warden of the Ebon Dragon's corpse* looking right at the results of a charm and thinking she sees his name being called is very different than Uriel not knowing what the exaltation can do in advance. Angels are a step above the guys who used to administrate natural law for Creation; it's like electromagnetism getting confused about if something is magnetic or not.

If the vice president of the electro-weak force misses the distinction then I'd contend it's one without difference.

* Especially because we're using Kakuri's homework for this and it literally runs up against the Ebon Road.

It's electromagnetism from at least three full patches of reality ago. It is still on theme for using powers out of time, you just struck against a particular rough spot in the way that interacts with the modern context.
 
So, I'm just realizing how freaky this should be from Hollow Man's perspective. Here he is, fighting a demon gifted / invested archmage / akuma 2.0 (or however he is conceptualizing Molly). Strange, but not too strange - demons are part of Creation here (that's actually quite interesting, metaphisically, because it might mean that Creation incorporated Malfeas and possibly other Primordials into itself at some point).

Not necessarily. If the White God is, for example; a second generation Devil Tiger turned Primordial, and we're living in his world body, the angels may be his deva, and he may have done something to the rebels analogous to what was done to the deva of the defeated Primordials to the rebel angels to turn them into demons.
 
Given that the Ebon Dragon has Ultimate Darkness Internalisation and the deep rules defining what reality can be have changed enough that resurrection is now possible, if there's anyone that managed to develop charm tech that would allow him to flip the polarity of his essence back to being alive if the right combination of unlikely circumstances came to pass it's the Shadow of All Things.
I am still betting on Luna clawing her way back into being alive at some point. Possibly to have already done so. And no, this is most likely not good. Maybe Oramus too. Three of the Maidens seem to be powering the fae queens. Gaia might or might not be alive in some way.
Personally, I'd prefer it if we gave the Ring (or an equivalent) to Daniel, simply because A) Charity interfering (and soul-sucking darkness sword), and B) he's still Catholic, and a nerd. That said, we did promise, and he is training in swords, specifically, as well as FCOF MA, so I recognize that it still makes sense if we do that.
We are reforging the sword. @BronzeTongue has a design in mind, if I recall correctly.
 
[X] Abide by the judgement, trust that the angel can drive Drusus off and you can recover the souls you came looking for, though it galls you to let him continue to exist
 
So, uhh... Another strange thing that I just thought of. Ok, let's say that the Dragon That Was (the Neverborn of Ebon Dragon according to Return of the Scarlett Empress) is bound under Ebon road. We are an Infernal. We are using a charm of Ebon Dragon. Ebon Dragon is not Dragon That Was. In order to become a Neverborn he has to experience Fetich Death, as I understand it. Why would his slumber be disturbed by invocations of Ebon Dragon's name and power? Is Ebon Dragon actually dead?
 
I am disinclined to acquiesce to the request of something Drusus summoned, but I'm uncertain what to pick. 🤔
 
[x]Yog

What the angel says does not track with the involved metaphysics as we understand it, best to verify who's understanding is correct and then act based on that instead of either doubling down out of stubbornness or backing down out of fear.
 
So, uhh... Another strange thing that I just thought of. Ok, let's say that the Dragon That Was (the Neverborn of Ebon Dragon according to Return of the Scarlett Empress) is bound under Ebon road. We are an Infernal. We are using a charm of Ebon Dragon. Ebon Dragon is not Dragon That Was. In order to become a Neverborn he has to experience Fetich Death, as I understand it. Why would his slumber be disturbed by invocations of Ebon Dragon's name and power? Is Ebon Dragon actually dead?
The conceit of ExWoD is that they're dead, or so completely transformed into something else as to effectively be so*. The quest doesn't have to be following that, but the explanation given for why the infernals are free is that the chains fell apart. That wasn't a property that needed maintenance.

This is speculation, but I don't think the chains could rust away while the Yozi were alive. Even unconscious there'd be some level of connection to keep things in place.

The Yozi didn't forget who they were, they had it taken from them. Maybe it's as simple as references to their old identities really pissing them off of they're awake enough to hear them, or the guard being concerned that might be the case without being certain of it.

I'm biased on this though; adding a little exalted is nice, but bringing back major entities is too much of a distortion. Holden got it right when he went with the approach "use any explanation you like as long as the result is they're too dead to personally matter again" for ExWoD.

* INB4 on his death the Ebon Dragon ended up tearing himself apart, resulting in one bit containing the worst of his impulses and the other an inversion of his nature. That is to say, the white god. The Angel's job is to keep his evil!Jizo asleep.

Because what is killing a shadow if not turning on a light? :V
 
Adhoc vote count started by Anaja on Oct 29, 2024 at 12:40 AM, finished with 168 posts and 30 votes.

  • [X] Plan In the Light of the Crown
    -[X] Use the Crown on the Current scene to ask "What are the beings disturbed by the events in this scene"
    --[X] If no being that the Angel may be bound to guard against waking is being disturbed, then
    ---[X] Better to seek forgiveness than ask permission, signal the others to keep fighting, keep the curse going
    ---[X] Activate Source Code Compliance Protocol
    ---[X] STUNT: Bright is the flame of your soul atop the mountain in the center of this foul nether realm. Like thunder is your voice, the rumble of a great Beast Upon the Mountain from before Ages past, in the language spoken before Creation itself was conceived: "Hear me, oh angel, and by the flames of my Crown know this to be true - you are mistaken, for none under your charge are roused by my words. My and mine alone is the power invoked"
    --[X] If the angel is right and there is something waking up, lift the curse, and unleash the dragon:
    ---[X] Lift the curse, then attack
    ---[X]Sophia: Activate Adaptation, then teleport and attack in melee
    ---[X]Molly: Switch to counterspelling support. Excellency if necessary.
    ---[X]Others: Continue as per previous plan
    ---[X]STUNT: You stare for a moment then shake your head. "Just the curse?" you say, conferring mentally with your companions "Okay." And as you relax your will, Sophia vanishes, reappearing behind a Hollow Man body in the distance with her sword already midswing.
    [X] Abide by the judgement, trust that the angel can drive Drusus off and you can recover the souls you came looking for, though it galls you to let him continue to exist
    [X] Better to seek forgiveness than ask permission, signal the others to keep fighting, keep the curse going
    [X]Plan Unleash The Dragon
    -[X] Lift the curse, then attack
    -[X]Sophia: Activate Adaptation, then teleport and attack in melee
    -[X]Molly: Switch to counterspelling support. Excellency if necessary.
    -[X]Others: Continue as per previous plan
    -[X]STUNT: You stare for a moment then shake your head. "Just the curse?" you say, conferring mentally with your companions "Okay." And as you relax your will, Sophia vanishes, reappearing behind a Hollow Man body in the distance with her sword already midswing
    [X] Lift the curse, launch yourself at the Hollow Man, with an angel here you shouldn't have to hold the center
    [X]Plan: Go big or go home
    -[x] ask a crown question:"How does he plan to escape?"
    -[x]use the info to get the others to stop him from escaping. Then:
    -[x]Lift the curse, launch yourself at the Hollow Man, with an angel here you shouldn't have to hold the center
    [X] Plan In the Light of the Crown
    -[X] Use the Crown on the Current scene to ask "What are the beings disturbed by the events in this scene"
    --[X] If no being that the Angel may be bound to guard against waking is being disturbed, then
    ---[X] Better to seek forgiveness than ask permission, signal the others to keep fighting, keep the curse going
    ---[X] Activate Source Code Compliance Protocol
    ---[X] STUNT: Bright is the flame of your soul atop the mountain in the center of this foul nether realm. Like thunder is your voice, the rumble of a great Beast Upon the Mountain from before Ages past, in the language spoken before Creation itself was conceived: "Hear me, oh angel, and by the flames of my Crown know this to be true - you are mistaken, for none under your charge are roused by my words. My and mine alone is the power invoked"
    --[X] If there is something waking up, lift the curse, launch yourself at the Hollow Man, with an angel here you shouldn't have to hold the center
    [X] Plan: Charms Heretical
    -[X] If the umbral fetid anger of your curse draws an angel of the Lord to rebut you and possibly draws the attention of things Beyond mortal ken, then you shall craft a new one from tenacity and and Iron Winds.
    --[X] Scouring of the Iron wind - With a bone chilling Roar The Inferno scours the efforts of her Target with the iron gales of the Five Fold Court of Fate and the predatory Roar of the great Beasts that roam its deadly plains.
    --[X] Stunt: The shadows shift and recede. In its place The Winds of your hell whip and whorl. If the shadowed hatred will not do, then you will curse him with everything you've got from your resolve at saving who you came for and tenacity at stopping this Abomination from hurting anyone else. Rolling your shoulders and taking a deep breath your face to the dead stars above. You roar. A roar so unnatural and thunderous a mix between the Roar of a thousand monsters and the grinding of a million shards of steel. That the labyrinth shakes beneath your feet and the skies quake and quiver at your exhalation.
    [x] "Uriel, Uriel, Uriel."
    -[X] Lift the curse, then attack
    -[X]Sophia: Activate Adaptation, then teleport and attack in melee
    -[X]Molly: Switch to counterspelling support. Excellency if necessary.
    -[X]Others: Continue as per previous plan
    -[X]STUNT: You stare for a moment then shake your head. "Just the curse?" you say, conferring mentally with your companions "Okay." And as you relax your will, Sophia vanishes, reappearing behind a Hollow Man body in the distance with her sword already midswing
 
Back
Top