Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

Fixed, thanks. As for the spell, It is not as subtle as it could be, you are basically invoking calibration, the idea of imperfect boundaries and grey areas to pass boundaries. In a perfect world, one in which no one transgressed the spell would not work, in this one it has limited aiming possibilities since there is no actual Calibration for you guys to invoke.
Is there a Calibration in WoD?
 
Incidentally adaptation of Calling the Calibration Gate has been added to the character sheet. A bit less flexible than I was hoping.
It's interesting that CCG can't go to our hell because it's too far away, but it can punch its way out of Creation entirely.

That has some interesting implications about where Molly's is extruding into. I'd have thought her nearest neighbors would be the thousand hells, but I doubt they're further from the mortal world than the Outside.
 
Would someone with a fire weakness also have this happen instead of getting immunity to being burned if given a form of fire SP splendor?

Yes. If you are uniquely vulnerable to something splendors cannot make you immune, they just make you no longer as weak

Is there a Calibration in WoD?

No, but there used to be one in Exalted is what I meant, magic that invokes a set period of reality going strange works to a finer degree than making things up as you go along

It's interesting that CCG can't go to our hell because it's too far away, but it can punch its way out of Creation entirely.

That has some interesting implications about where Molly's is extruding into. I'd have thought her nearest neighbors would be the thousand hells, but I doubt they're further from the mortal world than the Outside.

That is more than Outside is a bigger target. If you could aim the gate into your own soul it would work at that as well, but in such a way as would provoke an immune response from your own exaltation. It is something Molly instinctively does not want to do.
 
That is more than Outside is a bigger target. If you could aim the gate into your own soul it would work at that as well, but in such a way as would provoke an immune response from your own exaltation. It is something Molly instinctively does not want to do.
What if we open the gate from inside our hell pointing at earth?
 
Votes tied
Adhoc vote count started by Yzarc on Nov 21, 2023 at 11:01 PM, finished with 67 posts and 15 votes.

  • [X] Plan Exalted Effort
    -[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)
    --[X] Head of Arianna Ortega (6th Generation Equivalent)
    --[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
    -[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
    --[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
    --[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
    -[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of bone, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
    --[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection, Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).
    [X] Tears of the Summer Lady
    [X] Plan Exalted Effort
    -[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)
    --[X] Head of Arianna Ortega (6th Generation Equivalent)
    --[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
    -[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
    --[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
    --[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
 
[X] Plan Exalted Effort
-[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)
--[X] Head of Arianna Ortega (6th Generation Equivalent)
--[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
-[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
--[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
--[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
-[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of bone, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
--[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection, Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).
 
My vote was counted without the stunt so it showed up at the very bottom.
[X] Plan Exalted Effort
-[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)

--[X] Head of Arianna Ortega (6th Generation Equivalent)
--[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
-[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
--[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
--[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
-[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of bone, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
--[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection,
Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).
 
We should bring Olivia with us to Las Vegas. After all she is magical stealthy as well and has been training with alien guns.

Of course we aren't actually bringing her to fight, but help us with leg work. You just know that we are going to need to cover extra ground.
 
It's important to note that, even leaving aside the iron thing, a 3 dot splendor is much, much more powerful than a 2 dot one. For a 2 dot splendor the attempt to resist possession or mind control in case of a multi-element attack, such as being struck with a cursed dagger, is made at DC8. For a 3 dot one with mystic fortification, it's DC5. And no, we can't Mystic Fortification into a 2 dot splendor - there's no room, as, I think, we can all agree that both possession and mind alteration protections are needed.

Furthermore, a 3 dot splendor adornment remains manifested for a week, while a 2 dot one only lasts for a day, meaning that it takes far less mana (or whatever it is the fae use as essence analog).

Basically, even if you want to use Lily's tears, add a vampiric elder head as well to boost it to three dots. It's a much better result for a small (relatively) expenditure of resources.

You go and argue in a tied vote for someone to make a plan on par with yours using the opposing plan's idea as a base and for some reason you don't mention that that could split the vote that is tied with yours and let your vote win?

Fine I'll do, but I'm not splitting the vote I already voted for.

[X] Tears of the Summer Lady

[X] Plan Red Adamantinum
-[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)

--[X] Tears of the Summer Lady
--[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
-[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
--[X] Tears of the Summer Lady: List of conspirators whose conspiracy caused the previous owner of this stained piece of cloth to turn into the Summer Lady
--[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
-[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of
bright red steel burning with an inner flame yet only conmofrtingly warm to the touch, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
--[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection,
Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).

Edit: Fuck it going for broke even if I will probably lose:

Red Admantinum is an obscure fantasy metal that requires the tears of an unforgiven soulless being to be forged and bright red steel is crumbly and brittle if forged poorly and yet it is made into good quality modern steel if forged properly. This fits Lily and her situation to a T.

Edit 2: Approval voting for a modified version of my plan:

[X] Plan Red Adamantinum v.2
 
Last edited:
You go and argue in a tied vote for someone to make a plan on par with yours using the opposing plan's idea as a base and for some reason you don't mention that that could split the vote that is tied with yours and let your vote win?
I'm not sure if you'll believe me, but vote splitting wasn't part of my thought process at all. I was arguing solely based on the intended outcome - that a 3 dot splendor is much stronger than a 2 dot one. I realize that not all participants are interested in crafting, and so I tried to outline the main core differences and the reasoning why it was worthwhile to pursue it.
 
Heh. :cry2: And here I went and ran my mouth when the other vote was actually already winning:

Adhoc vote count started by Dmol8 on Nov 22, 2023 at 1:26 AM, finished with 72 posts and 16 votes.

  • [X] Plan Exalted Effort
    -[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)
    --[X] Head of Arianna Ortega (6th Generation Equivalent)
    --[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
    -[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
    --[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
    --[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
    -[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of bone, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
    --[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection, Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).
    [X] Tears of the Summer Lady
    [X] Plan Red Adamantinum
    -[X] Use two foci to make a 3 dot splendor (Mystically fortified Protection against Possession, Mind Control, and Iron)
    --[X] Tears of the Summer Lady
    --[X] Red Court Elder Corpse (7th generation equivalent)
    -[X] Use the foci for Crown questions before using them for crafting
    --[X] Tears of the Summer Lady: List of conspirators whose conspiracy caused the previous owner of this stained piece of cloth to turn into the Summer Lady
    --[X] Red Court Elder: List of all covert Red Court agents
    -[X] STUNT: The form the charm takes under your hands is a that of a small, burrowing owl carved out of a single piece of bright red steel burning with an inner flame yet only conmofrtingly warm to the touch, so intricate as to seem alive and ready to take flight at any moment. The talisman, and it is clear that this is more than a mere decoration, hangs from a triple strand chain, links of your brass, summer fae gold, and human iron weaving around themselves in an alien facsimile of DNA, interlacing and reinforcing each other, all existing in perfect inseparable harmony. If one was to count them, there's precisely 125 links in each strand, threes and fives of Fates invoked together.
    --[X] Talisman Mechanics: 3 Dot Adornment Splendor: Form of Dreams and Nightmares, Form of Portentous Moonlight, Form of Steadfast Earth, Sacred Protection, Mystic Fortification (-2 DC on Willpower rolls to resist possession or mind-control including multi-element attacks).
 
Edit: Fuck it going for broke even if I will probably lose:

Red Admantinum is an obscure fantasy metal that requires the tears of an unforgiven soulless being to be forged and bright red steel is crumbly and brittle if forged poorly and yet it is made into good quality modern steel if forged properly. This fits Lily and her situation to a T.

This edit has been added to my vote to give an explanation of my thought process for it.
 
We should bring Olivia with us to Las Vegas. After all she is magical stealthy as well and has been training with alien guns.

Of course we aren't actually bringing her to fight, but help us with leg work. You just know that we are going to need to cover extra ground.
That's a very interesting idea. We might want to equip her with a no-possession talisman first (a 1 dot splendor), but yes, that's an idea, if we are going for stealth
 
OK expanding on that whole Red Admantinum thing.

It's made of 4 pieces:

- Some sort of Admant/Adamantium/Adamantinum ore which is just a fancy name for a special blend of Iron ore historically that could produce steel in more primitive forges.

- Some sort of Essence of Eternal Fire

- Some sort of Demonic Essence/Blood

- Tears of an Unforgiven Soulless Being. The Unforgiven part is sometimes not used.

Bright red steel with an inner fire that is comfortably warm to the touch sounds like what we are trying to make to help Lily.
 
VOTE
[X] Tears of the Summer Lady


RATIONALE
You're gonna make things for a Fae Queen, use materials that are appropriately aligned.
She wept. Use those.

And keep the Red Court reagents in the refridgerator. We might actually need them against the Red Court;
The Red King has one named daughter, and we killed her. I dont have any idea if we will ever stumble across any other reagents that are so clearly linked to the head of state of a supernatural power like this.


--[X] Arianna: Where are the gods that this one stolen from held?
Why?

Something that can be asked by visiting, or even finding a picture of any of the old temples of the MayaAztec pantheons and using that as a focus; Google says there's at least 200 of them. And thats not counting their authentic idols in museums.
Or using a picture of that artifact we let Seeker have as a focus.

You're just burning shit to burn shit at this point.
 
Why?

Something that can be asked by visiting, or even finding a picture of any of the old temples of the MayaAztec pantheons and using that as a focus; Google says there's at least 200 of them. And thats not counting their authentic idols in museums.
Or using a picture of that artifact we let Seeker have as a focus.

You're just burning shit to burn shit at this point.
This question is better addressed to me, since I proposed it. What w9uld you suggest as an alternative?

Also, we need multiple foci to mount a proper rescue operation for the gods. Where are they held, how are they guarded, what is their condition, etc. I doubt mundane desecrated temples will hell us much.
RATIONALE
You're gonna make things for a Fae Queen, use materials that are appropriately aligned.
She wept. Use those.
Counter-argument 1: mechanically, there's no difference, and Red Court heads are easier to get.

Counter-argument 2: even if you want to use tears, pushing for a 3 dot splendor is much, much better. For the cost of a single 1 dot splendor you get a result that's much more powerful.

Counter-argument that requires a ruling: @DragonParadox are reagent sets a thing, where a total of several components is more than the sum of its parts? Ie, for example, if we got a similar focus from Maeve, or if we gathered a lady-queen-mother set, would the total power of the foci be more than the sum of the separate power foci?
 
Last edited:
Counter-argument that requires a ruling: @DragonParadox are reagent sets a thing, where a total of several components is more than the sum of its parts? Ie, for example, if we got a similar focus from Maeve, or if we gathered a lady-queen-mother set, would the total power of the foci be more than the sum of the separate power foci?

Conceivably if you were making a manse or something else that is off your current scale, but as you are operating on now, no.
 
This question is better addressed to me, since I proposed it. What w9uld you suggest as an alternative?

Also, we need multiple foci to mount a proper rescue operation for the gods. Where are they held, how are they guarded, what is their condition, etc. I doubt mundane desecrated temples will hell us much.
1)Why would we mount a rescue operation? Why is this even a priority?
Have you actually looked up the history of some of the Mayan Pantheon that were usurped? Or why noone intervened on their behalf when the Reds grabbed them? We certainly havent done the research IC.

They were not necessarily good people, nor is unleashing them on modern Mexican society necessarily a good thing.


2) Even if we wanted to? We are not mounting a rescue operation for the gods in the short to medium term.
Which means that whatever information this is will quite likely be obsolete by the time we actually have the ability to do anything about it. The setting is not static.


3) Like I said, short of getting our hands on the Red King himself, Arianna Ortega is possibly the highest tier Red Court information and sorcerous focus we are likely to get in the short to medium term, and there is a war on where that might be useful. Especially since Divination Magic is something thats up for us to learn.

Even the Lords of Outer Night are not likely to be as good links to the head of the Red Court as his own daughter is.

What you are suggesting is the magical equivalent of melting down boy-Pharoah Tutankhamun's mask for the gold it was made of.
Sure the gold is valuable.
But the gold is but a fraction of the market value of the artifact itself.


Counter-argument 1: mechanically, there's no difference, and Red Court heads are easier to get.
1) There is no mechanical difference between a 10 kilogram lump of gold and Tutankhamun's funerary mask.
Melted down, they have the same value.
That does not mean they are equivalent.

Similarly, all that it says it that Arianna's head can be melted down for X amount of magical mojo.
It makes no assignation to value of the head itself.


2) Red Court heads are easier to get, because making and replacing mooks is fairly straightforward for the Reds.
Red Court elder heads? Much less so.
It's telling that Morgan cutting down a Duke and two Counts was counted as a big deal in canon.

A low-generation equivalent Rampire elder is not exactly something you can find on a street corner; they didnt get to become elders by making a habit of putting themselves where you can stab them.
The one saving grace there is that most arent unique, and are more or less interchangeable.

Not like Arianna, daughter of the Red King is.


Counter-argument 2: even if you want to use tears, pushing for a 3 dot splendor is much, much better. For the cost of a single 1 dot splendor you get a result that's much more powerful.
I dont especially agree. Not in this case.
There is such a thing as overdoing stuff, especially when it comes to the balance of power between two Fae Courts.

Besides, splendors are explicitly upgradeable.
There is nothing preventing you adding a feature to a 2-dot in the future if we are so inclined and get the resources/an appropriate reagent then.

Counter-argument that requires a ruling: @DragonParadox are reagent sets a thing, where a total of several components is more than the sum of its parts? Ie, for example, if we got a similar focus from Maeve, or if we gathered a lady-queen-moyher set, would the total power of the foci be more than the sum of the separate power foci?
As the QM has confirmed, not a medium term issue.
 
Last edited:
1)Why would we mount a rescue operation? Why is this even a priority?
Have you actually looked up the history of some of the Mayan Pantheon that were usurped? Or why noone intervened on their behalf when the Reds grabbed them? We certainly havent done the research IC.

They were not necessarily good people, nor is unleashing them on modern Mexican society necessarily a good thing.
As a way to cripple Red Court power in a way that doesn't necessarily produce immediate apocalyptic response. And yes, I realize that, at least by modern standards, mayan and aztec gods are most likely complete monsters. They are still unlikely to be worse than Red Court, and only saving good people from underserved eternal suffering is a slippery slope I don't like. Strategically, rescuing them gives us allies, or at least removes a power source from Red Court. Possibly removes a large part of their strategic magical capability, if they are piggy backing on stolen divinity.
3) Like I said, short of getting our hands on the Red King himself, Arianna Ortega is possibly the highest tier Red Court information and sorcerous focus we are likely to get in the short to medium term, and there is a war on where that might be useful. Especially since Divination Magic is something thats up for us to learn.

Even the Lords of Outer Night are not likely to be as good links to the head of the Red Court as his own daughter is.
Any Red Court elder should do for any strategic intelligence question about red Court, like a random warden netted us all the traitors in White Council. Unless you are suggesting reviving and interrogating her somehow, Arianna is only exceptionally valuable for stuff she, and not Red Court in general, participated in. And only for one question.

And I am still not seeing an alternative proposal. Simply letting her sit in the fridge is not using her for maximum benefit. And, even all that aside, if you are using Lily's tears, at least ask for the list of Nemesis-infected in Summer Court.
1) There is no mechanical difference between a 10 kilogram lump of gold and Tutankhamun's funerary mask.
Melted down, they have the same value.
That does not mean they are equivalent.

Similarly, all that it says it that Arianna's head can be melted down for X amount of magical mojo.
It makes no assignation to value of the head itself.
No, mechanically for the purpose of crafting, there's no difference. Arianna doesn't provide us a better focus for crafting red-court related splendor, and Lily's tears aren't providing us a better focus for this talisman. Unless I am wrong. @DragonParadox is there some sort of resonance here where Lily's tears would be more valuable / be able to provide a better reagent than normal when used for the kind of the talisman we are making?
I dont especially agree. Not in this case.
There is such a thing as overdoing stuff, especially when it comes to the balance of power between two Fae Courts.
There is overdoing things, but this is very much not the case here. The counter to overdoing things here (and getting Lily's favor), is making a similar thing for Maeve, and getting her gratitude too.

In this case I firmly believe that we should be pushing for maximum effort. Right now both Summer and Winter ladies are ill-suited for their roles, and there's no inherent mechanism to fixing the situation (or at least none that are morally acceptable to me). Thus, it falls to us to help.
As the QM has confirmed, not a medium term issue.
But a long-term one. I very much want to try making a manse. The promised benefits are large enough that it's worth the effort, and this means starting to prepare and gather resources.
 
No, mechanically for the purpose of crafting, there's no difference. Arianna doesn't provide us a better focus for crafting red-court related splendor, and Lily's tears aren't providing us a better focus for this talisman. Unless I am wrong. @DragonParadox is there some sort of resonance here where Lily's tears would be more valuable / be able to provide a better reagent than normal when used for the kind of the talisman we are making?

In terms of that the Spelndor would do on its own, no, it does what it says.

The implications are more political, if you use the tears it means you no longer have them as a focus for divination or general thaumaturgy, which would almost certainly make Molly look more reliable to the Summer Court. Using vampire bits on the other hand projects strength, 'look at what I have killed'. Also on a personal level Lilly might be more comfortable with the tears than the distilled bat-horror essence, but that is very much secondary to her desperate need to have something that allows her to hang on to who she is.

There is also the possibility that Lilly could eventually learn to use the Splendor for some kind of fey magic, but that is again in the long term, depends on how she wrangles her mantle and a whole lot of things Molly does not have the information to make a good guess at.
 
Back
Top