Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

I have a question: does Rendered Villain Dispersal hide Molly's aura? Can Michael on the car get to the captives stealthily with Molly in a bottle?
 
I have a question: does Rendered Villain Dispersal hide Molly's aura? Can Michael on the car get to the captives stealthily with Molly in a bottle?
It disperses it over the volume of liquid we hide in, from my understanding.

Anyway... @DragonParadox when you return - do we have any focus for Alec or Izzy? The idea is we spend a mote to ask "does the captor of the person shown here knows that Molly Carpenter is not in NeverNever?". If yes, answer, if no, ignore for element of surprise.

Alternative approach is to roll empathy and intimidate. I mean, social-specked exalt. It might work if we try well enough.
 
[X] Don't answer, keep him guessing until Harry gets here

Better not to hear the threats.
 
we can look at our phone and Ask A Question about our caller. any ideas? also we need a mage to create a sep field and a distraction.ghouls can survive car crashes,right? sreal two cars, let twoof them crash into each other nearby.use the moment to create sep field and safe the hostages
 
Last edited:
we can look at our phone and Ask A Question about our caller. any ideas? also we need a mage to create a sep field and a distraction.ghouls can survive car crashes,right? sreal two cars, let twoof them crash into each other nearby.use the moment to create sep field and safe the hostages
I guess that we can ask for the caller's current location.
 
Can we ask Murphy to stop the traffic, we have photoes of them and we know where they are so we can just stop the traffic and shoot the driver with a snipper??

Ed: Or send a cyber devil to take control of It and make it crash with a building
 
Last edited:
I tried to be thematic. LIke, for the transfromation amulet that turns someone into a living diamond-skinned golem, a memorial diamond made out of a naagloshii's heart seems ldeal. Our blood, ok, I'll get rid of it. Mechanically there's no support for it, not when making a splendor. When making a prodigy this is basically how they are made, though. So, one might argue that by fulfilling one more creation step (if for an adjacent class of objects) we might be able to improve the power / quality of the splendor.
Some of that is fair, and covered under the resource dot requirements for the projects. I just take issue with the unnecessary risks in some of it or spending rare resources we don't have to on flavor.

Magical jade is going to be hard to acquire, when we use it it should be to do something. Like how the gossamer is likely to be key to making at least one splendor work.

I appreciate you going the extra mile, it certainly makes the items better, I just don't want new attack surfaces or waste.


Well, it's kinda like a shintai? No shintai aspects, which can be really powerful. Superhuman, yes, but focused superhuman. Expensive to make also.

Also, splendors and arcana are unique. It's in the rules. So, yeah, we might be able to make one behemoth that can tank what even we can throw (13 to 16 soak dice rolled at -3 difficulty, can soak agg), but we can only make one. Ever. Here:
Yeah, but I still think it's worth noting and perhaps avoiding making something that outplays our own core features. Not to hoard power, but because outdoing an exaltation in this manner seems like a red flag.

The issue is that "give people ability to lucid dream" or similar is mechanically described as "give someone oneiromancy 1", and that's splendor.
There's some overlap, but the similarities don't necessarily mean only one side can perform particular functions.

The 3 dot prodigy example is a minor Time Machine:

Midnight Clock (•••)
This ornately-tooled, gold-inlaid grandfather clock's bodywork is decorated with fanciful depictions of monsters creeping out from behind bushes, clouds, and tombstones. When its hands are dialed forward to 12:00, the clock and everyone in the same room with it are all snapped forward in time to precisely midnight. It does not require attunement, but may only be used by one of the Exalted.
That doesn't mean such effects are solely the domain of prodigies though.
Personally I would make the use something that deals with signet ring's main mundane function - that being a stamp. Hmm... interesting functionality, active use, dream focus (I agree, that's reasonable). Hmm, how about "when stamped onto a text, the wearer of the ring will dream the text's contents the next time they go to sleep". Or, if we go with more powerful version "the wearer of the ring and everyone who have put their signatures to the text". Story-wise that enables some interesting investigations and practically, gives the user ability to train in dreams by using various novels.
That's neat, but I'd limit it to the user. Group stuff is flagged as cause to spike the rating, and we already need a reagent and flaws to make a 3 dot effect work for a mortal.
"Where are you going?" you ask under your breath as the vision fades... then you realize the trick, though it does not make you feel any better. it is not going anywhere, just driving around busy streets where any show of magic would have dozens, hundreds of witnesses, not to mention each and every one of those people could be a hostage in a pinch if Broken Seeker should choose to unleash his power or his servants. You can run down any one of them, Hank proved that much, but all of them?
Depending on the exact model of car I think we could pull a nasty cyber Devil trick.

The air conditioning system and air flow for the engine intake are different, but they have libes running near each other.

Force a vent valve error like one of these and then burst a heating line in the right place relative to the compressor by playing with the pressure.

That lets you pass fuel-air mix through a computer controlled heating element, which could be overheated at the last mile to spray fire into the driver and passenger seats without hitting the back.

We pick a place where their aren't many people around, then fry them while maneuvering them off the road.
 
Can we ask Murphy to stop the traffic, we have photoes of them and we know where they are so we can just stop the traffic and shoot the driver with a snipper??

Ed: Or send a cyber devil to take control of It and make it crash with a building
That does kind of get her in trouble when shit inevitably blows up. Could see her demoted.
 
Blue, green, muddy and clear, filled with life and lifeless cold, you pass from one patch of water to another at first crossing the length of the Atlantic in a single bound then paying your respect to the rivers snaking inwards towards familiar lake Michigan.
As an aside, it's too bad we were so on task for this; turning the Atlantic Ocean into one big eye must be a real head trip.

We can just say fuck the masquerade and we jump him anyway. Like who is going to punish us.
Politics mostly. No masquerade police exist* to smack us down exactly, but people will be less willing to work with us.

* other than the usual whoever's around, learns of it in time, and thinks they can do something about it, but this is happening too fast for that to be a concern.

I have a question: does Rendered Villain Dispersal hide Molly's aura? Can Michael on the car get to the captives stealthily with Molly in a bottle?
It's nominal purpose is to hide us, so it has some coverage, but I think we have WoG that it isn't perfect. Supernatural senses pointed the right way could catch us.
don't particularly care about her career. Its just a job.
It also gives the game away early. The cops need time to move and our association is a known factor.

Ideally we want to strike in the uncertainty band where BS doesn't know we're active.
 
[X] Don't answer, keep him guessing until Harry gets here

I can't imagine anything we could say or hear here that would be worth it to give away that we are already in Chicago.

Do we actually want to maintain the masquerade?

If we don't, then I think we would still want prepared and controlled disclosure on our terms. Preferably after we have gotten human magic users more organized, figured out a better way to police warlocks and how to handle diplomacy between humans and non-humans, and have beneficial magical products to offer to mundanes, to avoid magic being seen as only a threat.

Making magical violence and collateral damage - and the freaking skinwalkers - mundane humanity's first introduction to the magical world is going to greatly increase the chance it will go for the full anti-supernatural witch hunt mode reaction, not handle things rationally.

So it's less about "who will punish us", but more if we want to be responsible for things likely going to shit.
 
Last edited:
If we don't, then I think we would still want prepared and controlled disclosure on our terms. Preferably after we have gotten human magic users more organized, figured out a better way to police warlocks and how to handle diplomacy between humans and non-humans, and have beneficial magical products to offer to mundanes, to avoid magic being seen as only a threat.
Formalizing the mundane material anti-magic design process could also be key.

Even if it's not as good without our direct effort, being able to personally do something that technically helps is a balm to paranoia and likely very useful on low level threats.

Learning someone could kill you by jinxing your car without anyone being able to stop or notice it scary, but would feel a lot less helplessly so if the next model year of you car is rated up to minor sorcerer level resistance. Just to name one example.
Pretty much this.
Naagloshi counts on us going to some lengths to not reveal magic...
And I honestly do not care.

Now, all the bystanders being potential hostages is a problem for Molly, but actually not using magic fearing its reveal far less so, in my opinion.
Worth noting he thinks we'll value it because most of the people breaking it rightfully see it as a tool for spreading death and chaos at industrial levels.

It can't stay forever, but just destroying it without a real management strategy in place is taking a moral stand on a pretty sizable corpse pile.
 
Now, all the bystanders being potential hostages is a problem for Molly, but actually not using magic fearing its reveal far less so, in my opinion.

The thing is Masquerade itself has potential "hostages" - peaceful non-humans and low-level human talents, or even just some neo-pagans/New Agers mistaken for real magic users.

Even if most of humanity would take a sudden violent disclosure well (which itself is unlikely, compared to lashing out in panic), authoritarian and theocratic governments could still perform some serious atrocities as a result.

And we have done no prep work to even try to handle any of it.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, but I still think it's worth noting and perhaps avoiding making something that outplays our own core features. Not to hoard power, but because outdoing an exaltation in this manner seems like a red flag.
Let me flip this argument on its head. 4 and 5 dot Splendor and Arcana crafting are pretty much the epitome of Exalted wonderforging. There's nothing more complex, hard, and expensive (in time, essence and rare resources) that an exalt can make. Exaltation are vestiges of the Age of Legends, yes, but if an exalt, when going all out, and doing the hardest possible ting, can't make something that even approaches them in one specific area? That's pretty sad. The level of accomplishment should be represented by the level of effort, and making high level splendors is absolutely something that requires a lot of effort, and thus deserving a good result.

Which is to say that I think spending hard-to-get unique resources, AP (probably multiple ones at that, quite possibly) and in-game effort should allow us to make individuals capable of standing somewhat on par with us in some ways. It's a result of more than a year of real life questing, after all.
Magical jade is going to be hard to acquire, when we use it it should be to do something. Like how the gossamer is likely to be key to making at least one splendor work.
Gossamer is almost certainly going to be the core of the ring, it maps just so well, there's no other choice in my mind. As to where to get jade - I expect Odin's elves to be able to sell us some for money.
That's neat, but I'd limit it to the user. Group stuff is flagged as cause to spike the rating, and we already need a reagent and flaws to make a 3 dot effect work for a mortal.
Yeah, ok, user-limited "experience the text written and stamped" effect seems reasonable.
 
[x] Plan sudden Reversal.
-[x] Use Hollow Mind Possession on the Network tower, that Izzy phone uses, have it track Broken Seeker location.
-[x] Fly to the hostages while Dresden and Micheal head to Broken Seeker location.
-[x] Once Dresden and Micheal are in position, comedown and slice the roof off the van, and grab the hostages, while knocking out the thugs, and get out drop then off somewhere out of the way. Then fly to link up with Dresden and Micheal, time to end Broken Seeker

If clippy can send an out of area message, it will know the correct network tower to take over. And the tower will be linked to the Izzy phone, and know it location. Get the hostages, to safety they cannot see Molly come down out of the sky. Once they are safe, we will be ready to take out Broken Seeker.
 
Last edited:
Worth noting he thinks we'll value it because most of the people breaking it rightfully see it as a tool for spreading death and chaos at industrial levels.

It can't stay forever, but just destroying it without a real management strategy in place is taking a moral stand on a pretty sizable corpse pile.
And even in the books there were partly very noticeable masquerade violations that amounted to pretty much nothing.
Now, I am not insistent on going loud throwing explicit magic everywhere, but I would certainly not decline a plan because of it being blatantly magical.

Otherwise relying on Molly's unwillingness to do obvious magic would become a very tempting go to strategy for any future adversary.
 
Last edited:
And even in the books there were partly very noticeable masquerade violations that amounted to pretty much nothing.
Now, I am not insistent on going loud throwing explicit magic everywhere, but I would certainly not decline a plan because of it being blatantly magical.

Otherwise relying on Molly's unwillingness to do obvious magic would become a very tempting go to strategy for any future adversary.
It's not like our hands are tied, we just need to be a little careful.

I already posted a low impact strategy that still involves using demon summoning to kit bash flame throwers while performing a hijacking. Not exactly denying ourselves the use of supernatural power here.

Let me flip this argument on its head. 4 and 5 dot Splendor and Arcana crafting are pretty much the epitome of Exalted wonderforging. There's nothing more complex, hard, and expensive (in time, essence and rare resources) that an exalt can make. Exaltation are vestiges of the Age of Legends, yes, but if an exalt, when going all out, and doing the hardest possible ting, can't make something that even approaches them in one specific area? That's pretty sad. The level of accomplishment should be represented by the level of effort, and making high level splendors is absolutely something that requires a lot of effort, and thus deserving a good result.
We're not autobot, some things are beyond reach.
 
Can we ask Murphy to stop the traffic, we have photoes of them and we know where they are so we can just stop the traffic and shoot the driver with a snipper??

Ed: Or send a cyber devil to take control of It and make it crash with a building

I highly doubt Murphy, a fairly low ranking and not popular member of the police, has the authority to suddenly shut down traffic just on her say so. This sort of thing generally requires time since everyone drives.
 
Back
Top