Why does everyone choose the delivery of owls instead of N.E.W.T? Do not think that I am against it, but after all, the delivery of N.E.W.T. is the same as the owls, only much cooler.


It's hard for new voters to find write-ins which gets buried in between pages after reading an update. Also once the majority commits to something it's difficult to sway them over to a vote with relatively few voters.

Looks like we aren't looking for the Chosen then. I hope Neville puts more effort on finding them - it's his guardian given task. If he dithers then he deserves to get swallowed at convocation. Everyone needs to pull their weight.

I'm pretty hopeful about the House Fealty Perk. Maybe we can take the Dementor visit perk again and get some more insight on the lore. It could help us Hatch and narrow down the others too possibly.
 
Last edited:
It's hard for new voters to find write-ins which gets buried in between pages after reading an update. Also once the majority commits to something it's difficult to sway them over to a vote with relatively few voters.

Looks like we aren't looking for the Chosen then. I hope Neville puts more effort on finding them - it's his guardian given task. If he dithers then he deserves to get swallowed at convocation. Everyone needs to pull their weight.

I'm pretty hopeful about the House Fealty Perk. Maybe we can take the Dementor visit perk again and get some more insight on the lore. It could help us Hatch and narrow down the others too possibly.
Neville deserves to die anyway.
Is the arrival of a dementor connected with the privilege of Loyalty to the House? I thought our choice only affected Harry's memories of this meeting.
 
It came after we took the From You Six Thousand Year Ago feat.

I'm all for brutally sacrificing Neville.. but the Convocation endgame seems to be a team effort. He is supposed to find the others who would offer their pieces of the puzzle. Then Harry and the Chosen would know their Enemy and deal with the threat.

Otherwise it might blissfully pass by them and then it would be too late to do anything about it. Quest end.

Ugh we have been too passive, we should have followed through the dungeon ages ago and finished the Ring arc way before now. We could have then tailored our build accordingly to the threat.
 
Last edited:
[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.

[X] Hermetic Attainment

[X] Singularity Attainment
 
Anyone who is choosing for harry to take his OWLs should instead have him do his N.E.W.T Birdsie said he could do it and it is way more impressive then him doing his OWLs and it won't cost more for us to do
 
Last edited:
McGonagall will laugh at you, of course

"Look at this eleven-year-old thinking he's fly enough to take NEWTs with the big kids"
but she can't actually refuse you if you submit the proper paperwork

she'll shake her head
she'll beg the Headmaster
she'll beg Sirius
to talk some sense into you
because you're putting your future in serious jeopardy
she will cry as they take you into the classroom

she will be stunned when you emerge with a paper graded 'O'
honestly, that grade will match her facial expression excellently
 
Last edited:
Us taking and passing the N.E.W.T would be a major reputation boost. Even Dumbledore and The Dark Lord likely didn't do something like this when they went to Hogwarts
 
This is one of the few moments for Harry when he can step out of the shadow of his own fame. Let's do it, it doesn't cost us anything.
 
The challenge with getting him to do it is that a lot of people don't know about the option and so are choosing OWLs instead even though is the worst option of the two
 
Informing people of the option by talking about it on the Quest form and discord would help. If someone logs on now and sees what we are talking about they may change their vote
 
Last edited:
I believe that there is a benefit to taking Frenzy over Rending; that being the 2x multiplier from Frenzy for further Astrology progress. Admittedly, I'm a bit iffy on whether on whether 'All subsequent progression in that field is made faster and easier' bit would apply to unravel the mysteries of the Impossible Perfection, or if that just applies to grinding up skill level, but if it does help with Impossible Perfection then throwing another multiplier on there would be quite huge.

You'd already have a pretty wild x10 multiplier and a x2 multiplier on Impossible Perfection isn't much compared to spending 25 Gnosis on it. Consider how many Excelsiors would be required to match up to a single Eternal [Subject] Mastery, for example. Especially given how immediately you'd need those benefits.

The Goal of All Life Is Death

Thinking about other builds.

[D] Plan Recursive Empowerment
-[D] Heavenly Sovereign (Permanent Self-Enhancement Magic)
-[D] Supernova Attainment

Given the description of Supernova with regards to Dark Arts i.e. that we could execute basically any illegal effect, despite our middling DA skills, I'm inclined to believe it allows us to cast anything that our Magical Power could cast, as long as it falls within our Domains of Greatness. That being the case, picking this option opens up a recursive self-improvement loop, where we can execute all the rituals Geist used to empower himself without actually needing the relevant magical skills to learn them, thus unlocking more rituals to execute. Given the relatively narrow scope of this Domain, I don't think it would be disempowered in the way that a Domain like Spells would be. With that in mind, we could open up bonuses from Transfiguration, Occulemency, Potions and Alchemy, to unlock more and more and more improvements to make. By the end of it, we'd might be able to punch out a giant physically and cast at the absolute peak of human potential magically. We'd still need the skills to back that up, but honestly, raw power can make up for a lot.

This is even better than it sounds, since we'd be able to achieve effects that would otherwise be impractical or morally abhorrent to achieve, like some rituals that would require the sacrifice of a thousand people, since we're just actualizing them through sheer willpower. It's probably got somewhat less absolute long term potential than the Singularity build but skipping ahead of the curve like this opens up so many new opportunities that could make up for it.

Alternatively, take Apparition as the Domain instead, perform DA self-enhancement, and then see if we can't make our way to the Celestial Realms for all the sweet loot there anyway.

What a caveman strategy!
 
Last edited:
Supernova has a no future potential because we lose the power as time goes on so we get weaker over time not stronger. That is why so many people did not pike it and instead pikes perks that we get to keep

Birdsie decried Singularity as the choice that would give us the same amount of potential as Supernova but for the long term but it's Perinate
 
[X] Plan Not Dying

[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.

Hopefully this fixes my vote being counted strangely.
 
I've updated the color post to include the write-in, but the things that I actually care to vote for are here:

[X] Unoculaic Attainment
[X] Hermetic Attainment [50 Gnosis]

This combination races to give Harry the perception abilities that canon Dumbledore used in the seaside cave to find a boat across the Inferi Lake. Unoculaic Attainment is the option that leans into L O R E for our existing quest hooks, and given that we know peak astrology is reflected by sky writing, I am certain that specializing in reading symbols will be profitable in the long run.

Hermetic is chosen as a compromise between the thread's addiction to buying +Potential blurbs and the thread's impending spanking by the Apocryphal Curse.



Unfortunately, I am pretty sure that the mechanically correct choice in Rihaku-Adjacent quests is to Rank Up, namely:
[ ] Singularity Attainment
[ ] Hermetic Attainment [50 Gnosis]
 
This is one of the few moments for Harry when he can step out of the shadow of his own fame. Let's do it, it doesn't cost us anything.
There is opportunity cost. For example, we could spend the write in on searching for Hufflepuff's ring instead, or gearing up for a conflict with all the sneaky tricks we can make, beg, buy, or borrow.

Passing the NEWT as a 1st year is pretty amazing, but don't lose sight of our priorities; survival and success.
 
There is opportunity cost. For example, we could spend the write in on searching for Hufflepuff's ring instead, or gearing up for a conflict with all the sneaky tricks we can make, beg, buy, or borrow.

Passing the NEWT as a 1st year is pretty amazing, but don't lose sight of our priorities; survival and success.
It won't work. There is too much preponderance of votes in the direction of passing the owl exam.
 
[X] Plan Not Dying

[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.
 
[X] Plan Not Dying
[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.
 
[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.

EDIT: ...I didn't click post reply why did this send
 
[X] Focus on finding the Chosen with Neville and the inner circle members. Do the absolute minimum necessary for classwork and attendance this month. Try to use the Star of the Chosen to divine who they are, see if you can use the Maurader's map and Ornias' assistance as well.
 
Back
Top