Rings and Grudges (A LOTR/Warhammer Fantasy Crossover)

[X] Gondorian Captain (Martial Skill 14) (Scorned Nobility – Will make it harder for you to gain good relations with the rest of Gondor as the Nobility distrust you.)
fuck pride get me a commander that knows what he is doing
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.

Because I like strong women

[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
[X] Snap Aragost out of it and get him thinking (Martial skill 7)
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
I would also look into writing more omakes.

You got lucky this turn we had so many in stockpile to prevent significant casualties to the throng. And we managed to save Arassuil.

I have at least 2 planned, however I'd recommend people start writing.
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something


for omake ideas I'm a bit tapped out
 
I have a question about Veterancy bonuses, we have a bonus from the War against Chaos that is slowly going away. Do the battles we are currently fighting contribute to any form of veterancy? are our warriors more experienced thanks to being blooded in multiple battles?
Thats currently being decided. I am of the opinion it should reflect the veterancy of the throng. The more casualties you have, the more verterancy you lose. The less casualties you take, while winning/fighting battles the higher the veterancy of the unit.

I am also of the opinion that we start making elite formations outside of just the grumbling guard to retain the chaos war verterancy, and look for means of increasing the warriors/quarrelers veterancy.


Understand if not for the debacle against the 'True Orcs'/black orcs you still would have the war against chaos bonus for longer. However we took a lot of casualties in that war.

One thing that could be argued is that most of our casualties so far have been beardlings. Not full beards or elders, so maybe we can retain the bonus for longer. But outside of making formations, I don't think that will count.

We should also look into militarised use of engineers. Which I think Madslayer and myself forgot to incorporate during this phase of the battle. (we brought 5 grudegraker wielding engineers and not a single one was used so far in the turns, despite how deadly they would be). If this is true, I'll haggle with Madslayer on whether we should go over the battle again, with their addition (all the other results are primarily the same, but with the addition of the engineers to assist with withdrawrals which are what primarily caused the deaths of Halton and his men - I had made inquests in to the use of the Steelbow Rangers [various tricks up their sleeves] but we couldn't think of anything they would currently do that they wouldn't think of as 'orcs work').

EDIT: Do note, the grudgerakers mentioned may be crank-guns, due to mislabeling (we'd been talking about engineers heading to the colony due to the high number of corsair attacks, so they could test their weapons, though this could also be just what sort of weapons the engineers had lying spare. Regardless we have far more than the 4 engineers necessary to man the cannon, that could participate in the battle with their personal weapons)
 
Last edited:
I have a question about Veterancy bonuses, we have a bonus from the War against Chaos that is slowly going away. Do the battles we are currently fighting contribute to any form of veterancy?

It will, though with your clan having been so small I did not have the chance to break up the groups a point that it is reaching now though it will be possible for your clan, the Ered luin dwarfs are very far below the standard in terms of training and experience for you guys so will take longer to get the experience they need, still, when I do create regiments(You guys can name them) They will be split between Old World and Arda Groups (Old world veterans will understandably have the better bonuses and DC in battle while those who have only fought in Arda While leagues better due to both training and equipment might still get slightly lower bonuses or the same and a lower DC count for their losses and injuries)

(After the additions to the population were made because of the imbalance early on that was gonna cause issues,(Check turn 4 added an additional 50 dwarfs and more Garazi) your clan arrived with 210 Veterans from the old world of which 201 are alive (The Majority lost were apart of the Rangers) (So your Throngs Actually Grown a fair bit as it sits just above 260 despite nearly having lost 32 dawi since arriving)(this does not include the losses for this battle)

Which I think Madslayer and myself forgot to incorporate during this phase of the battle.

They were used and since they're a shotgun equivalent are in the front, they will play a larger roll now that the grumbling guard not gonna be stuck in melee.
 
Last edited:
Doesn't that go against the Spirit of the whole thing? As in, the GM outright told us not to play and abuse the omakes System for points?
That was something dedicated to Fool, as he has a bad habit of spamming omakes attempting to derail plots or force in his own characters, and reposting ones he's posted in other quests/threads.

Its also to to prevent us from just making a ton of omakes, to make sure that we give a bonus to everything. (reaching 4 omake bonuses and you get a reroll). I believe we had a case like this back in Dawi Change the Game during a particularly bad winter turn (Madslayer waved it due to the circumstances).
 
Last edited:
Anyone else notice how the Tharbad Guard was consistently rolling 110+ during the battle?
Sheer dumb luck, and them being probably the most elite dunedain unit we've got available till Arnor kicks off (no Arthedain knights, or Sons of Numenor just yet). This partially from training and heritage, but mainly because they have access to Tharbads Millenia of Numenorean weapons and armor.

Your lucky Arassuil's role playing as a Cardolan warlord/chief. That steel is what prevented him from getting instadeathed
 
Last edited:
Sheer dumb luck, and them being probably the most elite dunedain unit we've got available till Arnor kicks off (no Arthedain knights, or Sons of Numenor just yet). This partially from training and heritage, but mainly because they have access to Tharbads Millenia of Numenorean weapons and armor.

Your lucky Arassuil's role playing as a Cardolan warlord/chief. That steel is what prevented him from getting instadeathed

Just saying, they're the real MVP of this fight.
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
[X] Lady Baheriel, she seems to at least have a head for battle (Martial Skill 11) (Burned Pride- Will make actions with Rosse Lond harder for the next decade as Aragost is insulted at having his wife put over him.
[X] The Western Wall Where the corsairs look to be preparing something
 
The thunderers should get a veterancy bonus before anyone else, they took basicaly 0 casualities.
also I got two omake at least, I wil write them even if I were to post them after the vote.
 
Last edited:
You've got an interlude where you strategise with the 'new commander' before we start our next phase of the battle. any navy related ones would also be welcome.
 
When is the next battle turn gonna be by the way
We may have an interlude out today (for you guys) where you'll make more advanced decisions on the future battle.

After that maybe another day or two. Really it's up to MadSlayer I'm just going off what I've heard from him before he went to bed yesterday.

He's currently working on mountains of mourn
 
Last edited:
Back
Top