Ya know, if the book is well written enough, doing things by the book tends to actually be the superior option. The reason it often isn't (in stories and reality) tends to be bad (or good but antiquated) bureaucracy , unanticipated situations... or bad writing. Yrs doesn't do bad writing, and Shenhua doesn't do bad bureaucracy, and in a cultivator world I imagine the threshold for unanticipated is much, much higher.
The theoretical "book" would almost certainly tell Xia Lin that Ling Qi, as the trained scout with field experience who was already in command, should have stayed in command here.
Xia Lin is not a natural scout. She is a member (or an officer) in a specialist formation that relies on a very synchronous set of arts to be as effective as they are. I've no doubt that she has received some form of command training. If we had a block of people here then I'd probably put her in command. I'd even say that given command of a group of scouts she would be able to deploy them to good effect. But we don't have a group, we aren't looking at a map working out where best to deploy our forces.
We have 2 people to investigate a potentially hostile enemy base. One of them is a trained scout with experience infiltrating hostile or potentially hostile areas. The other is part of a heavy assault formation, with arts suited to that. Who has the greater applicable experience here should be obvious.
Xia Lin still has relevant experience to contribute, such as her knowledge of the setup of military outposts or likely general protocol. But she doesn't have any compelling experience that should mean she takes over command.
Theoretical knowledge is good, but generally theoretical knowledge + practical experience is better, as it means you know when to deviate from the standard answer. Ling Qi has the knowledge, she completed the Sect's scout training. But she also has the field experience. Xia Lin doesn't, and her training was almost certainly focused more strongly on other areas.*
Honestly, if we drop Xia Lin into command here when we're probably better suited for it I half expect it to decrease out team cohesion. She seems strongly goal oriented, and dropping her into command when we're in our area of expertise whilst dealing with potential enemies of the state because we wanted her to feel more valuable is both bad for the mission and kind of patronising.
*Because you don't need or want your commanders to be expert in every job, just to have a good understanding of how to use them.
The theoretical "book" would almost certainly tell Xia Lin that Ling Qi, as the trained scout with field experience who was already in command, should have stayed in command here.
Xia Lin is not a natural scout. She is a member (or an officer) in a specialist formation that relies on a very synchronous set of arts to be as effective as they are. I've no doubt that she has received some form of command training. If we had a block of people here then I'd probably put her in command. I'd even say that given command of a group of scouts she would be able to deploy them to good effect. But we don't have a group, we aren't looking at a map working out where best to deploy our forces.
We have 2 people to investigate a potentially hostile enemy base. One of them is a trained scout with experience infiltrating hostile or potentially hostile areas. The other is part of a heavy assault formation, with arts suited to that. Who has the greater applicable experience here should be obvious.
Xia Lin still has relevant experience to contribute, such as her knowledge of the setup of military outposts or likely general protocol. But she doesn't have any compelling experience that should mean she takes over command.
Theoretical knowledge is good, but generally theoretical knowledge + practical experience is better, as it means you know when to deviate from the standard answer. Ling Qi has the knowledge, she completed the Sect's scout training. But she also has the field experience. Xia Lin doesn't, and her training was almost certainly focused more strongly on other areas.*
Honestly, if we drop Xia Lin into command here when we're probably better suited for it I half expect it to decrease out team cohesion. She seems strongly goal oriented, and dropping her into command when we're in our area of expertise whilst dealing with potential enemies of the state because we wanted her to feel more valuable is both bad for the mission and kind of patronising.
*Because you don't need or want your commanders to be expert in every job, just to have a good understanding of how to use them.
The theoretical "book" would almost certainly tell Xia Lin that Ling Qi, as the trained scout with field experience who was already in command, should have stayed in command here.
Xia Lin is not a natural scout. She is a member (or an officer) in a specialist formation that relies on a very synchronous set of arts to be as effective as they are. I've no doubt that she has received some form of command training. If we had a block of people here then I'd probably put her in command. I'd even say that given command of a group of scouts she would be able to deploy them to good effect. But we don't have a group, we aren't looking at a map working out where best to deploy our forces.
We have 2 people to investigate a potentially hostile enemy base. One of them is a trained scout with experience infiltrating hostile or potentially hostile areas. The other is part of a heavy assault formation, with arts suited to that. Who has the greater applicable experience here should be obvious.
Xia Lin still has relevant experience to contribute, such as her knowledge of the setup of military outposts or likely general protocol. But she doesn't have any compelling experience that should mean she takes over command.
Theoretical knowledge is good, but generally theoretical knowledge + practical experience is better, as it means you know when to deviate from the standard answer. Ling Qi has the knowledge, she completed the Sect's scout training. But she also has the field experience. Xia Lin doesn't, and her training was almost certainly focused more strongly on other areas.*
Honestly, if we drop Xia Lin into command here when we're probably better suited for it I half expect it to decrease out team cohesion. She seems strongly goal oriented, and dropping her into command when we're in our area of expertise whilst dealing with potential enemies of the state because we wanted her to feel more valuable is both bad for the mission and kind of patronising.
*Because you don't need or want your commanders to be expert in every job, just to have a good understanding of how to use them.
»Their task was surveying the rgeion« or »Their task was to survey the rgeion« (not sure which one is correct, or even if both versions may be viable)
For two days they traveled straight south at a swift march, and the climate swiftly cooled.
For all the apparent silence and tranquility, the whispers of bark and root were harsh things, a silent competition and jostling for soil and sunlight.
"I think I am inclined to the forest path," Ling Qi said thoughtfully. "Is there really no other information on it though?"
"The last significant survey of this region took place in the days just after Ogodei," Cai Renxiang replied. "And that was not truly thorough."
Xia Lin frowned. "Unfortunate. I still believe dealing with and silencing human foes would be more reliable, than dealing with either unknowns or dragons."
"I do not doubt everyone's martial prowess, but stirring up the wrath of foes upon our prospective allies doorstep strikes me as rude," Meng Dan said.
"If they become allies, those tribes will be foes regardless," Xia Lin challenged.
"That may be true, but is it worth risking greater attention?" Ling Qi said carefully. "I trust in Sect Head Yuan and the General, but we do not exactly know the full extent of our enemies forces."
Xia Lin continued to frown, but eventually nodded. "A fair argument. If we must deal with spirits then, the forest seems the better path. Should the dragon be recalcitrant, we would have no recourse but to retreat. Scouting has shown no sign of such a spirit in the forest."
"I am sure that there will be a fourth realm or two in such a region," Meng Dan mused. "If things go poorly that would still be within the realm of our scout commander to intervene."
"That is true, but I trust in Miss Ling and Lady Cai to avoid that," Gan Guangli said confidently. "That is why I believe the forest to be the best path."
With their arguments made, they fell silent, waiting for Cai Renxiang to give the final decision. The heiress stared at the map in Xia Lin's hands for a moment later before nodding. "The forest then, let us prepare to depart."
They left the camp within the hour, joining the outgoing scouting platoon. Twenty five soldiers, two in five of which were third realm with an accompanying spirit beast, all led by a core disciple of the fourth realm. Their task was surveying the region, and as such they wouldn't be following them directly into the forest, instead providing a cover for their presence from any watchers afar and above.
With the scouts, their path lead south, over the rocky hills and valleys that lay between the greater peaks in the Wall. For two days they travelled straight south at a swift march, and the climate swiftly cooled. Although it didn't bother Ling Qi by the time they reached the forests edge, many of the soldiers had begun to don warmer gear.
The forest itself was a strange sight. It grew from a steep 'V' shaped chasm between two cloud piercing peaks, with thick old growth trees growing at odd angles from sharply angled rock. Thick, knotty roots pierced the stone and dirt, forming a rough ground, and curved trunks sprouted upward to face the sky with a dark canopy of needles. The bottom of the chasm then, was dark as night even at midday, lit only by the faint phosphorescent light of fluttering insects that hung over the shallow, sluggish river that ran down the center. Viewed from above, Ling Qi saw it as a curving line of green that ran for many hundreds of kilometers toward the south horizon.
The first task would be one of pathfinder. Xia Lin and Ling Qi were going to go ahead of the group and determine the best path before returning to the others.
Ling Qi materialized on the low hanging branch of a tree at the forest's edge, sending fragrant needles raining down into the water below, where Xia Lin strode up through the ankle deep waters. She bounced her halberd on her shoulder as she peered into the darkness that lay ahead.
"What are your orders going forward?" Xia Lin asked. She stepped out of the shallow water and onto the tiny strip of stony shore that lay beneath Ling Qi's perch.
Ling Qi raised an eyebrow as she peered down. "I don't think I am in charge like that."
Xia Lin cocked her head, peering upward at her. "I think we are both aware of who Lady Cai favors, Miss Ling. You are my senior in her service besides."
"Lady Cai doesn't think like that. I am sure she means us to cooperate," Ling Qi replied. She peered into the forest. The persistent gloom was hardly a bother. Ahead the shallow river fell over a short cliffside, leading deeper into the valley. The trees were silent save for the occasional twittering birdsong and the rustling of grass.
If you only looked with mortal senses anyway. The dark branches teemed under her spiritual senses. Among the trees, thousands of mismatched knothole eyes peered back at her. Little spirits of wood and growth, hiding behind every clump of needles and clinging to every trunk. The river's burble was a low pitched song, echoing from the forest deeps. Faeries of cold and wind danced among the frost dusted canopy, fragile snowflake frames tinkling like bells. <What do you think, Sixiang?>
"Sleepy place, rivers not a regular flooder, so it shouldn't be a problem. No signs of anything real spooky yet. The little tree guys are cute, I kinda want one," Sixiang replied cheerfully.
"Zhengui does not like this place much," her little brother grumbled.
"Pfft, it's fine. You're just being grumpy," Hanyi scoffed.
Ling Qi did not allow the byplay in her head to distract her as she moved to the next branch, peering over the short cliff, it was only ten or so meters deep. Unfortunately the trees grew right down to the waterline, their gnarled roots forming a twisted bed that left not a spot of ground to walk freely on.
Xia Lin followed her, and where the faint light cast by her halberd passed, the tree spirits and faeries retreated, shying away. Things of shadow nesting in the darkness stirred, opening blinking yellow eyes that tracked the passing light with longing. "Miss Ling, it is not necessary to humor me," Xia Lin replied, looking down into the dark as well. "Your skillset is the more valuable one here."
Ling Qi paused, glancing down at the other girl. She wondered what had brought this on.
"She's gotten it into her head that little Cai doesn't much like her," Sixiang mused. "…and I suspect she might be feeling kind of extra."
Ling Qi blinked at the odd turn of phrase, but understood the intent. On the other hand, Xia Lin wasn't wrong, they wanted to avoid conflict wherever possible. "Well, if you insist. I think it would be best for you to stay on the river. The spirit of it seems calm, so if you can check down the run, and see if there's any obstruction to just using it, I can scout the periphery."
Xia Lin nodded sharply. "Understood. Meet here in one hour?"
"Yes," Ling Qi replied.
She stepped over the edge and fell into the dark, landing in the frothing water below without a splash. Ling Qi watched her stride forward through the now calf deep water for a moment before turning her attention back to the closely packed trees.
34, 37, 95
Ling Qi kept a tight leash on her qi as she explored the forest, not letting her power leak out into the surroundings as she made her silent way through the branches. She didn't even flex her aura when faeries swirled close to toy with her hair, or wood spirits clung to her hems with little claws of sap and bark, letting her carry them for a time before dropping onto new trees or rare patches of unoccupied soil. It made it easier to listen. It made it easier to hear the meaning in the soft song of wind in branch and the rustling of needles. The trees here were old and gnarled things, jealous of their places in the vale. For all the apparent silence and tranquillity, the whispers of bark and root were harsh things, a silent competition and jostling for soil and sunlight.
Among the trees she found few beasts, mostly birds and rodents, though she saw signs of wolves and game beasts further from the river, where the grade of the valley lessened and fallen trees had cleared trails. But deeper in the valley, she began to find webs. At first in small patches but swiftly growing more thickly strewn. In the shadows, many legged silhouettes skittered, both tiny and large.
As she continued to descend, on the path through the chasm, it only grew worse. Only near the river did the webs grow thin, though a few delicate structures connected branches on either side. For Ling Qi, the webs did not provide any obstacle, but for her less dextrous companions, she could see it being trouble. There was little room to traverse without ruining the creatures homes.
Unless Xia Lin found something very troubling, the river would likely be the best path.
Upon meeting back with her and explaining this, Xia Lin's expression failed to instill confidence.
"The river is clear of hostiles so far as I went. The fish are not carnivorous, and the waters are calm," Xia Lin reported. They stood back at the forest's edge, where the faint light of the autumn sun was allowed to reach the ground. "However, at the lowest point of the valley there is a significant anomaly. At first I believed it to be a grove of petrified trees, but upon closer inspection, I noted the signs of artificiality. Upon further inspection, I noticed signs of energies being conducted into the further portion of the river and valley."
Ling Qi frowned. "Do you have any idea what it is doing?"
"I do not specialize in formation craft, but I suspect some form of large scale misdirection effect," Xia Lin replied, tapping the butt of her weapon thoughtfully against the ground. "A number of the northward 'trees' have suffered environmental damage, which may explain the lack on this side."
Ling Qi pinched the bridge of her nose. Cloud Nomads didn't do stonework or formations, did they. Some other additional unknown group then? She thought that was unlikely. A ruined imperial outpost? Wouldn't they know about it then?
Ling Qi glanced toward the web filled forest warily. There was one group, associated with spiders, known for their skill at illusion and subterfuge. The Hui, deposed dukes of the Emerald Seas. She met Xia Lin's eyes, and understood the grim set of her features.
"…You said the construction was weathered, suffering environmental damage, right?"
"It was," Xia Lin replied. "It implies a lack of active upkeep and hasty construction."
So it did, Ling Qi mused. They still had limited time. "Then, let's go and clear the obstacle."
The site was as Xia Lin had described it, apparently petrified trees growing from the wide, shallow water, there were dozens of them. On the northern side a few had fallen, and taken their neighbors with them, scattering rubble throughout the river. With silver gleaming in her eyes, Ling Qi examined them, and confirmed Xia Lin's suspicions. The pillars were part of a large scale formation effect, a labyrinthine illusion that should have rendered the forest impassable.
Perhaps Cai Renxiang could brute force her way through the decayed illusions, but that would probably be quite noticeable. Exploring the site, Ling Qi considered just asking Xia Lin to knock down a few more pillars, to finish disabling it.
However… she was not expert enough in formations to know which others could be broken without setting off a feedback explosion, like she had so long ago in Elder Ying's Sect trial. And for a formation this size, the blast would not be so tiny. To disable it effectively, they needed to find the power source.
Luckily, Ling Qi was skilled enough to trace the lines of energy back and up the western bank, to a boulder that was not a boulder at all.
As the two of them peered down into the damp tunnel that descended beneath the ground, Ling Qi glanced at Xia Lin. This was enemy territory, most certainly. Perhaps she should let Xia Lin take command.
[] Pass command to Xia Lin
[] Maintain command
The above vote determines the way that you approach the event encounters, the social dynamic between yourself and Xia Lin, and the overall outcome of the event.
After the first section I was worried that there'd be nothing for me to edit but then I got plenty to edit. Also, I looked up how to do dividing lines; it's down with [hr][/hr] with optionally a number up to 5 for different styles.
As for the vote; I'm so not sure which is the better option :Ü™
Edit: The discussion has hardlined me into the Maintain command camp. [X] Maintain command
Anyone else kind of wish we'd find an Hui Formations Slip? Something that'd eventually let us make our own misdirection ward for our future home, together with some general secret/subterfuge formations for spying. I feel like one of the reasons we've been ignoring Formations is that we simply don't have any examples of worthwhile ones for things we don't want to invest entire Arts+Meridians in. But once we're past the intersect competition there'll be less pressure and more time to prepare for our fief and duties, and this would be our chance to get Ducal level formations in our field (and it'd be funny if we used them against whomever lived here). We get to cooperate with Li Suyin and Bao Qingling for the silk components, Meng Dan for the Hidden Moon, and sneak in some formation work into our embroidery sessions with CRX and Meizhen.