The Morrsley Village Experiment

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

I think I'll hold off my vote for now, only because being two off of hammer activating is making me paranoid of some random person jumping into the vote.

Hybrid said:
As long as one town is alive at the end of the game, I win. I have a kill ability and a couple of other abilities

That sounds like an SK wincon, not gonna lie.

Hybrid said:
Yandere

I swear, if that's the actual name of the role

Hybrid said:
Yeah, was kinda shocked when I got it. Essentially, I get a random name each night phase and I have to protect them or I die

This sounds too... odd to actually be one of your "supposed" powers imo.

Hybrid said:
I wish, I had to protect ItzNarcotic on the first night and wasted my jail ability on him, kinda why Nictis has been rubbing me the wrongw ay

Let's say that what you are proposing is true. Who did you protect last night, then?

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

mesonoxian said:
I'm not 100% sure I buy this.

On the positive side, this sort of role would makes Nictis roleclaim make a bit more sense.

On the other hand, an unlimited, town aligned vig who is immune to nightkills is really hard to square with how town heavy this game is. And the name is a weird break with the theme.

That seems like a totally broken mechanic. There is no play you can make that directly protects your target.

Sorry, but I don't think this makes sense.

This seems like something to have claimed Day 2. Also, wrapping someone in duct tape seems like a roleblock power, not a jailer flavor. IJW might disagree, but none of this feels right.

I'm keeping my vote where it is. If you flip "Yandere" I will be very surprised.

Prepare to be suprised then I guess and to Narcotic, I protected OneStopChopShop last night

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Prepare to be suprised then I guess and to Narcotic, I protected OneStopChopShop last night

Why?

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

mesonoxian said:
Why?

Cause he was a bit more discrete than the rest of yous, I figured he had less chance of getting offed

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Cause he was a bit more discrete than the rest of yous, I figured he had less chance of getting offed

That is the opposite of why you'd protect someone, though.

Meanwhile, Nictis has a well justified reason to try to block OneStop.

I don't buy it.

InterstellarHobo · Jan 25, 2020

So let's consider two cases.

Case 1: Hybrid is lying.
They are about 99% certain to be a fairly standard SK. Literally everyone should want them dead fastlike, and they are the obvious lynch.

Case 2: Hybrid is honest.
Test subjects want them dead by the end of the game. Control group wants them dead by the end of the game. They are a perfectly acceptible lynch.
We all side-eye IJW.

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Cause he was a bit more discrete than the rest of yous, I figured he had less chance of getting offed

I mean, I'll be honest here and no offense to OneStopChopShop, but I'd definitely prioritize a confirmed Town role - especially one who is likely a Power Role - over an unclaimed and unknown player.

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

Let me live tonight and Ill prove it to ya, ill tell you who im going to and you can see me do it

InterstellarHobo · Jan 25, 2020

Hol up

Hybrid said:
Prepare to be suprised then I guess and to Narcotic, I protected OneStopChopShop last night

Hybrid said:
Cause he was a bit more discrete than the rest of yous, I figured he had less chance of getting offed

Hybrid chooses to protect OneStop, because he was more discrete yadda yadda.

Hybrid said:
Yeah, was kinda shocked when I got it. Essentially, I get a random name each night phase and I have to protect them or I die

Hybrid gets a random target they need to protect, as in they do not choose who they need to protect.
Either they chose to protect someone other than the person they need to, which ??????
Or this is a load of horseshit.

Also, thinkin about this a little more, Hybrid's 'protect' action is a pretty braindead decision. 'Hmm, do I protect the person I need to live, or some random schlub? I WONDER'
If this is a role, then it's a mistake of a role.

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

@Hybrid The problem is that even if your claim were reasonable and within the theme of the game, your actions make no sense. You claim to have protected ItzNarcotic because of your requirement, but you protected OneStop because they are the least likely to get hit. That doesn't make a lick of sense.

And your targets were one of the scum, but there is no way that anybody could have known that night one, so basically a random player, and Cyricubed, who was an experienced probable townie that wouldn't have investigatives or protectives visiting them.

RaptorusMaximus · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Yandere

Yeah I'mma call bullshit on that chief. That's just a bit outside what I can believe.

[x] Lynch Hybrid

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

Ah, I was about to quote the same thing.

Yeah, this seems, at most, a flimsy and hurriedly made defense. The contradiction, as pointed out by IH, is a clear example of this, with how you "have to" protect me, whereas you "chose to" protect OneStopChopShop.

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

Inserted tally

Adhoc vote count started by ItzNarcotic on Jan 25, 2020 at 5:59 PM, finished with 102 posts and 4 votes.

3 people have voted
[x] Lynch Hybrid
1 people have voted
[x]Lynch OneStopChopShop
- Hybrid

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

Maybe I wasnt honest on my role actions but I am the yandere, no lie bout that.

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

I have one person specifically who I need to survive so that I win, theyre pretty much guarenteed town so ill help that side out

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

If you were on town's side, why are you just telling us now? You are pretty clearly immune to night kills, so usual concerns over security don't seem very likely.

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

mesonoxian said:
If you were on town's side, why are you just telling us now? You are pretty clearly immune to night kills, so usual concerns over security don't seem very likely.

Firstly, my role name is Yandere and that does not come with any positive connatations with it whatsover. Secondly, if I come clean with my role, I have to come clear with who I have to protect which means that they have more chance of getting attacked. Thirdly? it makes me a target for whoever the hell the strongman is and I can guess that there is someone that acts as a strongman

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

So, I am pretty much 100% onboard the ItzNarcotic is town train. Obviously, Nictis isn't town, by their own admission, nor is Hybrid.

That leaves InterstellarHobo OneStopChopShop and RaptorusMaximus as potentially th scum killer.

I really think IH is probably town, but not anything like 100% sure. More like 80%. Mind you, that 20% is reserved for "Damn IH is an amazing scum player". The other two are quite hard to read.

The other two I find myself hard pressed to pick between. I have a vague feeling OneStop is more likely the killer, but that is all. Any thoughts?

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Firstly, my role name is Yandere and that does not come with any positive connatations with it whatsover. Secondly, if I come clean with my role, I have to come clear with who I have to protect which means that they have more chance of getting attacked. Thirdly? it makes me a target for whoever the hell the strongman is and I can guess that there is someone that acts as a strongman

Imma be honest, this would've been better to know before we reached the point where hammer is only one vote away from activating.

Besides, even if this claim is or isn't true, the timing isn't too good, especially with all the suspicion and doubt on you at the moment. Posting this at the beginning of this Day Phase would've helped your case a lot more instead of now.

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

If yous like I could reveal who I have to protect but I will point out im putting myself at a disadvantage to do so

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

ItzNarcotic said:
Imma be honest, this would've been better to know before we reached the point where hammer is only one vote away from activating.

Besides, even if this claim is or isn't true, the timing isn't too good, especially with all the suspicion and doubt on you at the moment. Posting this at the beginning of this Day Phase would've helped your case a lot more instead of now.

Youre the one ive to protect, you absolute maniac

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
If yous like I could reveal who I have to protect but I will point out im putting myself at a disadvantage to do so

I don't understand why you wouldn't have used your unlimited use protection power on them everynight. I mean if that is your win condition and you are immune to nightkills, this seems like a very simple game for you.

ItzNarcotic · Jan 25, 2020

Hybrid said:
Youre the one ive to protect, you absolute maniac

Again? Really?

That seems a little... weird, to be honest with you. Out of all the players, why me again, especially after you supposedly protected me on N1?

mesonoxian · Jan 25, 2020

ItzNarcotic said:
Again? Really?

That seems a little... weird, to be honest with you. Out of all the players, why me again, especially after you supposedly protected me on N1?

I think the new claim is that they've always had just one player to protect and made up the bit about getting a different name every night. I don't believe it, but I think that is what is being claimed.

Hybrid · Jan 25, 2020

mesonoxian said:
I think the new claim is that they've always had just one player to protect and made up the bit about getting a different name every night. I don't believe it, but I think that is what is being claimed.

It is, I realise that the whole random bt has kinda cornered me but im being truthful here. I can "jail" Narcotic for a night for protection and if he/she (sorry) dies then I win if I personally kill the killer

The Morrsley Village Experiment

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Staying noided

Staying noided

Cosmic Vagrant

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Cosmic Vagrant

Staying noided

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Staying noided

Staying noided

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Staying noided

Fireside Eldritch Munchies

Staying noided