Nictis and Shadell have both pretty obviously missed the shibboleth.
TBH the "shibboleth" is understanding the rules of mafia, that town would automatically win immediately if there was no other faction. This is quite guessable, regardless of whether or not you've seen the town role cards, though clearer if you have. Or maybe it's something else. Plausibly all role cards are different. Plausibly people missed something you've seen in yours. The point is that knowing more than one faction exists is available before the game even starts unless things look really weird.
It also doesn't actually prove the assertion that self-identifying non-town exist. There are a number of possible things you could be jumping on, particularly since you're willing to claim, but unwilling to actually say anything useful to support this.
I have, meanwhile, made a pretty extensive argument why town shouldn't claim immediately, particularly with so many unknowns. You read those two posts and immediately declared me scum for not claiming by answering your question. I don't feel the need to repeat it tbh. Like I didn't play on your script; I made an argument why no one should play on your script; and you called me scum for not playing exactly as you predicted town would.
Anyway, my guess right now is town on IH and Ondine, 3P or scum on Nictis and Cyri. Hard null most of the rest. That said, I think IH and Ondine are being very unhelpful as town atm, or very clever if not, and, again, the "shibboleth" used for this judgement isn't actually a reliable tool in the first place since cards might look pretty different than expected.
I believe
@ondine is tentatively honest about everything, but also too certain for us knowing nearly nothing yet, though I also think she's likely reading too deeply into an early throw-away line from me that doesn't actually match up in the way she believes.