Actually, couldn't we just avoid that risk? The -3 only applies to Jaune.
[X] Plan: Silence is Golden
-[X] You don't trust yourself to say anything right now, it would only make things worse.
-[X] Leave it to Blue, have him do the talking.
--[X] Let him decide whether to do that over scrolls or by using Penny as an intermediary.
@Prok, how well would this work? The big stumbling block is getting our friend talking to the guy threatening us in the first place, but it wouldn't risk Jaune messing up at social.