...I'm curious; are they serious that a message containing a declaration of war arrived at the same time as the fleet or at they saying the large fleet of Batarian warships showing up was the declaration? Because my first thought was: "Uh...duh! Of course a large fleet of hostile warships showing up in your capital unannounced is a declaration of war."
The Batarians sent an actual declaration of war. It was very nice and full of propaganda. It arrived at approximately the same time as the fleet. There was technically even 5 minutes between the declaration and the first shots fired.
Holy shit! I had no idea they were that significant. I always got the feeling in the game that while xenophobia was common groups like Terra Firm were more fringe.
With all the focus they get and their ability to run a kickback scheme... gonna have to say Terra Firma's got some power. That said there's varying levels of sanity. You're actually responsible (in a round about way) for one of the saner members being in control, which has increased their standing. Though I did deliberately list them as a broader coalition. Further more the codex directly points out that xenophobia is strong enough in the SA populsation that they can't forge alliances with the Turians or Salarians even nine years from now. So it has to be enough that they could filibuster/veto/whatever.
In addition Earth is the vast majority of humanity. While the economy isn't going to hell in a hand basket, it could be a lot better and those big cities are still having big city problems.
...Now I'm concerned about Nova Bombs.
Nope we're good. On both a meta level and the fact that the Batarian aren't willing to pull out the nasty stuff yet. I'll want you if it starts being an issue on a meta level.
I'll run the numbers in a bit to try and track down the discrepancy.
Oh and at one point I just said -32 Drones
I broke that down as
-9 Sagittarius
-7 Aspidai
-8 Accipiter "Atmospheric Edition"
-8 Tribulus
In the latest update and am editing the older post.
The irony is that this whole "super-encrypted navigation system" cover-up is arguably worse than the crime. Canonically the drive systems and navigation are tied together with sensors by "Prothean" technology to prevent anyone from turning ships into FTL bombs, but the Batarians apparently can mess with that setup. This implies they have the ability to make FTL planet-killers, and that they have deployed them against humanity.
Here we go again

. Beware the following may contain ranting, I'm sorry in advance. I've tried to minimize it.
Okay look here:
The Conventions do not forbid the use of WMD on hostile worlds or in sealed space-station environments. Many militaries continue to develop and maintain stockpiles.
Lots of governments keep stocks of planet killers. The Batarians are one of them (by GM fiat if nothing else). The Planet Killer WMDs are the last thing the Batarians are going to decommission, seeing as they are their best deterrent. You can even use them on dead/hostiles world all you want and it's okay! The Batarians having horrible weapons is not news. The Batarians choosing not to use them even in a desperate war is news. Good news.
The mass effect galaxy has been living under something kinda like MAD since it founding. You know why people
hate the Krogan? They broke it. They started tossing around those weapons. Part of the point of the conventions was to go no we wont do that. Hell even the Rachni kinda kept to the rules for some reason (OoC: Reapers). The whole fleets and ships and armies thing? That's all limited warfare, a ritualized form of beating the crap out of each other when words don't work. And you know what? The Batarians haven't used any of the nasty stuff. They didn't even fire them at Arcturus station, a legal target for such weapons.
The Batarians aren't avoiding unlimited warfare because the can't use it, but because they choose not to, because actually doing it
would get the rest of the galaxy to dog pile on. The Batarians may have been stretching the forms of the ritual, but they are still in bounds. The flip side is also worth considering: if the Batarians get piled on will they use those weapons?
Furthermore, FTL plotters are not magic black box tech. They are manufactured and upgraded just like any other piece of high security tech. (
Link it talks about "archaic design no longer in service") The basic design comes from the Protheans; the engineering and security is all modern. If the Batarians have a better security system on their stuff then it actually a sign they are doing a
better job then everyone else.
Also why would the FTL plotter and safety interlock be the things that store the flight logs? Old flight logs aren't part of their job. Now one could use the flight logs to update the maps a plotter might you sure, but no reason to store that in the plotter/sensor interlock.
Look you like those, "this is like [some real-world country]" analogies right? When ever you do one remember to add, "if said country had a functioning nuclear ICMB stockpile." So this is like North Korea attacking South Korea, but North Korea has a functioning nuclear ICMB stockpile which they have chosen not to use right now and South Korea's populous has to much of an isolationist bent to have allies. At which point the analogy is so broken it's not worth continuing.
This isn't "Oh no they have horrible weapons they might be using", it's "We know you and the Batarians have these weapons. Isn't it nice you both still have livable planets?".
As for why the Citadel hasn't done anything about it... they have, economic warfare and espionage. The STG and Spectres are good, but they can't keep a government from keeping a planet killer stockpile. Even if they break it once it'll get rebuilt and if it keeps getting broken... not good. Especially if you missed some. Better to keep a good eye on it and slowly deal with it. Economic warfare will reduce the funding that goes to maintaining the stockpile and reduce the funding for the stockpile's security. (Alternatively the STG/Spectres can be ready to shut it down when someone goes to use it and then the military can act.)
War sucks... Unlimited warfare REALLY sucks, no wonder the Citadel is scared of it. Peace when possible, boarder skirmishes if not, space wars if thinks go really wrong, and unlimited war only as the last possible option.
Hopefully between my ranting I got some level of point across. Sorry about that but I keep seeing some of those points passed over, over and over again.
The cost of maintaining a Pynda is quite low, probably because PI super tech, so costs plus 20% is a pretty terrible offer. It's also one we kinda have no choice to accept since governments generally don't appreciate you telling them no.
20% was kind off of the top of my head after looking at other payouts I offered but I may have screwed it up. If there is a significant reason to change it I'm open to that. Like needing to average in the purchase price of a Pynda or something. Might lower the percentage to compensate though. The original idea is that the SA was basically paying out a fixed ROI so that calling in PMCs didn't fuck them over.
Feel free to contemplate.
Understandable. What sort of science do they prefer? Purely theoretical work, something 'pacifistic' like medicine, or something that makes everyone else in the galaxy really really nervous, like medicine?
Lots of stuff. Everything from physics to archeology. Genetics stuff tend to be avoided or deliberately have litl to no security.
So...what are our chances of getting some RP out of it at least? Middling?
You'd get something out of of it assuming everything worked out.
@Hoyr Based on information gathered from Anhur and specialists among the Abolitionists, what kind of support does a slave revolt need to survive and thrive without us putting boots on the ground for a few months? Is there a ready pool of advisors we could sneak in?
It depends a lot on the planet. It's worth observing that a lot of the Batarians buy into the system or consider the risk of rebelling to fair out weight the benefit. A revolt would probably need a source of a equipment, training, and some social direction other than "let's rebel".
Also Votes:
Currently winning:
[X] Stay (Low Risk, Low Profit)
-[X] One-third of forces stay (~25% of total ground forces) 224 Million
[X] Just the Pyndas (High Risk, 20% Costs as Profit)
[X] Guard Colonies (Medium Risk, Medium Profit)
-[X] Deploy Three-Quarters (75%) of ParSec's forces 1.125 billion/quarter.
Which seems like it has a pretty solid majority.