Remove ads

The Long Night Part One: Embers in the Dusk: A Planetary Governor Quest (43k) Complete Sequel Up

Investigate the Sea?

  • Yes

    Votes: 593 80.4%

  • No

    Votes: 145 19.6%
  • Total voters
    738
Reader mode
Doomed Wombat said:
Hard to do, I fear most of them come from 2500 pages ago when we were dealing with Garkill for a third time.

So 48-9 martial and we were still in his category.

@Durin
1. Was Macharius a paragon?

Just in case I'm wrong.


Yeah both the OOC reasoning, the fact that there is no "XP" and the fact that people can still earn paragon traits fine because they're still participating in battles I'd say this logic is somewhat flaws.

Paragon traits are not things to be ground out, they happen for important deeds. We don't earn XP towards them.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
1. he was around the border, either just over or just under
 
@Durin
1. To check are we going to be converting a muspelheim city to a ramilies?
2. Are the Eldar willing to rush samples of Tyranid back to the Trust for study assuming we get any and need to get them.
3. While reading emotions into the hive mind may seem like projection is it reasonable for us to assume that the Nids are desperate for as much biomass as they can get before any other concerns, except maybe survival?
 
Doomed Wombat said:
@Durin
1. To check are we going to be converting a muspelheim city to a ramilies?
2. Are the Eldar willing to rush samples of Tyranid back to the Trust for study assuming we get any and need to get them.
3. While reading emotions into the hive mind may seem like projection is it reasonable for us to assume that the Nids are desperate for as much biomass as they can get before any other concerns, except maybe survival?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
1. yes you are
2. they are
3. it is, what that means is really hard to guess given that they have the most inhuman mindset of any faction in 40k. and that includes the deamons
 
[X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
[X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
-[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
 
@Durin
1. Will choosing Rotbart take away Personal Attention actions?
2. Will the Autarch prioritize Eldar lives to a degree that will cause noticeable differences in Trust casualties in the same theaters than if Rotbart or Julius was commanding?
Adhoc vote count started by StormySky on Apr 8, 2019 at 9:10 AM, finished with 102 posts and 33 votes.
Click to expand...
 
Durin said:
1. Yes
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
@Durin, how many personal actions will it take away?
Adhoc vote count started by StormySky on Apr 8, 2019 at 9:38 AM, finished with 105 posts and 34 votes.
Click to expand...

Adhoc vote count started by StormySky on Apr 8, 2019 at 9:38 AM, finished with 105 posts and 34 votes.
  • [X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
    [X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
    -[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
    [X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
    -[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
    [X] Deploy thirteen PDF Army Groups, twelve Guard Armour Groups and one Elite Army Group- These forces should provide a boost to the ground defences, while being replaceable even if massive losses are sustained (2% of all PDF, 25% of all Guard, 10% of all elites) -21% base chance
    [X] Attempt to claim the position yourself (66% chance, diplomacy check (DC 75) increase chanced )- You believe that you would be the best choice as High Commander, and are willing to devote the time that will be needed to fill this position.
    [X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
    [X] Attempt to claim the position yourself (66% chance, diplomacy check (DC 75) increase chanced )- You believe that you would be the best choice as High Commander, and are willing to devote the time that will be needed to fill this position.
    [X] Attempt to claim the position yourself
    [X] Attempt to claim the position yourself
    [X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
    [X] Support Chapter Master Julius (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the great experience of Chapter Master Julius makes him the best high commander.
    [X] Support Chapter Master Julius (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the great experience of Chapter Master Julius makes him the best high commander.
    [X] Deploy thirteen PDF Army Groups, twelve Guard Armour Groups and one Elite Army Group- These forces should provide a boost to the ground defences, while being replaceable even if massive losses are sustained (2% of all PDF, 25% of all Guard, 10% of all elites) -21% base chance
    [X] Propose that Julius commands if the necrons agree to work together, and that Landeer commands if they refuse.
    [X] Deploy eighteen Guard Army Groups and six Elite Army Groups - Write in for reasons explained below (37.5% of all Guard, 60% of all elites) -unknown base chance
    [X] Attempt to claim the position yourself (66% chance, diplomacy check (DC 75) increase chanced )- You believe that you would be the best choice as High Commander, and are willing to devote the time that will be needed to fill this position.
    [X] Deploy eighteen Guard Army Groups and six Elite Army Groups - Write in for reasons explained below (37.5% of all Guard, 60% of all elites) -unknown base chance
    [X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
    -[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
Click to expand...

Adhoc vote count started by StormySky on Apr 8, 2019 at 9:39 AM, finished with 105 posts and 34 votes.
Click to expand...
 
[X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
[X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
-[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
 
[X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
[X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Nurgle on Apr 8, 2019 at 11:38 AM, finished with 110 posts and 35 votes.
Click to expand...
 
[] Deploy thirteen PDF Army Groups, twelve Guard Armour Groups and one Elite Army Group- These forces should provide a boost to the ground defences, while being replaceable even if massive losses are sustained (2% of all PDF, 25% of all Guard, 10% of all elites) -21% base chance
[] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
[X] Deploy sixteen Guard Armour Groups and ten Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a massive boost to the ground defences, but major losses would be sorely felt (35% of all Guard, 100% of all elites)- 11% base chance


[] Attempt to claim the position yourself (66% chance, diplomacy check (DC 75) increase chanced )- You believe that you would be the best choice as High Commander, and are willing to devote the time that will be needed to fill this position.
[X] Support Chapter Master Julius (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the great experience of Chapter Master Julius makes him the best high commander.
[] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.



Is it weird that I'm voting for options specifically because they're behind in the vote polls?
 
[X] Deploy twenty-four Guard Armour Groups and two Elite Army Groups - These forces should provide a significant boost to the ground defences, but would lead to replacement issues if massive losses are sustained (50% of all Guard, 20% of all elites) -35% base chance
[X] Support Autarch Amnedor Landeer (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the experience at larger scale conflicts that Autarch Landeer posseses makes him the best high commander.
-[X] Amnedor's experience in coordinating sector-wide war will be the most sorely needed capability in containing the Tyranids.
 
[X] Deploy thirteen PDF Army Groups, twelve Guard Armour Groups and one Elite Army Group- These forces should provide a boost to the ground defences, while being replaceable even if massive losses are sustained (2% of all PDF, 25% of all Guard, 10% of all elites) -21% base chance
[X] Support Chapter Master Julius (75% chance, diplomacy check (DC 70) increase chanced)-You believe that the great experience of Chapter Master Julius makes him the best high commander.
 
Moment of speculation: Do people think Macharius had only one Paragon trait or would he have had more than one?

He's almost Alexander the Great in space, so something about cutting the Gordian knot? Always knowing a solution to the problem he faces?
 
thatguy said:
Moment of speculation: Do people think Macharius had only one Paragon trait or would he have had more than one?

He's almost Alexander the Great in space, so something about cutting the Gordian knot? Always knowing a solution to the problem he faces?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Almost? He is one of the most blatant things historical characters in 40k
 
@Durin
1. Out of curiosity how is crime in the Imperial Trust at the moment? Just curious between the destruction of the under hives and the rampant militarisation.
 
Doomed Wombat said:
@Durin
1. Out of curiosity how is crime in the Imperial Trust at the moment? Just curious between the destruction of the under hives and the rampant militarisation.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
1. on the low end by Imperial standards and more on the corruption and crime of passion ends. So thieves are usually cooking the books rather then breaking and entering and assaults are usually unplanned actions rather then gang violence
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top