Ring-Maker [Worm/Lord of the Rings Alt-Power] [Complete]

Voted best in category in the Users' Choice awards.
Still don't get why "smart" and "able to justify doing bad things" are seen as contradictory. By this logic, Lex Luthor, Doctor Doom, Brainiac, and Darkseid are all morons.
Intelligence dosn't mean not stupid, sure they're intelligent but they're also neurotic, vain and have massive mental blind spots. I think Taylor's big problem is her ego, her logic goes "he disagrees with me, therefore he's wrong", the idea of a good idea origionating outside her own head is now forgin to her. On a different note I think Armsmaster is being a bit unresonable, honestly I think Taylor if anything was a bit restrained when dealing with Heartbreaker, I think just calling in a airstrike would have been reasonable, low risk, most people in the blast radius are as good as dead anyway and would still be way lower than the direct and indirect death toll of if he escaped.
 
I don't think the problem here is that you wrote paradigm shift badly. This is one of the best written fanfiction story, with very distinct and enjoyable style, so that's not really a problem.

The problem isn't really paradigm shift at all. Problem is that, to casual readers, who only react to current chapter without thinking much about the wider context - you have replaced Annatar readers knew and loved, with a different character who they don't know, and are not really inclined to love. I mean she is superficially similar, but that's about the extent of it. Their behaviour and thinking is alien.

And this can break a story. People become involved with characters, and if a core character is replaced (and in a way that seems irreversible), then the story that follows, become a different story to the one they enjoyed.

In other words, don't worry about the comments, they were unavoidable with the direction you decided to take the story. Some people may leave, but for those that remain, their protests will quiet down with time.

Me personally, I want to withhold judgement. What you try to do here is very bold, changing main character like that, but I have seen stories that did pull it off successfully, and if any has a chance, this one certainly does. Granted the change to main character is usually temporary and reversible, but hey, I don't really know what you have planned here, so I cant put it in context.

Anyway each individual instalment is well read and enjoyable. The atmosphere is deeply unsettling without being suffocating, or tiring, which is really difficult to pull of. Characters are still distinct. Overall its still really great, and I for one, am eagerly awaiting what you are going to treat us next.
 
Rereading the chapter, I came upon this paragraph.

Can you imagine, Heartbreaker the Master 9, one who was pretty much untouchable for twenty years then suddenly defeated by a slip of a girl in soot-covered armor.

He thought this will be a walk in a park, taking back his wayward child. The extra three capes were a bonus.

He was wrong. This was his one, and final mistake, crossing Annatar the Ring-Maker.
What you're saying is, he thought he could take her.
 
Dang... That shit was so metal! I loved it!

I was a little surprised at Armsmaster jumping ship like that. I can't really blame him though, with how Sauron!Taylor seems to have everyone of importance so thoroughly pocketed.
 
Anyone is welcome to do this. I may do so at some point, but for now I just think it makes more sense to focus my efforts on the story proper.

Ya' hear THAT everyone!? GET WRITING!

There's a balancing act in this story. I'm Tolkienizing things as much as I think I can get away with, but—and this is important—no more than that. Ordinary people in Brockton Bay don't go giving people epithets, as a rule. It's simply not done. So that's not something that's easy to make happen. It'd be cool, but it might also break things.

I wasn't meaning in the same way that epithets are granted in The Hobbit/Lord of the Rings, but more along the lines of the people on PHO getting it into their heads to start spinning potential titles for Annatar as a sort of joke, with Annatar acidentally stumbling across it and, with some poorly worded phrases, unintentionally sets everyone the (optional) task of creating a badass boast for her.
 
Interlude 9a:Colin
Many thanks to @BeaconHill, @Assembler, ShadowStepper1300, and @fabledFreeboota for betareading.

-x-x-x-​

Colin felt oddly naked as he trudged up the road. The afternoon sun beat down, bright and unwelcome, on his pale exposed skin. He'd stashed his armor and bike in an abandoned house for the moment, which he'd locked up with tinkertech. It wouldn't do to walk around wearing it right now.

He'd called Chief Director Costa-Brown, but hadn't gotten an answer. He'd left a message and fired off an email, but hadn't heard back yet. The same had happened when he'd tried to contact Legend. It was enough to worry him, but for now, there was nothing to do but go to ground.

He glanced back over his shoulder, to the east. The sea glittered in the sunlight, and the Rig rose over the city like a castle spire, tall and imposing. His eyes lingered on it for a moment. His thoughts turned to his workshop, and to the woman who would, by now, have found it empty.

I'm sorry, Dragon. I'll be back.

He nervously patted the radio on his belt. She hadn't called, and it was starting to worry him. He knew she couldn't quit the way he had—the world needed her—but still, he'd hoped to hear her voice. God knows he could use some advice right about now.

Then he turned, adjusted the duffel bag on his back, and went on.

He had been a Protectorate hero for almost as long as he'd been a cape. There had been no question about what he'd do with his powers, once he realized what the interwoven designs popping into his head were. He'd never really understood how anyone could do otherwise. How could someone choose villainy, or the life of a rogue, when heroism was right there?

I think I'm starting to understand now.

The PRT had set up a quarantine by the time he arrived, but it was unmanned—little more than yellow tape stretching around the house, yard, and a bit of the street. He ducked under it and looked around.

The house was nothing really special. A two-story rowhouse, no different from all the others around it. The parts of the yard that weren't burned were unkempt and overgrown. There were the remnants of once-tended flowerbeds under each of the first-floor windows. The brickwork around the little enclosures was crumbling and loose, now.

The blast radius was clearly visible. It reached out from a central point, almost perfectly circular, darkening as it went inward until the center was black as night. The wooden door was well inside that radius, and had been badly charred and left barely hanging by half-melted hinges. Strips of plywood had been hastily nailed in place over the entrance—a half-measure to deter looters.

He stood at the center of the blast, ground zero, and knelt. His fingers brushed at the stone of the path and came away black with soot. This was where Annatar had lain when she second-triggered. Shutdown had attacked the Wards from the window above, and then the PRT officers had foamed them.

It was tempting to say that this was where it had started. For a moment, as he looked down at the dark scar left by the explosion, he was almost able to convince himself it was true.

Then he looked up again, and saw the moldering flowerbeds, and knew better.

How the fuck did you miss something like that? Do you not bother with any kind of oversight? When a girl got shoved into her locker at your Ward's school, did you not even bother to look?

He stood up, cracking his neck. With a heave, he pulled apart the higher of the two plywood strips. Before he could hesitate any longer, he pushed open the door and went inside, stepping over the other board.

Inside was a hallway, with a wide opening into a living room on the right. It looked comfortable, furnished with couches, armchairs, and an outdated television, but by the dust on the coffee table and the stains on the carpet, it had not hosted guests or even been properly cleaned in years.

He was tempted to keep exploring, but the stairs were visible from here, and he had a feeling he should be upstairs.

The boards creaked under his feet as he started to climb. He tried to keep as quiet as possible, but after only a few steps, he gave it up as a lost cause.

There were two bedrooms on the upper floor. One door was open—the master bedroom. It was disheveled, with an unmade bed, and a few scattered articles of clothing lying scattered around the room.

The other door was closed. He stopped in front of it, raised his fist, and knocked.

There was no answer. For a moment, he wondered if he was wrong.

"Shadow Stalker," he said, and was surprised at how hoarse his voice was. "It's Armsmaster."

Silence answered him. It stretched for almost twenty seconds, and then a voice came from within.

"Come to take me in?" Shadow Stalker asked from inside. Her voice was quiet, little more than a broken whisper.

"No." He opened the door.

Shadow Stalker lay spread-eagled, in jeans and a t-shirt, on the twin bed in one corner of the little bedroom. One hand was twisted in the bedsheets; the other lay, clenched into a fist, over her heart. Her eyes were closed, and her cheeks were glazed with tear tracks.

He stepped into the room and crossed over to her. She didn't open her eyes, even when his shadow fell across her face. Her lips barely moved as she spoke, her voice little more than a dry croak. "How did you find me?"

"You didn't go home," said Colin quietly. "And you didn't go to your friend Emma's house, either. I couldn't think of anywhere else."

Shadow Stalker's face twitched at the name. "Emma isn't my friend," she said—not venomously or sadly, but simply as a statement of fact.

"I did get that impression when I spoke to her father on the phone."

Silence fell for a few seconds. Then Shadow Stalker broke it. "Why are you here, Armsmaster?"

Colin hesitated for a moment before answering. "Because you're right," he said quietly.

Shadow Stalker opened one eye, piercingly green. It sought his face. "You think?"

"Annatar just led the assault on Heartbreaker," he told her. "I… you should be glad you didn't see it."

"How many dead?" Shadow Stalker asked him, her face twisting slightly in pain.

"Six," he said grimly. "She mauled a kid with her mace, ordered Kid Win to destroy a car with a woman still inside, and threw a lightning bolt at another car full of children. And if we didn't have Panacea, I wouldn't like Battery's odds of recovery. It was brutal. Far too brutal."

Shadow Stalker's eye closed again. "Yeah," she said, almost a sigh. "That sounds about right. What's she saying about me?"

"Annatar claims you've been mastered by Oracle," he answered. "She plans to capture and free you. Obviously, I don't believe it."

Shadow Stalker gasped out something halfway between a peal of laughter and a sob. "Free me, huh?" she asked. "Fucking hell, Taylor. Guess that's it, then. That's all I am to her now. A broken tool, worthless until it's fixed."

"Annatar just underwent a second trigger event," said Colin, shaking his head. "She's not in her right mind, clearly. But she's also an incredibly dangerous and charismatic parahuman, who now seems to have control over an entire branch of the PRT."

Shadow Stalker didn't answer for a moment. "Why are you here?" she asked again, after a moment. "What do you want?"

He glanced out the window at the sunlight reflected in the windows of skyscrapers. "I want your help," he said. "I want to fix this."

"Fix what?" she asked, and suddenly she was sitting up and glaring at him with eyes that were bright with tears. "I don't see a lot left to fix here!"

"There's a city full of innocent people who need protecting," Colin said, meeting her gaze. "They need heroes, Shadow Stalker."

"I'm not a hero," she replied. Her shoulders slumped, and she fell back against the bed. "I can't even care about all those people. The only person I want to save is the one at the middle of all this."

"Annatar may not be beyond helping, Shadow Stalker."

"Maybe," she agreed sadly. "But I can't help her. I can't be who she needs me to be. I don't know how."

"Then why did you leave?" Colin asked. "Why leave without a plan? Why not stay, and try to get more information before doing anything drastic?"

Now Shadow Stalker laughed, and the sound was harsh, mirthless, and seemed to tear itself like claws out of her throat. "God, I wish I could be like you," she said, without opening her eyes. "Just… turn off like that. Stop paying attention to how I feel, and just do what I have to do. Everything would be so much easier if I could."

"I can't control how I feel, Shadow Stalker," said Colin quietly.

"Yeah, but you can control how you act," she said. Her hand rose from her chest, and her eyes opened and studied her fingers. "You can decide how much you want to show. You can put on a mask, and just deal with it." She shook her head, her eyes never leaving her hand. Colin realized suddenly that it was her left hand, and that on its ring finger glittered her Emerald Ring. "Whereas me? No matter how much I tell myself that I can't do something, no matter how hard I try to hide it… it still comes out."

Silence fell for several seconds. Then Colin cleared his throat. "I'm sorry," he said.

She blinked at him. "What?"

"I'm sorry," he repeated. "For implying you should have had more self-control." He spread his arms out. "After all—I didn't have much of a plan, either. It'd be hypocritical of me to criticize you doing the same."

Her lips twitched into a weak little smile. "Yeah, I guess," she said. "I dunno. God, I feel like such a fuckup, you know?"

Colin nodded. "Yes." Then he sighed. "What do you plan to do now?"

She shrugged, staring up at the ceiling. "Lay here."

"You can't do that forever."

"True. I'll die after a while."

He frowned. "This isn't the time for jokes, Shadow Stalker."

"What the fuck makes you think I'm joking?" she asked, her eyes sharpening as she look at him again.

His teeth gritted. "Look," he said. "I don't know exactly how you feel. I don't even know how I feel half the time. But I know you just lost something very important to you. So did I. Being a Protectorate hero is just about everything I have, and I just gave that up because I felt I needed to. So why, Shadow Stalker? Why did you give it up?"

She twitched in something like pain and glanced away from him. "I don't know," she said quietly. "I just… I couldn't. Taylor's becoming something she hates, and I couldn't watch her do that to herself. God, watching her stab herself wouldn't have been half as painful."

"But you don't have anything you want to do? Nothing you want to try to change about the situation?"

"What the fuck am I supposed to do?" she asked in a sudden, agonized scream, her hands punching the bed on either side of her. "Taylor doesn't care! Taylor doesn't—" her voice broke, and she bit down on a sob. "There's nothing left to do, Armsmaster," she said, once she'd recovered a little. "Nothing but wait, and see what tomorrow throws at me."

He stared at her for a moment, then slowly shook his head. "Okay," he said. "Fine. I understand. I'm sorry to bother you." He unslung the duffel bag from his shoulder and dropped it on the bed beside her. "I brought the things you left behind," he told her, "from your locker in headquarters. I suppose I shouldn't have bothered, but here they are. I don't need them. Your costume, crossbows, and sword are in there."

He turned around. "Let me know if you change your mind," he said. "Assuming you can find me. I don't know where I'll be."

He strode out of the room, and went to close the door. Just as it was swinging shut, however, Shadow Stalker croaked, "Wait."

He stopped and took a step back in. Shadow Stalker was staring confusedly at the duffel bag. "What did you say?" she asked slowly.

He blinked. "I brought everything you forgot," he repeated. "Your costume, crossbows, and sword. Why?"

"My…?" She sat up, reached for the zipper of the duffel bag, and pulled it open. Her eyes widened. "No," she whispered. "No fucking way."

"What is it?"

"I don't have a sword." She didn't look at him as she replied. Her hands were reaching into the bag.

"Don't you?" he asked blankly. "I found it in your locker."

"Have I ever used a sword in the field?"

"I assumed you'd been training with Annatar."

"I was," she whispered, pulling the black leather scabbard out of the bag. "Never got my own sword, though."

He frowned. "Then what's—"

With a ringing sound, the sword was drawn from its sheath. It shone red and white in the afternoon sunlight, as though reflecting a sunset and a full moon that were nowhere to be seen. The runes upon the blade seemed to flicker as though they were written in fire.

"Narsil," Sophia whispered, her eyes seeming almost luminous in the reflected glow. "But… why? Why here?"

"You must have put it in your locker after the fight with Shutdown."

She didn't answer. Her eyes ran up and down the blade, as though she could scarcely believe it was real. "It's not just a sword, is it?" she asked softly. "Any more than they're just rings."

"I wouldn't know anything about that."

Sophia's legs swung over the side of the bed. She stood, holding the blade high as though in salute. Slowly, she swung it through the air—once, twice. Her eyes followed it as it moved like a bar of light through the air.

"Shadow Stalker?"

"She saved me," Sophia said quietly. "She gave me a chance when I didn't deserve one. I wouldn't be here if it wasn't for her—not this me." She closed her eyes and pressed her brow to the flat of Narsil's blade. "And now… can I do the same for her? Is that—is it even possible?"

"I don't know," Armsmaster said. She looked up at him, as though she'd forgotten he was here. "But I know that you won't find out unless you try."

There was silence for almost a full minute. Then Sophia smiled. Her teeth glittered white in the sword's glare. "All right," she said, glancing back at the weapon. "Let's give it a try."

-x-x-x-​

Please consider donating to my Patreon. Many thanks to those who have already donated.
 
Last edited:
"She saved me," Sophia said quietly. "She gave me a chance when I didn't deserve one. I wouldn't be here if it wasn't for her—not this me." She closed her eyes and pressed her brow to the flat of Narsil's blade. "And now… can I do the same for her? Is that—is it even possible?"

"I don't know," Armsmaster said. She looked up at him, as though she'd forgotten he was here. "But I know that you won't find out unless you try."

There was silence for almost a full minute. Then Sophia smiled. Her teeth glittered white in the sword's glare. "All right," she said, glancing back at the weapon. "Let's give it a try."


Seriously though, this chapter has me so fuckin' hyped for the upcoming arcs.
 
There are other forces at work in this world besides the will of evil, Sophia. You were meant to have Narsil, and that is an encouraging thought.
 
Interesting that neither of them can voice the fear that drove them from the Protectorate. Note that I don't use "fear" here perjoratively. To fear that which will destroy you and respond rationally by retreating is not to be ruled by fear, but to respond healthily to it.

Both sense, on some level, that Annatar has become something that would twist them from their purpose if they let her. A Master more frightening than Valefor or Heartbreaker for her sheer subtlety. But Armsmaster only barely touched on the notion, and didn't approach the fear itself: that he, too, would be swayed if he stayed.
 
I find myself hoping they'll take long enough to defeat Taylor (whether in an intervention or in combat) that we get to see the world that her spirit would forge.
 
I find myself hoping they'll take long enough to defeat Taylor (whether in an intervention or in combat) that we get to see the world that her spirit would forge.
I'm wanting it to happen after she deals with Valefor, so that everyone can have positive tension releasing bonding by rofl-stomping Coil.
 
I'm not sure what good a sword is at healing someone's mental state/mind. I mean, what are you going to do, stab her with it? Wave it in her face?
 
Taylor, invest in some good gauntlets. The last thing you want is for Sophia to get lucky by cutting your fingers off.
 
I'm not sure what good a sword is at healing someone's mental state/mind. I mean, what are you going to do, stab her with it? Wave it in her face?
That might actually be surprisingly effective, silly as it might sound. Mostly because depending on how it's done that kinda thing has lots of narrative significance, and narrative significance has a lot of influence in Tolkien works. So given how wrapped up in Tolkien Taylor is it might very well make her pause when she sees a sword she knows intimately in the hands of a person she didn't expect.
 
Is it just me who feels like the foreshadowing of Taylor's inevitable defeat is rather too obvious? Granted, the perspective is hardly objective here.

That might actually be surprisingly effective, silly as it might sound. Mostly because depending on how it's done that kinda thing has lots of narrative significance, and narrative significance has a lot of influence in Tolkien works. So given how wrapped up in Tolkien Taylor is it might very well make her pause when she sees a sword she knows intimately in the hands of a person she didn't expect.
Nasty little shadowstalkeress. She stole our precious!
 
"She saved me," Sophia said quietly. "She gave me a chance when I didn't deserve one. I wouldn't be here if it wasn't for her—not this me." She closed her eyes and pressed her brow to the flat of Narsil's blade. "And now… can I do the same for her? Is that—is it even possible?"

"I don't know," Armsmaster said. She looked up at him, as though she'd forgotten he was here. "But I know that you won't find out unless you try."

There was silence for almost a full minute. Then Sophia smiled. Her teeth glittered white in the sword's glare. "All right," she said, glancing back at the weapon. "Let's give it a try."

would you kindly stop making me root for GADDAMNED Sophia?
and HOW did you even manage to make Armsmaster the voice of MORAL and REASON?
As always I will await your next chapter with baited breath.
 
Back
Top