Well, those things are noted. But well, there also seems nothing much townie in your behavior. I feel bad if this is truly a clash of playstyles, if so, take heart that if you prove town after this, the community likely will take that in account.
Hugh's Perfectly Normal Mafia Game Where Nothing Weird Happens Whatsoever
- Thread starter hugh_donnetono
- Start date
- Mafia
Well, those things are noted. But well, there also seems nothing much townie in your behavior. I feel bad if this is truly a clash of playstyles, if so, take heart that if you prove town after this, the community likely will take that in account.
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
Now I know that activity's just been wild today but I'm gonna have to call it here, we're outta time, sorry to cut everyone's conversation short 
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
The 4th Perfectly Normal Day Ends
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
After a...!
...
...
...
...Well certainly an eventful day, the day's target is fairly unanimous!
@Seven has been Perfectly Normally Exiled! They were Perfectly Normal Vanilla, a member of the Perfectly Normal Town!
...Yup!
However, they're not the only ones who have to leave today. Sadly, a certain other citizen has run into some financial trouble, and has to move away from the perfectly normal town. He packs his shuriken and his smoke bombs and leaves on the next train. There's a lot of tearful goodbyes, and everyone wishes him luck!
@Chiperninerm has left the game. As no replacement could be found after two day phases, his slot has been modkilled. He was Perfectly Normal Ninja, a member of the Perfectly Normal Mafia.
Night Four begins now, and will end in , after which there will be a 6-hour twilight period for night action resolution before Day Five begins.
...
...
...
...Well certainly an eventful day, the day's target is fairly unanimous!
@Seven has been Perfectly Normally Exiled! They were Perfectly Normal Vanilla, a member of the Perfectly Normal Town!
...Yup!
However, they're not the only ones who have to leave today. Sadly, a certain other citizen has run into some financial trouble, and has to move away from the perfectly normal town. He packs his shuriken and his smoke bombs and leaves on the next train. There's a lot of tearful goodbyes, and everyone wishes him luck!
@Chiperninerm has left the game. As no replacement could be found after two day phases, his slot has been modkilled. He was Perfectly Normal Ninja, a member of the Perfectly Normal Mafia.
Night Four begins now, and will end in , after which there will be a 6-hour twilight period for night action resolution before Day Five begins.
Day 5 Start!
hugh_donnetono
No use to complain
- Location
- Caught Out In The Rain
With the crow of the rooster, which is a staple in any perfectly normal town, the sun rises once again.
And once again, the mafia has slain another victim.
@Nictis has been Perfectly Normally Nightkilled. Their role was Perfectly Normal Alienist, a member of the Perfectly Normal Town.
An honorary crop circle showing will be held behind the town pyramid this evening in memoriam.
Day 5 has begun, and will end in .
However, as less than half of the starting player list is still alive, if everyone wants me to reduce the day/night cycle to 48/23 I can do that instead.
And once again, the mafia has slain another victim.
@Nictis has been Perfectly Normally Nightkilled. Their role was Perfectly Normal Alienist, a member of the Perfectly Normal Town.
An honorary crop circle showing will be held behind the town pyramid this evening in memoriam.
Day 5 has begun, and will end in .
However, as less than half of the starting player list is still alive, if everyone wants me to reduce the day/night cycle to 48/23 I can do that instead.
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Shocking. Who could have guessed Nictis would die?
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Okay, six players remain. If 2 of these were scum, we're at mylo.
- Shadell
- Draxy
- Wies
- Walker
- LostDeviljho
- Zaealix
LostDeviljho
Flame Dragon Princess
- Location
- The glorious Pacific Northwest
- Pronouns
- Any
You need to put your vote on a separate line there, for it to count.
[X] Vote Walker
Still pretty sure, it's Walker or Wies at this point. Also, called Chip being scum so that didn't come as too much of a surprise.
Not so sure if it's MYLO or not, otherwise would the game of been that state yesterday? In which case shouldn't we of lost, with that mis-vote of Seven? Though guess chip was out at the same time, so guess maybe not?
- Pronouns
- She/Her
With four scum, yesterday ends with 8 left alive, including 3 scum, dropping us to lylo today. With chip dead 2 scum+4 town means misvoting drops us to 2/2 after the night kill and 3/2 if we skip.
It's also possibly 5/1 but I'm inclined to disregard that world unless it becomes obviously true (e.g., we hit f3/4 and the game doesn't end)
It's also possibly 5/1 but I'm inclined to disregard that world unless it becomes obviously true (e.g., we hit f3/4 and the game doesn't end)
- Pronouns
- She/Her
I'm aiming to do large rereads on everyone left Alice today, and I'd encourage the same, though my time for this game remains sadly limited.
I have read up on some players, and I think LostDevilhjo is the most likely to be a wolf. Below is a selection of his posts. They contain hedging arguments, never really fully committing. I also don't like the policy vote on Seven.
Walker is also a suspect, but Walker has actually been comitting. There was a moment where it was certain Logos was the elimination and they could have switched from Comi to Logos, but didn't. I actually read that more as townie than a wolf.
Walker is also a suspect, but Walker has actually been comitting. There was a moment where it was certain Logos was the elimination and they could have switched from Comi to Logos, but didn't. I actually read that more as townie than a wolf.
- Pronouns
- She/Her
- Location
- PA
*Frowns*…
Six left…
It's entirely plausible I've been had this entire time.
Cultist seems liable to have won, Arsonist if possible well, he ignites tonight and we've still seen no signs of that Serial killer.
But, I will also say I'm not strongly sussing anyone in particular?
But that being said if you want a fairly arbitrary scum read list in order-top is highest suspicion, bottom is lowest, excluding myself for obvious self-preservation reasons:
1.LostDeviljho- slight reasoning in that earlier with Nictis could have basically been a pocketing play, if I understand how that's supposed to work. That it turned into general towncred is even better…
2. Wies-something something for some reason feel suspicious I'm not sure why but should probably re-read you in particular.
3.Shadell- can't crack that poker face or figured out your tells yet.
4.Draxy- under the radar.
Walker- also under my radar.
Actually…
@LostDeviljho You've claimed doctor to back my claim.
What HAVE you been doing with your night-actions since? I can at least say that much about myself.
Six left…
It's entirely plausible I've been had this entire time.
Cultist seems liable to have won, Arsonist if possible well, he ignites tonight and we've still seen no signs of that Serial killer.
But, I will also say I'm not strongly sussing anyone in particular?
But that being said if you want a fairly arbitrary scum read list in order-top is highest suspicion, bottom is lowest, excluding myself for obvious self-preservation reasons:
1.LostDeviljho- slight reasoning in that earlier with Nictis could have basically been a pocketing play, if I understand how that's supposed to work. That it turned into general towncred is even better…
2. Wies-something something for some reason feel suspicious I'm not sure why but should probably re-read you in particular.
3.Shadell- can't crack that poker face or figured out your tells yet.
4.Draxy- under the radar.
Walker- also under my radar.
Actually…
@LostDeviljho You've claimed doctor to back my claim.
What HAVE you been doing with your night-actions since? I can at least say that much about myself.
- Pronouns
- She/Her
They don't exist.
Doctor? ...but Devil claimed deprogrammer?
- Location
- PA
Point is he claimed to check someone N1 to back up my claim that Nictis was clear, but he hasn't claimed since.
- Location
- [REDACTED]
I am going to have more time this weekend, I told myself. I did not, in fact, have more time.
Going from memory about current players:
LDJ - Tends not to commit to a position until very late in a given day, and then sticks to it without much in terms of debate. One of two people not to bandwagon Seven yesterday, in preference of, uh, voting me instead. Hmm.
Shadell - First to catch the mountain, iirc. Has generally focused on style of arguments and expressed alignments, backing most reads with some evidence. Good taste in literature.
Wies - Role seems dubious, even for this game, but posting style has been generally hunt-inclined, suggesting town-ness. Towniness? Towncore? Flipflopped on Logos, but provided good reasoning. Has led votes but not won them D1/D2.
Draxy - Has been doing clerical stuff and keeping track of things, which is appreciated. Tends to hop on bandwagons last-minute for the previous day or two, which is a little odd, but also has reasoning when voting. Role is plausible. Nonetheless, some doubt.
Zaealix - Most of their play has been centered around their role, despite the general consensus of role-irrelevance. I've also never heard of an Investigator who only catches 3p but not scum, but I'm not going to claim encyclopedic knowledge enough to assert its nonexistence. Weird, but possibly not evil.
Walker - The other player who didn't bandwagon Seven. Excellent sense of style. Conflicted that people will vote him in mafia but not for council.
I am most suspicious of LDJ at this point, with Zaealix distantly behind them - Wies and Shadell have both commented on their tendency to hedge and their unwillingness to support positions even after they express them, and I'm also surprised by their sudden aggression towards Nictis hypothesizing the absence of powers D1 when they themselves claimed to have assumed the absence of a Cult immediately upon receiving the PM for their Cult-based role.
Going from memory about current players:
LDJ - Tends not to commit to a position until very late in a given day, and then sticks to it without much in terms of debate. One of two people not to bandwagon Seven yesterday, in preference of, uh, voting me instead. Hmm.
Shadell - First to catch the mountain, iirc. Has generally focused on style of arguments and expressed alignments, backing most reads with some evidence. Good taste in literature.
Wies - Role seems dubious, even for this game, but posting style has been generally hunt-inclined, suggesting town-ness. Towniness? Towncore? Flipflopped on Logos, but provided good reasoning. Has led votes but not won them D1/D2.
Draxy - Has been doing clerical stuff and keeping track of things, which is appreciated. Tends to hop on bandwagons last-minute for the previous day or two, which is a little odd, but also has reasoning when voting. Role is plausible. Nonetheless, some doubt.
Zaealix - Most of their play has been centered around their role, despite the general consensus of role-irrelevance. I've also never heard of an Investigator who only catches 3p but not scum, but I'm not going to claim encyclopedic knowledge enough to assert its nonexistence. Weird, but possibly not evil.
Walker - The other player who didn't bandwagon Seven. Excellent sense of style. Conflicted that people will vote him in mafia but not for council.
I am most suspicious of LDJ at this point, with Zaealix distantly behind them - Wies and Shadell have both commented on their tendency to hedge and their unwillingness to support positions even after they express them, and I'm also surprised by their sudden aggression towards Nictis hypothesizing the absence of powers D1 when they themselves claimed to have assumed the absence of a Cult immediately upon receiving the PM for their Cult-based role.