Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

IIRC, -1 difficulty from this charm also applies to Paths. Still not great, but.
I mean I am sure that just about member of the white council would give up their left arm and right testicle for it, but Molly already has super human skills and can set up a ritual room to amplify them even further. DC can't go below 3 usually.
 
I think that depending on the shape of the hell this would be something you find buried in your own soul somehow. I don't think just getting it because you bought the Hell makes sense.
This does not make sense though?

We are already initiated into Sorcery, if the tattered remnants.

I am talking about the Sorcery the Primordials used to make Creation.

Take the Kingdom Charm.

The Infernal shapes her heart, soul, and Essence into the shape of a realm of her devising, featuring what￾ever oddities of geography or natural law suit her nature.
System: The Infernal crafts a new Hell-realm with￾in her own Exaltation.
This seems less, Primordial World Body and more along the lines of Zen-Mu and Creation.

More, unlike the Devil Tiger charms, the realm does not die with Molly or any Infernal.

So it very much is a seperate creation while also being a part of her. The duality inherit in all Infernal Charms.

Why I am arguing that this would at the minimum unlock workings is that, at least in 3E the Primordials built Creation with Sorcery. It is literally stated as such.

Workings are how they did it and unlike Spells, you do not learn workings. You automatically do it with the costs associated.

Workings do not rely on the fundamentals of creation like spells. They were used to make them.

I feel it is appropriate to get it here as the Thousand and One hell is literally crafted not unlike how they built Creation. It is also a 20xp charm that does not really do much in a mechanical perspective.

So it is not as If it comes from nowhere.
 
Last edited:
This does not make sense though?

We are already initiated into Sorcery, if the tattered remnants.

I am talking about the Sorcery the Primordials used to make Creation.

Take the Kingdom Charm.


This seems less, Primordial World Body and more along the lines of Zen-Mu and Creation.

More, unlike the Devil Tiger charms, the realm does not die with Molly or any Infernal.

So it very much is a seperate creation while also being a part of her. The duality inherit in all Infernal Charms.

Why I am arguing that this would at the minimum unlock workings is that, at least in 3E the Primordials built Creation with Sorcery. It is literally stated as such.

Workings are how they did it and unlike Spells, you do not learn workings. You automatically do it with the costs associated.

Workings do not rely on the fundamentals of creation like spells. They were used to make them.

I feel it is appropriate to get it here as the Thousand and One hell is literally crafted not unlike how they built Creation. It is also a 20xp charm that does not really do much in a mechanical perspective.

So it is not as If it comes from nowhere.

Narratively giving you guys a whole new system of magic to play with right now would take up a lot of time that I do not think we reasonably have, there is the matter of dealing with the fall-out of the Kingdom itself existing, the agreement you made with Broken Seeker, the rest of the turn to cover etc...
 
@DragonParadox what happens if a living human escapea our hell? Let's say we throw Daniel in there, and he spends the next five years mastering himself, going on a spirit journey and then finally exits through the Golden Gate? Does he become a Wan Xian? He's not (un)dead, so becoming a Jade Court vampire wouldn't make much sense.
 
Narratively giving you guys a whole new system of magic to play with right now would take up a lot of time that I do not think we reasonably have, there is the matter of dealing with the fall-out of the Kingdom itself existing, the agreement you made with Broken Seeker, the rest of the turn to cover etc...
Might I then propose an alternative?

MODIFIED CHARMS
The Pentacle and the Scepter (••••)

The Infernal spends long hours in meditation on the time before time, the epoch before light and law first blighted the universe, and the remnant impossibilities of that strange and pitiless mythology. From the scraps of such madness, she may uncover the deeper secrets of sorcery.

System: Upon purchasing this Charm, the Infernal gains the ability to perform Sorcerous Workings, permanently lowers the cost of all ancient sorcery rolls by 1 Non Magic or Magic Reagent (to a minimum of 1), and lowers the difficulty of all ancient sorcery rolls by one.

So the reagents needed for a First Circle and Third Circle roll are reduced by 1. While it cannot do away with the need for a Magic Reagent in a Second Circle roll (Minimum 1) it can reduce the number of non magic reagents to 1.

Bolded for emphasis. Even in 3E you need to buy a Charm to unlock Sorcery so this would be a good way. The fluff is that Molly has gained the capacity in full but cannot use it without the right charm.

Would something like this work?

Because by base, we are spending 16xp for a Charm that only offers -1 difficulty in Sorcery Spells.

Having that charm unlock Workings and giving a reagent discount makes it on par with things like perfect effects (4 dot charms).

It also gives you time to space Sorcery over updates as we already spent 20xp and will not get the xp for this, if we ever vote for it.
 
Last edited:
[X] Fivefold Courts of Frozen Fate v. 1.3

I like the contrast of the Winter Court/Sailor Moon/alien deathworld aesthetics. I also prefer that version of Endless Suffering, which gives the inhabitants more agency over their voluntary immortality.

My concern is that the Resistance seems to be living in pretty shitty conditions compared to the five megacities, but it has a future solution quest built in, so I would rather deal with that than Overpopulation.
 
Also votes as they stand. Might as well as call it.
Adhoc vote count started by Yzarc on Aug 11, 2023 at 3:49 AM, finished with 201 posts and 48 votes.
 
Might I then propose an alternative?



Bolded for emphasis. Even in 3E you need to buy a Charm to unlock Sorcery so this would be a good way. The fluff is that Molly has gained the capacity in full but cannot use it without the right charm.

Would something like this work?

Because by base, we are spending 16xp for a Charm that only offers -1 difficulty in Sorcery Spells.

Having that charm unlock Workings and giving a reagent discount makes it on par with things like perfect effects (4 dot charms).

It also gives you time to space Sorcery over updates as we already spent 20xp and will not get the xp for this, if we ever vote for it.

That sounds more workable, you are right that charm is rather under-powered especially for this world which is more high magic than base WoD.

@DragonParadox what happens if a living human escapea our hell? Let's say we throw Daniel in there, and he spends the next five years mastering himself, going on a spirit journey and then finally exits through the Golden Gate? Does he become a Wan Xian? He's not (un)dead, so becoming a Jade Court vampire wouldn't make much sense.

Nothing special unfortunately, Han and Po are not separated so the latter cannot awaken

Also it's been 24 hours and the vote is pretty solidly Fivefold courts and has been since the start.

Vote closed.
 
Honestly not too put out TBH. My build was not that different from Yog's, me choosing overpop to him choosing opposition.

All in all, we now have a world with good World building and pretty much everything I wanted, especially with DragonParadox's clarification on the Opposition.
 
Winning Vote
Adhoc vote count started by Yzarc on Aug 11, 2023 at 3:49 AM, finished with 201 posts and 48 votes.
 
Arc 8 Post 56: Before the Throne
Before the Throne

18th of November 2006 A.D.

As the world shifts you reflexively reach out not with hands nor even with thoughts made real, but with your soul. In basalt and brass you are now garbed, girdled with old script just on the edge of knowing, upon your head a helm, a crown as on the eve of battle. But there is no battle to be seen. Instead you seem to be floating above a basalt floor threaded with silver wire in the shape of a spider's web which flows into walls of the same make make set with lanterns that burn with cold green flame, nuclear flame, you know behind behind leaded glass. Five lines of columns spiral inwards along the points of the silver web, jointed in gleaming brass and wrought of smooth obsidian, in a way that looks almost organic, or cybernetic maybe with the way the metal clamps tight around it.

"What... what is this place?" you have never heard Harry stutter before, though maybe that says more about your lack of observation than anything given the thing he is motioning at looks like one of those half-egg couches, if the shape was then filled in by a forcefield humming merily along.

That is just a dust cover, this place isn't used that often.

If circumstances were less weird you would wonder how you know that, or for that matter how you know which button to tap to turn off the static cover and rearrange it into a more open configuration to set Izzy on and then the next one for Alec.

Audience seating, for those favoured by the Throne

The thought directs your gaze inwards to the heart of the room for the first time, now that your friends are comfortable, safe. Beyond Harry poking at one of the couches like it's a live bomb, beyond your dad looking at the celling where gleaming red mechanical eyes on slender spider like limbs unfold to look down upon the scene....

Palace Security SUTRA performing an emergency scan of the chamber after unexpected spike in thaumic readings

You see it, base rising out of the floor like a black wave of basalt cresting before the shore, it flares into arm-rests of brass and of brass is wrought the throne's backrest sculpted like leaves, like flames, like great wings unfurling, studded with gemstones that glitter like ice, Upon that throne in script far older than is found anywhere else in the chamber, though not as old as some you have seen and written is spelled out a title, no a name:

Radiant Pearl of Sorcery Pure and Impure, Exalted Mistress of Mystical Arts, Boundaries, Crossroads and Transitions, Shaper and Builder, Beloved of All

When you were in eight grade your English Teacher had given out an assignment to look into the origin of your names. So of course you had, unsurprised to find the origins of Margret and Amanda, pearl and beloved of all, though very much surprised at one of the suspected roots of Katherine being the Goddess of Witches and Crossroads

Margret Katherine Amanda Carpenter.

That is my throne, the thought comes unbidden and unchallenged. Just as the armor you bear, just as the helm, the crown on your brow, in this place made enduring, this throne, this hall, this realm... are yours. Without conscious thought you head towards the chamber's heart, steps loud and echoing off the polished flood, by chance, if chance it be, right up a thread of silver bright.

As you reach the foot of the throne though you turn to look at Harry and at your father, only now noticing the absence of the sword at his side: "Dad where's...?"

"It... he, told me he could not follow where I was going, but that he would be watched," comes the reply, clearly more worried about you than Amoracchius at the moment. "Molly, what is this place?"

"It is the Palace of Soaring Majesty," a voice both familiar and impossible speaks as soft steps accroach from behind a pillar, familiar because you have heard it every day of your life for the past six months, impossible because you have not heard it aloud since that terrible wonderous moment in the depths of Arctis Tor. Usum looks much as when you had last seen him, androgynous, beautiful, thoughtlessly graceful in every movement. The smile he wears though, that smile is trouble. It's an 'I told you so smile' if ever you saw one.

"Set between the jaws of the Dragon of Night and the Dragon of Light in the realm which knows neither night nor day as the people of Earth know it, only the passage of its moon. To most of its inhabitants it is simply Creation, for they know of no other world but this. To the bureaucrats of the City of Swords it is the Fivefold Courts of Fate, forged as one in the Wars of Unity, governed by laws as perfect and imperishable as the Turning of the Wheel, to the Scholars of the City of Scrolls it is Sanctuary, though even they know not what calamity it warded the people from, to the tocatli mystics who contemplate the fate of all things it is the Web-in-Being, to those gurvel tribes that still dwell in the wastes beyond the life-giving light of the ring of flame it is the Anchor, the Pivot, the Fulcrum and variations uncounted in dialects almost as numerous. To the Machine Spirits of the Noosphere it is the Prime Root."

He pauses as if to take breath, though you know him enough to tell he is just trying to be dramatic. "To the faithful of the Covenant of the Empress-to-Be, five billion souls just about, human, tocatli, gurvel and seta, organic and synthetic and all heritages and states between it is the Realm in Waiting."

No, no, no, no... It feels like you are denying that the sun is hot that ice is cold or the sky is blue. Every word he is saying has the ring of not just truth, but common knowledge, something you know just as you knew how to operate the couches or what the camera eye is.

"Awaiting the return of their Creator, She in Whose Soul they are Cradled, though that last piece of the puzzle is known only to certain esoteric sects in the City of Fountains, Monastery of the World-Song. The Throne becomes you Majesty and you are Becoming."

Daring to glance back at the others you see Harry listening intently to something, someone, only he can hear and as for your dad... well you have never seen dad speechless before.

How does Molly react?

[] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl

[] Roll down some screens -you know how to do that somehow- figure out what is going on from a non-Usum perspective

[] First thing's first, get Izzy and Alec to some kind of medical facility, you can deal with the rest of this later.

[] Write in


OOC: With thanks to @Yog and @myrix for designing a rich world and its history, a great foundation to build on. Also I am not even going to make Molly roll Perception+Empathy, Usum is transcendentally smug.
 
Last edited:
[X] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl
 
[] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl

[X] First thing's first, get Izzy and Alec to some kind of medical facility, you can deal with the rest of this later.
 
Last edited:
[X] First thing's first, get Izzy and Alec to some kind of medical facility, you can deal with the rest of this later.

We have people who are hurt. Deal with that first. The coronation or whatever can wait.
 
[X] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl

Take our throne, and then we can order doctors to come here. Surveillance is watching. We're going to have to deal with people to get them help. That'll go faster if we take charge.
 
I'm gonna say it now but that mentor 5 better pay its worth coming soon. We need an angel contact to talk about our hell. Even if its just a single conversation with questions and answers. Maybe for giving them souls that want to move from our hell to heaven and know about the politics of this situation with God. Like God clearly made or had at least some interaction with the forming of hells when they were meant for rehabilitation. Maybe give us a fucking primer on the rules cause as much as I love our dad his mentor 5 hasn't been worth much he'd already have helped us regardless after all.

Edit: Mind you if there are some rules against this I can understand them not helping as powerful as they are they are not omnipotent and likely have equals.
 
Last edited:
Yeah. These guys have good healers. Best take control and have them check the two out.

We have no dots in medicine so it is not as if we can do much for them.
 
I'm gonna say it now but that mentor 5 better pay its worth coming soon. We need an angel contact to talk about our hell. Even if its just a single conversation with questions and answers. Maybe for giving them souls that want to move from our hell to heaven and know about the politics of this situation with God. Like God clearly made or had at least some interaction with the forming of hells when they were meant for rehabilitation. Maybe give us a fucking primer on the rules cause as much as I love our dad his mentor 5 hasn't been worth much he'd already have helped us regardless after all.

Edit: Mind you if there are some rules against this I can understand them not helping as powerful as they are they are not omnipotent and likely have equals.
Strong Disagree on the Mentor 5 not doing anything part.

Part of why the White Hats like the Monk who is teaching us MA is BECAUSE we got a vouch from up high.
 
[X] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl
 
Thanks DP, I'm just about ready to squeal in delight!

Given that Izzy and Alec are now comfortable and safe,
now that your friends are comfortable, safe.
and we are being watched and very soon we'll be greeted, either cordially as befits us or not so cordially with doubt, it's imperative that we ascend the Throne and prove that we are who we are.

[X] Ascend the Throne, he's right you can handle the rest of this later, but if people are waiting, if people are watching they should see a ruler, not a confused girl
 
Missed the world update I've been reading up on the votes.

[X] First thing's first, get Izzy and Alec to some kind of medical facility, you can deal with the rest of this later

Help first I think showing empathy would be good way to start her rule
 
Back
Top