Green Flame Rising (Exalted vs Dresden Files)

I keep forgetting that MiS is only supposed to work on Formori.

That we even get it to work on Ghouls and Whampires is a pretty generous interpretation already.
 
Subterfuge, it could be empathy if you actually gave a damn about his wellbeing, but Molly is not nice enough to care if the cannibal monster who kidnapped her friends gets hurt.
Ok, let's see. I have a so-so stunt, probably one bonus dice (it uses establsihed real events, so maybe 2? Let's not bet on that), Manipulation + Subterfuge is 6. Excellency is 12. WHWH adds that to 14, so a total of 15 dice (with stunt). Base DC is probably 8, so DC 7 with BSM (we do have BSM on, right?). 15 dice of key ability at DC 7 gives 8 successes on average. The probability of rolling no more than 4 successes is ~ 10%. That's good enough odds for me.

Let's try and turn it against Red Court. And then either ambush it later, or get False Springs Beckon and work on uncorrupting it.
 
So, if he buys it (and I think we have enough plausible deniability to obscure our Crown here), do we kill him later? I mean, this probably ends with a three-way ambush. Us + Broken Seeker + Blackstuff against Arianna Ortega, Broken Seeker + allies against us, us + Blackstuff + Listens-to-Wind against Broken Seeker. We would want When the Tigers Broke Free (which combines with Kingdom being signature to allow deployment anywhere we want).

Or it just ends with us killing Red King's daughter and using her soul as fuel, and a naagloshii... not ally, but a neutral party?

Anyway, I am actually excited about this. This has potential.
 
So, if he buys it (and I think we have enough plausible deniability to obscure our Crown here), do we kill him later? I mean, this probably ends with a three-way ambush. Us + Broken Seeker + Blackstuff against Arianna Ortega, Broken Seeker + allies against us, us + Blackstuff + Listens-to-Wind against Broken Seeker. We would want When the Tigers Broke Free (which combines with Kingdom being signature to allow deployment anywhere we want).

Or it just ends with us killing Red King's daughter and using her soul as fuel, and a naagloshii... not ally, but a neutral party?

Anyway, I am actually excited about this. This has potential.
Kill it. 100%, no regrets no remorse, kill it.
 
[X] Plan enemy of my enemy's enemy
-[X] Make it clear you know who that is already, on the one hand there is a good chance it will spook him into caving, for now at least, your friends safe and sound. On the other hand you will have revealed extreme divinatory powers to someone who is definitely not your friend.
--[X] Convince him he's being set up. Probably in hopes he and you take each other out. Use the meeting you had with a team of reads as an explanation to how you even knew he was in town in the first place. Make it look like they warned you about him, seemingly as repayment for aiding them and not attacking them. You should have known better than to ever assume Reds wouldn't have an ulterior motive.
--[X] Subterfuge excellency if needed
--[X] Stunt: You pause for several moments, as if deep in thought, and then speak again, aspecting your voice to look like you are just getting the idea, which, in a sense, you are: "But not when your contractor is setting you up to die a final death, isn't it? And if I'm right, that's exactly what is going on. You are here on the orders from the Reds, aren't you? I met a team of them, led by a count, several months ago when out of town getting some fish food, if you know what I mean. Worked with them for a bit, and let them go. They warned me, "to repay my generosity" about you being in town. Took me a while to verify it. It makes sense now that they knew you were here, if they are the ones to send you here in the first place."
 
Ok, let's see. I have a so-so stunt, probably one bonus dice (it uses establsihed real events, so maybe 2? Let's not bet on that), Manipulation + Subterfuge is 6. Excellency is 12. WHWH adds that to 14, so a total of 15 dice (with stunt). Base DC is probably 8, so DC 7 with BSM (we do have BSM on, right?). 15 dice of key ability at DC 7 gives 8 successes on average. The probability of rolling no more than 4 successes is ~ 10%. That's good enough odds for me.

Let's try and turn it against Red Court. And then either ambush it later, or get False Springs Beckon and work on uncorrupting it.
We have way too many rehab missions going already, we don't have the bandwidth to try for more. Especially on a big fish like this.

Better to just kill him and be done with it once it's clear we won't be breaking any sort of oath doing so.
 
We have way too many rehab missions going already, we don't have the bandwidth to try for more. Especially on a big fish like this.

Better to just kill him and be done with it once it's clear we won't be breaking any sort of oath doing so.
True. Doesn't mean we can't or shouldn't deceive it now. Ideally we'd be able to kill him and Red Princess at the same time. Super-ideally, we frame them for each other's murder and completely conceal our involvement.
 
Last edited:
Hmm... not a lot of votes so far.

As a small hint of what is to come depending on what happens in the next few updates you guys may have the option to buy your hell early as you did ancient sorcery.

Vote still open obviously
Adhoc vote count started by DragonParadox on Aug 7, 2023 at 7:06 AM, finished with 42 posts and 5 votes.

  • [X] Plan enemy of my enemy's enemy
    -[X] Make it clear you know who that is already, on the one hand there is a good chance it will spook him into caving, for now at least, your friends safe and sound. On the other hand you will have revealed extreme divinatory powers to someone who is definitely not your friend.
    --[X] Convince him he's being set up. Probably in hopes he and you take each other out. Use the meeting you had with a team of reads as an explanation to how you even knew he was in town in the first place. Make it look like they warned you about him, seemingly as repayment for aiding them and not attacking them. You should have known better than to ever assume Reds wouldn't have an ulterior motive.
    --[X] Subterfuge excellency if needed
    --[X] Stunt: You pause for several moments, as if deep in thought, and then speak again, aspecting your voice to look like you are just getting the idea, which, in a sense, you are: "But not when your contractor is setting you up to die a final death, isn't it? And if I'm right, that's exactly what is going on. You are here on the orders from the Reds, aren't you? I met a team of them, led by a count, several months ago when out of town getting some fish food, if you know what I mean. Worked with them for a bit, and let them go. They warned me, "to repay my generosity" about you being in town. Took me a while to verify it. It makes sense now that they knew you were here, if they are the ones to send you here in the first place."
    [X] Eyes Bigger than your Mouth
    -[X] [Stunt] A flicker of amusement enters into Molly's tone "Did you sign a pledge of loyalty? Agree to keep their secrets in all ways? Surely one as old and clever as you can share without speaking a word if nothing else"
    —[X] Something cold sweeps in, snuffing the lightness in her voice like a candle. " You're very well prepared for today, but what about tomorrow? You can hurt my mortals, and that's certainly leverage, but it has a shelf life and I know you"
    —[X] " Even if you dodge the wizards' till their blood is dust I will remember the insult if nothing else". How many centuries of spiteful circling is this really worth to you?
 
True. Doesn't mean we can't or shouldn't deceive it now. Ideally we'd be able to kill him and Red Princess at the same time. Super-ideally, we frame them for each other's murder and completely conceal our involvement.
Too risky, I'd rather kill them one at a time than potentially choke up fighting both at once.

Getting away entirely clean is enticing, but is also asking for a lot out of a complicated situation with powerful opposition.

buy your hell early as you did ancient sorcery.

So what's the splash zone on the aura for becoming your own planet? Because I think we're going to start getting noise complaints from supernatural Chicago if we keep this up. :V

… you know, once someone has the guts to come check on what happened.
 
So what's the splash zone on the aura for becoming your own planet? Because I think we're going to start getting noise complaints from supernatural Chicago if we keep this up. :V

… you know, once someone has the guts to come check on what happened.

No, no, no... you have always been a planet* dreaming wrapped in memories of ages past yourself containing multitudes.

That is much less alarming you see :V

*if you choose planet, you can get one the size of a house if you want
 
Too risky, I'd rather kill them one at a time than potentially choke up fighting both at once.

Getting away entirely clean is enticing, but is also asking for a lot out of a complicated situation with powerful opposition.
True. However, my plan doesn't lock us into fighting both at once. We can just as well ambush Arianna first, and Broken Seeker afterwards, or Broken Seeker now, and Arianna later (that would be harder to do without Broken Seeker's help, but might still be doable). Right now it spins a plausible lie to him, to get our friends out of the line of fire using both the Crown results and our quest history.

As a small hint of what is to come depending on what happens in the next few updates you guys may have the option to buy your hell early as you did ancient sorcery.
Hmm... Either sending Broken Seeker to our hell, or sending souls of friends into our hell, or transporting all of us into our hell?

Anyway, I'm down for that.
 
I suppose the easiest way to solve a hostage situation is to just kill the hostages. Send them to our personal hell, and just help them escape as a Jade vampire later. Technigulie even an infinity repeatable trick.
 
Last edited:
No, no, no... you have always been a planet* dreaming wrapped in memories of ages past yourself containing multitudes.

That is much less alarming you see :V

*if you choose planet, you can get one the size of a house if you want
I'm sure suddenly noticing the new planet/content (because who buys a broom closet like a peasant?) is substantially less concerning.
True. However, my plan doesn't lock us into fighting both at once. We can just as well ambush Arianna first, and Broken Seeker afterwards, or Broken Seeker now, and Arianna later (that would be harder to do without Broken Seeker's help, but might still be doable). Right now it spins a plausible lie to him, to get our friends out of the line of fire using both the Crown results and our quest history.
Yeah, I was just commenting on the general line of thinking.
Hmm... Either sending Broken Seeker to our hell, or sending souls of friends into our hell, or transporting all of us into our hell?

Anyway, I'm down for that.
That guy is way too dangerous to leave unsupervised in anything but pieces within Molly's world body.

I suppose the easiest way to solve a hostage situation is to just kill the hostages. Send them to our personal hell, and just help them escape as a Jade vampire later. Technigulie even an infinity repeatable trick.
There's probably a nerf stopping infinite Jade armies from being a thing.

Something like requiring real spiritual trials to properly transform. Which @Yog wrote some excellent options for, but none of which are particularly short term.

Also we technically might have to steal souls from the white god to try even try, and Molly would have Issues with that.
 
The point of the first quote is that BS doesn't take payment in experience, as DP confirmed in a later post. She can't be paying him with Harry, because he gets that by default.

She brought him something to satisfy his physical tribute demands, and implied they were from the council.
Could be apprentices or something for all we know.
Possible, but unlikely. IMO.
I read that more as her offering those, and being rejected out of hand.
I suspect if she hadnt been who she was, offering something like that would have gotten the speaker killed.

What? He's specifically telling Harry messengers not all created equal or identical, and semi divine doesn't mean they're exactly what he expects them to be.
It also says nothing about what the Holy People actually were/are.
You are misunderstanding me.

When Bob talks about pagan gods and pantheons, he's generally quite good at being specific. Supernatural society seems to have a good idea of who's who. And gods were supposed to have been active in human society until fairly recently by immortal standards, while the Holy People are supposed to have left in pre-history.

I am saying that whatever the Holy People are is in this cosmology? I dont think Butcher portrays them as a pagan pantheon.
And given as naagloshii walk around with intellectus, which is a trick no god Im aware of in the series has, let alone their minions, we're unlikely to be looking at something from a pagan pantheon.

I don't like revealing our divinatory abilities, but as long as we stab it in the back the moment our friends are free and kill it, it should be ok. If anyone has any other ideas, I am willing to listen. Maybe ask what it actually wants out of life? Other than petty sadism against mortals.
I dont see a reason to reveal even that.
We captured one of his people spying on us on Halloween. Thats in and of itself enough hard evidence to have followed up on him and his identity.

No freebies for kidnappers.
I'm sorry, but you are failing reading comprehension pretty terribly here. It's Harry who brings up angels here, as an analogy, because he's primarily christian culturally, so he wouldn't use valkyries or some other manner of divine servitors from other religions. Bob then responds with "Or like those guys on bikes in New York, maybe?" and says that "not all messengers are created equal", which to me reads like he agrees that naagloshii are like angels, in that they are divine messengers, but they are not equal to angels in any way, with a comparison to bikers in New York being just as valid.

Nowhere does it say that naagloshii are affiliated with or are angels. Or that Holy People are angels. In fact, Holy People aren't discussed at all in this text.
I didnt say naagloshii were Christian angels, or that whoever they were serving were the classic JudaeoChristian angels.
Just that they werent serving a pagan pantheon.
At least, Butcher didnt write them that way.

Its not like the Old Testament doesnt have multiple instances of angels allegedly walking the Earth in human form.
With and without sanction.

Also, we've seen the part-human kid of a naagloshii.
He was...formidable. Jump in the face of a Coin-wielding Bigfoot barehanded kind of formidable.


I don't believe that's the case. The White Council knows what happens when a wizard is captured and turned by the Red Court, which means it's happened before.
Im sure its happened to wizards and sorcerers before, especially given the Red Court domination of Latin America.
At least some of the Red Court sorcerers we see in Changes have to have had pre-existing skills before being vamped, after all.
That doesnt mean it has happened to a White Council wizard before, which was my argument.

There's a fair number of magic users who never get strong or skilled enough to make the White Council; in Chicago alone, we saw around half a dozen of them in McAnally's during Dead Beat.
And the White King had three witches around in his employ during Blood Rites.

Much likelier victims of Red Court predation, than a White Council wizard.

===
Plus, note that Rampire reproduction requires the cooperation of the target.
They can turn a magic-user into a half-Red, but the magic user still has to take the last step to become a Red by draining someone else of their blood to become a full Red.

Its not exactly a slam dunk for turning a magic user, and if the magic user is strong enough to use a death curse, everyone involved in trying to coerce the victim can go up in a metaphorical or possibly literal fireball as the wizard goes From Hells Heart I Stab At Thee. Which is a fairly effective deterrent against attempts at forced conversions.
 
Plus, note that Rampire reproduction requires the cooperation of the target.
They can turn a magic-user into a half-Red, but the magic user still has to take the last step to become a Red by draining someone else of their blood to become a full Red.

Its not exactly a slam dunk for turning a magic user, and if the magic user is strong enough to use a death curse, everyone involved in trying to coerce the victim can go up in a metaphorical or possibly literal fireball as the wizard goes From Hells Heart I Stab At Thee. Which is a fairly effective deterrent against attempts at forced conversions.

Cooperation is perhaps overstating it. Yes inductees have to actually be the ones to do the draining, but being in their right mind is not required. Someone who has been starved, drugged to the gills to make them more agresive and then thrown at a already bleeding human... might resist the process once, they might even resist it twice, but do it enough times and you will get a vampire out of it.
 
Possible, but unlikely. IMO.
I read that more as her offering those, and being rejected out of hand.
I suspect if she hadnt been who she was, offering something like that would have gotten the speaker killed
Keep in mind he never said 'I would not fight that', he sad 'you do not pay me in fights I have to do on my own, you pay me in sacrifices'. Also you guys still do not know the terms of the deal since you asked 'who' not 'what'.
The first thing they seem to have offered it is 'eat this very scary being and you will be freed of your curse' to which the answer was 'How nice you are paying me in experience. I am not an intern' :V

DP is pretty explicit here about BS not taking payments in the form of its own fights, and the next line clearly ties this to the council.

He almost certainly got fresh meat instead of hot air for this at least partially in advance.

I am saying that whatever the Holy People are is in this cosmology? I dont think Butcher portrays them as a pagan pantheon.
And given as naagloshii walk around with intellectus, which is a trick no god Im aware of in the series has, let alone their minions, we're unlikely to be looking at something from a pagan pantheon.
Valkyries. Also big land spirits; intellectus is a big deal, but it doesn't necessarily make you a specific type of creature to have it.

Edit: fixed my messed up source quotes.
 
Last edited:
Im sure its happened to wizards and sorcerers before, especially given the Red Court domination of Latin America.
At least some of the Red Court sorcerers we see in Changes have to have had pre-existing skills before being vamped, after all.
That doesnt mean it has happened to a White Council wizard before, which was my argument.

There's a fair number of magic users who never get strong or skilled enough to make the White Council; in Chicago alone, we saw around half a dozen of them in McAnally's during Dead Beat.
And the White King had three witches around in his employ during Blood Rites.

Much likelier victims of Red Court predation, than a White Council wizard.

===
Plus, note that Rampire reproduction requires the cooperation of the target.
They can turn a magic-user into a half-Red, but the magic user still has to take the last step to become a Red by draining someone else of their blood to become a full Red.

Its not exactly a slam dunk for turning a magic user, and if the magic user is strong enough to use a death curse, everyone involved in trying to coerce the victim can go up in a metaphorical or possibly literal fireball as the wizard goes From Hells Heart I Stab At Thee. Which is a fairly effective deterrent against attempts at forced conversions.

I had a quick look, and while the infected has to feed on human blood to transform, I can't see where it says they have to knowingly or voluntarily do so. That means that a captured wizard couod simply be infected he fed someone's blood while unconscious.

The passage where Harry described the concern the Wardens have about bein wizards being captured makes no mention or suggestion that such resistance is possible, and in this case its absence strongly suggests it's not. The implication is that capture wouod almost automatically produce a spellcasting Red.

And although it's a slight side point, I think it's suggested in places that Red Court vampires aren't converted humans but more like a type of creature more like a parasitic wasp/chest rusted alien that gestates inside a human before eating them from the inside out, but with the added ability to eat their host's memories and any magical talent they have, beforr processing to wear their skin as a mask.

They may be non-humans who kill and replace their victims, even if some of them falsely belong they have continuity of identity.
 
Back
Top