Remove ads

Game, Set, [MAFIA]

Do people like pointless polls with their mafia?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 7 24.1%

  • No.

    Votes: 2 6.9%

  • I didn't answer this.

    Votes: 7 24.1%

  • Wynaut?

    Votes: 13 44.8%
  • Total voters
    29
Reader mode
I am going to head to bed. I should have gone a couple hours ago.

If y'all decide to vote for me tonight, that is cool. Don't worry about waiting up. I think I have given every defense I can.

In order not to slow things down unnecessarily, I'll go ahead and vote.

[X] vote Young Pyromancer
 
... for the record, I still think waiting to make your case against someone until they have less time to explain themselves is stupid. I get the logic of putting them under pressure, but I feel that the best way to catch a wolf is through open discourse, not through last-minute pressure tactics.
 
Young Pyromancer said:
... for the record, I still think waiting to make your case against someone until they have less time to explain themselves is stupid. I get the logic of putting them under pressure, but I feel that the best way to catch a wolf is through open discourse, not through last-minute pressure tactics.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Pretty sure that isn't the point. There are other reasons to want to let someone else form their own opinions before you present your own.
 
Hmh my reading.

It is a hard one I confess.
YP had the early drawback but is also very hammery, If I am not mistaken in my calculation , him breaking the tie that killed swarmingu prevented scum from winning that night if I saw that right? But they also tried to hammer tykan in after my call out, which makes sense as they suspected be in general to be scum.
Which more or less works out there for 40/60

Meso has a safe claim in the cop, and I felt that the way that they argued was somewhat a bit to safe there. Together with a tendency to vote for town , which they got called out on but argued that it was the sensible way to vote at that time.
Now on the one hand they are to veteran to normally do that by what I heard here, on the other hand that would exactly be why they as a Veteran could do that.

but one of their posts on a reread made me suspicious
mesonoxian said:
@Shadell I asked about the roleblock flavor was because I didn't yet know if you were town. My investigation didn't have flavor, I just got a result. Roleblocking doesn't return results at all, so I figured scum probably didn't get any feedback, and would be guessing. If you said something completely different, I would have treat that as a null result since Nictis might have varied them for fun. If they had matched I would have seen that as a point in your favor.

That you didn't answer made me really suspicious. It is why I kept doubting you after your interaction with IH and ondine.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...

@Shadell @Young Pyromancer Did you get flavor for every of your night actions?
 
Scia said:
Hmh my reading.

It is a hard one I confess.
YP had the early drawback but is also very hammery, If I am not mistaken in my calculation , him breaking the tie that killed swarmingu prevented scum from winning that night if I saw that right? But they also tried to hammer tykan in after my call out, which makes sense as they suspected be in general to be scum.
Which more or less works out there for 40/60

Meso has a safe claim in the cop, and I felt that the way that they argued was somewhat a bit to safe there. Together with a tendency to vote for town , which they got called out on but argued that it was the sensible way to vote at that time.
Now on the one hand they are to veteran to normally do that by what I heard here, on the other hand that would exactly be why they as a Veteran could do that.

but one of their posts on a reread made me suspicious


@Shadell @Young Pyromancer Did you get flavor for every of your night actions?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
For the roleblock I got told I stepped into a hole in the ground and took all night to crawl back out.

I got something like (paraphrasing) "You interrogate X, you believe they are Town" for my actual results. So I guess that is a kind of flavor, but that is all I got.

The exception was my first investigation after the roleblock (on Young Pyromancer if I remember correctly) which was prefaced with a note about dusting myself off after getting out of the hole.
 
Oh, and the night I took no action (night before last, I can't remember if that was 4 or 5) I got a note about feeling relaxed after we caught a couple scum and taking a night off.
 
Right, looking back on flavors. First I tried to sell someone girl scout cookies even though I wasn't a girl scout, then was the clown bit, then I ran into them at the store because I needed to buy more whipped cream, then I asked them to help look for my lost pet alligator with me, and finally I came Christmas caroling to someone, because I thought it was Christmas, even though it was summer.
 
[X] Null

I put my vote on so I wouldn't hold up EoD until I woke up. No need for that now.
 
I am unsure about my vote as i can see the argument for both .
My gut is debating it back and forth so i feel thst I am also trusting in the analysis of @shadel
 
@Shadell I hate to say it, but I think it comes down to your argument. I know this isn't a great position to be put in.

I did not play well last Day phase. When Tykan went after me acting so certain of his conclusion , I took that as clear evidence he was scum and didn't consider the (in retrospect obvious) possibility of us both being town. So if we wind up losing because I looked scummy that's on me. You'd be fully justified voting either way to be honest.
 
Same. I've tried really hard to play well this game, but I did some stupid things and probably look scummy as a result. There also aren't any good pieces of evidence against Meso aside from waffly play and pushing Tykan there. He's played really well this game, and I've had to re-think whether it was Scia several times, and even now I'm somewhat doubtful. If you vote me, I won't hold it against you.

What I WILL hold against you is if you vote for me without getting a chance to respond to your arguments. :p I've yet to see any real arguments against me other then the hammer bit, and I've explained my thought process for that. I also think all the points in favor of me counter that bit out, so I'd like to hear what makes you suspect me more than Meso.
 
No one's hammering until tomorrow. We have a day left, and, atm, I need it. I've delayed giving my own arguments because it's going to be very easy for everyone to jump on confirmed town and sheep me, and I'm worried any real push to either direction will lock it. I'll get something out longer in a bit.
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top