Remove ads

Game, Set, [MAFIA]

Do people like pointless polls with their mafia?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 7 24.1%

  • No.

    Votes: 2 6.9%

  • I didn't answer this.

    Votes: 7 24.1%

  • Wynaut?

    Votes: 13 44.8%
  • Total voters
    29
Reader mode
Ok so we have :
  1. @Shadell
  2. @ondine
  3. @Young Pyromancer
  4. @Zaealix
  5. @Totadileplayz
  6. @Tykan
  7. @mesonoxian
  8. @Scia
  9. @Swarmingu
Shadell and I are mech cleared and until I hear a CC I'm not discussing it again.

The post Z linked of Totos only puts him in a good light. He assumes nothing, works through the logic and comes to a rational answer. I would consider him safely town. Scia I believe is as well based on her logical attempts to solve.

So we have
Meso
Tykan
Z
Swarm
Young Pyro

3 of them are scum.

In terms of who I find most suspicious I would put my bets on meso, Z and Young Pyro.

Also, it's currently 6-3. If we kill a town tomorrow will be 4-3 or even possibly if there's arson we just lose. Now is the time to claim y'all. Any real info you know and your roll, I think. Thoughts @Shadell ?

I want to hear from meso, Z and Young Pyro first, personally. I'm very curious to hear their claims.
 
Young Pyromancer said:
This, along with your stuff about Meso later in the post, sounds like you're going to vote on meso, but when he flips village you plan to be all 'I told you so'. If we lynch him and he's village, you're my next suspect.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Setting up a potential mislynch?
And if there even is a tomorrow.


Tykan said:
@Nictis, probably a very stupid question, but the scum abilities have a drawback as well, right?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
mesonoxian said:
That's been confirmed:
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Tykan said:
Thanks, missed that one. As I said, stupid question ;)
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
The theater, the theater, what's happened to the theater?!??!
 
ondine said:
Setting up a potential mislynch?
And if there even is a tomorrow.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
What do you mean? We know how many scum there are. I don't think they could be dousing and killing on the same nights so we definitely have another day. Or rather if they are able to kill and douse simultaneously, we're already doomed.
 
I am considering claiming. I'll listen to the opinion of the rest of town, though.
 
mesonoxian said:
What do you mean? We know how many scum there are. I don't think they could be dousing and killing on the same nights so we definitely have another day. Or rather if they are able to kill and douse simultaneously, we're already doomed.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
It's possible that they've already doused. Then they could simply kill tonight. We don't know if that's the case or not, but it's possible.

I've never been town before, but mechanically speaking. Claiming gives us nothing right? The Scum would know what roles don't exist, so they have a buffer they can simply step into. Thus not giving any information to town I feel. But, that's just my personal thoughts on the matter. It's at best a risky proposition that I simply don't know how it would work.
 
Totadileplayz said:
It's possible that they've already doused. Then they could simply kill tonight. We don't know if that's the case or not, but it's possible.

I've never been town before, but mechanically speaking. Claiming gives us nothing right? The Scum would know what roles don't exist, so they have a buffer they can simply step into. Thus not giving any information to town I feel. But, that's just my personal thoughts on the matter. It's at best a risky proposition that I simply don't know how it would work.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
We have at most one more mistake we can make before we lose the game. Possibly zero. So we need to kill mafia now.
 
That is we may not lose at this next mistake bit we would at the one after.
 
mesonoxian said:
What do you mean? We know how many scum there are. I don't think they could be dousing and killing on the same nights so we definitely have another day. Or rather if they are able to kill and douse simultaneously, we're already doomed.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
This is what TMI looks like to me.
Why wouldn't mafia have a faction kill as well as an arsonist? We don't know the combination of roles for each mafioso..unless we do.
 
ondine said:
We have at most one more mistake we can make before we lose the game. Possibly zero. So we need to kill mafia now.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
Yeah. I think I can help a bit. I'm the Cop. Unfortunately, I have a very big drawback, one of the scum each night is immune to my investigation. Night one I tried to visit InterstellarHobo, but I was roleblocked. Last night I visited @Young Pyromancer and got a town result. Of course, there is a 1 in three chance I'll read scum as town and I don't know if that is the same as or in addition to the lawyer.

That's also why I was down on Cop Cover day 2. I was the Cop, but I had no result. If I made one up and got nightkilled, it would validate my false claim. If I didn't and everyone else did, I would stand out, which I was trying to avoid.

I know this is pretty weak data, but it is what I have and I think it helps narrow down our suspect list a bit, at least provisionally.
 
  1. Shadell
  2. ondine
  3. Young Pyromancer
  4. Zaealix
  5. Totadileplayz
  6. Tykan
  7. @mesonoxian
  8. Scia
  9. Swarmingu
That leaves us five people I think are suspect. Just four if we go with town reading Totadile.
 
I will. But I'm going to do it last because I'm already cleared and I might catch someone in a lie.
 
ondine said:
So @Totadileplayz whatcha waiting for?
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
for a reason why We should actually go about doing this.

Since as far as I can see it's simply harmful to town. Since all mafia already know what roles are in play and which aren't thus allowing them perfect cover for this mass claiming. Which makes any role claims on our side have no real use in my eyes. Thus, I don't see value in it. For now until that's resolved I'm not going to go about telling you my role.
 
Totadileplayz said:
for a reason why We should actually go about doing this.

Since as far as I can see it's simply harmful to town. Since all mafia already know what roles are in play and which aren't thus allowing them perfect cover for this mass claiming. Which makes any role claims on our side have no real use in my eyes. Thus, I don't see value in it. For now until that's resolved I'm not going to go about telling you my role.
Click to expand...
Click to shrink...
It's not D1. We have our backs against the wall. I would rather hear from Tykan and Swarm and Zaealix first though.
 
Right, so I think the key to victory here will be figuring out the maf's drawbacks and exploiting them. I can't figure out what the drawback of the normal kill would be. The arsonist might take two nights to ignite or something. The RB being every other turn or no person twice in a row makes sense balance-wise. Not sure about the lawyer. Rolecop might be that they're not told the person they scanned's drawback, just the ability? Any other ideas?
 
Reader mode
You must login or register to reply here.
Remove ads
Back
Top