Still counts as an acknowledgment and it empowers them narratively.
They exist misinformation not worked in canon. I think it is better create narrative mythos of they exist but ultimately they exists only as obstacles in the path of true Enlightenment which we overcome to become truly free. It is not Abrahamic version of Satan rather Buddhist version of evil. They are after all embodiment of certain negative emotions which exist in everybody. We need to accept them as natural while rejecting any sort of excess like Chaos God who more or less extreme point of emotion to reach equilibrium within his or her soul. Having negative emotions is natural but we need to accept them and make sure they do not take unreasonable influence upon his or her soul. But impose narrative upon Chaos Gods as obstacles rather than sorta devil alternative. They will remain powerful but they must conform the narrative and act accordingly due yo human belief that impose such narrative.
 
Fan Morgal will need to help Lorgar with the prayer eating at a later time.

However, trying to ignore Chaos altogether to starve them is not a viable option either. It worked so well for the Emperor...
 
Not disagreeing on the "ignore chaos" part but acknowledging them gives them a back door. More on this later.
 
I suppose it depends on how you look at it. To my mind Lorgar didn't rebel against the Chaos Gods because they had no authority over him to begin with.
Think of it this way. He convinced the equivalent of the Everchosen to reject chaos and side with the other side.

He contested thd ownership of the said person's soul in defiance of all logic. He then purified Chaos taint. Something even the Emperor cannot do.

He should not have been able to do that but did so anyway.
So, the big thing I'm wondering is how we approach planetary conquest now we know that a diplomatic victory isn't possible.
Most people are slaves and serfs and the people who Hold their whips are the priests who preach about thd Gods. You have fertile ground here, especially with that rebellion Aspect.
It's the fact that they have an Intimacy, so will spend willpower to negate any attempt to. Any genuine worshiper of Chaos will probably have such an Intimacy, and we can't distinguish who does or not on a population scale.
Can spend Willpower does not mean will, especially if their Archtype supports the action.

That was mainly for PC and while any one can do it, it must make sense to do so and does not for oppressed people to spend Willpower to not rebel against their oppressors.

It is all in context of the Intimacy. Fear and hate is not love and admiration.
 
Hm, Lorgar may want to keep the fact that he can purify Chaos corruption a closely guarded secret, especially from the Emperor. There is no telling how he would react.

Well, then, with the aspects of Faith, Enlightenment, Purity, Illumination, and the Rebel, there is fertile soil aplenty for a revolution. As with Morgana from Persona 5, the hope of the Collective Unconsciousness for freedom from an oppressive order.
 
So, the big thing I'm wondering is how we approach planetary conquest now we know that a diplomatic victory isn't possible.
Most people are slaves and serfs and the people who Hold their whips are the priests who preach about thd Gods. You have fertile ground here, especially with that rebellion Aspect.
hmm . . . i'm more worried by the aftermath of a planetary invasion
whether we have a clean unified uprising by a majority of a population to purges a small cadre of tyrants and chaos worshipers or a full scale purge that butchers entire sections of the corrupted inhabitants the problem would be who we install afterwards.

like tyrants and dictatorial governments typically have a few key leaders that control a major section of a nation, so we purge khorne's hold over a planetary guard, or nurgle's influences from a planets agriculture, tzeentch's hold over the bureaucracy and slaanesh's hold over the nobility and the incentives that has tyrants/dictators hold their power for. and those key leaders have underlings that may or may-not take over and fall so we actually have to purge and replace more jobs due to potential survivors being inclined to chaos (with a democracies having to lession to more voices and key roles that support a leader, that means more people to replace if corrupted due to having more roles needing to be screened).

like we could leave the clean up to the administratum but . . . nah, i have more trust if we installed competent people into those roles ourselves what wouldn't re-fall to chaos

IIRC , correct me if I'm wrong, OTL lorgar had the slowest rate of conquest due to having his legion stay and preach; are we going to do the same thing? are we going to spend time assigning people to the purged roles in government?

i can see lorgar's specialization in socials to help sus out who's loyal and the gems out of the potential replacements, should we get lorgar some extra skills in teaching so he can raise the incorruptible to an acceptable level of skill, cause the constraints of being uncorruptible and being skilled in there intended role has a small pool to recruit from and planets might not have enough of those people.

TLDR: how fast should we liberate planets? cause the logistics to have a planet safe from re-falling to chaos looks bad.
 
Hm, if Lorgar fails to meet the Emperor's quota, instead of Monarchia, one wonders what the punishment would be. Perhaps the Emperor would unleash Russ and the nauseating Rout upon Lorgar and his Legion. The Emperor has done it before to 2 other Primarchs. He would not hesitate to do so again if he decides that Lorgar has failed him for the last time.
 
Hm, if Lorgar fails to meet the Emperor's quota, instead of Monarchia, one wonders what the punishment would be. Perhaps the Emperor would unleash Russ and the nauseating Rout upon Lorgar and his Legion. The Emperor has done it before to 2 other Primarchs. He would not hesitate to do so again if he decides that Lorgar has failed him for the last time.
Lorgar only received a punishment because he was slower than Magnus a man who very specifically didn't use heavy tactics preserved most of the knowledge of the people he took and helped rebuild after he took them. So Not only was he slower than someone who had the least amount of Space Marines possible to the point where he started with 1,000 and by the Horus heresy still had less than 100,000 he is also illegally converting the population of planets to a completely made up religion also religions are illegal on top of that.

So let's see that's not just failing to meet quota that's high treason on multiple accounts misuse of allocated resources (Space Marines, Imperial papyrus Imperial ships administratum resources Cult mechanicus resources) forceful conversion from not just religions at all because to be frank he outlawed religions as a organized structure not as a personal faith so converting anyone at all is illegal.

So I will say the emperor a genocidal Tyrant I'm never going to defend him but by even the most lax legal standards Lorgar should have been executed.
 
Hm, if Lorgar fails to meet the Emperor's quota, instead of Monarchia, one wonders what the punishment would be. Perhaps the Emperor would unleash Russ and the nauseating Rout upon Lorgar and his Legion. The Emperor has done it before to 2 other Primarchs. He would not hesitate to do so again if he decides that Lorgar has failed him for the last time.
that is unlikely to happen, the reason the Emperor burned Monarchia was that Lorgar was ignoring crusade war goals to carry out forced conversions to the imperial creed while squandering resources building temples and monuments to the worship of the emperor in the style of the ecclesiarchy at its worst , he was wasting so much time, resources and effort on this that serval sectors that his legion was supposed to clear got bodied by the orks , hence why the Emperor punished him , like if the delay was for good reason like warp turbulence, difficult compliance campaigns talking more time , logistical issues and industrial consolidation efforts the emperor would have been annoyed but accepted it war on a galactic scale is hard but cannon Lorgar had none of those reasons he was just not doing his job and instead playing cult leader hence Monarchia
 
Well, no need to wait even that long. Considering how Lorgar is developing, by the time that the Emperor does meet him here, if Lorgar does not keep certain details about himself secret, the Emperor could unilaterally decide that Lorgar is too dangerous and must be eliminated after he outlives his utility.
 
Also, I have plans with the Vision quest. Especially since Chaos definitely knows that something is wrong.

So expect it to be.....interesting, in the Chinese sense.

Votes as they stand.
Adhoc vote count started by Yzarc on May 23, 2024 at 2:26 AM, finished with 80 posts and 5 votes.

  • [X] Traps and tricks: Choose to lay down traps and other technological devices to weaken and reduce the hordes before they attack next turn.
 
Also, I have plans with the Vision quest. Especially since Chaos definitely knows that something is wrong.
I feel like the Vision quest is kind of pointless now, Lorgar just got his soul drawn no pulled into the warp confronted the 4 chaos gods and chaos undivided and defied them in their realm where they are at their strongest, usurped their champion's mind and soul from them and returned to his body unharmed, what would the Vision quest even gain him at this point ? it feels like a pointless waste of time now
 
Similarly, the discovery the Webway Eldar that they're also vulnerable to the Thirst and the discovery of how to use the pain of others to stave it off also takes many, many centuries, before which they stay locked up in the Webway as venturing outside it is dangerous for them, so the Dark Eldar don't exist at all yet.
the dark eldar do exist though, well the proto dark elder at this point anyway, their raids on Vulkans home world are where his hatred of eldar comes from and after the heresy it's a dark eldar raid on his home world that see Jagatai Khan lost in the webway trying to chase the dark eldar down to retrieve his people
 
The vision quest is specifically about him and his powers.

The chaos part was external, the vision quest is internal.
 
So expect it to be.....interesting, in the Chinese sense.
The chaos part was external, the vision quest is internal.
i was about to start ranting about how Lorgar should avoid turning some chaos daemons into females to join his Chinese cultivator imperial harem and how we got nature and machine spirits at home but just saw its just him fighting is multiple personalities
 
We are going to have to finish conquering the wound as fast as possible, because if not we will allow the chaos to expand more and more.
 
the dark eldar do exist though, well the proto dark elder at this point anyway, their raids on Vulkans home world are where his hatred of eldar comes from and after the heresy it's a dark eldar raid on his home world that see Jagatai Khan lost in the webway trying to chase the dark eldar down to retrieve his people

The thing is, the Dark Eldar don't exist yet. The Webway Eldar are still hiding in their cities under the illusion that as long as they don't go outside the wards on the Webway protect them from Slaneesh's Thirst.

It's just a plot hole that a Horus Heresy writer who didn't bother to check the timeline introduced. Initially the raiders on Vulkan's world were just unidentified Xenia, I believe. Then Eldar were shoe horned in as a familiar enemy by a writer who couldn't be bothered about continuity.

Same with having an Avatar of Khaine show up at one point to be Worfed.

Hm, if Lorgar fails to meet the Emperor's quota, instead of Monarchia, one wonders what the punishment would be. Perhaps the Emperor would unleash Russ and the nauseating Rout upon Lorgar and his Legion. The Emperor has done it before to 2 other Primarchs. He would not hesitate to do so again if he decides that Lorgar has failed him for the last time.

Our advantage is that we can help Lorgar in ways that speed him up, for example we can:

1) Givine him very powerful psyker abilities like high end Precognition and Scrying that make him a more effective general
2) Making his Legion's Librarians very powerful, skilled and stable psyker-shamans who can either work independently or support him in a chorus, as Lorgar's Mythos would probably make him very good at leading choirs of psykers
3) Making his Legion and the auxiliary units in his Expeditionary Fleet's senior officers incredibly skilled
4) Making him new loyal Navigator Houses with strong, pure genetic gifts and granting their founders great skills they can pass on, so he has more and better of them than other Primarchs, so his fleet moves faster and more safely
5) Reverse engineering the blueprints for archeotech Geller fields, warp drives, and Navigation tools and giving them to loyal Magi's who we've given relevant Savant specialisms to, so that Lorgar's fleet moves even faster
6) Reverse engineering STC templates from relics and giving them to Forge Worlds in return for their material support
7) Developing a comprehensive genetor augmentation package that non-marine elites can use to increase the number of supersoldiers
8) There are some more ambitious things we might be able to do if we can make demons who can possess people and/or have various useful spirit charms that can be used to give people augmentations.

Lorgar is likely to be one of the least accomplished Primarch without our help, as he's the least good at war and has a poor starting world. However, with our assistance he can overcome a lot of that.

Think of it this way. He convinced the equivalent of the Everchosen to reject chaos and side with the other side.

He contested thd ownership of the said person's soul in defiance of all logic. He then purified Chaos taint. Something even the Emperor cannot do.

He should not have been able to do that but did so anyway.

Most people are slaves and serfs and the people who Hold their whips are the priests who preach about thd Gods. You have fertile ground here, especially with that rebellion Aspect.

Can spend Willpower does not mean will, especially if their Archtype supports the action.

That was mainly for PC and while any one can do it, it must make sense to do so and does not for oppressed people to spend Willpower to not rebel against their oppressors.

It is all in context of the Intimacy. Fear and hate is not love and admiration.

Fair enough. From what I'd read of Colchis, I hadn't got the impression that the Covenant was oppressive in the slaves and serfs sense, but more in a heavily religious pre-modern society sense, where life revolved around the church and a word from the local priest about heresy would have you ostracised at best or burned at the stake by your neighbours at worst. The whips and chains the priests held weren't physical, they were spiritual and social.

If it is such a segregated society where the majority doesn't actually share the leadership's faith, that's rather different.

On the other hand, we've just seen that priests of the Covenant have the ability to relatively quickly inspire hundreds of people brought up to reject them into such faith in the Chaos Gods that they become Chaos Warriors and their leader a Chaos Champion.

If they can do that to a desert tribe which is their ancestral enemy, what can they do to a captive audience?

The vision quest is specifically about him and his powers.

The chaos part was external, the vision quest is internal.

Given that the vision quest is internal, does passing it make you a shaman? I would have thought that would be all about your relationship with the external spirits of the world?
 
Last edited:
Given that the vision quest is internal, does passing it make you a shaman? I would have thought that would be all about your relationship with the external spirits of the world?
Sort of. You are walking the umbra of the planet. The border where the warp meets the Worldsoul.

This case is special as the WS is mostly dead, being kept alive literally by hopes and prayers. But he will get Spirit touched from this and bargain for gifts.

Though do not expect any till you fix the Worldsoul.
 
On the other hand, we've just seen that priests of the Covenant have the ability to relatively quickly inspire hundreds of people brought up to reject them into such faith in the Chaos Gods that they become Chaos Warriors and their leader a Chaos Champion.

If they can do that to a desert tribe which is their ancestral enemy, what can they do to a captive audience?
To be clear, it was thd nephew dho "united" the tribes by going kneel or die. Hundreds are all he was able to gather out of the entire population.

As I said, do not take the words of a chaos champion as truth.

But yeah, the Chaos Gods have been sending visions ever since Kor Phaeron died so that is now catching up to you.

In short, your actions have consequences and your choice to let word of Lorgar's existance spread has caught up to you.
 
Sort of. You are walking the umbra of the planet. The border where the warp meets the Worldsoul.

This case is special as the WS is mostly dead, being kept alive literally by hopes and prayers. But he will get Spirit touched from this and bargain for gifts.

Though do not expect any till you fix the Worldsoul.

If he has Spirit Ties, can we then use SPoF to grant him inherent Gifts he can safely use with the Gnosis the planet is giving him, even if the Spirits themselves can't grant him Gifts?

To be clear, it was thd nephew dho "united" the tribes by going kneel or die. Hundreds are all he was able to gather out of the entire population.

As I said, do not take the words of a chaos champion as truth.

But yeah, the Chaos Gods have been sending visions ever since Kor Phaeron died so that is now catching up to you.

In short, your actions have consequences and your choice to let word of Lorgar's existance spread has caught up to you.

Actions have consequences, which is very much fair enough, but it does leave us in a challenging situation.

The Covenant has moved very fast and very competently here. Colchis is three times the size of Earth with multiple continents, with what passes for civilisation mainly limited to city states on the coasts, and in three Terran years they've managed to deploy deep into the very inhospitable interior of the right continent, and convert and destroy that continent's desert nomads. That's fast for a Feudal World, given the travel speed possible on such a large world at a pre-industrial technology level, although the Covenant may retain some archeotech flyers. If they do; that's another kind of problem, as we don't have any defences against air strikes.

Presumably the rest of the nomads chose the 'die' option, which means that the dessert tribes are effectively extinct save for our own tribe?

We're currently outnumbered about ten to one in terms of combatants, and given the enemy are chaos warriors presumably they're individually superior as well.

One thing I don't quite understand is our tech level. How much of a tech advantage do we have over the enemy? Do we even have a tech advantage? Being a post-apocalyptic former high tech world, Colchis presumably has DAoT relics floating around, and the enemy will have all that the rest of the desert tribes scavenged over the millennia; plus any that the Covenant supplied them with to enforce their kneel or die ultimatum.

Are we facing people with swords, spears, and bows, or a motley collection of techno-barbarians with a mixture of hyper-tech small arms like lasguns, plasma pistols, melts-guns, armoured in carapace armour made from salvaged hyper-tech materials like plasteel and ceramite?

And, by contrast, what do we have? We have no sources of any raw materials or the infrastructure to refine them to have made anything meaningful in the way of equipment, even if the Magi have the knowledge, beyond what processed materials Thalassa brought with her, and some of that was used to make things like condensers. We're Resources 1, after all, so we literally can't afford to make anything with a non-trivial cost.

Talking this through, I think we and Lorgar are probably going to need to personally kill all the enemies, unless Thalassa has the equipment to cook up a particularly nasty bioweapon. By the look of it our tribe doesn't have either the numbers or force multipliers to do anything but get killed against an enemy of this scale.

Hopefully Lorgar fulfilling our request to redeem our nephew counts as repaying a favour for VEE purposes. That way post Vision Quest we can use VEE to give him another five dot psyker power, one powerful enough to make him very, very deadly in combat. Something like photokinesis, an ability to create and control light including lasers would be ideal if that is possible, for synergy with his Mythos.

Otherwise, I think we'd need to go down the bioweapon route, and make something incredibly lethal which we mutate our tribe to be immune to.
 
>Photokinesis

I think that'll just be Hellfire with a refluffed power type. Hellfire is an actual grab bag of a bunch of elemental damage shenanigans as is, this would be a fairly minor addition.
 
If he has Spirit Ties, can we then use SPoF to grant him inherent Gifts he can safely use with the Gnosis the planet is giving him, even if the Spirits themselves can't grant him Gifts?
It would count as charms but even otherwise, gifts are not yours to grant. More on this later but I may allow themed Gifts if/when you get your own world soul.

The Covenant has moved very fast and very competently here.
Just realised that the Nephew would brief you once he recovers. So more on this later before the fight but after the vision quest.

Ignore my previous post on this.
 
[X] Traps and tricks: Choose to lay down traps and other technological devices to weaken and reduce the hordes before they attack next turn.
 
Back
Top