Should the world be a Low Fantasy setting?

  • Yes

    Votes: 63 70.0%
  • No

    Votes: 27 30.0%

  • Total voters
    90
  • Poll closed .
They carry out their long delayed revenge only if they continue to hold a grudge against us.

Remember the lesson of PoC: They might forget the good you do, but the grudges stay a long time.
Then wouldnt they forget how we recognize them and remember how we killed and conquered them?
 
Wich was actually because they attacked us first.
I find it ironic that they are rebelling against us but they didn't rebel again Urth and instead chose to attack us.
Urth oppressed them as is customary among their people, rather than doing something so insulting as help. Truly, we're so culturally insensitive.
 
Pay them off their Hero is now faced with the conundrum of attacking the hardened and powerful source of their legitimacy...versus using their cavalry to sweep into the lowlands to conquer unopposed.

Or just not respond and look more like we're weak and distracted.
 
By removing ourselves their unity will fray as there's no great threat for them to face together.

Just to be clear, even if you do give the Maradysh independence, you are still the region strongest power just to the north-west of them.

I find it ironic that they are rebelling against us but they didn't rebel again Urth and instead chose to attack us.

You might want to have a look at who had a Martial Hero in each of those situations then.
 
Pay them off their Hero is now faced with the conundrum of attacking the hardened and powerful source of their legitimacy...versus using their cavalry to sweep into the lowlands to conquer unopposed.

Or just not respond and look more like we're weak and distracted.
We really don't want them to rush off into the lowlands and conquer. If they do that they'll actually be able to beat us when they come back around.
 
Pay them off their Hero is now faced with the conundrum of attacking the hardened and powerful source of their legitimacy...versus using their cavalry to sweep into the lowlands to conquer unopposed.

Or just not respond and look more like we're weak and distracted.

So we will basically help them create an empire. Great. Maybe we can gift them Greenbay as well when we are on it.
 
Then wouldnt they forget how we recognize them and remember how we killed and conquered them?

It's far easier to destroy relation then to build them, but it doesn't mean we should destroy relation once it got tough, because that's how you end up in unnecessary wars in the first place.

Effective diplomacy is when both sides have a use from a deal.

We have a use from recognition: a buffer state that doesn't hate us.
 
Urth oppressed them as is customary among their people, rather than doing something so insulting as help. Truly, we're so culturally insensitive.

Furthermore, Urth didn't really oppress them. He was just an unnatural abomination that conquered them, stuck one of his guys in charge of them and then took the bodies of their dead.

In the eyes of the Maradysh, the People have been more oppressive than Urth was.
 
Furthermore, Urth didn't really oppress them. He was just an unnatural abomination that conquered them, stuck one of his guys in charge of them and then took the bodies of their dead.

In the eyes of the Maradysh, the People have been more oppressive than Urth was.
He also sent them to fight us, which they could not win and that's why so many died, but let's keep revising history.
 
Furthermore, Urth didn't really oppress them. He was just an unnatural abomination that conquered them, stuck one of his guys in charge of them and then took the bodies of their dead.

In the eyes of the Maradysh, the People have been more oppressive than Urth was.

So one more ally for them.
 
We have a use from recognition: a buffer state that doesn't hate us.
Which is the other thing
The whole reason I wanted upriver plains was to avoid having to care about this.
I dont want a buffer state between us, I want to have our own city be the buffer between anyone else and our cap. After that anyone else can be past that.
 
He also sent them to fight us, which they could not win and that's why so many died, but let's keep revising history.

The Maradysh blame the People for that since even if it was in self-defence, it was the People who did the actually killing and not Urth. Furthermore, they don't view the self-defence justification as being valid due to the fact you conquered them afterwards.

So one more ally for them.

No actually. The Maradysh view the walking dead as evil monsters and would not willingly serve them.
 
Which is the other thing
The whole reason I wanted upriver plains was to avoid having to care about this.
I dont want a buffer state between us, I want to have our own city be the buffer between anyone else and our cap. After that anyone else can be past that.
The whole point of a buffer is that you have to be willing to let it fall in order to protect something else.
By our traits, every village is treated equally, and we will start taking penalties whenever any of them start to fall.
The idea of buffer outposts is one that isn't compatible with our civ.
 
Because that's how the Ymaryn literally annexed their neighbors?

In early age when they didn't have their identity formed.
With the way they are going they will be a monarchy and i clearly remember Ymaryn having a chance to marry a Highlanders and unite the civs but people throwed a fit about a monarchy and you can guess our relationship with Highlanders later, a relationship that was good for unification turned into a hatred.
 
Last edited:
Because that's how you get friends? Because it benefits us as well? Because this is not a zero-sum game? Because, contrary to what alot of people here think, the world is not divided into just subjects and enemies?

And yet there are examples that civs that are friendly turn into a monsters. And the way these guys are going is just helping a future enemy.
They didn't even shoved us a sign of good will while we are showing a ton of it to them and they ask for more.
 
Back
Top