This is a really dumb time and place to pick a fight.
Broken Seeker is an old monster famous for betrayal that knows he pissed us off. Moreover, his misread of Molly's social cues has left him convinced she has a literal fetish for backstabbing.
There is no way he spent months playing games on his hunt for Dresden and then put himself in a tube with us far away from anyone he knows we care about without a plan of some kind. Even one as simple as his 13 minions set up to eat an orphanage if he doesn't make it home before dinner.
We're also still surrounded by enemies, and elder vamps should never be discounted. Immediately turning to infighting at the earliest technical opportunity is a cartoon villain level tactical and strategic failure.
And yes, the rep stuff is still in play. It's unjust, unfair, and stupid, but the supernatural world doesn't care about our opinions on fairness.Yet.
This shouldn't be a surprise, it works the same way with regular old humans. Go to a bank you owe money with a laundry list of understandable, but not legally relevant, reasons why you're late on your payments and see what it gets you.
Raging against the machine by shooting yourself in the foot spites no one but you.
We can kill this guy later.
[X] Shout at him that you are supposed to split the loot, he'll probably get a kick out of that (Charisma+Empathy Base DC 6)
[X] A deal's a deal, even with a monster, let him eat