- Location
- florida
It struck me more as isolation through anonymity than the usual kind.We just freed a demon from social isolation and alienation.
And send it into real isolation?
That seems mean.
Space can be unkind though your right.
It struck me more as isolation through anonymity than the usual kind.We just freed a demon from social isolation and alienation.
And send it into real isolation?
That seems mean.
We might be. What about our family (Michael probably aside) and friends, though? What happens when they start going after Charity, or our siblings, or Rosanna, or the people from our school? They can and probably will use such connections as leverage/blackmail against us and milk them for all that they're worth. I'm guessing that the reason that they didn't do so against Dresden was not being able to easily find such connections, Marcone and Michael possibly aside.If shit really goes down we are better suited to staying in the Umbra than most mortals, or starting a new life outside USA or with a perfect dusguise within.
While God might help our dad out of legal trouble it's not the thing we should count on.We might be. What about our family (Michael probably aside) and friends, though? What happens when they start going after Charity, or our siblings, or Rosanna, or the people from our school? They can and probably will use such connections as leverage/blackmail against us and milk them for all that they're worth. I'm guessing that the reason that they didn't do so against Dresden was not being able to easily find such connections, Marcone and Michael possibly aside.
So right now we do not, in fact, have such charms. Also, I'd rather not have to find out just how scary the Library of Congress people are...That being said we do have charms for these sorts of scenarios. We would just need to buy them.
This attitude is sort of annoying; there are plenty of entirely legitimate reasons to be suspicious of and unimpressed by a government agency that is acting like this.Its very reasonable for them to have acted this way, but refusing to see things from their point of view or empathize is pretty much the Internets watch word.
Arrest warrant =/= Search warrant.Indeed. The point is - we need to somehow prevent feds / unfriendly cops from accessing Dresden's inner sanctum. Otherwise, he'd be in a lot of legit trouble, regardless of fabricated murder charges.
We also need to snatch Bob before anyone else does.
The WC, by order of the first Merlin, keeps wizards out of politics because its a skip and hop from backing different sides to shooting at each other. Even back when they used to be advisors to rulers, they did their best to stay out of direct politics even when their mortal proteges might be hostile.Ohhh. I did not know that. Yeah. I feel the their policy of 'no state/governmental politics' means that this is probably not the first time this sort of thing has been attempted over the centuries and won't be the last.
You certainly dont lack for ambition. Literally no power base, and you want to pull a Red Court on the US Govt's natsec apparatus.
They do not know that and people with several degrees of separation are not going to know the situation on the ground. It is just a case of policy makers on top who do not have touch with what is going on.
To be fair, they should know.Not sire I want Molly TO work with the Government. I am not opposed but do not particularly care for some faceless Bureaucrat, especially one that may order Molly to be disected.
Still a good VEE target when we get that charm.
Not actually credible.Look, this is basically the FBI scrambling trying to figure out what the fuck is going on since the War between the Red Court and White Council erupted. Everything we've seen indicates that these people are in wildly over their heads.
They need someone to give them a basic primer on the supernatural or they'll accidentally insult a Winter Fae or something similarly dumb. Harry's not going to do it after all - he's more likely to sit in the chair and insult them for a few hours and then hold a massive grudge. He doesn't even explain stuff to Karen Murphy he's not going to tell the FBI shit.
Its not paranoia if they are actually out to get you.Mate, you're coming off as a paranoiac.
At no point in the update do they mention wanting to experiment on Harry. They mention they're doing some minor tests with some current minor talents with the Library of Congress researchers - but nothing that would set alarm bells off.
As for the approach. This is just how the spooks operate - there's a fairly credible case to be made against Dresden for Greene's death if you don't know about the supernatural and they're offering to make it go away in return for him helping them
The White Council tends to move slow, and they actually have diplomats.What do y'all think the White Council's reaction to this is going to be? A lot of Senior Council members might not be his biggest fans, but Harry is popular among the rank and file and the effin Blackstaff is his grandpa. This sort of provocation cannot go unanswered.
^^^^You've neglected to make mention of their initial "go to" method of trying to threaten Harry Dresden with false accusations of murder to try and get him under their thumb. Good people do not resort to that sort of thing as their first option.Smart people do not resort to that sort of thing as their first option. One should attempt the carrot before reaching for the stick.
These people did not and that fact is relevent when considering their intentions, value, and trustworthiness.
They aren't Mulder and Scully. They're the Cigarette Smoking Man.
Yes, the murder happened.And you forget that the murder happened. The evidence actually exists. To anyone who isn't aware of the supernatural, it is compelling. To most of CPD, Dresden is a cop killer. The only reason he hasn't fallen down some stairs, or wasn't shot "resisting arrest" and his place hasn't been searched, is because these guys asserted jurisdiction. Yes, they took Dresden. But this could easily be protective custody, in a sense. This was a very soft take, all things considered. Very diplomatic.
That raises an interesting question, did Butcher ever mention how the witch hunts were supposed to have gone down in Dresden history? 🤔Because things get very different when the fantasy witches have the superpower to blow up the entire courthouse.Government: "catches wizard"
The church: "this is the only thing we have and you're gonna steal this from us? We did witch hunts before they were cool!
Yes.That raises an interesting question, did Butcher ever mention how the witch hunts were supposed to have gone down in Dresden history? 🤔Because things get very different when the fantasy witches have the superpower to blow up the entire courthouse.
Are there other governmental groups out there who are clued in? As an example FBI, KGB, NYPD, et cetera. Do they have their own versions of Special Investigations, and if so, would we ever see them in the course of the novels?
A detail that a lot of readers have forgotten is the end of Fool Moon where Susan Rodriguez, the reporter, actually got on videotape the werewolf and the big closing fight scene at the end. And then the videotape disappeared and most people kind of forget that the videotape just sort of disappeared. They just sort of put it down to oh, that's random background stuff. It's not random background stuff. Somebody made it disappear, and yes, there are people like that that exist and the difference is that most of them assume that anybody involved with the supernatural is the bad guy, they don't make contact. Not only is Dresden the exception because he's reaching across the aisle, so to speak to work with Murphy, but Murphy's the exception because she's reaching out to work with Dresden. There's something more going on there but the only side of the story we get to see is Harry's side of the story.
Note that you are free not to agree with Mr Butcher's interpretation; there's plotholes to my eye afforded by the existence of the NeverNever. But thats offical Word of Jim on the subject.Quote from: chadu on February 22, 2010, 04:57:13 PM
They kinda /do/ win. It's one reason the White Council thinks of itself as something so ohmygodmighty important. But bear in mind a few things:Our biggest issue: why don't wizards just WIN (in pre-complex tech eras)? I argued for the sliding scale of "born in X, advanced tech shows up in Y" idea… but it's not satisfying.
1) The White Council /exists/ in order to limit the power of wizards. These days, it's mostly about keeping wizards out of the black magic–but in the past, it was also to keep wizards out of politics. They would show up as advisers, rarely (most "court wizards" were charlatans or underpowered schmucks), but the Council itself was very much against getting involved in things.
That's mainly because if the Council threw its weight in anywhere, it was all but guaranteeing a civil war among its own members. (Remember, it's very Euro-centric.)
The original Merlin learned a lesson about wizards involving themselves in politics.
They already have too much power to use wisely, from his point of view.
2) Wizards were a hell of a lot more rare in centuries past. Their numbers have increased along with the world population, but back then a given country was lucky if it had produced a single wizard-level talent more than about one generation in three.
3) Travel in general was a lot harder. Disease, in general, was a lot more rampant and likely to kill you. Yeah, wizards have the capacity to recover from things, but they don't have any particular increased resistance to contracting a disease. They just come back from it in better shape than regular folks. For example, if you get a good case of pneumonia (like I did), you've got a reduced capacity to resist subsequent similar infections. And that's it. In fact, having gotten pneumonia once gives you a pretty darn big mathematical probability that you're going to die of pneumonia in the future. (Pneumonia being one of the main things that actually does the killing when you've got cancer or other serious medical issues.) Wizards don't face that same danger. If they beat it, they beat it, and it isn't of any more consequence than getting over a cold.
But even so, before antibiotics, wizards were as worried about disease as everyone else was. And a great way to not get diseases was to STAY HOME. Which most of them did. That kinda limited how much conflict they would actually get involved in.
4) The Inquisition. Fact of the matter is that the Inquisition, for better or worse, made everyone REALLY aware of practitioners. If a wizard started slinging his power around willy nilly, it would attract attention. Probably /hostile/ attention, at that. Which leads us to…
5) Wizards have to sleep. Yes, an enraged wizard could probably kill just about anyone he wanted to, flatten towns, all the mighty wizard stuff. But… there are about a million humans to every full-blown wizard talent. A strong wizard can kill a mortal with about as much effort as it would take you to pick up a piece of gravel and toss it twenty feet. Now, go out to a gravel pile and do that a MILLION times.
You aren't going to finish that project today.
The appearance of overwhelming power is one of the only things guaranteed to make human beings unify out of sheer fear for their survival. (Example: see Haiti. Overwhelming power of nature drew a response of overwhelming relief efforts from fellow human beings. Now, imagine that someone told those people that the earthquake was someone's fault. Someone real, and dangerous, but someone who you could punch in the nose. Think about that.)
Wizards were certainly a force of nature. One that would frighten people enough to go after them with overwhelming numbers and a vengeance.
Of course, that leaves many, many other things they could do to influence events. The most powerful such was the gathering of information and rapid communications. Their ability to travel rapidly, to gather information and send it elsewhere was something that didn't really get beat until a Mr. Ford, Mr. Marconi, and some guys named Orville and Wilbur came along. And they were basically in the information business, which is an excellent way to guarantee security.
They were also largely responsible for the Renaissance, in the Dresden universe. Not directly, but by going out and finding the best and brightest minds and seeing to it that they got the education and the chances they needed to succeed in life. Some wizards even did direct mentoring of various brilliant figures of European history (DaVinci and Gallileo were two prime examples).
But they stayed out of direct involvement in wars and politics, instead focusing on becoming involved in the intellectual progress of society. Wizards from France and Germany, for example, would treat each other much the same way as opposing lawyers in a big case. Even when their clients were tearing each other to bits, that didn't meant that the two wizards were foes. They were, in fact, professional colleagues, who were likely to go off and get a beer and roll their eyes at their clients' foolishness.
(All of this is mostly focused on the White Council, which was centered in Europe. Wizards in other areas of the world, such as the Americas, eastern Asia, and Australia have far different histories.)
But that factor–the sheer weight of numbers of mortals–dictated the role they had to assume to survive and prosper. They hoped that a more advanced, less warlike culture would provide a better place for wizards to live. In fact, it did. But it also robbed them of the extreme power they'd possessed until that time, relative to vanilla mortals.
6) PEOPLE BELIEVED IN MAGIC AND IT SCARED THEM. I mean, there was none of this "but there's no such thing as magic" nonsense involved. And not all the witch hunters were in it for the money. There was a class of men who knew all about the various forces of the supernatural, out there in the darkness, and who made themselves as able to contend with them as any mortal could be. If a wizard went all kaboomy on mortals, he knew that there was someone who was going to hunt him, striking in a moment of vulnerability.
(I'll leave it to you to deduce who they grew up into, eventually. It isn't complicated or hard to see.)
End of the day, even wizards bleed. And as the wise Governor of California says, if it bleeds, you can kill it.
But they sure as hell enjoyed their centuries on top of the food chain.
No.
I am grateful to you as your post has caused me to reexamine this fact its associated implications.You might consider the potential recruitment avenues by which these guys got their minor talents to work for them in this setting, if their approach to recruiting someone who has literally been for hire as a freelancer in the phonebook for at least five years is "Wait till we can get him on a false murder charge".
The bolded bit of your write in looks to be operating on the assumption that the people who ordered for Harry to be arrested do not know that he can just be paid by state officials (like the police) to aid them.---[X] Using Clippy to distort our voice, or better yet, having it speak for us, say, "Just from overhearing this conversation between yourself and Agent Wright, it is obvious just how ignorant you are of the supernatural. Otherwise, you would not have kidnapped a Warden Commander of the White Council, or the Lawmakers as you call them, during a war with bloodthirsty vampires. Ignorance can be forgiven, but that only goes so far."
----[X] "If you wish to have any hope of salvaging this situation, you should release Mr. Dresden, clear his name, and have someone make an appointment to speak with him at a later date, like you should have from the very beginning. For God's sake, he advertises his services in the phone book."
Good point. I've edited my plan to remove mention of Harry being listed in the phone book.The bolded bit of your write in looks to be operating on the assumption that the people who ordered for Harry to be arrested do not know that he can just be paid by state officials (like the police) to aid them.
Thinking on it, they certainly do know that he's available for hire if he's worked with the Police Department in the past. That he does stuff for pay.
Therefore we can assume that they want him to do things that he would not do for money.
Your write in therefore has Molly showing these people a gap in her reasoning/knowledge, that she thinks that these people might be on the up-and-up, and such gaps/errors generally ain't good when it comes to trying to negotiate.
If you're going with the "Harrys too much of a Big Deal to do this shit with and ye have Royally Fucked Up" approach alone I think it would still work, but I think you should modify the last subvote in some manner.
As it is, I now prefer to get help from the lawyer-priest, and bring him the recording we have, and if need be, point out to him what uju32 brought to my attention.
Those happened, I think, but in the main, not with wizards. They did call them witch trialsNo.
That was a very long answer to a very different question from the one I asked, and I'd appreciate if you crop more next time. The only tangential mention of witch hunts in that wall of text suggests it involved more assassination-style behavior from witch hunters, which tells me very little.
Historical witch hunts frequently involved trials. People were interrogated and tortured into confessing before a court. Witnesses were called to testify that they'd seen the accused witch meeting with the Devil. These behaviors should change a lot when witches can set the interrogator on fire, and/or have friends who can set the false witnesses on fire afterwards. Is Butcher suggesting that Dresdenverse history replaced the trials with assassinations, wholly or partly? Were the assassinations done freelance, or by kill order from a judge, with trial in absentia? The magic powers he's added to the world should have more implications for how the world looks!
But maybe I shouldn't prod too much at the tapestry of retconned history that a masquerade fantasy inevitably has.
It's the US government, you can say a lot of bad things about it, but not that is it given to timidity in the face of external threats.
I doubt most of the real wizards would even be caught if it came to that. Wizards are really good at countering threats when they have time to prepare; regular mortals can do a lot with mundane engineering , but unless they go full clarketech they can't stop a wizard from doing things like fucking off into another dimension with a moment of effort if they want to.Most mature wizards would presumably be able to simply walk out of jail after a night's rest, with some exceptions;
I kind of doubt that. I bet he could do a lot of damage, but this isn't a white room fight and everyone else would get a say too. I'd bet on them figuring it out and shooting missiles at him before he managed more than a few serious strikes.That's true, but on the other hand Ebenezer McCoy could almost certainly personally destroy the United States (if he can set Krakatoa off he can set Yellowstone off), and could destroy the government a lot more easily.
And the US government has been shown to back down in the face of annihilation, as seen in the Cold War.
A motivated Senior Council level wizard with prep-time is a walking apocalypse, and it's only the metaphysics around magic that keep them in check - and the Blackstaff doesn't have to care about that.