The Morrsley Village Experiment

Can anybody lay out a reason to target @Cyricubed beyond bad feelings?

Since Null is no longer in the lead, I guess it is time to vote.

[X] Lynch ondine
 
I just want to point out that I gave the Test Subject wincon.
IH verified it.
I think biggerfish first said Test Subject.
And Shadell gave the blue color. Although the 3p thing still nags at me.

And yet! Everyone believes IH who verified me, but they don't believe me. How does this make any sense?
 
I am a test subject, the faction color is a shade of blue. I hope that's true for everyone whose declared test subject so far...
Huh, that is interesting. Do you mind if I ask about the color of your ice cream?
Frankly I'm tired of the deflective bullshit and how exactly what I said earlier about Scum would claim town is being thrown back at my face casually. On top of that you keep evading the question, no, all you did is say I claim town and that everyone else has to die. You didn't claim Test subject, others leaked that. I think you've played along with IH's claim or at worst your scum with IH. Every turn you've tried to get whoever seems easiest to lynch and that included me once I started calling out your BS. I'm tired of this and I don't care much for your claim anymore unless you've got a power that basically GM confirms you in thread, I'm set on your lynch.

[X] Lynch Ondine
... Really tempted to follow this, because scum being informed about the Town is a thing and it's matching up with my thoughts on ondine nearly all Day.

*grumbles*
To that end, I'd definitely
Sorry, you cut out?
I think Ondine is legitimately a Test Subject- early on, you can see him figure out what I'm talking about or very plausibly fake it. Then they pushed along the same lines I was using for my initial claim.

Ondine almost certainly has access to a Test Subject role card, and I think is more likely to be a Test Subject than not.
There's a reason I've been feeling that ondine was just playing along with you, but maybe that's just because both of you were avoiding the subject like the plague.

I'd recommend you read her initial response again and question if it's her getting it or her playing along, because honestly it could go either way in my eyes. And like I mentioned before, it's really easy to nod along as Scum.

Posting because I'm limited on time, reading page 24 at the moment.
 
I also find it very weird that @mesonoxian was on the train with me and IH for a long time and then when it became obvious he needed to pick a side he switched from buddying with IH and I to being against me. Because he doesn't like the Cyri lynch, even though I have given a lot more proof to being town. That makes me think he is not a Test Subject. I don't know that he's whatever other thing, or control, but I would bet on one of them.
 
I just want to point out that I gave the Test Subject wincon.
IH verified it.
I think biggerfish first said Test Subject.
And Shadell gave the blue color. Although the 3p thing still nags at me.

And yet! Everyone believes IH who verified me, but they don't believe me. How does this make any sense?
It's not that I don't think you're town. (Though given the vague nature of the confirmation and the potential of scum havin enough information to put this together, I am far from certain you are). It is that you are voting to lynch somebody on Shadell's say so and a hunch. I'd much rather we didn't do that.

You're just the easiest member of that group to pressure because you already have two votes on you, and if @-Rosen or @Nictis switch we'll be tied.
 
You're just the easiest member of that group to pressure because you already have two votes on you, and if @-Rosen or @Nictis switch we'll be tied.
Hint hint, nudge nudge, I see. You got it buddy!

Not sure I'll finish catching up by Day End, so I'm sticking my vote where my mouth is.

[x] Unvote Null
[x] Lynch ondine


Plus I just don't particularly want Cyricubed dead right now, he's largely been arguing against bad plays and I'm not seeing much reason to actually think he's scum here. I am expecting scum to be among those who were nodding along to the vague reasoning instead of those who took a stance against it.
 
I don't like either of these lynches

If we're gonna vote ondine for voting on Shadell's call then we should be lynching Shadell.
 
Essentially ondine swapped over to Cyri only after Shadell posted 578 acting like lynching Cyri was a set in stone thing, when it didn't even have a real wagon at the time.
Particularly I am much more suspicious of Shadell's act here than ondine's act here, because at least ondine's progression is apparent here.
 
I wasn't voting on her call. I had found Cyri suspicious.
Essentially ondine swapped over to Cyri only after Shadell posted 578 acting like lynching Cyri was a set in stone thing, when it didn't even have a real wagon at the time.
This isn't true. I had been voting Cyri before. ffs.
 
I wasn't voting on her call. I had found Cyri suspicious.

This isn't true. I had been voting Cyri before. ffs.
That's why I said I'm not really suspicious of you for it, since you already had your progression beforehand. Shadell is the one who should be getting flak here, not you.
 
I'm pretty sure I'm missing context here.
Basically IH makes this post:
I think Ondine is legitimately a Test Subject- early on, you can see him figure out what I'm talking about or very plausibly fake it. Then they pushed along the same lines I was using for my initial claim.

Ondine almost certainly has access to a Test Subject role card, and I think is more likely to be a Test Subject than not.
To which Shadell responds basically "So we're lynching Cyriccubed"...

and people just do with no further explanation.
 
Particularly I am much more suspicious of Shadell's act here than ondine's act here, because at least ondine's progression is apparent here.
It is not my preference, but I will switch to Shadell for self pres if Cyri and meso or nictis will as well.

@InterstellarHobo You are the only one anyone thinks is a TS will you please tell them I am one? What can I do to prove it to you personally that I am?
 
Basically IH makes this post:

To which Shadell responds basically "So we're lynching Cyriccubed"...

and people just do with no further explanation.
ondine has a progression before Shadell makes this post. It's a bad progression, but it's a progression nonetheless.

Lynching ondine for this is a horrible move when Shadell should be the one pressured. He's the one without a progression on Shadell.
 
@mesonoxian Sorry, can you try to lay out your reasoning in full?
It is a lack of reasoning that is the problem. @Cyricubed might very well be scum, but there has been no argument made to support that. He went from zero to four lynch votes in half a page with no discussion. That looks suspicious as hell, and if it isn't scummy, that's worse, since it suggests there is no underlying logic anybody can explain.
 
It is a lack of reasoning that is the problem. @Cyricubed might very well be scum, but there has been no argument made to support that. He went from zero to four lynch votes in half a page with no discussion. That looks suspicious as hell, and if it isn't scummy, that's worse, since it suggests there is no underlying logic anybody can explain.
Shadell has even less reasoning than ondine here please
 
Why am I being ignored.

I'm honestly about to try and flip to one of the ondine voters at this point because im like 99% sure there is scum in there
 
Twenty minutes.

I don't want a Cyricubed lynch, he's being scumread for the grand reasoning of attempting to stop bad plays.
I'm still sorta feeling a Town Shadell, but it's mostly gutread.
Ondine is still my strongest scumread.

I'd prefer, in order, an Ondine lynch, a Hybrid lynch (Also gutread though), and then Null Lynch personally.

I'm pretty sure that the null lynch is just a meme and won't have any effect on the gameplay. Same deal with Ice Cream, I'm pretty sure that it has no actual game relevance but is just a nice touch that IJW added onto the game.
 
Back
Top