There is a fair bit stopping others from taking Itachis place. Zetsu helped Itachi, which he would have no reason to do if Itachi doesn't want to join, nor would Fugaku just let some other person kill him.
Hell, the only one who could conceivably be the other lynchpin of the plan is Shisui, and the only reason he wasn't available was that he was dead at that point.

You know, a lot of Zetsu and Madara's and Tobi's plans rely heavily on luck, and timing.

Though from master planners, genius' and an immortal plant person who's been manipulating fools for millennia at least... it was luck they could control.
They did run the Konoha Police Force. Like, completely. That's pretty darn prestigious.
I mean, yeah, being in charge of almost all of the village security and being the third guy down the rung if the Hokage and jounin commander are incapacitated... yeah I'd call that pretty important.
 
Hell, the only one who could conceivably be the other lynchpin of the plan is Shisui, and the only reason he wasn't available was that he was dead at that point.

You know, a lot of Zetsu and Madara's and Tobi's plans rely heavily on luck, and timing.

Though from master planners, genius' and an immortal plant person who's been manipulating fools for millennia at least... it was luck they could control.
I'm not convinced there was a plan and they haven't just been dicking around for most of the tim
 
I'm not convinced there was a plan and they haven't just been dicking around for most of the tim
More like Kishimoto wanted to tie it back into the plot and make Itachi less villainous then before.

Edit: That's what I think anyway.

But hey, we got the most heartwarming goodbye in the series from Itachi to Sasuke... so silverlinings.
 
Last edited:
More like Kishimoto wanted to tie it back into the plot and make Itachi less villainous then before.

Edit: That's what I think anyway.

But hey, we got the most heartwarming goodbye in the series from Itachi to Sasuke... so silverlinings.
No, i meant over all. I do not see how anything Obito did between creating the Akatsuki and near the end of Part 2 had any relationship with his end goal of collecting the tailed beasts and reviving Madara. He and Zetsi could have easily just blitz all the jinchuriki and fill up the statue quick. Reviving Madara is similarly simple, just have Zetsu, the guy invisible to sensors, go steal Konohas forbidden scroll. Tobirama already made the Impure World Reincarnation jutsu.
 
[X]Itachi: The Young Uchiha was in the garden, staring at his plants, his mind deep in thought. The birthday child is not enjoying himself lke others have.
 
No, i meant over all. I do not see how anything Obito did between creating the Akatsuki and near the end of Part 2 had any relationship with his end goal of collecting the tailed beasts and reviving Madara. He and Zetsi could have easily just blitz all the jinchuriki and fill up the statue quick. Reviving Madara is similarly simple, just have Zetsu, the guy invisible to sensors, go steal Konohas forbidden scroll. Tobirama already made the Impure World Reincarnation jutsu.
I personally just think Kishimoto wanted to wrap up Naruto after so long and was just... trying to finish it all up in as satisfying a way as possible. And it was a good ending for a very good story.

But in Story?:... I don't know, Zetsu playing speed chess in case he decided he needed to Kill Obito and get a replacement ready in Itachi? Obito wanting to get EMS? I really don't know. I'm going to do it one way in case we ever get to that.
 
Last edited:
But in Story?:... I don't know, Zetsu playing speed chess in case he decided he needed to Kill Obito and get a replacement ready in Itachi? Obito wanting to get EMS? I really don't know. I'm going to do it one way in case we ever get to that.
Those got problems with them as well. Honestly, i can only think of 3 solutions
1) Complete overhaul of canon, nobodies goals line up so they all gotta play around eachother without tipping their hand (Obito doesn't want to gather the beasts and has a different plan, for example)
2) squish the power ceiling down or raise a bunch of people up, so that Zetsu and Obito CAN'T just blitz the jinchuriki and have to be sneaky and manipulative
3) they were just dicking around, carrying out personal vendettas and the like with the main plan on the back burner.
 
Those got problems with them as well. Honestly, i can only think of 3 solutions
1) Complete overhaul of canon, nobodies goals line up so they all gotta play around eachother without tipping their hand (Obito doesn't want to gather the beasts and has a different plan, for example)
Wasn't that one thing you didn't want to happen?
2) squish the power ceiling down or raise a bunch of people up, so that Zetsu and Obito CAN'T just blitz the jinchuriki and have to be sneaky and manipulative
Probably going to happen. I like having people not be useless because of bullshit.
3) they were just dicking around, carrying out personal vendettas and the like with the main plan on the back burner.
Possibly the most canon answer out of all of them.
 
Minito's fate is tied to the Kyubi Incident, which will happen regardless of your choices. However, there are only two ways for Minato to survive in this timeline. Only I know which routes they are.

The Uchiha Clan's fate is still up in the air which you do have an effect on, depending on what you choose.

Or maybe I'm just trying to stir up some primal fears before the dice shove their foot up my ass with good rolls.
Don't jinx yourself please. Also Zetsu is an asspull.
 
[X]Itachi: The Young Uchiha was in the garden, staring at his plants, his mind deep in thought. The birthday child is not enjoying himself lke others have.

Time to chat with my favorite Akatsuki member!
 
[x]The Dog: You sensed a man in the rafters, watching over the entire party… he seemed lonely, so you're going to join him.

While meeting Itachi would be nice, the option is too funny to pass up. When we both go to the ninja academy, then we can meet him and become BFF, right now meeting Kakashi will get noticed and also can be a nice way to earn our genius tag.
 
When we both go to the ninja academy
You're forgetting that he'll have graduated before we even start:
Article:
At age six, Itachi enrolled into the Academy, where he consistently scored the highest in each subject and quickly learned any skill taught to him, resulting in him being praised as the best of his generation. After four months, his teachers unanimously agreed let him take the graduation exam early due to Itachi being more than advanced enough for genin-level, which he passed later that month.

He spent less than half a year at the academy, and if we don't befriend him now, Shiro has no reason to enroll in the same cohort as Itachi, meaning that we'd miss him entirely.
 
You're forgetting that he'll have graduated before we even start:
Article:
At age six, Itachi enrolled into the Academy, where he consistently scored the highest in each subject and quickly learned any skill taught to him, resulting in him being praised as the best of his generation. After four months, his teachers unanimously agreed let him take the graduation exam early due to Itachi being more than advanced enough for genin-level, which he passed later that month.

He spent less than half a year at the academy, and if we don't befriend him now, Shiro has no reason to enroll in the same cohort as Itachi, meaning that we'd miss him entirely.
We're in the same age-group as him. We'll be enrolling at teh same time. Though I agree that that feels a tad too late to become BFFs.


Damn, I REALLY wish we got two picks. I love both the Kakashi and Itachi options!
 
Inserted tally
Adhoc vote count started by Magoose on Dec 21, 2019 at 11:34 AM, finished with 99 posts and 31 votes.
 
[X]Itachi: The Young Uchiha was in the garden, staring at his plants, his mind deep in thought. The birthday child is not enjoying himself lke others have.

Totally didn't forget to vote.
 
The Party Part 2
The Party Part 2

Itachi turned to see you, as you walked forward to greet him. "Hello. My name is Shiro." You replied with a small bow.

"Itachi." The birthday boy replied as he gave a small bow himself before he turned around and sat down, looking at the garden.

"What are you looking at?" You asked as you sat down next to him.

The Uchiha scion looked at you with a curious glare. "You first?" He replied.

"I saw the person who's birthday it was sitting alone outside, instead of enjoying the party that is for him?" You replied. "Unless of course, the party is the problem and you wish to be alone?"

That made Itachi's eyebrows raise in an inquisitive and… curious manner. He looked at you, presumably at the pale eyes that you had. He was smart, clearly, like you. But he was unsure of himself. Itachi looked at you again, this time with his eyes scanning you. "Are you a genjutsu sent by my father to come and bring me back to the party?" He asked.

You nodded no. "No… And I'll prove it." You flicked the top of his forehead with your finger.

Itachi did not flinch when you did that. Only looking at you with curiosity. "Now I'll ask again… what are you looking at?"

Itachi looked back into the garden. It was full of small shrubs, reaching out into the sky with dirt and water on their leaves. "I just wanted to be alone in my garden."

"Are you afraid of something in there that you believe that your garden is a safe place for you, even when your family is waiting for you?" You asked.

Itachi flinched as he heard those words. "No." His quick no did not fill you with comfort. "I'm just… overwhelmed with my father's expectations. He views me as a genius, and wants me to bring honor and glory to the clan."

Ah… so he felt pressured. "Than stop caring about what anyone else wants from you… and do want you want. Enjoy yourself. Have fun. Greet people and do things that you want to do, even if it may anger your father." You then gave a smile. "You are your own person, not a continuation of your father's will."

Itachi than gave a frown. "I…" he paused before thinking some more. A smile rose in its place. "Thank you."

You nodded. "Your welcome."

The young boy stood up and walked over to his party, greeting everyone he met along the way, with a smile on his face.

"How did I know exactly what to say?" You asked yourself aloud.

Atlas rumbled in your mind. "You wished to help him… I merely… assisted with my knowledge."

"Were you controlling me?" You asked fearfully.

"No." He replied. "Everything you said, was you alone."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You returned to the party with more life in it than before, Itachi was speaking to everyone with a gleeful smile on his face.

Who do you talk to now?:

[]Continue speaking to Itachi: You were… very happy for him, and seemed very happy to play with you.

[]Hana Izunuka: The young girl was trying to steal some cake… you might stop her… you might not. But you did want to speak to her.

[]Minato Namikaze: The man no longer had pigtails in his hair, and he smiling at the young Uchiha now enjoying himself. Your father was standing next to him, laughing at a joke.

[]Kushina Uzumaki: The Hokage's wife was now sitting down, drinking some tea, still speaking to her friend.

[]Fugaku: The Uchiha Clan head was... both happy and annoyed. You didn't know why, but the way he looked at you made you feel off.

[]The Dog: The man was still in the rafters. Alone. You did not want him to be alone.

[]Sit alone: There is nothing here that interests you anymore… You're going to eat cake. Maybe Atlas can be a good conversationalist.

AN: Enjoy.
 
[X]Minato Namikaze: The man no longer had pigtails in his hair, and he smiling at the young Uchiha now enjoying himself. Your father was standing next to him, laughing at a joke.

Followup, Itachi's change changed the Minato scene. Capitalize
 
Back
Top