Doomed Wombat
Let's go Darling!
- Location
- Dancing on wires!
Can I also add to not having the jingoistic parts in.
Just makes us look like asses.
Just makes us look like asses.
-
Going forward, links to content from Twitter (now X) will no longer be embedded. Pre-existing links should not be affected.
The Long Night Part One: Embers in the Dusk: A Planetary Governor Quest (43k) Complete Sequel Up
- Thread starter Durin
- Start date
- Location
- Alice Springs, Australia
no, you dont have enough of an understanding to modify them, you barely have enough to reproduce them
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
Yuck.
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
-[X][Plan] Middle Ground, Avernus
-[X][Argument] Avernus' status as a Deathworld greatly increases the amount of attrition the Orks are subject to, particularly with an idiotic Warlord in charge of it maximizing the damage they suffer; Avernus also already has an Ork Infestation from previous invasions, so the long-term effects on it are minor.
Can I just say that if I was around for the planning vote I wouldn't have us doing major naval attacks on the Ork Fleet? Lives are cheap, ships are not.
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
-[X][Plan] Middle Ground, Avernus
-[X][Argument] Avernus' status as a Deathworld greatly increases the amount of attrition the Orks are subject to, particularly with an idiotic Warlord in charge of it maximizing the damage they suffer; Avernus also already has an Ork Infestation from previous invasions, so the long-term effects on it are minor.
Can I just say that if I was around for the planning vote I wouldn't have us doing major naval attacks on the Ork Fleet? Lives are cheap, ships are not.
- Location
- Australia
Isn't that the same logic Chenkov uses to march conscripts across minefields? (With "ships" in this case being Leman Russes.)
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
Depending on the yield of the landmines and their precise configuration, that particular argument may range anywhere from legitimate to dumb.
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
More arguments I would include in the vote, but don't really fit well:
*Vanaheim's Shipyards are SUPER IMPORTANT to the Trust's Survival.
*The Ork Warboss is dumb enough that they might actually get them damaged from suicidally stupid attacks.
*Do not fight a Paragon General with a Paragon Diviner with armies of psykers and superhuman mooks on prepared homeground.
*Vanaheim's Shipyards are SUPER IMPORTANT to the Trust's Survival.
*The Ork Warboss is dumb enough that they might actually get them damaged from suicidally stupid attacks.
*Do not fight a Paragon General with a Paragon Diviner with armies of psykers and superhuman mooks on prepared homeground.
Eh, splitting the vote that's already in the minority seems like it's just going to guarantee it loses, not worth that.
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
You can approval vote.
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
He's looking for a fight, but OTOH it's not like the Avernites are the only civilization on Avernus..
- Location
- Australia
We want to ensure he lives. It's going to be hard enough keeping him away from trying to blow up the planet or kill all the Sun Beetles if he attacks us. Sending him off to the other side of the world where we can't project power at all would make it all but impossible to intentionally keep him alive if he decides to try something catastrophically stupid.
Last edited:
- Location
- Leicester UK
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
After thinking about it I'm willing to accept a small degree of war weariness to take up our role as the tank of the core worlds again now the option has a reasonable write-up, mostly because I think the political capital Rotbart can build up will be worth it when we inevitably cause the High Council to simultaneously facepalm again.
After thinking about it I'm willing to accept a small degree of war weariness to take up our role as the tank of the core worlds again now the option has a reasonable write-up, mostly because I think the political capital Rotbart can build up will be worth it when we inevitably cause the High Council to simultaneously facepalm again.
I personalty find the request for resources for Avernus to be phrased in a almost childish passive-aggressiveness. If we are going to demand more resources then we should mention what resources, like an actual politician not a sulking child.
Then again I'm not voting for Avernus anyway so not sure how relevant my opinion is here.
Then again I'm not voting for Avernus anyway so not sure how relevant my opinion is here.
Doomed Wombat
Let's go Darling!
- Location
- Dancing on wires!
Wait the being sullen action, or the volunteering it for war again action?
Romka
Master of Stealth
- Location
- In a barrel
Why wouldnt we be able to hold as many troops there? They have more cities than we do.
- Location
- Leeds
@Shard Thank you kindly.
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
-[X][Plan] Middle Ground, Avernus
-[X][Argument] Avernus' status as a Deathworld greatly increases the amount of attrition the Orks are subject to, particularly with an idiotic Warlord in charge of it maximizing the damage they suffer; Avernus also already has an Ork Infestation from previous invasions, so the long-term effects on it are minor.
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
-[X][Plan] Middle Ground, Avernus
-[X][Argument] Avernus' status as a Deathworld greatly increases the amount of attrition the Orks are subject to, particularly with an idiotic Warlord in charge of it maximizing the damage they suffer; Avernus also already has an Ork Infestation from previous invasions, so the long-term effects on it are minor.
Answered by Durin:
But my reason was that on Mar Sahra we had the problem of not enough room for our troops. With Svartalfheim mainly having cities only instead of a hive and cities as on Mar Sahra I beliefed we would be limited even more.
That still does not sway me enough to support Svartalfheim. It is closer through.
[X] Plan Deathworld Avernus
Doomed Wombat
Let's go Darling!
- Location
- Dancing on wires!
We had plenty of room on Marsara just not enough fortifications.
Svartalfheim doesn't have that problem
Shard
One and Many
- Location
- Malaysia
The Ork warboss is so dumb we have the luxury of deciding which world to fight him on.
This is usually not a thing that happens.