Not sure. Of course, Albion does have giants as one of the local powers...
Are you sure? Money isn't a huge constraint right now, and ninja flash bombs would be awesome.1 or 3. Which one do you want? (2 is out because I don't want expensive weapons)
§ . we are already using Guldur far too much for my taste.1 or 3. Which one do you want? (2 is out because I don't want expensive weapons)
I think three personally for better defense, use against monstrous units, and we can use it on the Dragon more effectively.1 or 3. Which one do you want? (2 is out because I don't want expensive weapons)
Er...cultural inegration and intermarriage=gift of the Valar in the children
interethnic children without certain moral standards=Gift of Eru.
What do you even mean with "If ever?"
I'm sorry, I can't help myself.Again and AGAIN this argument goes on...
It's like listening to a record set on repeat...
It really is.Again and AGAIN this argument goes on...
It's like listening to a record set on repeat...
But remember that there is a difference between cultural integration and full ethnic mixing. For example, the Irish, Germans and Poles are completely culturally integrated into American society, with the only signs they were there being a drinking festival, some types of sausages, and beer. They are also completely intermixed ethnically, where many American Caucasians have no idea if they have Irish, German or Polish heritage. They've been in America for about 100 years.
The Vietnamese, by contrast, have been in America for about 50 years. The second and third generations are almost completely integrated culturally. Intermarriage is, however, still rare.
So when you're talking about timelines for cultural integration, and for for intermarriage to spread the Gift of the Valar, you're talking about two separate, but related, processes. And the magical elements introduced will skew things beyond any real world analogues, but almost certainly in the direction of making things more difficult.
As far as I can ascertain, you're arguing for this scenario:
That as soon as Gaels move in to Arnor, lower class Dunedain will leap at the chance to marry these new immigrants- so much so that within one or two generations, there will no more pure blooded Gaels, unless more have moved Arnor in the intervening years. At the same time, Gaels with enthusiastically embrace Arnorian customs, with no friction or resistance. And so within two generations, Gaels will be so thoroughly integrated into Dunedain society that the only sign they were ever there will be occasional festivals with traditional Gaelic costumes and Gaelic food.
Even in that insanely optimistic outlook, you still have two generations of mutant children, Chaos cultists, and untrained potential sorcerors that Dunedain laws are not equipped for dealing with.
Because it really is a hard decision? Because a case can be made fir morality or immorality of both approaches?It really is.
What is it about this thread which inspires such circular arguments.
I know, twas a rhetorical question.Because it really is a hard decision? Because a case can be made fir morality or immorality of both approaches?
This quest has something few other quests do: meaningful hard decisions. This is a large part of it's appeal. Unfortunately, it comes with some drawbacks, which we are currently experiencing.
Wow that was magnificent I can't wait to see where you take this.Tome of the Arcane, part 1
The Magizks Of The Worlde
Author: Nolondur No-one's son
- First words
'What you see before you is the culmination of more than a decade of workings and sweat of mine own making, all in effort to gather the most fact-based tome of the energies and fluctuations of power both within and outside of this new world.'
'This tome has gone through the hands of the royal family, hands of sidhe and has been approved as safe content by both. I hope it shall bring you knowledge of dangers, opportunities and existing entities all. Let the Valar be my witness when I swear that no harm shall come from reading the words I've written on these pages.'
- How this book came to be
'It must be mentioned that when I began this journey of discovery, it was originally intended for a far different tome to be written, about the Sidhe themselves being the absolute focus.'
'It had been a year after our king sailed to the court of the Sidhe and returned with our otherworldly visitors with their distinct peculiarities.'
'I have always been a curious mind, even as a lad. The only knowledge I had and wouldn't touch or seek, were those of the infernal tomes and knowledge of the arch-evil itself, but other, safer sources of knowing had always called out to me like a a moth is called by fire -
albeit with far less accidental suicide if I do say so myself.'
'Nevertheless, these mysterious people intrigued me immensely - I had to learn more about them and I commenced an unofficial fact-gathering mission, talking with sailors and guards that had had been part of the crew on the ship - truly, the knowledge I learned was intriguing and sporadic both, with talk of a great banquet and challenge of arms where Prince Elendur dueled and claimed victory three times.
Yet this did not fill the pit that was my curiosity, only brought it to the front. So much was still not known, so much still unanswered.'
'On the day I heard that one of the sidhe was a sorcerer of sorts with energies arcane, was the day where my thoughts, just like the thoughts of many of our kin, ground to an halt like before walls of a fortress. I couldn't understand how such a thing could exist and be allowed to walk in the halls of our new home - yet I am og the sort that seeks out the reason for such acts instead of simple guesswork. There was no sight I would consider more unlikely that our wise king would follow in the footsteps of those who had so hunted us - as so, the only reason I could see this happening was if there was a fundamental difference 'between the sorcerers of the King's Men and the sorcerers of the Sidhe.
This hypothesis however, while clearing our king from malicious intent as to be expected, was still just a hypothesis, a guesswork.
I would not leave it that: I had to know. My focus had completely shifted from knowing about the sidhe to knowing about if this power was a danger or not.'
'So did I seek one of these sidhe and attempted to reap knowledge from talks with this being, only to find myself flummoxed before this woman who spoke in riddles and half-hidden smiles, her eyes glinting at the mix of jest and slight ridicule she dispensed at me.
Undeterred, I would attempt to speak with these impossibilities of the sea again and again. Slowly did the work progress, but progress I could still claim, for while they spoke in riddles they spoke of the subject matter and as my understanding grew so did their curiosity of some of their number turn towards me. For I had began to speak in riddles back to them, if not surprising then at least humoring them that one of Man would try to use their own ways to speak with them.'
'As time passed, It became clear to me that while each sidhe did have more knowledge about these energies they utilized for their shifting shapes and how one of them could control water as if it was part of her very being - than any of Man of Arnor could boast, their knowledge was less academic and more of knowledge towards their own bodies and the ways to use it in ways that would not harm them - but did some of them let slip that there were ways a Man could use a sorcery in ways that they as a whole could not. This had intrigued me as much as it brought fear into my heart, if such things could be co-opted as back in the old lands of our home.'
'It took me a whole circle of an week to decide how to proceed next. Yet in the end, the decision I would make seemed so obvious at that time. I felt it impossible that all of sidhe did not have the aptitude towards progress and preservation of knowledge. So I decided to go for the source. I bartered, I gambled and I begged, for all the sidhe I could find, for them to allow me to meet one of their learned individuals.'
'Finally, my call for knowledge was answered: one sidhe whose name I had never heard, nor seen before on lands of Arnor, had one day appeared to me during an evening walk. Here, she gave me an choice: she shall take me to meet one of the sidhe knowledgeable of the energies in a way most couldn't match. In return, the sidhe I would meet shall have me as her servant for a year and a day.'
'I accepted.'
'Even knowing what that sentence truly means now - of how long "a year and a day" truly meant for the sidhe - I would still make the same choice.'
'Those were years... well spent.'
'When began the night after the day after, I took a rowing boat up to the sea, where I met my guide. She held a talisman to me and ordered me to put it on; and the moment I put it on did she pull me down to the water and I found myself able to breath without air. Transforming into marine-life, she pushed me back to the boat after being satisfied that this, this item of power was a functional one. The water around the boat sped up, faster and faster, until I found it submerging and following an underwater current towards the unknown.'
'I couldn't tell you how long it took for me to reach my destination, nor could I write down of how the place that would be my residence looked like from the outside, for during the travel I found myself in a trance. The first clear memories I would have would be of me snapping awake within a hall made out of living underground plant-life and rock. Noticeably, the room I currently inhabited was one of air and not water, seemingly a guestroom of sorts for men when the lord of the residence would such want to host.'
'Finding the talisman that had given me the ability of watery breathing sitting on a table close-by, I placed it again on my neck and dropped myself onto a hole on the floor that led to areas filled with it; there did I meet my host and the sidhe I had been looking for - their identity I shall not give, for their first demand was that I would never share it with others without their permission.'
'They explained to me that while I would be able to learn from them, they shall have the right to learn from me - knowledge for knowledge, an equal exchange for both Beings of learning. Just to be certain the balance of scales was in order, I told that I was planning on spreading the information I would gain to the rest of my kind and they answered that I was allowed to write the things I learned and spread them to my people - after all, my servitude during the discussed time was the price for that particular caveat as otherwise they would have simply made dealings in knowledge with knowledge without the Oath of Year and a Day.'
'So it was that I started my work in earnest: with questions flying to one another we both began to write down the information given by the other, albeit I still not know the material they wrote on, for it was no paper as was to be expected from a being that lived underwater where the material would be useless. They were focused closely on the Older Lores of our people: wanting to know of the past of our old world - indeed, the reason they had found this arrangement appealing was so they could be the first of their kind to truly know and learn all of the older tales, for the Sidhe enjoy the arts of songs and tales, both which the delegation send to the sidhe courts had offered by the bards that took part in the meeting. Yet this had only enhanced the need of knowing my host felt, just as the knowledge about the deeper depths of the power had called to me, for my people to know from the best source possible in order to guard against a possible threat.'
'Luckily for me, I could provide the asked price easily enough, for as an dedicated scholar I did not just remember the stories vaguely, for I had taken every word to memory. Even some of the actual songs I could still remember, allowing me to write the notes the original tales were sang with.
The tales of the birthing of the worlde did they find the most important; and so did they enjoy the words of splendor and power that he had me recite the music notes I've heard before starting the actual story and they began to play them with their own harp as I began.'
'At the part of betrayals of most foul by the workings of Melkor, Later named Morgoth, did my host open in tears and shouts of rage; so large was their reaction that they broke one of their harps, throwing it at the walls while the emotions overtook them. They made me recite the descriptions of the Great Trees where light shined down upon the worlde and later did I find them, painting with colors of real world and imagined onto canvas that couldn't be truly only from this worlde, trying to give life even to an imitation of that time of joy and brightness as if in effort to defy this beast that they themselves had named a Chaos God - while uncomfortable and unwilling with agreeing of Melkor being the exact same as the Primal Evils of these lands, I did say and admit that even if these two forces were of different sorts, they and their forces both were still Forces of Destruction onto themselves like no other, in any case.'
'So the time passed and the part of my bargain where I was a servant rose its head, as my host send me to do certain tasks and actions such as cleaning important artifacts of sorts. I shall not go into detail there, for what is important that I noticed that time seemed to move slower than it should. In time, I realized that the bargain I had struck was far longer-reaching than I had thought, but I felt no hurry to leave as I still had much to learn about the energies; energies I could at that point already name as either realms of madness or realms of magic, depending who you asked.
Indeed, my host noted my acceptance of the newly revealed fact and said to me smiling that I had learned an important lesson to bring to the Dunedain, saying that while they themselves would only keep me there until the transaction was complete in full - as I would wish it to be, in truth -, some others would have taken longer advantage from a servant with this much to give them.'
'Indeed, the sidhe saw nothing wrong with what was happening and thus I came to the realization that they truly were a being like no other: their minds and thought, while could follow the workings of a human (as I would later learn, to the point where they may decide adopt the culture of Man as their own and life as like one of us), others of their kind who did not do so could prove to be dangerously deceptive.'
'Not evil, for my host truly did not see it as an dark act and I felt no malice - yet this teaching I shall bestow to you alongside the other words written on these pages, to be careful of agreements made without looking at the specifics agreed upon carefully'.
'Finally, after many years of mutual discovery and teachings, both my host and I found ourselves at a point where everything we could (or at least were willing to) share, was shared. I left the place I had worked on tirelessly for at least a decade of time if not more, only to find that the worlde had only gone through a much smaller number of time.'
'A Year... and a Day.'.
2218 words.
1. I won't be able to go on for a while
2. I want the catapult option for the weapons series reward and if possible I want the Cauldron for the Gaels sequel series. I will confirm this once I return, but the Cauldron option might not be able to be delayed.
3. I might be asking too much, but I would appreciate it if the Gaels subplot could be delayed until I returned, not least because I am offering the only compromise option possible atm which may be acceptable to both parties. Besides there are too many plot threads going on anyway.
Said when his exams are done in a week or two he should be able to access SV again.What does he mean "wait for him"? How long is he going to be off then? I thought it would take two turns about until the Gael are here?