The intent is fairly clear, and it probably translates alright if you squint, but taken uncritically it implies even wilder things about the setting than the gun.
Could you elaborate on this? At first glance, it doesn't seem particularly wild.

Kakashi literally chops lightning in half at one point, it's safe to assume that Jonin are so superhuman that guns actually don't matter.
While its rare, humans in our world have dodged bullets, I feel like by the time you're a chunin in the Naruto-verse, a world that already has a superhuman standard to its humans in the first place, you're probably pretty okay handling a basic handgun.

Anything past that... Well I'm not getting into a gun debate with gun enthusiasts, let alone a gun debate with my Naruto fanfiction thread XD
I'm perfectly on board with ninja dodging guns. I just assume they do it the way real people do it--by being faster than the gunman, not than the bullet. They also have ninjutsu. Notably, the Body Flicker Technique is so common it's surprising that it isn't one of the Academy Three, and that's before we get into the kind of ninjutsu a jōnin should be able to unleash.

(Also, I bet you anything that Kakashi's Lightning Cutter backstory is an embellishment.

GAI: You are too slow and lazy, my rival. Come, join me in a hundred-lap race around Leaf to see who's faster!

KAKASHI: I don't need to race you. In fact, I'm so fast, I cut a lightning bolt in half with my bare hands the other day. Hell, I even call my Chidori the Lightning Cutter. Don't bother challenging me until you can beat that. (Oh, Sage, why did I say Lightning Cutter? What am I, fourteen? This is going to be all over the village by sundown, I just know it.)
 
I'm wondering if there's actually normal gunpowder around, or if all bullets in-setting require a small explosive seal instead. It would explain the rarity of guns, and why most ninjas don't bother if it's such a time and chakra investment.

And for a girl who works all day at a weapon shop, Tenten's had the time to learn and manufacture the rounds herself.

Guns existing in any fashion is definitely no weirder than Mecha-Naruto or Mecha-Kurama. ...Naruto's filler did some really silly things.
Ostrich ninja
 
I'm perfectly on board with ninja dodging guns. I just assume they do it the way real people do it--by being faster than the gunman, not than the bullet. They also have ninjutsu. Notably, the Body Flicker Technique is so common it's surprising that it isn't one of the Academy Three, and that's before we get into the kind of ninjutsu a jōnin should be able to unleash.

(Also, I bet you anything that Kakashi's Lightning Cutter backstory is an embellishment.

GAI: You are too slow and lazy, my rival. Come, join me in a hundred-lap race around Leaf to see who's faster!

KAKASHI: I don't need to race you. In fact, I'm so fast, I cut a lightning bolt in half with my bare hands the other day. Hell, I even call my Chidori the Lightning Cutter. Don't bother challenging me until you can beat that. (Oh, Sage, why did I say Lightning Cutter? What am I, fourteen? This is going to be all over the village by sundown, I just know it.)
I'm choosing to believe Kakashi's embellishment, because it's cooler that way.

As for bullets... Nah, all the end game ninjas are faster than bullets, fite me XD
But yeah I dunno what he's smoking about the idea that Chunin exam nominees should be able to outrun bullets I uh...
Was better stuff than I was on last night, that's for sure.
 
Didn't mean to suggest that I wasn't on board with the story. It makes sense when The Gamer is, in fact, a Gamer.

I just can't stop noticing all the giveaways in Naruto fanfiction where authors ignore the Military dictatorship that is the Leaf Village, and act like it's just a 1980s American city.

It's an active training center and logistical headquarters for superhuman child soldiers/assassins.

Also, firearms mass adoption is less likely to cause the mass social upheaval we saw historically, due to trained shinobi being able to outmaneuver peasant levies. No level of peasant training is going to take them to crossing the continent in a day and a half. Moving beyond that has made them a new class of soldier, and changed the political power distribution in the process.

I love theorycrafting about the social situation in Naruto. Honestly the whole setting really seems like it's right on the cusp of absolute madness.
 
I recall an old pen and paper RPG (think it was one of the Rogue Trader editions?) where due to a quirk of the system high level characters didn't use guns. Basically the damage of a gun wasn't tied to a character's stats or anything. The did the same damage for a low level newb as an epic demigod. However the damage of a thrown weapon was based on strength. So after a certain point you were better off fishing a bullet out of your gun and manually lobbing it at someone.

I imagine things are similar with ninja. A jonin can toss a kunai faster and with more force than a bullet from any hand-held gun. Probably a decent chunk of chunin could do the same.
 
I just can't stop noticing all the giveaways in Naruto fanfiction where authors ignore the Military dictatorship that is the Leaf Village, and act like it's just a 1980s American city.
A big part of that, is that it being a Military Dictatorship is fanon.
We're shown no real proof of that, at all, in canon. At best we see evidence towards the opposite. The hokage always seem to include others in their thoughts and decisions, and aside from what I've heard about one instance of Danzo, we never see any crazy laws come out. Naruto was allowed to deface the damn monument.

There being a military leader doesn't automatically make it a dictatorship, and we just don't see enough into Konoha decision making to know if it well and truly is.

It not being a military dictatorship is also fanon, to be clear, we just don't know.

And when you're lacking concrete details, writers - especially fanfiction writers - are going to write what they feel comfortable writing.
And most of us live in a modern city, that is not run by a military dictatorship.
 
No level of peasant training is going to take them to crossing the continent in a day and a half.
Is this a thing we see happen? It doesn't ring any bells.

There being a military leader doesn't automatically make it a dictatorship, and we just don't see enough into Konoha decision making to know if it well and truly is.
There being a single, unelected military leader whose power is not checked by other institutions sounds like a military dictatorship to me. It might be a nice military dictatorship where the dictator cares what other people think, but it's certainly not a democracy, and not even an oligarchy (the next step down on the ladder from Hokage is "ordinary jōnin").

Edit: The last bit might not be strictly true, as there are leadership positions like the ANBU Commander and the Torture and Interrogation Force head, but none of them appear to have influence on government.
 
Last edited:
At risk of furthering the derail, the political situation of Konoha seems to be that of a client state to the Land Of Fire, at their most independent, and simply the Shinobi arm of the land of fires military at the least. I call it a military dictatorship, but it really seems to just be a Military.

We don't know the Hokages specific relationship to the Fire Daimyo, whether they're equals with different functions, or why they can take missions that involve non-land of fire clients.

Does the daimyo give out his own orders to the hokage, who assigns them to the Jonin they think is best suited?

Now a mod can come in and quote my opening comment to chastise me for knowingly furthering a detail when I already called it out as a derail. Please know in advance I will derive sexual pleasure from it.
 
Is this a thing we see happen? It doesn't ring any bells.

There being a single, unelected military leader whose power is not checked by other institutions sounds like a military dictatorship to me. It might be a nice military dictatorship where the dictator cares what other people think, but it's certainly not a democracy, and not even an oligarchy (the next step down on the ladder from Hokage is "ordinary jōnin").

Edit: The last bit might not be strictly true, as there are leadership positions like the ANBU Commander and the Torture and Interrogation Force head, but none of them appear to have influence on government.
It can sound like it all it wants, it doesn't make it that way.
I don't care if people want to believe it's a certain way, that's fine.
But when people assert it as fact... they are asserting fanon as fact.

For whatever reasons, Kishimoto did not decide it was important to go into how Konoha works as a political structure past that there are Kage, and there's a Daimyo they probably please.
We see some evidence for a dictatorship, we see some against.
One of the against would be when Sarutobi died and instead of like, trying to get Konohamaru to step up as the next god king or whatever, they went searching for eligible people, actively, with people clearly given authority to make that decision. That doesn't sound very military dictatorship to me.

There's also Naruto running around quite literally shouting about how he plans to topple the current regime and take its place, and everyone's just like "You do that kid, go nuts." Headpats

Like, I'm not saying anyone's super wrong for thinking so.
But the moment you're saying things like other people are "ignoring how Konoha is" you're asserting fanon.
Personally, I'm actually more on the side of military dictatorship than 1980s American city, for sure, and that'll come up in Arc 5 quite a bit.

But asserting that it is, is asserting fanon, and that's why we all see so many stories contradicting it.
 
At risk of furthering the derail, the political situation of Konoha seems to be that of a client state to the Land Of Fire, at their most independent, and simply the Shinobi arm of the land of fires military at the least. I call it a military dictatorship, but it really seems to just be a Military.

We don't know the Hokages specific relationship to the Fire Daimyo, whether they're equals with different functions, or why they can take missions that involve non-land of fire clients.

Does the daimyo give out his own orders to the hokage, who assigns them to the Jonin they think is best suited?
We can get some insight by looking at the case of Sand, where the Wind Daimyo heavily damaged the hidden village's economy by outsourcing missions to Leaf instead (according to the wiki; I confess I don't remember this detail). This implies a strictly subordinate relationship, since the Kazekage couldn't just tell the Wind Daimyo to cut it out, and was instead forced to take a series of increasingly extreme steps to ensure Sand's survival over the following decade. It also shows that the country doesn't fund the village directly, implying they are not tied into a formal structure where the village is seen as a resource to invest in.

This also illustrates the important principle that, after a point, Kishimoto just doesn't know what he's doing with politics, so we will only drive ourselves mad by trying to make the Narutoverse make sense. Why would you pay a foreign village to do your work instead of your own, when not only is Leaf inherently less trustworthy and ultimately subordinate to a different leader whose interests are not your interests, but doing so actively cripples your own country's military capability?
 
It can sound like it all it wants, it doesn't make it that way.
I don't care if people want to believe it's a certain way, that's fine.
But when people assert it as fact... they are asserting fanon as fact.

For whatever reasons, Kishimoto did not decide it was important to go into how Konoha works as a political structure past that there are Kage, and there's a Daimyo they probably please.
We see some evidence for a dictatorship, we see some against.
One of the against would be when Sarutobi died and instead of like, trying to get Konohamaru to step up as the next god king or whatever, they went searching for eligible people, actively, with people clearly given authority to make that decision. That doesn't sound very military dictatorship to me.

There's also Naruto running around quite literally shouting about how he plans to topple the current regime and take its place, and everyone's just like "You do that kid, go nuts." Headpats

Like, I'm not saying anyone's super wrong for thinking so.
But the moment you're saying things like other people are "ignoring how Konoha is" you're asserting fanon.
Personally, I'm actually more on the side of military dictatorship than 1980s American city, for sure, and that'll come up in Arc 5 quite a bit.

But asserting that it is, is asserting fanon, and that's why we all see so many stories contradicting it.
I think konoha works as a non familial monarchy where the next kage is supposed to be chosen by the reigning kage but if they die before choosing a successor it falls to a council of advisors to choose their next leader
 
Is this a thing we see happen? It doesn't ring any bells.
Peasant training or crossing the continent? When I say the crossing a continent, I'm referring to how ninja move many times faster than civilians. The tree jumping and other movement techniques let them travel at speeds that are poorly defined, but incredibly fast when extrapolated out to continents and days.

As for peasant training, I'm referring to the democratization of force created by cheap firearms in the periods just after the enlightenment, and how they did considerable damage to the ruling classes attempts to hold onto power.

That same level of damage wouldn't be inflicted on the elemental nations, since Ninja are so much more dangerous than a Knight, even without massive supply lines and taxation ensuring their economic backing.
 
Could you elaborate on this? At first glance, it doesn't seem particularly wild.
So, the intended reading is likely just being a member of the majority ethnicity for the area.


On the other hand, an uncritical reading might think the Naruto clone was literally identifying himself as a white male, and implying that that is the majority ethnicity such that it's disqualifying for adding diversity to anything.

In a setting that's pretty heavily coded as fantasy!Japan.

What did the fantasy!Nanban do for that to happen!? Who is fantasy!Portugal in this!? What happened that this ethnicity swap is otherwise unremarked upon!?
 
So, the intended reading is likely just being a member of the majority ethnicity for the area.


On the other hand, an uncritical reading might think the Naruto clone was literally identifying himself as a white male, and implying that that is the majority ethnicity such that it's disqualifying for adding diversity to anything.

In a setting that's pretty heavily coded as fantasy!Japan.

What did the fantasy!Nanban do for that to happen!? Who is fantasy!Portugal in this!? What happened that this ethnicity swap is otherwise unremarked upon!?
I actually hadn't thought of that, that's amazing.
Go Logos
 
So, the intended reading is likely just being a member of the majority ethnicity for the area.


On the other hand, an uncritical reading might think the Naruto clone was literally identifying himself as a white male, and implying that that is the majority ethnicity such that it's disqualifying for adding diversity to anything.

In a setting that's pretty heavily coded as fantasy!Japan.

What did the fantasy!Nanban do for that to happen!? Who is fantasy!Portugal in this!? What happened that this ethnicity swap is otherwise unremarked upon!?
I mean, the setting's coded as fantasy!Japan, but if you're going to tell me that Sakura's pink hair or the Yamanaka's pupilless eyes are expressions of the Japanese phenotype...
 
Chapter 47 - Arc 4 - Brawling in the Streets: Anger Issues
You ever look at a chapter you wrote and go "You know, not a fan... Fuck me."
I'm not saying I hate this chapter, and I will stand in defense of my characterization on all parts, but even after several edits I'm like "Ehhhhh, uhhhh... Hmmmmmm...."

It feels more forced than organic, I guess is the wording? I'm not saying this couldn't have happened organically, I just don't feel like this was organic.
That's kind of the issue with being on an update schedule and working though. Sometimes it's 11PM and you're just like, "fuck it."

I've given it one last edit before posting it here, I like it a bit more now than before, but uh, enjoy.
Or join the Patreon, jump 21 chapters ahead, and get past this awkward while supporting me taking less time for work and more time for this story so this just doesn't happen.


"Cover your ears." Tenten orders, and Sakura for her credit does exactly as she's told.
She doesn't even look at Tenten as the girl sticks her head up over the counter and takes aim.
She sticks her fingers in her ears, and says a silent prayer to the Kami that this isn't going to mess with her too badly.

Bang-
Bang-
Bang-
Bang-
Bang-

It just keeps going, how big is that weapon's magazine? She doesn't check, she doesn't look, she just knows that her ears hurt. Even with them covered, her enhanced senses as a ninja almost make her pass out.

"Why do you have a gun?" She says it the moment the shooting seems to be done, but she doesn't hear herself say it, and has to look up at Tenten to read her lips for her response. She's not sure when the older girl got earmuffs on, but she did, and that's probably for the best.

"I'm a ranged specialist." Tenten explains, coming down so her head isn't in the firing zone and it's easier for Sakura to read her lips. "Guns aren't great for the field where ninja have full mobility, but they're amazing for situations like this, why wouldn't I have one?"

"But-" Sakura doesn't bother to finish her own statement, Tenten's right. She looks at her crossbow with a bit of shame. They both operate under the same concept, not getting stronger based on the user but being very good for low level enemies. Why is she carrying around a crossbow instead of a pistol or something, fire bolts be damned.

Maybe she'll see if Higurashi's can get her one when she gets back, just for situations like this...

"Look, do you scoff at weapons because they're a little unorthodox, or do you take them just in case they're useful? I love kunai, but we're in a closed shop and they're down a narrow passage towards the exit. Guns shoot straight, that's what they do." Tenten continues, clearly not noticing Sakura got her point already.

"Ah…" Sakura gulps, nodding to herself in a show of understanding. "Are we sure they weren't the academy students?"

"Nope. But I'm sure we can check after we investigate. Body shots don't normally kill those with ninja training that easily." Tenten shrugs.

"And if they did?" Sakura asks.

"Well, they were throwing attacks into this guy's shop…" Tenten ponders, "Neji might be mad, we executed the wrong targets, but I'm okay with this."

"Me too." Sakura agrees, before getting up to go check on the enemy.





It turns out there were four of them, and they are badly injured.
She can see Tenten is expecting a lecture, but Sakura doesn't have anything like that in her. She inwardly wonders why she'd think she'd get yelled at for taking down the enemy? Even her team doesn't yell at her.

"We should patch them up," Sakura says, dropping by one of the four downed boys and searching in her pack for medical supplies while he groans.

"Right!" The girl with the gun cries out, getting right to work beside her.
It's a lot of work, but she's sure this will help her to know in the future, so Sakura doesn't complain, she just treats the wounds in the best she can with the sub-part medical supplies she could afford after wasting so much of her money. She'll need to add that to her list of stuff to get better quality supplies for. It seems medical is where you want the good stuff, or it becomes far more of a pain in the ass than she expected.

As she finishes treating the second, and finds Tenten's right behind her with her second, Sakura can't help but smile at a pop-up that arrives.

You have earned the First Aid Skill:
You now have hands-on experience with first aid and treating wounds. Healing items applied by you are 10% more effective, you will never forget how to use a healing item after you first learn, and healing items are more likely to show up in loot.

That's nice, too bad she didn't have that back in Wave. She might have been able to treat her eyes a little instead of going blind, maybe she'd have a potion or something.

It says healing items, so it probably counts magical ones. She hopes magical healing items exist, that'd be very convenient.

"They're academy students." Sakura says, after a bit, "there's nothing on them that indicates the preparedness of a real Genin."

"It's too early to be taking captures, Neji wants the academy students later." Tenten points out, "what if they're just bad Genin?"

"You want to kill them?" Sakura asks, already drawing her weapon from its sheath.

"No I just… right, let's rope 'em up and bring them to him, see what he thinks." She doesn't look happy about that decision.




Sakura can already tell something bad is about to happen by the nervousness in the way Tenten ties them up to chairs for Neji. Her hands are skittish, and awkwardly fumbly for a dexterous girl like her. Sakura lines them up in a proper row so that when he comes back from his part he can see them easily.

She's not disappointed, bad things do happen.

From the moment Neji enters the room she can see the frown on his features is one of unbridled rage. He's a stoic boy, the kind that rarely shows his emotions in a way that's readable for someone with low charm like her, but the mood chart helpfully expresses the murderous chart image for her right beside his head.

"Tenten, you understand we still have weeks on this mission, correct?" Neji scolds, looking at them and the gags Sakura tied up on their mouths to prevent needless annoyances. They just wouldn't stop whining about how Tenten shot them.

"Yes." Tenten looks a little ill, guilt showing in her eyes, shame too. Neji probably isn't a very good teammate. She couldn't imagine feeling that guilty even if Kakashi called her out on something.

"And we do not have the supplies to take care of four extra people," Neji asserts, "you are aware of that."

"But you said not to kill them…" Tenten pouts, looking anywhere but him, she rubs her arm nervously, and Sakura can't help but relate her to an abused girlfriend in a video game. It's odd because Neji doesn't look like the type… She decides to keep her mouth shut and observe, maybe she can learn something about profiling.

"I said they weren't a threat, there was no harm in letting them regroup and capturing them later when they would be less of a burden. Now they know where we are." He points out, practically shaking despite standing so very still, it's an odd oxymoron that has Sakura's keen eyes focused. She's happy her hearing is back, otherwise she'd be missing the practical hissing under his breath, which provides a lot of needed context here.

"They probably already did know where we are." Tenten defends herself. The look on her face makes it very clear she didn't intend to say that, because now she looks scared. Should she get involved? She feels a little rage at seeing him treat Tenten like this boil inside of her. She agrees with him but Tenten's right, he did ban killing the students. If Sakura had her way, this conversation wouldn't even be happening.

"Probably is not a guarantee." Neji makes a hand sign, and just as suddenly as he made it, his veins protrude around his eyes. It's possibly the most visible Doujutsu ever. Sasuke's eyes turn red, but Neji's do a whole circus act. His eyes gain definition in a way they didn't before, and Sakura knows something is about to happen.

"Wait, Neji!" Tenten moves to stop him, and freezes in place mid-shuffle when his glare turns towards her. The Byakugan allows you to see a full range around you, which means that glare was very intentional, and had nothing to do with focusing on Tenten, which is something Sakura grasps immediately thanks more to mind than charm. She's grateful the two overlap sometimes or she'd be even more of a lost wreck in life.

It's then that he does something which matters very little to her, but changes the world for Tenten. He walks down the line of prisoners, and gently pokes their foreheads one at a time while maintaining a false eye contact with the weapons girl.

Sakura watches Tenten's expression waver and crack. She ignores the dying boys entirely, they don't matter, but Tenten does. She whimpers, as they die, she begs for him to have mercy. They can keep one, maybe two, surely it wouldn't be that big a deal.

The second dies with an odd gurgle, Tenten's eyes fill with tears-

He kills a third despite her clear and obvious pain, and that's all Sakura can take.

She sees flame, a whispered madness takes over her vision as quickly as her rage ignites deep inside. Before Sakura even knows what she's doing, Neji's dodging to the side and her sword is where his head just was.

"What are you-" He shouts at her-

She doesn't hesitate to move in while he talks, forcing the elite boy to jump back and fall into a combat stance. She doesn't know what she's doing either, if she's perfectly honest, moderate treason maybe?

What matters is Kakashi's words, that she shouldn't hesitate or she'd die. Her sword goes through one of the dead, and it flares to life from its place inside them within a second. Neji's focus on her is clear, and she can tell he's surprised. "Can't you tell how much you're hurting her?" Sakura's voice comes out more trembling than angry, and even she has to double take at that.

"You're hurting a teammate intentionally to make a point, you're disgusting, the Leaf doesn't need ninja like you in charge." Sakura's voice echoes in on itself. She pulls her sword from the dead student strapped to a chair with a flick of her wrist, and notes the absence of a splash. Everything that needed to be pulled from him was, extracting a massive amount of power in such a short time, it all feeds her rage. "So I'm stopping you."

"Tenten was right about you, I'll put you in your place and let the Hokage decide what to do about this." He doesn't look bothered, his smirk seems satisfied, happy about this. It looks like he's been waiting for someone to try and stop him for some time, and that only makes her all the more eager to be the one to do it. Her second hand lands on the hilt, and she lets out a primal growl, before her feet take her across the room to him in an instant. He pushes a hand forward-
She slashes towards him-

The loudest clang she's ever heard rings in her ears before the vibrations hit her. It's so much so fast, she finds she's smashed her weapon directly into a brick wall that appeared out of nowhere.
Sparks fly, her power is sent out and is intercepted entirely, her momentum is halted and she's pushed back from the force of her own attack coming back towards her with equivalent energy. It's a law of physics she doesn't normally have to deal with because normally that part of the energy is bled off by the strike continuing through her opponent and her own controlled deceleration.

Here she finds she's sent back across the floor hard enough to burn it, boards are torn up beneath her feet and her whole body is wracked with untold agony that threatens to rip her apart. Her sword stabs into the floor just to give her something to hold onto as she falls to her knees.

Looking up, she finds Neji's in the same condition, sent backwards hard enough there's blood on his cheek and the floor is destroyed. He's still standing, better off than her, but still clearly worse for the engagement.

Standing between them, having taken the entire impact, is none other than the push-up master. Looking like a green hero, his short hair billowing, and looking none the worse for it but a little dirt caught on his clothes and the waver of his expression. "Enough." The boy says, but he doesn't need to, the both of them have already lost all sense of rage that filled them just a moment before. They're too shocked by what just happened, and in Sakura's case at least, happy about it. Killing an ally is probably frowned upon by Konoha law. Sakura's weapon is depowered, and as a show of faith in his teammate, Neji deactivates his Byakugan. The blood that her blade had held in it that was discharged is everywhere, splattering the walls, the dead, Neji, her, Tenten, Lee's the only one who looks untouched.

Standing in a field of consequence without a single blemish besides a little dirt, he looks like a hero in a strange land. She's never felt less like the protagonist before, he's clearly standing in front of her.

"Perhaps I went a bit far." Neji asserts, taking a breath to visibly calm himself.

"The Hokage will decide my punishment." Sakura says as calmly as she can manage herself, working herself to a shaky stand so she can sheath her sword. "I shouldn't have done that, and will understand if I'm to be removed from the mission."

"No," Neji says out of nowhere, shocking her attention back to him instead of the boy between them. "Lee would not have stepped in if your attack would not have seriously harmed me, because if he stepped in, it means Gai was about to step in but allowed him to instead to avoid getting in the way of the mission. I thought you were a nobody, but if you could harm me, then you are not here to learn how to fight from professionals, you are here to learn temperament."

"What's that have anything to do with this?" She growls at him, feeling her hand twitch, but knowing not to let it go anywhere near her weapon right now. She's in so much fucking trouble, holy crap. She's going to be on D ranks until she retires.

"It means that my duty here was to teach you how an adult conducts themselves, and I have failed. If you agree not to write about this in your report, I will do the same." His offer has her taking a step back, but it's nothing if not generous.
Aggressively generous.

"I agree, on the condition that you apologize to Tenten, and let me kill the final captive while she is not here to see it." It feels a little odd to negotiate when he is definitely doing her the favor, but, his nod is more than enough for him.

"This was too far, I am not handling command very well and I lashed out. I apologize, and will endeavor to learn from this." She watches the boy bow to Tenten, and that has her reeling more than anything.
She definitely misunderstood him, and she'll need to observe his character more from here on out. The him she's observed would have sent her home just now. Kakashi would probably approve of her actions, even if he'd put her in the dirt a bit before bringing her to the Hokage to make her beg for forgiveness. The fact that he'd be intentionally hurting her to prove a point doesn't escape her, but there's a difference here, she thinks. She's not sure what, but she's sure it's different.

Bottom line though, she needs to test just how much of her rage is her and how much is Thirsty, because holy shit, talk about a firing offense. Maybe she needs to talk to Sasuke's guy?
He's mentioned a guy.
 
I know you said you were very unhappy with this update, but I liked it! It's interesting to see how other teams' maladaptive coping mechanisms differ and interact with Sakura's.
 
Bottom line though, she needs to test just how much of her rage is her and how much is Thirsty, because holy shit, talk about a firing offense.
60/40 is my guess.

On the one hand Neji was acting like a bitch and pushing one of the few buttons Kakashi seemed fit to install into one of his students, on the other hand it'd be kinda hard to explain a decapitated teammate.
 
Hm. An interesting scene. I do agree that it could have been done better in theory, but for all I know it might have been a choice between declaring it finished like this or dropping the fic, and if that's the case I'd rather have this.

Also, what the fuck Neji, I'd ask what is wrong with you if I didn't already know.
 
eh.. It dose seem a bit forced... but in a way that fits the scene, due to us as the reader missing an internal conversation due to our POV as the readers? I can easily see it being cleared up with a little internal monolog on neji's part as I can somewhat see his internal reasoning, but that would spoil the scene if we knew what he was thinking before/during the event.

If it still does not feel right, perhaps try an omake of the scene from Neji's perspective, along with his internal thoughts? That could be quite interesting to see how he's dealing with Sakura himself, despite his Stoic exterior.
 
"Why is she carrying around a crossbow instead of a pistol or something, fire bolts be damned." The crossbow is much quieter, and thus much more useful for ninja work, especially if using a gun is going to cripple your hearing for any amount of time.

"Body shots don't normally kill those with ninja training that easily." See, if we dunk the suspected witch in water and she dies, then she's innocent. If she lives, then she's clearly a witch and we should burn her.

"Now they know where we are." Wouldn't they know that already? It's a village, not a town. Plus, they already killed the fake inn keeper who is now unable to check in with the other ninja, which makes it even more obvious where they are.

I do wonder what message Neji was trying to send Tenten here. Because, if it was "kill them all", then this is 100% his own fault for not saying that outright when they originally talked about it. Tenten was literally doing exactly what he told her to do.
 
I feel like Neji was needlessly antagonistic here. He reads like the fanon version used to bash his character by making him stupid unlikeable. Why did Neji kill the four captured enemies without even interrogating them for information? Why he is killing them slowly and deliberately in front of TenTen?

Hell, why is TenTen being distressesd by Neji killing them when she wanted to kill them before Sakura stopped her to take to Neji to get his verdict on whether to kill them or not?

I feel like the second half of the chapter would've been better if Neji got the info out of the captured enemy confirming they know nothing before berating TenTen for going loud with her gun on them, making their foes more cautious and harder to deal with. Not to mention TenTen not thinking about their supplies and how they can't capture anyone at this point if they want to finish the mission without raiding the village.
 
I know you said you were very unhappy with this update, but I liked it! It's interesting to see how other teams' maladaptive coping mechanisms differ and interact with Sakura's.
I was always going to dislike the chapter more than most. I know the end this chapter was playing for, and I'm not happy with the build up, so it feels like I forced it.
Where as you all just kinda see what happened.

A few might go out of their way to be a dick but largely speaking, I always expected my biggest detractor to be me here.
I'm happy you enjoyed it.
Natural causes. His head just fell off. If Danzo can get away with recruiting a lot of people of ROOT, and can kill more than half of them in training, there's a lot of natural causes going around.
Died to Natural Causes of Being a Dick.
Hm. An interesting scene. I do agree that it could have been done better in theory, but for all I know it might have been a choice between declaring it finished like this or dropping the fic, and if that's the case I'd rather have this.

Also, what the fuck Neji, I'd ask what is wrong with you if I didn't already know.
It was more deadlines.
I update this story 3 times a week but it doesn't make enough money for me to spend the kind of time I want to spend on each chapter.
I wrote it, I didn't like it, I rewrote it, I didn't like it.
I rewrote it again-
It needed to go out.

This plot is needed for later, so it had to happen, but I'm just not a fan of the lack of build up to this.
It's fine, because it's fanfiction. Everyone knows Neji's one twitch from snapping, but if this wasn't a fanfiction people would be very confused right now. "he didn't seem that bad, what the fuck?"
The lack of build up isn't something I'm personally happy with, but honestly, a part of that is that I didn't have a good outline for this Arc. I had to move when I was supposed to make the outline.

So while I had events that needed to happen, I didn't know how I was doing them, and I had deadlines. I think I was late each chapter when I was writing this part of the story? Like this was not a good time for the story, and the best I can hope for is that people enjoy it enough to stick through.

Later on Patreon hit like $150, and I suddenly had more time to write.
It's currently at $200, and I'm using some extra time to edit through a lot of the chapters before they go public, so, let it not be said I'm not using my support to better my passion project.
eh.. It dose seem a bit forced... but in a way that fits the scene, due to us as the reader missing an internal conversation due to our POV as the readers? I can easily see it being cleared up with a little internal monolog on neji's part as I can somewhat see his internal reasoning, but that would spoil the scene if we knew what he was thinking before/during the event.

If it still does not feel right, perhaps try an omake of the scene from Neji's perspective, along with his internal thoughts? That could be quite interesting to see how he's dealing with Sakura himself, despite his Stoic exterior.
That's possible, I might do so.
I do wonder what message Neji was trying to send Tenten here. Because, if it was "kill them all", then this is 100% his own fault for not saying that outright when they originally talked about it. Tenten was literally doing exactly what he told her to do.
He has anger issues, the message was "I have anger issues."
He said not to kill the Academy students to appease them and then it immediately backfired on him.
A more mature person would recognize that's on him, Neji, still did but he took an attempted murder.
There's obvs more to it but...
I feel like Neji was needlessly antagonistic here. He reads like the fanon version used to bash his character by making him stupid unlikeable. Why did Neji kill the four captured enemies without even interrogating them for information? Why he is killing them slowly and deliberately in front of TenTen?

Hell, why is TenTen being distressesd by Neji killing them when she wanted to kill them before Sakura stopped her to take to Neji to get his verdict on whether to kill them or not?

I feel like the second half of the chapter would've been better if Neji got the info out of the captured enemy confirming they know nothing before berating TenTen for going loud with her gun on them, making their foes more cautious and harder to deal with. Not to mention TenTen not thinking about their supplies and how they can't capture anyone at this point if they want to finish the mission without raiding the village.
I definitely wouldn't call it "bashing", you may need to rewatch his canon scenes. We are shown absolutely nothing but "He's an unrepentant asshole with crazy anger issues" up to well past this point in canon. If anything he's better mannered here than canon, certainly not a fanon bash.
But, I do agree that I'm not completely happy with it.
Interrogations might have been good.
A build up of Neji not handling the pressure well might have been nice, that way it wasn't fucking, out of nowhere.
But uh, canon Neji is legitimately sadistic. So him taking out his anger by trying to hurt an easy target is just, not unrealistic.

A lot of the first half of this arc was on a deadline without a ton of guidance and just kinda had to move on whether I liked every aspect or not.
 
Last edited:
Am I the only one that thinks the reaction to Sakura's meltdown to be unrealistic?

Sure Neji somehow figures out she wasn't aiming to be lethal because Gai doesn't intervene, but everyone just figuring out that she's on the mission specifically to manage her temper and accepting her behaviour as expected seems pretty strange.

To us it's plausible for her to loose control because of the murder sword of stabbiness, but how the heck does everyone accept that her loosing it and attacking Neji is normal if they don't know about it? Is it just accepted that ninja lack self control and a little mutilation between fellow genin is team building?

I mean Kakashi had to prevent Naruto and Sasuke from killing each other their new Jutsu, so maybe. But I would have thought Gai would have to explain things to relieve the tension.
 
Back
Top