Does Yonatan have a noble title at this point, or does his rank count for snobbery purposes? Because otherwise Maggie isn't completely risk-free, given that she's effectively a commoner's wife right now.
I've been thinking about this for a bit, and i figure I might as well toss in a little bit of commentary on the Johnny & Maggie side. Your post makes a good jumping off point. And no, he doesn't have a noble title of his own (the hierarchy of titles is Marquess > Baroness > Countess > Duchess > Grand Duchess > Empress).
Yonatan's shitposting at Yui about his lack of marriage prospects was my way of further establishing this trait about Yonatan: that when it comes to his personal life, when it comes to things personal (as opposed to professional), he's quite the unreliable narrator. He undersells his attractiveness as a marriage prospect but consider this:
In an Empire run by foxthot nobles, where sucession is more often than not Matrilineal (when Yui was born, Masatada was pushed down the line of succession), where nobles have privilege, advantage and wealth, Yonatan Chew has:
- Made a good life for himself despite coming from a commoner background without any of the advantage of fox nobles.
- enlisted out of high school and clawed his way up to be the third in command of the entire Imperial Navy. He can't go any higher, there's only so much salt and competence can go against the glass ceiling, but he's still in a great position to be.
- From an operational standpoint, he's the most powerful man in the Navy. All the fleet commanders ultimately report to him - the First Star Lord may be the head of the navy, but he sets policy, while Commander Fleet Operations executes (which is why the position has, for decades, been unofficially referred to as Third Star Lord).
- He's got an eye for talent, and he has a network of officers he has trained, mentored, led, befriended, served with, fought alongside, who will backchannel info to him. He taught Yui how to gain the trust and loyalty of one's subordinates, and he did this despite being a salt ossan instead of a beautiful fox princess. (Yonatan considers himself the unfun uncool ossan, but he's actually rather popular among his subordinates and among the Navy rank and file.)
- Prince Masatada isn't Yonatan's patron, Yonatan is Prince Masatada's patron.
This bears repeating: In an empire that favors girls like Yui - rich, foxgirl, noble, politically-connected, female - Yonatan, a middle-class human commoner man with no connections, has risen to be third in command of the Imperial Navy.
This is a man who should be drowning in foxtails sent by Great Houses to influence him. And so, enter Captain Amagi Ri-Sumeragi, Adjutant to Commander Fleet Operations, a Marquess and member of Great House Sumeragi's cadet branch, who seduced her way into Yonatan's life... by being really, really, really good at her job. Actually she's probably a better staff officer than Yui, but Johnny has *some* tact and isn't completely savage towards his niece, even if he has that facade up.
The funny thing is that I actually feel like writing Yonatan side more than Yui route quest, lmao, but commitment ho!
Also so long as they're officially not married, Amagi has zero risk of their relationship affecting her standing within Great House Sumeragi.