Hugh's Perfectly Abnormal Mafia Game Where Everything Weird Happens Oh God (And We Promise It's Not Mountainous This Time)

Not being able to join the observer channel after death is standard for any closed setup. Being able to join it would prove that Mediums and Retributionists do not exist. There is almost certainly a dead chat.

Honestly I feel like this would be best with a Night 0.
Two things:
1) Where I'm used to playing, there aren't usually roles like retributionists and mediums.
2) ^^, they have a specific chat within the spec/dead chat for the dead to talk to the medium on the off chance they have them.

Is deadchat optional here usually?
 
Yeah, currently of the opinion that nothing Hugh has said can be trusted or is misleading in some way, even if I try analysing it anyways, though I'm probably reading into things far too much.
Like earlier on was looking at the tags for this and saw they go 'mafia' 'not' so was thinking this could be cult, or have some other fucky opposing force/strange win con. I.E.; a ton of SK's, arsonists, or even be an all town game or some such like that.

So to answer the question going around.
Role card - Yeah there's probably more there than I'm seeing
Win con - Maybe, though no idea what it could be. Haven't really seen other win cons that aren't just 'majority rules'. Though have heard stuff like that vig game before, with it being all town with the win con as no-voting? Personally find that specific win con unlikely purely because it's a repeat, even if I did read into it a bit too much with those tags. I'm of the opinion that if there's a weird win con it'll be something unique and unexpected. Though that's more based off what I would do here, not Hugh, so who really knows.
Death flips - Ehhhh, maybe?
Mountains - Probably not. Think we'll all kill Hugh if it is, and probably Shal and Terra too for being accomplices to this
Dumb stuff - Maybe, though not sure exactly what that could be. Like what qualifies as 'dumb'. It's a pretty broad concept, and after last game a lot of people may be calling mountains dumb.
 
Nah. I mean, you don't have to post in it, but generally if there's a dead chat you'll be automatically added to it when you die. What you do with that is up to you.
Interesting.
Starting to lean towards there are secret roles here.
Unrelated to the conversation, I've just been mulling things over.
 
...I'm torn between poking at this and aggressively shutting it down. Ordinarily this isn't the sort of discussion I'd like to see D1, let alone within 24 hours of game start, but this is potentially a very weird game and I confess I'm curious as to some of the details on how. Would appreciate a second (third, fourth, etc.) opinion.
I don't like it either, mind you, I'm just confused enough to be frustrated. Especially with other people saying things that make me suspect this entire game is going to be us being played for blindfolded fools.
 
This is a situation of "no one else is talking, so I'm going to talk" for me.
I have seven hours of shift and I work from home, a hoe is bored and multitasking.
 
Almost certainly that is the point.
Of course, of course.

Anyway to weigh in:

I don't think my rolecard is explicitly lying to me, but there is a lot it doesn't say that makes me suspect the joke is in what wasn't stated.

I suspect that Hugh's comments in game will be the same level of not-actually-lying, where while everything he says is technically true, it's probably leaving out rather vital information.
 
Of course, of course.

Anyway to weigh in:

I don't think my rolecard is explicitly lying to me, but there is a lot it doesn't say that makes me suspect the joke is in what wasn't stated.

I suspect that Hugh's comments in game will be the same level of not-actually-lying, where while everything he says is technically true, it's probably leaving out rather vital information.

Yeah, exactly.
Lying by omission.
 
Does anyone actually like their role? Everyone so far has just been complaining about theirs.

I wouldn't say I'm complaining as much as just am exceptionally confused but I have ideas about what's going on that I want to mess around with first.

Im going to echo Nictis in that I think a N0 would probably make more sense of things.
 
Pretty sure this is just YP doing the thing again and trying to mech-solve too early; it's happened the last couple of games too.
Yeah, yeah, I know, I'm not realistically gonna end on this vote but that doesn't mean I have to like it.
 
so its just me and you rn nictis
do you have any thoughts or are we both head empty
Your 12/12 is showing Bun. Honestly I am somewhat inclined to sideye Wiadi somewhat. In the sense that while I won't deny that YP does try to hide behind his ineffective attempts at mech solving early as scum, I can at least understand enough of the complaining potentially that I think Wiadi went a bit too hard on it and then just kinda backed off when Walker pointed it out. The whole exchange there feels a little off with the shifting away, as much as I don't like the playstyle either.
 
Your 12/12 is showing Bun. Honestly I am somewhat inclined to sideye Wiadi somewhat. In the sense that while I won't deny that YP does try to hide behind his ineffective attempts at mech solving early as scum, I can at least understand enough of the complaining potentially that I think Wiadi went a bit too hard on it and then just kinda backed off when Walker pointed it out. The whole exchange there feels a little off with the shifting away, as much as I don't like the playstyle either.

this has nothing to do w 12/12
this has to do w the fact that me and nictis were the only ones here at the time
smh
 
Back
Top