[X] (House) Ravenclaw
[X] (Motivation) A large part of it is that you want to learn as much as you can and you want to be around people who feel similarly (for once) and a tiiiiny part of it is that, well, you want to see the look on your brothers' faces when they see a Weasley get sorted outside Gryffindor.
-[X] Oh and Luna too you guess ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
Thanks. This is helpful to hear and good for me to keep in mind.

I have ideas for how to make magic more entertaining to read about if players want to have Ginny go deep into magical lore research, but I agree that that sort of content usually ends up pretty dry/less entertaining to read. If we end up pursuing that, I'm hopeful the workarounds and puzzles I have in mind for it are able to keep the text interesting. My other quest, The Hyūga Affair (currently on hiatus), had a decent amount of text devoted to the inner workings of chakra that readers said they enjoyed, and I'm hopeful that I'm able to translate that spark into discussion of the magic system here's working if players choose to dig into it.
That's great to hear actually, and I'm all for the deep research, even if some may find reading about it a bit dry. I just fear that people trying to explain the stuff we see often times mugglefy the magic out of Harry Potter. If you haven't read it so far, Taures headcanon pdf is a great source of citations (even if I disagree on some of his conclusions) on magical theory we are given in canon. Not that I'm saying that you should follow any or all of that, the thread did vote in making this story AU, just to give some insight into all the stuff that makes Harry Potter magic so interesting to me ( and a lot of other people, if we look a the sales of the original books). I'm not even saying that all of the canon J.K. Rowling published over the years is good or interesting for a story, never mind your story, just that there is a lot of interesting stuff to build on.
 
I have to say I'm annoyed I didn't know about this earlier, because Here is what I might have chosen:


For family link, I would have gone for one of these two.

[] Mafalda and her family.
Mafalda, being the only girl in your family near your age, was your best friend growing up. When she and Luna had their row, you choose to side with blood, and the two of you were all the closer for it. Auntie Leonie dotes over the two of you together, and Tristram's always full of a quiet rage you that you can't help but shiver from. Their world is so different from The Burrow…
Traits: Weasley, Pureblood Connections, Deceit II, Proud, Worldly, Burrow Outcast
Abilities: Dark Arts improved to P (Poor). Wandlore improved to D (Dreadful). Dark Arts set as starting Affinity and Focus.

Dark Arts & Hanging with cousin Mafalda would have been fun.

[] Charlie Weasley, dragon tamer.
Your other family members were cool, but Charlie tamed dragons. Dragons. No. Think about it. Dragons. One time, he told your family he let you touch a dragon egg—but, between you and him, he let you ride a dragon hatchling on its first flight. He's so cool. Sometimes people give you weird looks when you talk about how dragons are. That's okay. Those people are weird and you're so cool you got to ride a dragon before you started Hogwarts.
Traits: Weasley, Dragon Tamer I, Care for Magical Creatures III, Creature Person, Worldly, Oddball
Abilities: Flying improved to Acceptable (A) or P (Poor) {pending later choice}. Flying selected as starting Affinity and Focus.

The character description alone is enough.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For trait pick, here is what I would have gone with:

[] Egyptian Spells
From Bill, you've learned the basics of the new wanded school of Egyptian magic. You learn a number of Egyptian hexes, jinxes and charms that are not present in the curriculum of Hogwarts or most European schools. While not better than their European variants, they often require different counter-spells or techniques than those your peers are familiar with.

Knowing a different school of magic would have been interesting.

[] Prophetic
Divination takes you whether you will it or not. You are expected to undergo one major vision a year and have the potential for smaller visions. You gain Divination III. Your Affinity influences the visions that you receive through your divinity. Some other minor skills—including Astronomy and Ancient Runes—benefit from your innate mastery of divination.

Divination could be handy in certain situations.

[] Opposed Wand
You and your wand do not get along. Advances in wand relationship take longer and regressions take place more easily. Your wand is more likely to switch ownership to another individual if you are defeated in a duel or other challenge.

Again this could have been interesting and/or fun.

[] Quibbles
You bought in fully to Luna Lovegood and her family's peculiar view of the world. You truly believe in a variety of different magical creatures whose existence cannot or will not be confirmed. You are, at a minimum, viewed as odd; many would go as far as to call you insane. Your relationship with Percy and The Twins is significantly reduced

Luna is cool, no doubt about it.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

As for the current vote this is what I want:

[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) The ambition to prove that your family deserves to stand as tall as any other and that you personally can overcome whatever challenges put before you. Getting the chance to outshine those who have always looked down upon you in their own house doesn't hurt. Ravenclaw would be more comfortable -- it's an obvious fit for your proclivities-- but Slytherin would push you to be the best you can by simple necessity.

@Corvus Black, has even better reasoning, plus there is always the chance that cousin Mafalda will end up in Slytherin and she sounds like fun.
 
Last edited:
[X] (House) Ravenclaw
[X] (Motivation) A large part of it is that you want to learn as much as you can and you want to be around people who feel similarly (for once) and a tiiiiny part of it is that, well, you want to see the look on your brothers' faces when they see a Weasley get sorted outside Gryffindor.
-[X] For Luna too

Ravenclaw seems appropriate for this Ginny and Luna is a good character to keep around.
 
'Not Gryffindor... Not Gryffindor... Not Gryffindor...'

I'm also compelled to point out that regular British School Houses usually sort their students randomly (though siblings are usually grouped together, like we also see in HP), rather than Hogwarts' profiling
 
[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) The ambition to prove that your family deserves to stand as tall as any other and that you personally can overcome whatever challenges put before you. Getting the chance to outshine those who have always looked down upon you in their own house doesn't hurt. Ravenclaw would be more comfortable -- it's an obvious fit for your proclivities-- but Slytherin would push you to be the best you can by simple necessity.
 
[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) Those boys you've been crushing on? Pretty and powerful? That's your goal too. They're above it all, so much better than everybody else in a way you've not quite quantified yet. It's something you're working towards, though. You don't want to be just another Weasley, you want to stand out from the crowd and make a real impact. You're not abandoning your family, but what better way to protect them than within the pit of snakes itself? If you prove yourself enough then even within Slytherin they wouldn't dare to insult your family. And it's not like it's forever, anyway. You'd daresay you're more worldly than your peers, and to say that you want to travel is an understatement. There are things out there that you might come across that ordinary magic alone would be insufficient to deal with, and you doubt the other Houses can teach you the less reputable arts.
 
So, anyone want to start a discussion on why the chose what they did? I chose my motivation since while I like the idea of heading to Slytherin, I didn't want a Ginny that was gung-ho about dark magic or going full Slytherin from the very beginning.

Sort of like an inversion of Harry's sorting, where she's pretty certain that she'll end up in Gryffindor. Except that when the Hat talks to her about going to Slytherin, it confirms to her that, yes, that little voice in the back of her mind was right. Slytherin will help her not be "just another Weasley," and that's enough to tip her over onto the start of her path.
 
Last edited:
[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) The ambition to prove that your family deserves to stand as tall as any other and that you personally can overcome whatever challenges put before you. Getting the chance to outshine those who have always looked down upon you in their own house doesn't hurt. Ravenclaw would be more comfortable -- it's an obvious fit for your proclivities-- but Slytherin would push you to be the best you can by simple necessity.

I'd rather Ginny have some actual ambition rather than her reasoning being, "Meh, Luna or hot boys."
 
[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) The ambition to prove that your family deserves to stand as tall as any other and that you personally can overcome whatever challenges put before you. Getting the chance to outshine those who have always looked down upon you in their own house doesn't hurt. Ravenclaw would be more comfortable -- it's an obvious fit for your proclivities-- but Slytherin would push you to be the best you can by simple necessity.

I'd rather Ginny have some actual ambition rather than her reasoning being, "Meh, Luna or hot boys."
While I totally respect the ambition you voted for, I would say that "hot boys" is a misrepresentation of the one I believe you are referring to. And even then, for an eleven year old girl with the "crushing" trait that wouldn't be out of the question when choosing her environment in the magical boarding school. Note that it says
That's your goal too. They're above it all, so much better than everybody else in a way you've not quite quantified yet.
so she is channeling her somewhat sappy and irrational characteristics into a way of self improvement, which is admirable. Also note how some of the other traits that were previously voted on are built into the motivation. And lastly, the thing I personally most admired by that vote, is the pure audacity and naivety in asserting that she will need "less reputable" magic to make her dreams come true - which doesn't really make her some edgy "Dark Magic is actually totally cool" cliché but an eleven year old that thinks that she knows best.
 
Last edited:

grip not grp

You wonder how he paid for his own subscription; Mum had canceled hers last year when that awful op-ed about Dumbledore's 'willing neglect of safety in our schools' got traction.

I'm kinda of glad somebody is concerned about safety at Hogwarts.

The program, put in place by Barty Crouch Sr.
Of course, the Ministry lets him do it because it distracts from the mysterious case of Mr. Crouch,"

I'm guessing that Barty Crouch Sr. got the job he desired (Minster of Magic) but then something mysterious happened to him. If that is true that seems a good AU element.

(all but Lockhart's collection

It seems Lockhart is still DADA teacher this year. Are we getting Incompetent fraud Lockhart, Competent fraud Lockhart (I.E. Applied Cultural Anthropology!Lockhart) or a Lockhart who actually did the things he said he did?

I'd heard stories about the Dursleys but I never imagined they were true.

How come Bill has heard stories about the Dursleys?
 
Last edited:
i hope crouch is still in charge. he is 100 times more competent than Fudge ever was
 
Crouch should still have a son here, and Bellatrix's wand was up for grabs, which means that she was still caught and sent to Azkaban. In canon, Crouch's son was with her and arrested at the same time, which when it came to light caused Crouch to be disgraced in the Ministry. He still seems to be well-regarded here though.
 
i thought bellatrix was alreaddy cought and it was krakaroff who revealed Barty crouch jr also tortured the longbottoms. might be wrong tho i never read the books even though i have book one
 
[X] (House) Slytherin
[X] (Motivation) The ambition to prove that your family deserves to stand as tall as any other and that you personally can overcome whatever challenges put before you. Getting the chance to outshine those who have always looked down upon you in their own house doesn't hurt. Ravenclaw would be more comfortable -- it's an obvious fit for your proclivities-- but Slytherin would push you to be the best you can by simple necessity.
 
[X] (House) Ravenclaw
[X] (Motivation) A large part of it is that you want to learn as much as you can and you want to be around people who feel similarly (for once) and a tiiiiny part of it is that, well, you want to see the look on your brothers' faces when they see a Weasley get sorted outside Gryffindor.
-[X] For Luna too
 
[X] (House) Ravenclaw
[X] (Motivation) A large part of it is that you want to learn as much as you can and you want to be around people who feel similarly (for once) and a tiiiiny part of it is that, well, you want to see the look on your brothers' faces when they see a Weasley get sorted outside Gryffindor.
-[X] For Luna too
 
I thought Bellatrix was already caught and it was Karkaroff who revealed Barty crouch jr also tortured the longbottoms. might be wrong tho I never read the books even though I have book one

That's movie canon not book canon. In books, Karkaroff did offer up many of his fellow death eaters to get released from Azkaban, including Augustus Rookwood. However Barty Crouch Jr. was already in jail as he had been caught alongside Bellatrix, Rodolphus, and Rabastan Lestrange.
 
Last edited:
[X] (House) Ravenclaw
[X] (Motivation) Due to certain traits such as an Eidetic memory and being a bookworm Ravenclaw would be rather fitting as well as the presence of Luna. Though at the same time Gryffindor is where many previous Weasley's have ended up in. Plus there's a chance members of the house could know of a variety of items that others might not due to such factors like being eccentric or what could otherwise be rather unusual interests that could be of potential interest. The possible competitiveness of some house mates could also have the potential to drive yourself to further progress. Whether it be through a form of competition or working together who knows what could be learned and gained. Some members of the house could even potentially be able to help both your own wanderlust and know more about the world. Perhaps there's even some who know other lores as well? Those who are eccentric could help your imagination and perhaps even assist in developing your own techniques.
-[X] A tiiiiny part of it is that, well, you want to see the look on your brothers' faces when they see a Weasley get sorted outside Gryffindor. Plus just being any any of the other houses besides Gryffindor could make you stand out due to the difference.


Right, wanted to have much more but was having trouble so basicly ended up forcing to write some more. Mostly looked at Ravenclaw wiki page some. Perhaps more could be added but I don't know.
 
[x] (House) Slytherin
[x] (Motivation) Those boys you've been crushing on? Pretty and powerful? That's your goal too. They're above it all, so much better than everybody else in a way you've not quite quantified yet. It's something you're working towards, though. You don't want to be just another Weasley, you want to stand out from the crowd and make a real impact. You're not abandoning your family, but what better way to protect them than within the pit of snakes itself? If you prove yourself enough then even within Slytherin they wouldn't dare to insult your family. And it's not like it's forever, anyway. You'd daresay you're more worldly than your peers, and to say that you want to travel is an understatement. There are things out there that you might come across that ordinary magic alone would be insufficient to deal with, and you doubt the other Houses can teach you the less reputable arts.
 
So, anyone want to start a discussion on why the chose what they did? I chose my motivation sice while I like the idea of heading to Slytherin, I didn't want a Ginny that was gung-ho about dark magic or going full Slytherin from the very beginning.

Sort of like an inversion of Harry's sorting, where she's pretty certain that she'll end up in Gryffindor. Except that when the Hat talks to her about going to Slytherin, it confirms to her that, yes, that little voice in the back of her mind was right. Slytherin will help her not be "just another Weasley," and that's enough to tip her over onto the start of her path.
Personally, I want her to be more willing to use questionable magic from the start, I don't want to wrestle with her upbringing arguing that dark magic is bad, I want to play a budding dark lady, and installing some Slytherin values like ambition, cunning and the importance of power seem like good things to do.

Likewise, blurring her morals will make things convenient later on, if we become good enough to kidnap death eaters from their home and killing them before Voldemort returns, I would tell Ginny to go for it, I want her to be pragmatic in her methods, because damm, Harry using disarming charm all the time was face palming worthy.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top