Not sure if I like this but:
After glancing one last time at the mirror and verifying that yes, Celia was gone, Buffy made her way to the living room where Samantha was waiting. Today the brunette had her hair in a ponytail, causing it to frame her face in a way that almost looked elfin. She had a pair of jean shorts on that were only just loose enough to be interesting and a blue blouse that did similar things to her curves. Buffy had to remind herself that the last person she sl- Oh wait, that was in her imagination. Still, she was pretty sure that she was straight. Not that there would be anything wrong with her if she wasn't. Sam wasn't and that was awesome. Great. Wonderful even. Goddess, even her denials in her head sounded a bit much.
Glancing over her friend, Buffy shook her head. Sam certainly pulled off her outfit today, but the girl was her friend. She in no way was going to let it affect her. So she drew a bit on her inner Cordelia, which made sense, since the girl was a figment of her imagination anyway.
"Sammy, how'd you manage to get that outfit past my parents?" Buffy asked with a small smirk on her face. Look at the kine. All painted up pretty for the slaughter. The best wool is sheared from then.
Buffy's smirk started to fade a bit as Samantha replied. "It's all in the stance, Buffy. Are you ready to go?"
"You know it." Buffy refused to let the creepy voice dictate her feelings. Sammy was going to be fine today, and she would make sure of that. Even if it meant a return to the mental hospital, she would not let anything happen to her friend.
"Then let's get out of here." Sammy grabbed her by the arm and led her through the front door, pausing only to let Buffy say goodbye to her parents at the door.
Once outside, Buffy noticed something, more specifically she noticed the lack of something that she had expected to be there. "No car today, Sammy?"
"Well, we can't exactly have a nice walk together if we're driving to our destination, now can we?" Samantha smiled at Buffy. "Besides… the car's in the shop."
Buffy snorted and they continued walking. "What happened? It seemed fine when we went to the mall."
"Oh, the check engine light came on after class on Tuesday, and I brought it in. Turned out to be something with the timing belt or something. I don't know, I'm not that good with cars other than driving them." Samantha shrugged as they passed some playing children on the sidewalk.
"Better than me, for certain. So, where are we headed?" Buffy had to ask as the neighborhood clearly had changed a lot while she was… away. Years gone in a near-blink of an eye, and she was elsewhere. The world and we are immutable, the kine upon it are not. She was pretty sure that she wasn't included in that "we" in the creepy voice. Otherwise she'd… do something…. How do you kick the ass of a disembodied voice? It doesn't have an ass to kick.
"Oh, I figured we could have lunch at Sergio's and then take a ride on the bus down to Santa Monica so we could enjoy some time on the beach. Get some sun, sand, and enjoy the view."
"Sounds great." Buffy paused. The only Sergio's she knew of in the direction the pair were walking was… Hell. They were going to walk right past Hemery. This was going to suck. On the positive side? Daylight. If the gym wasn't full of vampires, she wouldn't need to burn it down. Not that she would need to burn it down. Not that she admitted to burning it down in the first place. Her expulsion was totally unjustified. Mice with cigarettes could easily have been the culprit. Or a burning cross clutched by a crazed master vampire, either-or.
Samantha seemed to sense Buffy's unease and offered a reassuring smile. "Don't worry. We're just going to be walking by the campus. It's not like anyone we knew will even be there, and you have to see the renovations they did to the gym from outside."
Buffy nodded. She supposed her friend could be right. Of course, that did nothing to alleviate the combination of nervousness and guilt that set in when she saw the school zone sign, indicating that they were within range. She could see the chain link fence around the area. Being that it was a school day, there were several cars in the parking lot, and she knew that there would be more in others.
Hemery was more or less like any other high school of the area. It was made up of a few buildings connected by covered hallways, and it reflected architecture that dated back to the mid-fifties. The main building had stone steps leading up to the first floor, and Buffy remembered that was where she was told. Merrick found her there and told her about the vampires. It is what started her delusion. Was Merrick just a hallucination brought on by the delusion? Was he another man that was just delusional himself? There were a bunch of kids that went missing around that point in time who were never found as far as she knew.
She paused, staring at the steps. Remembering Merrick's death was hard. The man had killed himself rather than letting Lothos use him against her. Her first Watcher didn't want her to have to slay him so he took that choice away. No, not that choice… that possibility. A tear ran down her cheek for the departed man, be he hallucination or no.
"Hey, Buffy, are you okay?" Samantha placed her hand on the blonde's shoulder, real concern reflected on her face. "I wouldn't have had us walk by here if I knew that it'd be an issue…"
"No, I'm just remembering someone from the hallucinations that died…." Buffy said, waving it off. "He was… a good friend."
"And the stairs of our high school reminded you of him…. Wait, was this friend like that creepy guy who came up to you after school one day?" Wait, what? If Merrick was a hallucination, Sam wouldn't know about him.
"What?" Buffy asked ever so eloquently.
"Yeah, the guy… slightly balding, moustache… I remember now, he was wearing this ugly tweed suit… I think you walked off with him rather than… What, did he drug you or something? Did that cause your hallucinations and the… If he hurt you in any way…" Samantha's tone went to threatening.
"He didn't, Sammy… And he's dead. He died a few days before the gym incident. I'm okay, really. Let's go have our lunch." Buffy offered her arm to her friend again, and Samantha took it. The two continued on their way, Buffy barely pausing to give the gym a once-over. It looked brand new, which given that she'd burned it down six years ago was saying something.
The pair made idle chit-chat as they continued on their way past the school toward the restaurant, but Buffy's mind wasn't on the conversation. Merrick, the man who had told her she was the Slayer in the first place, was real. Independent confirmation placed him at the high school when she remembered him to be. She didn't hallucinate his presence. Maybe she had hallucinated the conversation, seen his death in another light. Just because Merrick was real didn't mean that vampires were, but this changed things. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
The creepy voice was now speaking in Latin. Lovely. What did all of this mean? If Merrick were truly a real person, if he had approached her at Hemery and she wasn't the Slayer, why had he come to her specifically? Merrick's approach of her only made sense if he were a Watcher and she a Slayer. But she'd displayed no Slayer abilities here. She didn't have the nagging desire to go out and hunt. She didn't even remember her dreams, for crying out loud. Nothing beyond a vague sinking feeling. Sunnydale was a hallucination. She had been delusional thinking that she was the Slayer, hadn't she?