[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
But as you just said, Coil can't be trusted to do anything but what is best for Coil. Since he's the one pulling the levers on his power...
We need to create sufficient incentives for honesty and sufficient disincentives for dishonesty or remove such things as free will entirely from the conversation.

Which is why I say Negotiate force him to the table like any other normal bitch who wants to come in from the cold.
 
This is a very smart bargain on Coil's part. Honestly, while it's possible something can fuck with his precog (even if he doesn't know it to be such), we've never seen anything yet that stops it. It's still a very good asset.

That said? Coil's still a dick. If he weren't asking for us to tacitly approve his domination of the city and was otherwise offering to turn sides, abandon his enterprises, turn a new leaf, maybe.

This? Nope. Now let's just hope he doesn't unleash Noelle yet.

[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
This is a very smart bargain on Coil's part. Honestly, while it's possible something can fuck with his precog (even if he doesn't know it to be such), we've never seen anything yet that stops it. It's still a very good asset.

That said? Coil's still a dick. If he weren't asking for us to tacitly approve his domination of the city and was otherwise offering to turn sides, abandon his enterprises, turn a new leaf, maybe.

This? Nope. Now let's just hope he doesn't unleash Noelle yet.

[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
So he's not offering why don't we offer,cajole, make. Put that Charisma to work. We can litearlly print money with omni metal. He can certainly sell a pardon.
 
I don't think we're and eclipse caste nor that we have super oathbinding powers.

And we're a hero so Counter press? How about you open up your soul and seek redemption and a a pardon and ten percent of my bounties to legit aims for each major consultation? Or Cauldron interrupt.


Imprisoning him serves Justice! Retributive justice. Reinforces rule of law and all day. Also kind doesn't help anyone he's hurt of could help save the people who got jollies. Sparking heroism in his soul or otherwise forcing a situation where he helps actively will ultimately help more people. World's dying all hands on deck. Just unwilling to budge on actively making people's lives suck when we can just make his suck less.


And while Fate binding will go screwy unless it makes go time, the real time, all the time or pops the vision , we should still have save if he follows through and doesn't get compromised by Simmie from LEO.


Just maintaing his operation is a no go.

Also wish we had magic girl or techno.

Noelle is likely listening. Need to deal with her and we suck hard core really really hard core so insanely hardcore at healing.

I have to ask, what cipher are you using?
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this,where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

Wow, Coil sure loves to buy into his own hype doesn't he?
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

We are a Hero, capital H. While some villains can be redeemed coil is not one of those,
Villains don't get a free pass just because they could be useful.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[x] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.


This is obviously him trying to get the travellers to attack us, so we should use luck manipulation and cheat outrageously.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

I'm not bothered so much about making things conform to the legal system as that we're giving Coil carte blanche as long as he mostly confines his misdeeds to Brockton Bay. The hope of saving people later is not worth letting him hurt people now.
 
Last edited:
changed to

[X] A counter-offer: He'll join the heroes. Abandon Coil's assets (donate them to charity) save a small sum for himself to live comfortably, rebrand himself, and join the heroes starting from a clean sheet. Redemption is (almost) never impossible, and if he's willing, he could do it. Otherwise, jail.
 
Last edited:
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

Yeah, fuck Coil.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
We haven't used any abilities that mess with precogs here, I don't think.

If we say no, won't this timeline colapse? It's unlike Coil to have come to this meeting without a pre-established split. Maybe even one as far back as shortly after Avatar offer Levi.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

Meh, Coil Overstimates himself. His power isn't as powerful as he thinks.

I can imagine it. Everytime there is an S Class battle, and casualties are great, Avatar receives a phone call from Coil, and Coil says only seven words each time.
"Do you feel like a hero yet?"

No phones in the birdcage, sorry
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[x] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

We have to stay true to our character. We are an uncompromising hero, we are the definition of heroic. If we allow evil to flourish due to our inaction, we don't deserve the name.
 
One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule.
Not really. Coil did a lot to improve the city, whether the regular Worm reader wants to admit or not. Additionally, his goal is to remove supervillains from the city and keep it as tightly ordered as possible. He wants to be in control, not to make the world burn around him.

He's definitely an evil sadistic bastard, but he's a neat one. he knows not to creates unecesary suffering. He keeps his torture fetish to discarded timeline, for example, and those are simple phantasms.

On the other hand, there is no way the Avatar would compromise himself like this. Supervillains don't get to do their dirty deeds unchecked because they are useful. Not if the Avatar has anything to say about it.



So if he wants to repent? Getting him a pardon for his past crimes as well as a very cushy job would be on the table. There's room to negotiate with a highly pragmatic individual like Coil. There's simply no way the Avatar could allow to compromise himself by selling out BB to a sadistic supervillain overlord.


Meh, Coil Overstimates himself. His power isn't as powerful as he thinks.
It really is. It doesn't have any of the known weaknesses of Precog (it handles blindspots like Scion and Endbringers just fine, isn't bothered by other precogs, none of it). There's really nothing whatsoever that suggest that it doesn't work as advertised.

And what he told The Avatar is more than perfectly possible. It's just the tip of the iceberg. There's much more that can be done with this power.

The problem isn't there. It's that to save Worm you can't start making deals you're going to regret. You can't compromise your core values. The Avatar can't make a precedent of letting villains buying his Official Seal of Approval for their operations. We should probably negotiate with Coil given how amazingly useful he is, but not at the cost of letting him run unchecked.
 
Last edited:
Not really. Coil did a lot to improve the city, whether the regular Worm reader wants to admit or not. Additionally, his goal is to remove supervillains from the city and keep it as tightly ordered as possible. He wants to be in control, not to make the world burn around him.

He's definitely an evil sadistic bastard, but he's a neat one. he knows not to creates unecesary suffering. He keeps his torture fetish to discarded timeline, for example, and those are simple phantasms.

On the other hand, there is no way the Avatar would compromise himself like this. Supervillains don't get to do their dirty deeds unchecked because they are useful. Not if the Avatar has anything to say about it.



So if he wants to repent? Getting him a pardon for his past crimes as well as a very cushy job would be on the table. There's room to negotiate with a highly pragmatic individual like Coil. There's simply no way the Avatar could allow to compromise himself by selling out BB to a sadistic supervillain overlord.



It really is. It doesn't have any of the known weaknesses of Precog (it handles blindspots like Scion and Endbringers just fine, isn't bothered by other precogs, none of it). There's really nothing whatsoever that suggest that it doesn't work as advertised.

And what he told The Avatar is more than perfectly possible. It's just the tip of the iceberg. There's much more that can be done with this power.

The problem isn't there. It's that to save Worm you can't start making deals you're going to regret. You can't compromise your core values. The Avatar can't make a precedent of letting villains buying his Official Seal of Approval for their operations. We should probably negotiate with Coil given how amazingly useful he is, but not at the cost of letting him run unchecked.

If someone like him is gonna get "redemption" then he needs someone to observe him 24/7 while making use of his knowledge and abilities.

Question, how often or how casually do Villains take to killing non-capes?
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.
 
[X] One little girl is safe, but the city has thousands of people who will suffer if fiends like Coil rule. If you make a compromise like this, where does it end? Can monsters escape justice for their crimes, simply by having enough power, or being useful? No. That is not the world you're fighting for. You're fighting for a world where people like Coil can't prey on the powerless.

Why were we given a choice again? This is like asking me if whether I would like to spare Sauron because he will give me a cheatsheet and some cookies.

HE'S MOTHERFUCKING SAURON!
 
Back
Top