The difference is that I don't believe that the odds are actually that stacked against us?
You're also assuming that everything remands static forever, that it can never get better (It can, it was confirmed we can later upgrade it to trigger more often, even if we can't remove the chance of a backfire without getting the Patent Police on our ass), and that we can't ever mitigate it. That it can only hurt us, instead of help us.
(And again, I've literally asked "Hey does it activate at all if we miss a clash, or is it a perpetual threat of hurting us but can fail to help us" before I got sucked into this argument, and he hasn't even had a chance to get back to the computer to read it yet).
Because as something that we can turn on in a boss fight after we've juiced ourselves up, it's already viable. With some upgrades, we'd even be able to risk it for regular encounters. That's not bad.
Anyway, sorry for accusing you of being a Heartvoter, you're just arguing so strenuously against this that I sort of associated you as one.