What caused their food crisis, I'm not seeing a reason. I think their primary resource is fish?
And how do we know the mountain clans who are asking for farming have lowland holdings? I don't know where you got that info.
Fish didn't really even enter into it.
@veekie was mostly right. The Mountain Clan's problems were caused by a sudden surge of overpopulation that was rendered unsustainable due to previous bad weather. Remember all the way back in Kaspar's time when you were at war with South Lake? The Mountain Clans were vacuuming up refugees left, right, and center. This allowed them to clear more and more ground, putting more of their land under cultivation or hunting. This was actually the exact
wrong thing to do, though. The soil in the mountains is extremely thin; their aggressive horticulture and gathering damaged the soil further. They stripped off some of the tree cover around them, causing the soil to either dry out or get washed away during rain. The rain was especially killer, anything more than a minor rainfall will turn all of the paths the Mountain Clans have built into rivers. The tops of their mountains are bare rock and the degree of forestation on their mountains actually decreased. Centuries of slow climbing vegetation was undone.
This sudden crash in food supplies triggered a crisis where the Mountain Clans suddenly didn't have enough food. That triggered a round of internal violence before it spilled out across their neighbours. They started stealing food and turning into raiders, trying desperately not to starve. They managed to take some land at first, but they earned the hate of pretty much all of their neighbours (Arrow Lake, Island Makers, Bond Breakers). They weren't able to maintain their gains and shrunk as a result, sliding back into starvation.
@Redium Regarding the "figurehead" leader from Hill Guard, who is he a figurehead for and how do they control him? Also, regardless of how uncharismatic or dull he is, doesn't he still have a huge amount of power, at least when it comes to intercity decisions that affect the whole tribe? I mean within his own town people know that they can walk over him as long as a local faction backs them, but during official Triumvirate meetings he is literally the tie breaker between Aeva and Priit, who hate each other's guts. Can't be a small thing that, right?
The figurehead is a result of your Formalized Big Man Leadership technology. You recognize that someone needs to be in charge and they're promoted by acclaim. The current leader is very much the least bad choice at the moment; no one really wants him to be in charge, but he's least objectionable to everyone else. He also doesn't
do anything as a Big Man. If he tried to exert himself, his 'subordinates' would flip the table and escalate the current low-level conflict, almost certainly murdering him.
Normally, what would happen if a single Big Man couldn't get enough acclaim to be declared in charge of the entire group would be that a state of anarchy would develop. Interregnums are fine and normal under Big Man leadership. The issue is that you're slowly transitioning away from the Big Man system. You still have the need to have an acclaimed leader, but also recognize the the tribe is unwieldy enough that it's impossible to go without leaders.
The council functions on consensus for the most part. If everyone is not on the same page, things can get very rough, very quickly. Unless you have a Hero, it would be impossible for one Big Man to interfere and meaningfully unseat another. The distance would simply be too great and their connections would be generally weak.
@Redium Speaking of, how much does having our Admin/Art hero ruling Crystal Lake and our Martial hero ruling The Fingers differentiate the two in the long term? And does Hill Guard suffer in comparison for not having had a heroic Big Man ever since Kaspar gave it autonomy? I assume the game mechanics aren't as granular to calculate where which infrastructure gets expanded more other that actual construction projects or what kind of behavior is more encouraged in one part of our nation versus another, but maybe you still have something in mind.
For instance, are there any stereotypes the rest of the People see in their brethren of Hill Guard/Crystal Lake/Fingers? Are there any differences in believes and worldview, what with each city housing a different holy order as well as a different larger than life Big Man?
Edit: Huh. The Frost-Scarred don't have a personal shrine listed anywhere. Where do they meet and how are they organized in light of that? Also, how is the ancient shrine of Crystal Lake used nowadays (beyond simply being another shrine with a great view on the titular lake)?
Second Edit: I'm even more confused/curious regarding the Fangs now. Their description says they are based out of Crystal Lake, they have an actual Temple in Hill Guard and, if I understood the narrative correctly, Priit is a member of the Fangs, making them more aligned with him (ruler of the Ember-Eye home town) than with Aeva (ruler of the first (current?) home town of the Fangs).
So... How they be doing things these days?
Whatever differences have been created between Crystal Lake and the Fingers have from being ruled by Heroes will be smoothed over in time. Remember, Kaspar was born 120 years ago and he's barely remembered as an actual person. Only Aeva and the oldest elders have ever met him. Everyone else is subsisting on tall tales told about his life and leadership. Within another turn or two, Kaspar will only be a legend. Ten turns later and he will never have been a man at all.
Hill Guard isn't really suffering so much as it's not in prominence. The more you interact with Rahu Bay and the Peace Builders, the more important that it will become. Is it as important as the Fingers at this moment? No, but it will be easily that influential in the future. Crystal Lake will always be special as the People's first home and Natural Wonder.
The People aren't really large enough for stereotypes to be a big deal yet. They're still small enough that one person can go to a friend and ask: "Do you know a guy ______?" and their friend would say yes. At the furthest, there's no more than three degrees of separation between any individual. Despite all of the territory you control, you are a very small town.
Something
interesting is going to happen soon with the Holy Orders; reform is needed. That's all I will say about your edits.