Welcome to Brighton (Mafia game)

What's with this sentiment?

[X] Null
[X] TPK
Look at Shadow Shinobi's post. Just look at it.

Are you allowed to do that in this way? Weird. If we have an investigator, I recommend TPK.
Of course I'm allowed to. I can say 'I don't even know what to think about how to lynch any more, so I'm taking a step back and will re-examine the situation tomorrow'

And give me a break. There are over ten people in this game with less evidence that they're Town than I am, primarily among them you.

You know what?

[x] Lynch atk50

There. That's my suspicion of you for your continual shifty behavior in the form of a vote.
 
Ugh... we have a bit less than 5 hours left in day and I now have reason for very strong suspicions on a player... but I brought the reasoning to our great DM because its something they really need to adjudicate on.

I don't know the morals for this situation...

But,
[X] Null Shadow Shinobi
Is no longer the person I want lynched for both their claim and the new information I just got.
 
What's with this sentiment?

[X] Null
[X] TPK

Size, color, formatting.

Are you allowed to do that in this way? Weird. If we have an investigator, I recommend TPK.

He is, in fact, very much allowed to say 'fuck this day' in a day with less than 12 hours left (at time of his posting). People can give up on the last 12 hours of a day without saying anything, even.

Ugh... we have a bit less than 5 hours left in day and I now have reason for very strong suspicions on a player... but I brought the reasoning to our great DM because its something they really need to adjudicate on.

I don't know the morals for this situation...

But,
[X] Null Shadow Shinobi
Is no longer the person I want lynched for both their claim and the new information I just got.

6 hours, 7 minutes as of right now.
 
Most likely, the reveals are pissing him off and muddy the water significantly. Frankly, I kind of agree with him that its kind of annoying and ridiculous, though I'm still voting for somebody who I find fairly suspicious.

I have addressed your concerns, have I not? If you still have concerns, what are they? And why not give me a chance to prove it with a night kill? I have declared my target.
 
I have addressed your concerns, have I not? If you still have concerns, what are they? And why not give me a chance to prove it with a night kill? I have declared my target.

The amount of claimed vanillas doesn't match with your proposed setup. Even with the idea that one or more of them is lying (almost certainly), there are enough claimed vanilla players that having a small town like you are claiming doesn't make sense. The numbers are significantly stacked against one group without town having an abundance of power roles to balance the game out.

Pick it out of the claimed vanilla players since at least one of them is likely to be lying.
 
I am simply not at liberty to reveal that information. However I get to keep my suspicions at least.
Before anyone jumps on ComiTurtle over this, he went to me and I warned him I would modkill him were he to submit as evidence the information he PMed me and asked about.

So he is indeed not able to provide it.

... and if someone suggests he reveal it and he does I'm modkilling both of you, to be clear.
 
The amount of claimed vanillas doesn't match with your proposed setup. Even with the idea that one or more of them is lying (almost certainly), there are enough claimed vanilla players that having a small town like you are claiming doesn't make sense. The numbers are significantly stacked against one group without town having an abundance of power roles to balance the game out.



See The Game of Mafia Rules for example: 5 vanilla town + 1 detective + 2 mafia is considered balanced. (Granted, there's no roleblocker there - but there's no doctor either.) I can find as many other writeups as you want, but a lot of people believe that having a bunch of vanilla town is in fact balanced. (And I was just guessing 7/3; I said 8/2 was possible as well.)

Will you now please drop that claim, or do you wish me to find more evidence that people in general consider many-vanilla-town to be balanced?

Or are you trying to claim that the non-town and non-cult factions are biased against town? That's not what I'm claiming; the town/cult balance appears to be (or at least, the GM could plausibly have believed it to be) entirely independent of how many neutrals there are.

Pick it out of the claimed vanilla players since at least one of them is likely to be lying.

That's TPK (Village Fisherman) and Megaolix (Village Blacksmith), right? Also, I missed: Rikimaru said I should target Megaolix or Atk50.

So...Megaolix it is, assuming Megaolix is not lynched.
 
Ah, crap, did not mean to psot that.

That's TPK (Village Fisherman) and Megaolix (Village Blacksmith), right? Also, I missed: Rikimaru said I should target Megaolix or Atk50.

So...Megaolix it is, assuming Megaolix is not lynched.
Also, screw you. You just listen to Rikimaru, never mind that I'm town vanilla?

And you not minding at all is supposed to make me believe you really side with town?
 
I have returned my computer broke and I am currently borrowing my friends phone but I have decided to role claim.

I am the village hunter a member of the village people and I watched tpk last night and he was visited by the phoenixian but neither of them mentioned anything about it so I assumed that the phoenixian was some sort of body guard but now I'm not sure....


That is actually a very lookout thing to do. Keeping quiet and trusting that a roleclaim with evidence will be enough.

So Phoenixian is either non killing town or powered nonkilling scum.

However shadow shinobi isnt fully cleared just yet. Her claim makes tpk look slightly more suspicious but also not really.

Traditionalist Wizard pair might have a different skill each - ones a dodger the others a killer - and tpk could have godfather style night immunity. Since he doesnt have Nanimanis alibi he could still be scum.
Ah, crap, did not mean to psot that.


Also, screw you. You just listen to Rikimaru, never mind that I'm town vanilla?

And you not minding at all is supposed to make me believe you really side with town?

Dont kill mega. I got convinced yesterday he cant be scum. If wingedcat is honest then mega is hunter. If winged is lying then megas rejection of the charade makes him town because town hates confusion and lies.


With shadow shinobi as lookout i am replacing their scum place with atk50 since at least one scum is probably talkative to try and lead town.

Also not much time to switch.

[X] LyNCH Atk50
 
Not to mention if atk50 is town then their vanilla claim means we havent lost a power role.

We have 3 power roles atm.

Oh yeah shadow shinobi watch me tonight
 
I have returned my computer broke and I am currently borrowing my friends phone but I have decided to role claim.

I am the village hunter a member of the village people and I watched tpk last night and he was visited by the phoenixian but neither of them mentioned anything about it so I assumed that the phoenixian was some sort of body guard but now I'm not sure....
This post. Physically hurts me.
 
Are you allowed to do that in this way? Weird. If we have an investigator, I recommend TPK.

Ask cakestepid what info phoenician found on tpk/ what he did.

We can then use the statement by cakestepid to parse the night phase. If cake says he didnt visit tpk then either shadow shinoi or cake are scum and there are at least a bumch of good thinkers in town even if we lost nani and tpk
 
Having gone and reread the entire thread, I've just found that I'm too tired for this right now and that nobody truly stands out to me. The one thing I noticed Pawn seemed to be sticking to the sidelines unusually often, but then so have I. Might just be me noticing it early and then confirmation bias hitting. Winged Cat seems reasonable as a lynch target, their claimed setup really feels like it's been doctored or is missing something, and even if it is true they're a loose cannon. Tired and would rather not put us one from hammer though, so not directly voting.
 
Ask cakestepid what info phoenician found on tpk/ what he did.

We can then use the statement by cakestepid to parse the night phase. If cake says he didnt visit tpk then either shadow shinoi or cake are scum and there are at least a bumch of good thinkers in town even if we lost nani and tpk
If you wanna ask someone something maybe @Cakestepid them so they can show up sooner.
 
Having gone and reread the entire thread, I've just found that I'm too tired for this right now and that nobody truly stands out to me. The one thing I noticed Pawn seemed to be sticking to the sidelines unusually often, but then so have I. Might just be me noticing it early and then confirmation bias hitting. Winged Cat seems reasonable as a lynch target, their claimed setup really feels like it's been doctored or is missing something, and even if it is true they're a loose cannon. Tired and would rather not put us one from hammer though, so not directly voting.
There are currently five votes on Winged Cat and hammer is eight.
 
Back
Top