Thank you for actually giving feedback.

I will put together a new plan this evening. ...so in like 13 hours. My commutes a bitch and I'm not doing all that work over the phone.
Looking forward to it. You might want to edit your the post with your plan to say "Will change later". Also, I respect your ability to handle feedback well.
 
[X] [Devils] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan building a fire department
 
[x][DEVILS] Retain the Devil Brigade as an expeditionary warfare unit forming the basis of the CFC's special operations forces contingent.
[X]Plan Foundations
[X]Plan Better Tools To Make Tools
 
Since Foundations is currently at third place, I think it's important to address the major flaw in it that makes me oppose the plan. Picking "A standing core" now. I think that approach is terrible.
If we look at our strategic situation, we are essentially in a modernization race, especially in military matters, with Victoria. A race we have a head start in, but also a race in which Victoria has an easier time moving forward by virtue of their foreign patron, Russia. With that viewpoint in mind, our AP must be carefully spend, and our current head-start must be maintained and expanded at all costs. A standing core moves us a good bit further by slowing us down for the rest of the seven-year-plan. While the military benefit is good and even necessary in the middle of the plan, it's a terrible pick at the start of it. Our current high numbers of free AP are the result of economic extortion of the Victorian governments, a state of affairs that is ending soon with the coming end of the Victorian Civil War. We must build our economy and state revenue now (increasing free AP) in order to start with the costly military options in the middle of the plan. Now is not the right time and sacrificing our advantage to combat a manageable and constant background problem is a bad idea.

Also, to the people who are voting "Retrain the Devil Brigade": The leading option is "[DEVILS] Retain the Devil Brigade as an expeditionary warfare unit forming the basis of the CFC's special operations forces contingent.". I would urge you to change your vote to that in order to not split our vote two ways.
 
The vote count in regards to the fate of the Devils is actually a horrible mess because some plans include them also and yet people voting for plans are still voting for the Devils separately. I think I've seen one instance of someone voting for a plan that keeps the Devils while themselves voting to have the Devils disbanded.
 
[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1
 
[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1
 
[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1

[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.
 
Went to bed, couldn't sleep, saw this question.

Honestly, while Expat Outreach is important Source Foreign Arms is essential. I want them both but I feel like Foreign Arms will take time- both to complete and to negotiate the details of our relationship with whoever our sponsor is via subvotes- and I feel like we need it more than Expat Outreach. I don't agree that Outreach will help Source Arms- it's an option designed to help our domestic industry more than anything else. If you switched the point I'd look for another plan.

But if you wanted to move the point from somewhere else to Expat Outreach I'd probably be okay with it- I'm just unsure where you could find a point to move.

That sounds totally fair, having thought about it, I agree that Expat Outreach probably won't help us source arms either.

What if for Plan Arms and Departments, Talks and Training v2 (Plan Arms and Departments, Talks and Councils?) We moved the AP from Retraining Campaigns to Establish Council Representation, with the intent of using Council Representation to assist with Expat Outreach and then Expat Outreach to assist with Retraining Campaigns?
 
[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1
 
[X] [Devils] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan Arms and Departments, Talks and Training
 
[x][DEVILS] Retain the Devil Brigade as an expeditionary warfare unit forming the basis of the CFC's special operations forces contingent.
[X] Plan Arms and Departments, Talks and Training
[X]Plan Foundations
 
[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.
[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1
 
[X] [Devils] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.

[X] Plan building a fire department
 
While much of your reasoning is solid - my other major objection is mobilizing the army, especially with the Devil Brigade retained posing a powerful deterrent already as explained by Poptart, but I can see why someone would prefer a mobilized army plan to a more development focused one - I can't support a plan which leaves out those two critical options.
The Devils would be less than a thousand people, not all of whom are frontline troops. Without an army backing them up, they cannot credibly provide armed security for all the Midwest. I was not attempting to imply that they could.
@PoptartProdigy
QUESTION
1)Do we, IC, know what happened to the contents of Fort Knox?
Whether from local talk or documented word on the Internet and reputable sources?

2)Did any of the gold we received in reparations bear US Mint markings?
  1. Anybody with a bag handy happened to it.
  2. Probably some, but not a notably cohesive mass. Victoria did not loot Knox in organized fashion. The gold just kinda diffused across the Country in the chaos of the Collapse. Some reached Victoria — more than their share, with how they value gold — while some did not.
Also, to the people who are voting "Retrain the Devil Brigade": The leading option is "[DEVILS] Retain the Devil Brigade as an expeditionary warfare unit forming the basis of the CFC's special operations forces contingent.". I would urge you to change your vote to that in order to not split our vote two ways.
I merge votes that are substantially similar but different in phrasing.
 
[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1

[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.
 
[X] Plan: Buli-Buli Fall '76 v1
-[X][DEVILS] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.
 
So regardless of the plan, here's what I want specifically.
[ ] Military Training Reform
[ ] Source Foreign Arms
[ ] To St. Louis, And Beyond
[ ] Victorian Intelligence
 
Last edited:
[X] [Devils] Break up the Devil Brigade to serve as a training cadre for both enlisted personnel and officer candidates.
[X] Plan Arms and Departments, Talks and Training
 
Back
Top