Bigger response later, but I did not jump on Nani and declare them immediately scum, even after they refused to -basically- do something as simple as reveal Town's IC name. I said that it made them more suspicious than anyone else is at this point, because it's D1 and we don't have anything else to work with beyond random guessing.
And if you look, the difference between making a kill based on fluff claims and declaring someone is suspicious because (in effect) they can't tell you Town's name is apparent. Scum might have been given Town's name, but we all know that TOWN knows Town's name for sure. Logically, the only people who can't reveal Town's name are Scum, if they were not told about Town in their role PMs.
Again, I am not basing my suspicion on fluff, but on the simple fact that Town MUST know Town's name. If Nani cannot give evidence that he knows that name, then he cannot logically be Town.
