- Location
- Israel
I really like Iron Man 3, and actually did like the Mandarin twist. Sure, it isn't comic accurate, but the message of the twist is was rather smart of the idea that the face of terror can actually be faked.
There Was An Idea: A Kevin Feige Quest
- Thread starter Charcolt
- Start date
- Superhero
- Location
- Europe
You say that, but I enjoyed IM 3. Definitely a lot more than IM 2.
- Location
- Israel
Charcolt, how long until the votes are closed?
[X] (IM) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
overmind
Ruler of the Swarm
[X] (IM) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
- Location
- USA
[X] (IM) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
- Location
- Europe
[X] (IM) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
I'm not qualified to say anything about the music, and if I'm honest it does feel a bit like we are treating Iron Man as the golden child, but ultimately there are two movies in phase 1 which have to be a hit. It's the first, which is Iron Man, and the last, which is the Avengers. Everything else must only be passable to good (though I of course prefer every last one to be fantastic), to get this off the ground.
In the end, we can always introduce new and more iconic character motifs down the line in future installments, especially once our budget expands.
[X] (TH) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
I'm not qualified to say anything about the music, and if I'm honest it does feel a bit like we are treating Iron Man as the golden child, but ultimately there are two movies in phase 1 which have to be a hit. It's the first, which is Iron Man, and the last, which is the Avengers. Everything else must only be passable to good (though I of course prefer every last one to be fantastic), to get this off the ground.
In the end, we can always introduce new and more iconic character motifs down the line in future installments, especially once our budget expands.
Charcolt
Comic Fan
A Shocker movie or short series (on an equivalent of Disney+) could be very fun!
It'll close in just under an hour or so when I've written up the Hulk casting call update!
It'll close in just under an hour or so when I've written up the Hulk casting call update!
avatar11792
Et Sic Incipit
- Location
- Planet Earth, North America
[X] (IM) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
My headache was stolen from me during my sleep, don't keep an eye out for it, I'm grateful its gone.
I really like the Shocker movie idea, we should do something like that. Marvel's villains always got the short end of the stick in the MCU, we should balance that out a small bit.
I have an idea, which I want to propose:
Why don't we have a Pixar-esque short film before every MCU film, after say Iron Man and Hulk? The franchise is established on (hopefully) good grounds, and we can use the shorts to tell small stories that flesh out the MCU more, or establish character beats. Think like "The Consultant" short they had on one of the DVD extras, only instead of being only a DVD extra its a Pixar short piece.
I really think this could become a great element of the MCU formula, if done right. It would also double as a way to introduce or cameo small characters, gauge audience reactions and reviewers too without risking too much investment on a full-length movie.
[X] (TH) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
My headache was stolen from me during my sleep, don't keep an eye out for it, I'm grateful its gone.
I really like the Shocker movie idea, we should do something like that. Marvel's villains always got the short end of the stick in the MCU, we should balance that out a small bit.
I have an idea, which I want to propose:
Why don't we have a Pixar-esque short film before every MCU film, after say Iron Man and Hulk? The franchise is established on (hopefully) good grounds, and we can use the shorts to tell small stories that flesh out the MCU more, or establish character beats. Think like "The Consultant" short they had on one of the DVD extras, only instead of being only a DVD extra its a Pixar short piece.
I really think this could become a great element of the MCU formula, if done right. It would also double as a way to introduce or cameo small characters, gauge audience reactions and reviewers too without risking too much investment on a full-length movie.
JaceAoT
The Architect
- Location
- The Netherlands
[X] (IM) We're already going a bit over budget with some of the special effects we need to pull these things off. The music isn't bad even it isn't necessarily memorable.
[X] (TH) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
[X] (TH) Your job is to make a perfect film and that's what you're going to do. Reach out to one of the big names and get this thing's soundtrack stuck in everybody's head.
4. Pre-Production: Casting Call (The Incredible Hulk)
Charcolt
Comic Fan
You were honestly a bit taken aback at how much interest there was in signing on to a Hulk movie. Obviously the character is pretty well known; Hulk has been around for almost fifty years now, and more of these Hollywood types than you'd expect consider Gwen Stacy to be their first heartbreak. Still, you don't win an Academy Award for your heart-wrenching depiction of Mr. Hyde's Jolly Green Giant cosplay. Apparently though folks have been passing around the script and liking what they see. A lot of big names were interested in Ang Lee's fiasco before getting their hands on the script, and hearing "this time it's good" has been enough to bring most of them back to the audition process.
You've even got Leslie fucking Nielsen interested in a cameo once he heard about the film's setting.
Casting Bruce Banner: The star of the show! Bruce Banner is one of the smartest men on the planet, transformed by an experiment gone wrong into a rampaging brute called the Hulk (who this actor will also be portraying via mocap). You're looking for someone who is believable as a genius but also capable of showing the immense repressed anger Bruce is holding back at all times.
Casting Rick Jones: A young man who becomes a friend and confidant to both Bruce and the Hulk throughout the course of the movie. In casting Rick you're looking for someone capable of showing genuine emotion as well as being comic relief in a movie which otherwise has a somewhat subtle humor playing second fiddle to the drama and action.
Casting Geoffrey Crawford: The catalyst who kicks off the plot and the true antagonist, Doctor Crawford is a scientist attempting to recreate the experiment which birthed the Hulk. Not so much a physical threat, Crawford should be able to play as intelligent and sinister, someone the audience will buy as an antagonist in a film featuring a giant hairy monster with big claws and sharp teeth.
Casting Paul Cartier: A kidnapped townie who was transformed by Crawford's experiments into the monstrous Wendigo (the physical threat to Hulk and the creature terrorizing the town). Cartier should be someone likable and who more or less appears what he is: just a normal guy who got caught up in something truly horrifying. Ideally a northerner.
Casting Marie Cartier: Paul Cartier's wife and the mother of their children. A somewhat small role where a less known actress could be a solid choice, Cartier should (like her husband) be a somewhat likable northerner (from either Canada or the upper Midwest) who simply got caught up in the affairs of superheroes and supervillains against her will.
Casting Samuel Sterns: A down on his luck loser who is taken by Doctor Crawford and transformed into the Leader (a villain we are setting up for a theoretical sequel who will be shown fully transformed at the end of the movie). You obviously want someone willing to sign on for said sequel (if it happens) and who has some serious range to establish him here and build him up for later.
Casting Betty Ross: Bruce Banner's true love and the daughter of General Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross, Betty has a somewhat small role (only appearing via phone call before the climax and the post credits scene) but nonetheless we want someone who could play a more involved part in a hypothetical sequel and create audience investment from a short and emotional conversation.
You've even got Leslie fucking Nielsen interested in a cameo once he heard about the film's setting.
Casting Bruce Banner: The star of the show! Bruce Banner is one of the smartest men on the planet, transformed by an experiment gone wrong into a rampaging brute called the Hulk (who this actor will also be portraying via mocap). You're looking for someone who is believable as a genius but also capable of showing the immense repressed anger Bruce is holding back at all times.
[] Edward Norton - Norton is obviously a very talented actor who has apparently been interested in portraying the Hulk for half a decade now. He's certainly help bring in viewers and critics alike, but he does have a reputation for being difficult to work with, particularly when it comes to demanding rewrites and edits that make the movie more to his liking. Is he worth the risk?
[] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
[] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
[] Hugh Dancy - Dancy is a somewhat lesser known name but he really impressed you in his audition with his ability to portray Banner's constantly suppressed rage. As far as your desire to cast lesser known actors who won't risk overshadowing the character they're playing, Dancy seems like a close to perfect Bruce Banner to bring into this project! He might be cheaper too.
[] David Duchovny - The last guy you're considering is best known as Agent Mulder from The X-Files. He's got something of a cult following for that but this wouldn't be his first foray onto the big screen. He's a smart guy used to the rigors of portraying a smart guy on screen and he's still young enough that he could portray the character for as long as you plan on using Bruce Banner.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
[] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
[] Hugh Dancy - Dancy is a somewhat lesser known name but he really impressed you in his audition with his ability to portray Banner's constantly suppressed rage. As far as your desire to cast lesser known actors who won't risk overshadowing the character they're playing, Dancy seems like a close to perfect Bruce Banner to bring into this project! He might be cheaper too.
[] David Duchovny - The last guy you're considering is best known as Agent Mulder from The X-Files. He's got something of a cult following for that but this wouldn't be his first foray onto the big screen. He's a smart guy used to the rigors of portraying a smart guy on screen and he's still young enough that he could portray the character for as long as you plan on using Bruce Banner.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Rick Jones: A young man who becomes a friend and confidant to both Bruce and the Hulk throughout the course of the movie. In casting Rick you're looking for someone capable of showing genuine emotion as well as being comic relief in a movie which otherwise has a somewhat subtle humor playing second fiddle to the drama and action.
[] Dave Franco - Brother to James Franco (Harry Osborn in Raimi's Spider-Man movies), the younger Franco hasn't quite had his breakthrough into film yet but is interested in the opportunity. He's untested and seems to bring an enthusiasm and energy to the role, but maybe someone more established would be safer?
[] Garrett Hedlund - A pretty new actor who got his start in Troy a few years ago, he's consistently gotten work since then (even if we don't talk about Eragon). The rest of his performances have been well received in the past and he's not doing anything big that would keep him from signing onto this!
[] Luke Mitchell - Another untested new guy who had a solid audition for the part, Mitchell is Australian and seems to regard Rick Jones as a character who could kick-start his career (which, given that it hasn't really started yet is pretty accurate). Are you willing to take a risk on casting this part, though?
[] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[] Ian Harding - Yet another largely untested young actor (you're noticing a pattern here), Harding has only really appeared in a short film called Groom With a View. He's decently good looking and could be a solid choice for Rick Jones if you're okay with giving him a chance to kick-start his career.
[] Tyler Hoechlin - One of the youngest and most experienced actors you're considering for Rick, Hoechlin is a likable and talented guy. The only real concern you have about him is that he might be too good looking to pass as the character. Honestly he looks like he ought to be portraying Superman.
[] Sam Claflin - The last of your untested stars has yet to appear in movie or television, but he impressed with his audition. Signing him on would, again, be something of a gamble, but he seems like he could pull of a character who has to be likable and charming but still show some inner depths.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Garrett Hedlund - A pretty new actor who got his start in Troy a few years ago, he's consistently gotten work since then (even if we don't talk about Eragon). The rest of his performances have been well received in the past and he's not doing anything big that would keep him from signing onto this!
[] Luke Mitchell - Another untested new guy who had a solid audition for the part, Mitchell is Australian and seems to regard Rick Jones as a character who could kick-start his career (which, given that it hasn't really started yet is pretty accurate). Are you willing to take a risk on casting this part, though?
[] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[] Ian Harding - Yet another largely untested young actor (you're noticing a pattern here), Harding has only really appeared in a short film called Groom With a View. He's decently good looking and could be a solid choice for Rick Jones if you're okay with giving him a chance to kick-start his career.
[] Tyler Hoechlin - One of the youngest and most experienced actors you're considering for Rick, Hoechlin is a likable and talented guy. The only real concern you have about him is that he might be too good looking to pass as the character. Honestly he looks like he ought to be portraying Superman.
[] Sam Claflin - The last of your untested stars has yet to appear in movie or television, but he impressed with his audition. Signing him on would, again, be something of a gamble, but he seems like he could pull of a character who has to be likable and charming but still show some inner depths.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Geoffrey Crawford: The catalyst who kicks off the plot and the true antagonist, Doctor Crawford is a scientist attempting to recreate the experiment which birthed the Hulk. Not so much a physical threat, Crawford should be able to play as intelligent and sinister, someone the audience will buy as an antagonist in a film featuring a giant hairy monster with big claws and sharp teeth.
[] Rhys Ifans - This Welsh actor is probably the one who bears the strongest resemblance to Crawford's comic book self. He's been consistently cast in movies for more than a decade and been nominated for his share of awards in that time. Honestly you're not exactly sure how he'd pop on screen but he seems decently talented.
[] Mark Ruffalo - Ruffalo is already being considered for Banner, but there's been some chatter that he might be a good fit for the film's antagonist as well (obviously he can't do both). He's got a likable way about him after all and he's someone you know could pull off a smart guy and an angry guy at the same time.
[] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kids which could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Mark Ruffalo - Ruffalo is already being considered for Banner, but there's been some chatter that he might be a good fit for the film's antagonist as well (obviously he can't do both). He's got a likable way about him after all and he's someone you know could pull off a smart guy and an angry guy at the same time.
[] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kids which could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Paul Cartier: A kidnapped townie who was transformed by Crawford's experiments into the monstrous Wendigo (the physical threat to Hulk and the creature terrorizing the town). Cartier should be someone likable and who more or less appears what he is: just a normal guy who got caught up in something truly horrifying. Ideally a northerner.
[] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[] Joshua Jackson - Another Canadian who can pull off the look you're going for if he grows a beard (though he's still a bit young for the part), Jackson has been consistently getting work since the early 1990s and a movie like this could be a big opportunity for him if he wants to transition more fully to movies.
[] Josh Duhamel - Duhamel is from North Dakota and sort of fits the look you're hoping to find in your Paul Cartier. He's only been starring in films for a few years now but he's done well for himself and was just this year one of the cast members on the Transformers movie. Given that that has a sequel on the way in 2009 maybe he's a bit overworked!
[] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Joshua Jackson - Another Canadian who can pull off the look you're going for if he grows a beard (though he's still a bit young for the part), Jackson has been consistently getting work since the early 1990s and a movie like this could be a big opportunity for him if he wants to transition more fully to movies.
[] Josh Duhamel - Duhamel is from North Dakota and sort of fits the look you're hoping to find in your Paul Cartier. He's only been starring in films for a few years now but he's done well for himself and was just this year one of the cast members on the Transformers movie. Given that that has a sequel on the way in 2009 maybe he's a bit overworked!
[] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Marie Cartier: Paul Cartier's wife and the mother of their children. A somewhat small role where a less known actress could be a solid choice, Cartier should (like her husband) be a somewhat likable northerner (from either Canada or the upper Midwest) who simply got caught up in the affairs of superheroes and supervillains against her will.
[] Sarah Polley - A native Canadian actress, Polley is one of the team's top picks for Marie Cartier. Despite her youth she's been appearing in pictures since the mid 1980s, and while she hasn't appeared in any comic movies the script and general appeal here seems to have won her over enough to audition for a part.
[] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Samuel Sterns: A down on his luck loser who is taken by Doctor Crawford and transformed into the Leader (a villain we are setting up for a theoretical sequel who will be shown fully transformed at the end of the movie). You obviously want someone willing to sign on for said sequel (if it happens) and who has some serious range to establish him here and build him up for later.
[] James McAvoy - A young actor, you've heard some very good things about McAvoy (and his performance in Atonement which will be coming out this year) from Hollywood insiders. He's not at all opposed to appearing within a comic book movie and seems like he could pull off both sides of the Leader - pre and post-transformation.
[] David Thewlis - A slightly older take on the character could come from David Thewlis, though the timing might be tight given that he's got a Harry Potter movie coming out this year and another one likely in 2009. You think he's got the potential to portray someone sinister if given the chance to be a big time villain.
[] Peter Stormare - An experienced guy who certainly fits the physicality of the pre-transformation Sterns, Stormare is the oldest of the actors you're considering for a part which doesn't have a set age attached to it (though you've been discussing keeping him closer to Banner). Maybe his take on the character could be a fun one though.
[] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
[] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] David Thewlis - A slightly older take on the character could come from David Thewlis, though the timing might be tight given that he's got a Harry Potter movie coming out this year and another one likely in 2009. You think he's got the potential to portray someone sinister if given the chance to be a big time villain.
[] Peter Stormare - An experienced guy who certainly fits the physicality of the pre-transformation Sterns, Stormare is the oldest of the actors you're considering for a part which doesn't have a set age attached to it (though you've been discussing keeping him closer to Banner). Maybe his take on the character could be a fun one though.
[] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
[] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
Casting Betty Ross: Bruce Banner's true love and the daughter of General Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross, Betty has a somewhat small role (only appearing via phone call before the climax and the post credits scene) but nonetheless we want someone who could play a more involved part in a hypothetical sequel and create audience investment from a short and emotional conversation.
[] Liv Tyler - Tyler is certainly a well known face given her portrayal of Arwen in the Lord of the Rings movies and her appreciation for the old television show has left her interested in the role of Betty Ross even if her appearance is mostly setup for a sequel where the love story could be explored more properly.
[] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[] Rose Byrne - Since her small role in Attack of the Clones in 2002 (oy), Byrne has been doing quite well for herself. Like the others listed here she's willing and eager to appear within a comic book movie and understands that her character is mostly being set up as a main character in a theoretical but likely sequel.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
[] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[] Rose Byrne - Since her small role in Attack of the Clones in 2002 (oy), Byrne has been doing quite well for herself. Like the others listed here she's willing and eager to appear within a comic book movie and understands that her character is mostly being set up as a main character in a theoretical but likely sequel.
[] I'm thinking of someone else (write-in).
- Location
- Israel
Fuck! This is too hard! I need to think here about these choices...
- Location
- USA
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
Don't think he needs to be changed. And he should be here for the long haul which is good.
He'll be in it for the long haul. As much I as I like Joaquin Pheonix, he isnt going to be a long term Hulk so he is a bad option imo.
[X] Sam Claflin - The last of your untested stars has yet to appear in movie or television, but he impressed with his audition. Signing him on would, again, be something of a gamble, but he seems like he could pull of a character who has to be likable and charming but still show some inner depths.
Random Pick, no real reason
[X] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kids which could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
In Monk and Spy Kids, Shalhoub really embodies that manic energy that I think fits the mad scientist role well. He can definitely play a smart person who is super intense and clearly insane and he can play an evil character. I am super down for such a villain.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
If he gets even more famous in this world, then we might see a Firefly reboot in this timeline. A man can dream
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
We want to get Whedon for Avengers 1. So lets build connections lmao.
[X] David Thewlis - A slightly older take on the character could come from David Thewlis, though the timing might be tight given that he's got a Harry Potter movie coming out this year and another one likely in 2009. You think he's got the potential to portray someone sinister if given the chance to be a big time villain.
Save James McAvoy for a bigger role imo. He can do a villain like he did in Split, but he can do a lot bigger roles later. I do like Lupin so thats why im going with him.
[X] Liv Tyler - Tyler is certainly a well known face given her portrayal of Arwen in the Lord of the Rings movies and her appreciation for the old television show has left her interested in the role of Betty Ross even if her appearance is mostly setup for a sequel where the love story could be explored more properly.
Random Choice, don't care.
Don't think he needs to be changed. And he should be here for the long haul which is good.
He'll be in it for the long haul. As much I as I like Joaquin Pheonix, he isnt going to be a long term Hulk so he is a bad option imo.
[X] Sam Claflin - The last of your untested stars has yet to appear in movie or television, but he impressed with his audition. Signing him on would, again, be something of a gamble, but he seems like he could pull of a character who has to be likable and charming but still show some inner depths.
Random Pick, no real reason
[X] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kids which could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
In Monk and Spy Kids, Shalhoub really embodies that manic energy that I think fits the mad scientist role well. He can definitely play a smart person who is super intense and clearly insane and he can play an evil character. I am super down for such a villain.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
If he gets even more famous in this world, then we might see a Firefly reboot in this timeline. A man can dream
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
We want to get Whedon for Avengers 1. So lets build connections lmao.
[X] David Thewlis - A slightly older take on the character could come from David Thewlis, though the timing might be tight given that he's got a Harry Potter movie coming out this year and another one likely in 2009. You think he's got the potential to portray someone sinister if given the chance to be a big time villain.
Save James McAvoy for a bigger role imo. He can do a villain like he did in Split, but he can do a lot bigger roles later. I do like Lupin so thats why im going with him.
[X] Liv Tyler - Tyler is certainly a well known face given her portrayal of Arwen in the Lord of the Rings movies and her appreciation for the old television show has left her interested in the role of Betty Ross even if her appearance is mostly setup for a sequel where the love story could be explored more properly.
Random Choice, don't care.
Last edited:
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[X] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[X] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Last edited:
Magoose
SV's Questing Fanatic
- Location
- California USA
- Pronouns
- He
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Rhys Ifans - This Welsh actor is probably the one who bears the strongest resemblance to Crawford's comic book self. He's been consistently cast in movies for more than a decade and been nominated for his share of awards in that time. Honestly you're not exactly sure how he'd pop on screen but he seems decently talented.
[X] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Peter Stormare - An experienced guy who certainly fits the physicality of the pre-transformation Sterns, Stormare is the oldest of the actors you're considering for a part which doesn't have a set age attached to it (though you've been discussing keeping him closer to Banner). Maybe his take on the character could be a fun one though.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Rhys Ifans - This Welsh actor is probably the one who bears the strongest resemblance to Crawford's comic book self. He's been consistently cast in movies for more than a decade and been nominated for his share of awards in that time. Honestly you're not exactly sure how he'd pop on screen but he seems decently talented.
[X] Justin Theroux - Maybe he didn't quite make the cut as Iron Man (not that anyone was going to stop Favreau from picking Bob), but Theroux is still a talented actor who could portray the somewhat rugged but likable family man that is Paul Cartier. He definitely seems interested in signing on with Marvel in any case.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Peter Stormare - An experienced guy who certainly fits the physicality of the pre-transformation Sterns, Stormare is the oldest of the actors you're considering for a part which doesn't have a set age attached to it (though you've been discussing keeping him closer to Banner). Maybe his take on the character could be a fun one though.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Ghostdevil
The Devil of Ghosts
- Location
- United States
Tempted to take Garfield, if only to stop the shit that is the Amazing Spiderman.
- Location
- Israel
Okay, okay, I've relaxed a bit and I apologize for the outburst, but that was too much of a powerhouse list. I think I've made a partial list of the best contenders for the roles and some I've already decided:
Bruce Banner:
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
Edited my post to match my future pick.
Rick Jones:
[X] Dave Franco - Brother to James Franco (Harry Osborn in Raimi's Spider-Man movies), the younger Franco hasn't quite had his breakthrough into film yet but is interested in the opportunity. He's untested and seems to bring an enthusiasm and energy to the role, but maybe someone more established would be safer?
Dave Franco is a good actor in my opinion and his eventual performances in 21 Jump Street and The Disaster Artist shows he can do both comedy and drama. He is also factually youthful and good looking, so I think he is a good choice.
Crawford:
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
I had a hard time deciding between Branagh and Shalhoub, but I will go with Kenneth Branagh on this one, because he is a very good actor and director and we'll make connections with him to direct the Thor Movie.
Paul Cartier:
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
Random choice, but we bring in fanboys in to this and they will watch this flick! Bringing a man to please them nerds and do so in a manly fashion!
Marie Cartier:
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
No need to even hesitate. Like Nathan Fillion, has connections to Whedon, known to the nerds (I mean, come on, she's the...top 3? Top 5?...Top 3 hottest actors in the Buffyverse), and is a pretty good actress for a one time deal.
Leader:
[X] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
From the description it seems like he had a kickass audition and it might help him make a breakout and get his name recognized. James McAvoy will have an excellent career and doesn't need Marvel in my opinion. Sure, we could make sure Fox never get him with their filthy, franchise ruining, Deadpool defiling hands, but he still doesn't need Marvel in my opinion.
Betty Ross:
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Easiest fucking pick for me. From all the roles I've seen her in, she is extremely talented and is simply a beautiful actress with a lot of talent and comedic timing, as well as dramatic capabilities. She has done incredibly well in Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang with Robert Downey Jr. and Val Kilmer, and she will be excellent in True Detectives.
Bruce Banner:
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
Edited my post to match my future pick.
Rick Jones:
[X] Dave Franco - Brother to James Franco (Harry Osborn in Raimi's Spider-Man movies), the younger Franco hasn't quite had his breakthrough into film yet but is interested in the opportunity. He's untested and seems to bring an enthusiasm and energy to the role, but maybe someone more established would be safer?
Dave Franco is a good actor in my opinion and his eventual performances in 21 Jump Street and The Disaster Artist shows he can do both comedy and drama. He is also factually youthful and good looking, so I think he is a good choice.
Crawford:
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
I had a hard time deciding between Branagh and Shalhoub, but I will go with Kenneth Branagh on this one, because he is a very good actor and director and we'll make connections with him to direct the Thor Movie.
Paul Cartier:
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
Random choice, but we bring in fanboys in to this and they will watch this flick! Bringing a man to please them nerds and do so in a manly fashion!
Marie Cartier:
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
No need to even hesitate. Like Nathan Fillion, has connections to Whedon, known to the nerds (I mean, come on, she's the...top 3? Top 5?...Top 3 hottest actors in the Buffyverse), and is a pretty good actress for a one time deal.
Leader:
[X] Glenn Howerton - Another young man, Howerton is a mostly fresh face for audiences. He's been appearing in movies and television since 2002, but he hasn't quite broken out yet. Setting himself up as the villain in a superhero flick could be good for him, and he did pull off a sort of manic intensity in the auditions.
From the description it seems like he had a kickass audition and it might help him make a breakout and get his name recognized. James McAvoy will have an excellent career and doesn't need Marvel in my opinion. Sure, we could make sure Fox never get him with their filthy, franchise ruining, Deadpool defiling hands, but he still doesn't need Marvel in my opinion.
Betty Ross:
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Easiest fucking pick for me. From all the roles I've seen her in, she is extremely talented and is simply a beautiful actress with a lot of talent and comedic timing, as well as dramatic capabilities. She has done incredibly well in Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang with Robert Downey Jr. and Val Kilmer, and she will be excellent in True Detectives.
Last edited:
avatar11792
Et Sic Incipit
- Location
- Planet Earth, North America
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Reasoning:
- Ruffalo: He's the perfect Hulk, likeable and charismatic, with the intensity and simmering something underneath the skin. Plus humor.
- Garfield: My lord, he's much better as a Rick Jones character than as the SPiderman we got. Hes the perfect age, snark level fits like a glove, etc, but he can also seriously act. Excellent fit with Ruffalo too, can see them riffing off of each other given the proper environment.
- Branagh: *looks on Google* My lord, he looks the part now that hes aged a bit, and his acting is very good. He could get across the "hidden villain" element very well.
- Fillion: ...I can never get enough of Fillion, and he needs to be part of the MCU somehow. Even if this vote doesn't go through, I'd want him to be something in the MCU.
- Carpenter: I am a huge Buffy fan, and Cordelia is much like this character's description of "normal girl thrown into extraordinary events". Can see her getting along very well with Fillion, which is important bc theyre a married couple.
- Rockwell: Carry his quirky IRL IM2 acting into a Leader? It would work great.
- Monaghan: Hell no to Liv Tyler, and I love Monaghan's looks and movies. She'd have good chemistry with Ruffalo too I imagine, which is obviously important to sell the idea these twqo might fall for each other.
EDIT:
- Replaced Sam Rockwell for LEONARD FUCKING NIMOY. So much good!
- Placing Sam Rockwell back in, Nimoy is a bit too old, and if we're doing sequels...yeah, we'll need younger actors.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
[X] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Reasoning:
- Ruffalo: He's the perfect Hulk, likeable and charismatic, with the intensity and simmering something underneath the skin. Plus humor.
- Garfield: My lord, he's much better as a Rick Jones character than as the SPiderman we got. Hes the perfect age, snark level fits like a glove, etc, but he can also seriously act. Excellent fit with Ruffalo too, can see them riffing off of each other given the proper environment.
- Branagh: *looks on Google* My lord, he looks the part now that hes aged a bit, and his acting is very good. He could get across the "hidden villain" element very well.
- Fillion: ...I can never get enough of Fillion, and he needs to be part of the MCU somehow. Even if this vote doesn't go through, I'd want him to be something in the MCU.
- Carpenter: I am a huge Buffy fan, and Cordelia is much like this character's description of "normal girl thrown into extraordinary events". Can see her getting along very well with Fillion, which is important bc theyre a married couple.
- Rockwell: Carry his quirky IRL IM2 acting into a Leader? It would work great.
- Monaghan: Hell no to Liv Tyler, and I love Monaghan's looks and movies. She'd have good chemistry with Ruffalo too I imagine, which is obviously important to sell the idea these twqo might fall for each other.
EDIT:
- Replaced Sam Rockwell for LEONARD FUCKING NIMOY. So much good!
- Placing Sam Rockwell back in, Nimoy is a bit too old, and if we're doing sequels...yeah, we'll need younger actors.
Last edited:
- Location
- New York
- Pronouns
- He/Him
Not Fillion, save him for an actual starring role later on!
He can do it!
He can do it!
Lab_Accident
A 2D 1D4
- Location
- Your dreams
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Another actor you have your eyes on is Ruffalo, whose career has been steadily rising the last few years. He's not quite as talented as Norton, but he'd certainly be easier to work with and as a native Wisconsinite might be a good fit for this particular movie. If you want him though you'll have to move fast as he might be closing the deal with some smaller projects.
[X] I'm thinking of someone else (Seth Green). He's played Rick Jones, he can do it again. Plus, another feather in our Joss Whedon hat.
[X] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kidswhich could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
Ties to Whedon is always good, and they're good picks.
[X] I'm thinking of someone else (Leonard Nimoy). Offer the role to Nimoy. He always wanted to not be Spock, I say give him a chance. The Leader is a really charismatic villain and has the potential to be a recurrent villain if we play our cards right. Plus, instant hit with the geeks.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[X] I'm thinking of someone else (Seth Green). He's played Rick Jones, he can do it again. Plus, another feather in our Joss Whedon hat.
[X] Tony Shalhoub - Another talented guy you've had your eye on is Shalhoub, who just has a certain mad scientist vibe to him. You also know he doesn't take himself too seriously given his appearance in Spy Kidswhich could help create a somewhat eccentric and memorable villain in this second move of the MCU.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
Ties to Whedon is always good, and they're good picks.
[X] I'm thinking of someone else (Leonard Nimoy). Offer the role to Nimoy. He always wanted to not be Spock, I say give him a chance. The Leader is a really charismatic villain and has the potential to be a recurrent villain if we play our cards right. Plus, instant hit with the geeks.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Last edited:
Fezzes
Knight of King Stannis Baratheon
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
[X] Hugh Dancy - Dancy is a somewhat lesser known name but he really impressed you in his audition with his ability to portray Banner's constantly suppressed rage. As far as your desire to cast lesser known actors who won't risk overshadowing the character they're playing, Dancy seems like a close to perfect Bruce Banner to bring into this project! He might be cheaper too.
I want Ruffalo. I really do. But I feel like venturing a bit more into the unknown. Even though Ruffalo really should be the best option. I think it's the cheapness while still "really impressing" Favreau. I know nothing about him, honestly.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
Mostly to see what this does to Amazing Spiderman.
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Ruffalo is already being considered for Banner, but there's been some chatter that he might be a good fit for the film's antagonist as well (obviously he can't do both). He's got a likable way about him after all and he's someone you know could pull off a smart guy and an angry guy at the same time.
Ruffalo playing a Hulk villain the the negaverse? Eeeeexcellent. This would amuse me.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
Do I even need to say anything? It's Nathan Fillion.
[X] Sarah Polley - A native Canadian actress, Polley is one of the team's top picks for Marie Cartier. Despite her youth she's been appearing in pictures since the mid 1980s, and while she hasn't appeared in any comic movies the script and general appeal here seems to have won her over enough to audition for a part.
From the descriptions she's a safer pick. Whedon connections are hard to pass though...
[X] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
Rockwell is insanity, but I could see him being the right kind of insanity. Either him or Peter Stormare, I think. Rockwell might drag around the horror/mystery tone of the movie, but I trust him. And if I can't, then I definitely trust Stormare. The Leader shouldn't need to do much physical work, so age isn't an issue.
[X] Rose Byrne - Since her small role in Attack of the Clones in 2002 (oy), Byrne has been doing quite well for herself. Like the others listed here she's willing and eager to appear within a comic book movie and understands that her character is mostly being set up as a main character in a theoretical but likely sequel.
This is straight up random.
I can and probably will get talked out of most of these votes.
I want Ruffalo. I really do. But I feel like venturing a bit more into the unknown. Even though Ruffalo really should be the best option. I think it's the cheapness while still "really impressing" Favreau. I know nothing about him, honestly.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
Mostly to see what this does to Amazing Spiderman.
[X] Mark Ruffalo - Ruffalo is already being considered for Banner, but there's been some chatter that he might be a good fit for the film's antagonist as well (obviously he can't do both). He's got a likable way about him after all and he's someone you know could pull off a smart guy and an angry guy at the same time.
Ruffalo playing a Hulk villain the the negaverse? Eeeeexcellent. This would amuse me.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
Do I even need to say anything? It's Nathan Fillion.
[X] Sarah Polley - A native Canadian actress, Polley is one of the team's top picks for Marie Cartier. Despite her youth she's been appearing in pictures since the mid 1980s, and while she hasn't appeared in any comic movies the script and general appeal here seems to have won her over enough to audition for a part.
From the descriptions she's a safer pick. Whedon connections are hard to pass though...
[X] Sam Rockwell - It's hard not to like Sam Rockwell and his somewhat wacky characterizations. He wasn't your choice for Tony Stark but you've kept a close eye on him and are really hoping to work him into a future projects. The Leader would be a somewhat unusual choice for him but you're interested to see what he could do with it!
Rockwell is insanity, but I could see him being the right kind of insanity. Either him or Peter Stormare, I think. Rockwell might drag around the horror/mystery tone of the movie, but I trust him. And if I can't, then I definitely trust Stormare. The Leader shouldn't need to do much physical work, so age isn't an issue.
[X] Rose Byrne - Since her small role in Attack of the Clones in 2002 (oy), Byrne has been doing quite well for herself. Like the others listed here she's willing and eager to appear within a comic book movie and understands that her character is mostly being set up as a main character in a theoretical but likely sequel.
This is straight up random.
I can and probably will get talked out of most of these votes.
- Location
- USA
Bruce Banner:
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
Yeah, I'm going for Phoenix here. The guy is pretty great at all the roles I've seen him in. I definitely would be interested in his take on the Hulk. Also, his Joker trailer came out recently so it is fresh on my mind. He usually does well playing people with anger issues and self destructive tendencies.
Marie Cartier:
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
Betty Ross:
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
Yeah, I'm going for Phoenix here. The guy is pretty great at all the roles I've seen him in. I definitely would be interested in his take on the Hulk. Also, his Joker trailer came out recently so it is fresh on my mind. He usually does well playing people with anger issues and self destructive tendencies.
Marie Cartier:
[X] Charisma Carpenter - Another Whedon protege, well known for playing Cordelia Chase in Buffy and Angel, Carpenter has more experience in television than movies but is nonetheless being considered by the team. Casting her could definitely help her career if all goes well and maybe build some ties to Whedon.
Betty Ross:
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.
Fezzes
Knight of King Stannis Baratheon
- Location
- Sydney, Australia
Fuck, you may be right.
...I've just had an image of Fillion as the proper comics Clint Barton, silly to the core. I will die unsatisfied, knowing this never happened.
- Location
- USA
Norton did an admirable job in the role given what he had to work with, so I don't think his acting chops are in question here. However, the fact that he was recast does have to make us consider why he was recast in the first place. According Marvel's representatives, after it was announced that he wouldn't reprise the role in the Avengers, they said it was because he was difficult to work with, demanding a rewrite to the script of the movie. I don't think we will have that happen here, especially as we have a solid script, but if there's a chance for it to happen, I would rather we not try to jeopardize the entire project, as our casting call results are mostly because of the script here. As for what Norton's agents said in the aftermath, they said that he was willing and eager to reprise the role, and that it was a monetary decision by Marvel to cut him from the part, which they of course denied. As for Norton himself, he said that he chose not to do it, though this may simply be something he now thinks of in hindsight, as he didn't want to be confined to simply playing a single character. All things considered, there's too many factors at play here for him to be considered a safe bet, especially if we are hoping to have a sequel in the future.
Ruffalo is a good pick. Not someone too expensive for us to get, and someone who we know can embody the character of Bruce Banner well on screen, especially his onscreen chemistry with the rest of the Avengers. Contrasting him with Norton, while he may not have as wide of an acting range as him, he is also more easy to work with, and as Marvel has shown, it's the unified vision and adherence to the plan that has allowed it to set itself apart form the competition. Then again, for a production like this, which is seen as a little more auteur compared to the canon Hulk movie, maybe we want to hit it out of the park?
Joaquin Phoenix's talent is well known. Then again, he is also known as someone who is rather hard to get, and as an actor he is definitely more of the artist than someone in it for the money. However, all of that aside, the fact that we have his interest here is something that should definitely be considered. With his bevy of Academy Award Nominations, among his other awards and accolades, Phoenix's talent needs no introduction.
From what we've learned about this script and the story behind this version of the Hulk, there will be a lot more nuance here than in the original, and that is something I think we will want to indulge in. Right now, our reputation as a studio is being established, and for better or for worse, Marvel initially and still is to some degree pegged as a studio system which relies on being formulaic to achieve its result, and is called rather bland by some as a result. If we try to cast Phoenix in this role, in this movie, I think we have a good shot of countering that argument before it begins. Furthermore the fact that Phoenix is somewhat more flexible in terms of money makes him someone who can potentially serve as both a name brand to draw in the crowds, but also someone who won't get Perlmutter to come crashing down upon us.
Now, as for the big elephant in the room, sequels. Yes, from what we know of Phoenix he is generally not one to indulge upon franchises or sequels, as he is more of an auteur, someone who follows his passions. And while it may hurt to have to recast him later on, I don't think it will be that bad for us as we will likely have actors like Ruffalo to call upon, who we know can play the part well. However, if we do interest him enough to continue in the idea that is the MCU, then all the better. I'm just thinking that Phoenix here is a result of our stellar casting roll, and I would rather we not waste it.
The most talented actor out of the bunch. He can handle more dramatic moments, but also has great comedic timing for humorous moments. I think that as this production is something that will be a little more nuanced than the usual superhero fare, he can definitely excel here and kickstart his career under us.
Branagah is a solid actor, I know him more for his Shakespearean roles than Harry Potter but they tell enough about his acting chops. While the villain role here isn't that important to the movie, at the same time, I think it would be good if we could make sure the villain is at least memorable rather than forgettable. Also, this could serve as a chance for us to talk to him about Thor.
Again, someone who is talented and makes a memorable villain. The eccentricity may make the movie more eccentric and play well with the other actors.
It would be a steal for us if we could get Fillion in this. He obviously has talent, but also, his connection to Whedon is something we will need if we wish to get the Avengers to be what it was.
Considering that Marvel's casting team is usually spot on about their choices for most roles, I will tend to defer to them here. The fact that it's been hinted that she was won over by the script, and is only here because of it is enough for me to believe that we should trust in our team to see this through.
The main reason to choose this option I think is the Whedon ties. Then again, as this role isn't too major, perhaps that is all we need.
We know he can handle roles such as this well. His later BAFTA and Golden Globe tell enough about his acting talent. If we surround him with a talented cast, like it looks like we are about to do, I have no doubt we can utilize him well enough for a sequel to get off the ground.
She did well in the original. Plus, the fact that she is interested in the character doesn't hurt at all either. With a better script this time, perhaps we can utilize her better for the sequel, even though we know here that she is just going to be the love interest.
We know she's talented, and the fact that she's interested in a multi-picture deal makes it so that we can be much more flexible in regards to our future sequel plans.
[X] Joaquin Phoenix - There was quite a bit of interest in Phoenix for the part but little hope of actually getting him. He has a reputation of only taking on projects he's interested in and passionate about, regardless of the money. But after reading the script and talking with Leterrier he's definitely interested. He's an excellent actor who you think could really tap into that inner anger.
[X] Andrew Garfield - A rising star from the UK, Garfield is apparently going to be named one of Variety's "10 Actors to Watch" according to one of your connections. From what you've seen of his work he is a hardworking talented kid, someone who deserves better than the projects he might be saddled with later on.
[X] Kenneth Branagh - Definitely a talented and qualified actor with a long filmography (even if audiences most likely know him as Gilderoy Lockhart from Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets). Branagh could bring an enthusiastic energy to the party that could make Crawford a more memorable villain than he otherwise might be.
[X] Nathan Fillion - If you want to bring in the fanboys while still finding a genuinely talented actor there's no one better than Firefly's Captain Malcolm Reynolds. Fillion actually is Canadian, and apart from a small project he's working on with Whedon (based on the WGA strike, which you've luckily managed to distance yourself from) he's not too busy.
[X] Sarah Polley - A native Canadian actress, Polley is one of the team's top picks for Marie Cartier. Despite her youth she's been appearing in pictures since the mid 1980s, and while she hasn't appeared in any comic movies the script and general appeal here seems to have won her over enough to audition for a part.
[X] James McAvoy - A young actor, you've heard some very good things about McAvoy (and his performance in Atonement which will be coming out this year) from Hollywood insiders. He's not at all opposed to appearing within a comic book movie and seems like he could pull off both sides of the Leader - pre and post-transformation.
[X] Michelle Monaghan - Another talented actress who has been rising in popularity since the dawn of the century, Monaghan has been willing to get involved in comic book movies in the past (though her scenes in Constantine were unfortunately cut) and is interested in a multi-picture deal to portray Betty Ross.