- Location
- Watchung,New Jersey
Mmm, I was just thinking about how all the quotes in the begging were in a interview format, and I just got a connection: Was Mrs. Baxter the woman who compiled those interviews?
Not all of them but a decent chunk of the quotes were from interviews with Baxter.Mmm, I was just thinking about how all the quotes in the begging were in a interview format, and I just got a connection: Was Mrs. Baxter the woman who compiled those interviews?
Assumingly both Sparta and The Minoan Kingdom them think themselves morally superior to the other. Spartans because they're not a monarchy and Minoans because they treat the native population far better.But hey, at least none of them are crowning themselves. Right?
"Make the Downtimers do the backbreaking work so I don't have to" Is a dangerously appealing thought when you're barely getting by in a crude Log Cabin out in the middle of 'state' that's only sort of keeping itself together.Urgh. The sad part is that Sparta probably sounds like a sweet deal for many uptimers and their descendants. Getting your own personal fief with slaves is an attractive thing when backbreaking labor is the alternative.
Being part of the aristocracy is nice if you aren't overy concerned with morals.
When you lack the smarts to make simple tools to turn hard labour into merely common work.Getting your own personal fief with slaves is an attractive thing when backbreaking labor is the alternative.
When you lack the smarts to make simple tools to turn hard labour into merely common work.
Eh. So much open uncontested space, and everyone just keeps fighting over others crap.
There's a scene in Island in the Sea of Time that in part inspired this. Basically it's Nantucket's first harvest since the Event and the Machine they built to do the actual harvesting has failed miserably so this year and this year only they're going to have to bring it in purely by hand, with Steel Scythes. The People of Nantucket are complaining pretty bitterly about the work, because it's horrible and most of them aren't used to anything like this sort of labor, even though they've got a pretty decent system worked out. Meanwhile Swindapa is basically outpacing most everyone and wondering why everyone's complaining considering she's used to doing this annually with worse tools.One city was ISOTed. You obviously won't have neither the tools nor the industrial base to accomplish that.
Even with a steel plough farming is fucking hard work. Tractor, advanced chemicals and harvesters are not going to happen ITTL for a while. There isn't really a way to avoid the backbreaking work.
There's a scene in Island in the Sea of Time that in part inspired this. Basically it's Nantucket's first harvest since the Event and the Machine they built to do the actual harvesting has failed miserably so this year and this year only they're going to have to bring it in purely by hand, with Steel Scythes. The People of Nantucket are complaining pretty bitterly about the work, because it's horrible and most of them aren't used to anything like this sort of labor, even though they've got a pretty decent system worked out. Meanwhile Swindapa is basically outpacing most everyone and wondering why everyone's complaining considering she's used to doing this annually with worse tools.
So imagine you're a former accountant or something of that nature and you're stuck in this situation. You're spent most of your life working towards where you were before the Event only to have it taken all away from you and now you're facing a life of breaking your back just to get enough to eat every year. There's no tractor coming, there's not harvester, not for decades at least. And certainly no chemicals. You're probably taking in the Harvest using Steel, maybe even Bronze Scythes. We're talking 16 hour days of hard menial labor doing something you almost certainly consider far beneath you. But you know there are Downtimers out there, people used to this kind of life, people who could do this kind of life without any complaints. And these people, they don't have the education you've had, they don't know the things you do. Why should you have to suffer when you can just use those ignorant people? It's not like you're making things worse for them in the grand scheme of things. If anything you're making things better for them with all the new knowledge and tech you're introducing.
Early farming was grueling, labor intensive and brutal on health. I have to imagine a lot of people would want to avoid it if possible, even if it meant doing some rather nasty things.
One city was ISOTed. You obviously won't have neither the tools nor the industrial base to accomplish that.
Even with a steel plough farming is fucking hard work. Tractor, advanced chemicals and harvesters are not going to happen ITTL for a while. There isn't really a way to avoid the backbreaking work.
It's a matter of perspective. For a downtimer for example:
When someone thinks of a plough, most people see a giant wedge of mental (or wood), slowly dinging through soil.
But what if instead you could dig in a few thin angled blades (or wooden spikes) in, and make a small motion up to dig them out?
When someone thinks of harvesting, they imagine being bent down or on their knees ,and slowly cutting stalks down with a scythe, one or a few at a time.
But what if instead you had a stick with thin ropes attached along its length, and spin that against the stalks.
When someone thinks of threshing, they imagine hitting the grain stalks against the floor, and then slowly collecting the seeds.
But what if instead you had a few thin pieces of wood, arranged into something resembling a post fence (only tightly packed, wider up top, narrowing down).
This is something that uptimers should be able to logically figure out, to use that knowledge that supposedly makes them better, to make those existing harvests bigger, and easier to collect. Less energy and time spent on planting two fields, mean you can plant one more. While also eliminating the "backbreaking" from labour.
Granted, I fully understand that initially they had no choice in the matter, as survival took precedence. But a year later? Two? Five?
These solutions are simple, but applications of simple physical principles, and the tooling they already posses as evidenced by their 'tools of war', could have led them into solving any future food crisis in one or two years.
And then I sincerely doubt that absolutely nobody in any of those groups heard of raised beds, no-till, or straw growing.
Heck, just dividing the pastures would yield a raise in the number of animals and meat size+quality.
Kay. That's just sad.
Part of the reason I chose the Bronze Age, besides my love for the era, is that I wanted to play around with things are at least somewhat familar (Classical Greek Myth and Ancient Egypt) and have them at a time when they'd be more unfamiliar. So Egypt is controlled by the Hykos and Mycenaean faith is actually quite different from Classic greek myth even though many of the same gods are around, at least in name.
Iron ingots should be a very popular exchange good. With its basic form its very easy to make everything from nails, clippers, tongs, to gears and beams. And given the population numbers and spread it is unlikely to go out of favor ,or be subject to large price slips.